Enjoyed my double scoop with cookie butter and cookies & cream! The vibe is bright and beachy. They…read morehave a ton of workers (great!), though they were a little curt, I think in the effort of efficiency, despite it being not super busy when I was there. Tasty flavors, including cute local ones. Overall a good experience!

Downtown Squan, summer ice cream, tons of happy kids-this pretty much ticks all your summer snack…read moreboxes. Fairly priced, which isn't always so in a somewhat resort town.

Absolutely the best summer treat!!…read more If you are in Spring Lake, forget any other ice cream places this is where you need to go. Not only do they have an insane amount of different flavors and toppings. They also freshly make the waffle cones right in front of you and are extremely generous with the scoops. The line was long, but went by so quickly because the staff is very efficient and working so fast. After a long beach day, this is definitely such a cute and cozy area to walk to near the Spring Lake Park to end your day on a sweet treat!

Cash only ice cream parlour! Has an ATM inside. Plenty of delicious options. Street parking. Ample…read moreof spacing between tables. Highchair seen. See images for reference.

This cute ice cream shop has delicious ice cream but leaves some room for improvement…read more I think the ice cream here is actually really good! I got the Elvis and midnight jersey and both were delicious mixed together! The service here was definitely lacking. Not sure if it was because it was midweek but the people working the counters didn't seem to really want to be there. Usually ice cream shops would at least offer one free sample but no such case here. Also, I had to come back up to get a bowl for my overly melted ice cream and they just kept looking at me and going away from the line to "help" others when other staff were already helping them. If you are okay with just getting ice cream and not caring about service, this is not a bad spot!

We wanted to treat the kids after a day at Sandy Hook beach and decided to go for a new spot. Glad…read morewe did! I went off the recommendation of other Yelpers and can confirm, yes the Elvis ice cream is incredible. My family members enjoyed all of their picks too. The line moved pretty quickly, so I am confident that I can come back anytime during the beach season for more.

Ordered A cup of ice cream wanted the hot fudge on the side because it melts the ice cream and…read morewasn't going to eat it for awhile but they said they don't do that!!! Makes 0 sense!! I was willing to pay for it not asking for it for free.. could have gave me the same amount they would have if they added it to the ice cream.. again makes no sense. And they use to do it. I was a frequent customer But sorry I won't be back

Ive been to a couple Nicholas Creamery Locations i do Love there Ice Cream but if i could Make 1…read moreSUGGESTION........the ingredients such as Pistachios, Coconut...etc....i believe there needs to be Way More in the ice cream. its very limited with there ingredients. When i had gotten both of those flavored ice creams there was hardly any pistachios in the pistachio ice cream or hardly and coconut flakes in the coconut ice cream. Def needs more toppings in it. When i get pics of there ice cream i feel im decieved by the way it looks as when i go there it doesnt come out like that at All!!!!

Nice flavors!! They even had jersey tomato basil. I ended up getting bourbon coffee and mint chip…read more Both were very good. I walked from the beach to there.

I came back for yet another flight of four different flavors. As always, they were all very creamy…read moreand fulfilling. Peanut Butter Palooza - This was homemade peanut butter ice cream with peanut butter cups and Oreos. This was unreal, one of my favorites tried here. There was plenty of peanut butter flavor, but not too much where it was an issue. Oreos were a nice compliment. Root Beer - This tasted exactly like root beer and was unique being in ice cream form but could not have too much of it as I became tired of it quickly. Grandma's Strawberry Shortcake - This was homemade strawberry sweet cream with strawberry jam swirl and shortbread cookie pieces. This was alright. The crumb pieces were too large, and surprised there was not more of a strawberry taste. Mango Lassi - This was homemade Greek yogurt sweet cream with homemade mango jam swirl. I wished there was more mango. I liked the slight change with Greek yogurt being used and it was very apparent. The sugar and whatever else was used helped to offset the blandness of regular Greek yogurt.

A solid choice for ice cream. Went on a rainy day and there was no wait. Fairly friendly staff who…read morequickly received ingredients in the flavors. Nice selection of ice creams and clean inside. Pricing was on par for ice cream. Ended up with a small Robert Brownie Jr. Overall, the experience and food was just okay - wouldn't seek it out again but wouldn't mind trying it again either.

Wouldn't recommend if you're a minority/not white. My father speaks English at a basic…read moreconversational level, it's not perfect, but he's completely understandable. While trying to practice his English, he placed his own order. During the entire ordeal, one of the male employees in the back started laughing and was giving "that look" to his co-workers. Furthermore throughout the entire experience they kept giving us strange looks, as if we didn't belong or something. Definitely won't be coming back due to this customer service.

First time trying this spot since they moved to their new location! The interior is still a bit…read morebare and could use a little more warmth and character, but the ice cream more than makes up for it. I ordered the chocolate chip cookie dough, and I'll honestly be dreaming about it forever!! It was that good! There's street parking available, but no indoor seating at the moment. Definitely worth a visit if you're craving incredible homemade ice cream! No vegan flavors

It's so hard to eat custard anywhere else after having it at Surfside! Truly the absolute best!!read more

Great ice cream! We got Rocky road on a waffle cone and coco loco which is coconut flavor with…read morecoconut and chocolate pieces. the waffle cone was slightly stale but nothing really to care much for. They also have vegan ice cream for those that want. service was good and it was a cute ambiance.

Cute spot, but I found the ice cream to be expensive for the portions, and they had less vegan…read moreoptions than were on the main menu.