Our first time staying in CB South and Tullys was the recommended restaurant so a bit surprised to see it has only 3 stars. We had a pleasant experience, went on a Saturday night in March, it was filled, but not busy by any means. There was really nice live music, a perfect level of volume for the space we were in. We got the wings, Philly cheesesteak, and ceaser salad, and were happy with everything! The only complaints were the fries were really salty and the lettuce in the salads weren't totally chopped. read more

See all

We ate dinner here last night, and had a great experience. We opted to sit at the bar, which is full service. There are a lot of bar seats, as well as in restaurant seating, with large tvs, displaying current games/sporting events. There are tap handles all around the ceiling - I instantly had the feeling they take their beer options/menu seriously. The ever rotating beer menu is displayed on a tv (two screens worth of options), and I was excited to see a wide variety of beers. I opted for an IPA to start. The menu has a Philly vibe to it (not sure where else you can find a cheesesteak on an amoroso roll), with appetizers ranging from cheese curds, to fried pickles, or fried mushrooms, to potstickers and pork green chile. I ordered the Italian - which you can have cold or toasted (always go toasted!), comes with your choice of cheese, and a large amount of meat (capicola, salami, pepperoni), lettuce, tomato, banana pepper and onion. It was delicious (and substantial). The fries are delicious - seasoned and crispy. My husband ordered the meatball sub, which was also substantial, and very tasty, and he opted for a Caesar salad as his side, which was very good. Our friend ordered a salad, which was huge. The bartender was awesome, and Tully came out of the kitchen a few times to chat, and we learned more about him, and the restaurant. Great guy, and love what he's doing here. We will absolutely be back! read more

See all

The food was great again. So fresh and clearly pride coming from the kitchen. great service from locals and a great local vibe.

Tullys offers a wonderful welcoming atmosphere with a huge menu catering to whatever you may be in the mood for. Best pizza and BBQ in the valley hands down! read more

I am a local, live close and often meet friends here. I ordered wings as a take out early evening. They must have been left over from the night before. They were tough and inedible! I thew them out. I often order them and had an expectation. This was beyond disappointing. I will avoid Tullys in the future. Beware. O stars read more

Food tastes like cleaning the kitchen is optional. The meats taste like months worth of grease buildup is smoking it's flavor into the meat.

We ordered from this place because it was so close to where we were staying. We got a salad with added steak and a gluten free pizza. The staff were super helpful when we called in with many questions about allergies and the food was ready when they said it would be. All of the food was great! The salad was fresh and well composed and the pizza was savory and filling. It was some of the best food we had while visiting crested butte! So happy considering the reviews on here were negative. read more

Gosh we loved Tully's! Great friendly bartenders, pizza, excellent mixed drinks, and a view to die for! Love the deck as well as the inside. I'm so glad I celebrated my birthday there! We will be back! read more

Their menu look amazing, but they are so severely understaffed... it's really bad. Don't waste your time coming here until the owner staffs this place. Not the employees faults at all, but the owner needs to step it up. Either staff the restaurant or don't be open. read more

I have had Tullys many times before and they have always let me down, but today was en exception. The meat tasted like a grill, but not in a good way. I got nachos and pulled pork. It tasted like the pulled pork has had the pork pulled out of it. I also got fried pickles and the oil really desperately needs a change. The fried pickles taste like everything that is fried but pickles. The smell alone of this food makes me feel sick. A health inspector has to go out there soon. The food tastes like no one has cleaned the grill, countertops, and oil in months. Don't eat here!!! read more

The wait staff is the WORST most unfriendly and unhelpful that I have ever encountered. They look like they are unhappy that people showed up at the restaurant. VERY unorganized. DO NOT GO THERE unless you want an extremely long wait and arrogant attitudes. This place sucks!! read more

A big part of the menu is barbecue, but unfortunately that's not a priority for the kitchen. While I was hoping for some brisket and my friend wanted their pulled pork, they were out of both. We settled for burgers, and later found they were out of the dessert we wanted. It wasn't a busy night (a Tuesday), so their inability to stock the food that people come for was a mystery to us. Our server was friendly and competent, and the place had an acceptable vibe, but I can't imagine what might make me go back when there are so many other dining choices in Crested Butte. read more

We stopped by while staying in Crested Butte South. We walked right up with no wait and were greeted by Will at the bar who was friendly and helpful with the menu. He recommended the house margaritas and I will definitely be back for another. The food hit the spot and was well prepared. Thanks again! read more

The pulled pork and Cuban sandwiches were outstanding. The venue and staff were also great. Can't wait to return.

