The best pizza in Santa Paula made to order in a brick oven they make the best calzones and salad. Friendly staff very clean. We all love it. The price is good. read more

This past Monday I was craving pizza and decided to place an order to go here for their lunch special and it was a good deal. For $13 bucks you get a personal pizza with two toppings, a small salad and a drink. After placing my order I was told my order would be ready in 10-15 minutes. I got there in 12 minutes and they were pulling it out of the oven as I was walking in. Service here was on point. Good portion of food considering the lunch special. The pizza was of good quality and tasty. Very thin pizza crust. Salad was also good and fresh. Overall I really did like this place and would definitely come back again. Make sure to keep them in mind the next time your craving a pizza. Let's make sure we continue to support local 805 businesses. Thanks Tuscany Pizzeria for the good lunch. read more

See all

I've eaten here a few times,gotten heart burn and never anything to love about the place to go back.Definitely an off experience every time.Throughout the years the business went downhill and the previous owner never held regular hours and finally moved on.Under new ownership now they uphold their hours of operation but the quality hasn't improved. Ate here with family last night and potato skins frozen in the middle. Pizza was extra thin as if they pressed a medium dough into an extra large,it was like cracker crust! Cheese was cheap and had collagulated already when delivered. The calzone lacked everything including a brushing of olive oil or butter on top. Above our table where we sat were boxes of toys collecting dust on a shelf with price tags as if we were at a swap meet,making our dining experience tacky and classless. To top it off they don't have restrooms and the owner told me to go across the street to another restaurant for bathroom use. Really? Isn't there a law that requires every restaurant to have at least one bathroom???Can't even wash hands there before eating! The food there was the only thing we ate all day and it gave us all diarrhea!!!!! Not going back ever!!!!!! If you want good pizza go to Pinyon pizza in Ojai or Ventura not Santa Paula unless you desire dominos, Ameci, pizza man Dan or little Cesar's! read more

What a cute local place!! And..... They have Chicago deep dish!!! Whoop whoop!!! Parking can be a challenge on a weekend, so make sure to add a little extra time. I called in my order and the man helping me so so easy to work with. I called and wanted a deep dish everything pizza..... he was very accommodating and helped me understand what the pizza was named and what came on it. The location was super cute!! Small!!! But perfect for a quit bite :) Outstanding job team! I will be back!! read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

See all

Hands down this is the place for pizza! Quality, execution and the best part is the total family energy it gives off! We had a large group of ten and fit perfectly all together. Celebrating a birthday having a laugh and meal and the staff was all in playing happy birthday music and even providing some free treats at the end of the meal! I can't say enough how much the small details really make this place one of the best restaurants as a whole in the county!! read more

See all

Tasty, but not a true Margherita Pizza. I ordered the Margherita pizza and it tasted good--the crust was nicely done, the tomatoes were fresh, and the overall flavor was enjoyable. However, it didn't really match what I'd expect from a classic Margherita. It came topped with black olives and jarred minced garlic, which shifted the flavor profile and made it feel more like a standard veggie pizza than the simple, traditional Margherita I was anticipating. If you're not particular about authenticity, you'll probably enjoy it. But if you're expecting the classic basil-mozzarella-tomato trio, this version might not hit the mark. On the service side, the lady there is friendly and accommodating. Generally speaking, I would recommend going there, especially if you wanna support small businesses. read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Their version of Margherita Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

Was there about few weeks ago and this was Fire absolutely delicious , good people friendly . Place kinda small but the food can't tell you how much me and my girl friend enjoyed it . Churros were also very delicious will most definitely be my new pizza spot for Santa Paula read more