Great place to hang out in CB South. The pizza was amazing -- love the thicker crust. The burger and ruebens were excellent, too. What a great deck for sunny evenings. The service was a little on the slow side. And the draft beers were almost all pale ales -- where are the Pilsners? How about Paulaner or Späten? read more

See all

They claim to have the best onion rings around. They don't. Cold, greasy Returned them and they guy says, "not my problem". Won't be eating there again. They refunded the money, except for the tip. read more

Good pub food. It's your best option, only option, for food in cb south. Service was super slowwwwww. Good wings. Cheese steak.

Fantastically laid back atmosphere. We got there early before it got too crowded they had a great selection of brews on taps, everything from Lagers to Stouts. We just had a couple of drinks and a basket of fries, so can't review the food, but the tables next to us had pizza and wings and they smelled fantastic. The only thing that kept me from giving them 5 stars was that they didn't have tasting flights available to sample their beers. But I am nitpicking. We will be back. read more

Cute bar in CB South. Beware of Will the bartender. We asked for 2 glasses of red wine and he served us the top end without asking. Our 2 glasses of red wine cost 50.00. Would have been nice if he gave us an option. read more

Great food, lots of drink selection, and amazing service. What a gem in south crested butte. Owner is super friendly. Lots of outdoor seating (with cornhole boards) with space for our 2 young kids to run around during dinner. read more

I've never left a review before but felt I had to warn other people of this place. Zero stars would have been my preference. The owner/chef? was sitting at the bar and insulted us as he was walking back to the kitchen. Was he drunk? I don't know. We put our menus down and walked out. We were very disappointed and had been having a nice time up until then. Shame on you, Tully's. read more

Owners need to focus on servers to kitchen disconnect. Great staff, slow service. As locals, We'd like to see Tully's succeed!

Awful service. Ordered a pizza to go. Waited 30 minutes (the time they told me it would take) until I went to pick it up. When I got there, they said it would take another 20 minutes. After 20 mins I asked them if the pizza was even in the oven yet. They said no so I left . How long is a pizza supposed to take? More than 50 mins? I don't think so. Wasted my time and it wasn't even ready. They didn't even offer me a drink. Disappointed and very angry. read more

This place is fantastic. So glad it's in CB South! Food is great, staff fantastic. Best gluten free pizza I've ever had and the regular pizza is outstanding. Amazing pulled pork and the homemade chips are to die for. read more

FUN for hanging out with friends on the deck. Easy food and fun atmosphere right in CB South. Salads, sandwiches, and fries were all delicious. read more

Decent food, great staff, but often slow. Definitely worth coming down to CB South during the busy seasons, but otherwise, there are better places to dine out. read more

This is a great place and one of my favorite places to eat in the Crested Butte area. It is actually in Crested Butte South and has absolutely great food. try the pulled pork sandwich. read more

Placed a to-go order and was told it would be ready in 30 minutes. When I got there, they hadn't even put the order in and was told it would be another 30 minutes. The owners were sitting there and didn't even seem to care. I always tip good even when I get to-go. This is not the first time this has happened and they weren't even busy. They have also made mistakes with my orders in the past. I live in CB South and am so tired of trying to give them a chance on getting the right order or them even putting it in! Never going back. read more

Great menu options for everyone and a fantastic burger! Very cool, brand new setting in CB south with a pool table upstairs and huge deck

Large pizza with lots of toppings . Cuban sandwich that was excellent . Hamburgers are large Korean Dont miss the onion rings. Cincinatti three way too. The day we went the weather was excellent and they kept the garage doors open so outside was inside. What a Hidden Gem for South Crested Butte. Good food and nice place! read more

I was CB South in July visiting my brother and sister in law and made Tully's a daily stop after fishing. They have an outstanding beer selection and the food is fantastic. When we went with my kids for dinner, my 9 year old who doesn't like anything said it was the best meal she has ever had (she highly recommends the cheese cake). Being from Chicago I am a little picky when it comes to pizza; Tully's pizza did not disappoint and can stand up to the great places we have in Chicago. He did a great job building the new Tully's and created a great atmosphere to hang with friends or bring your family. read more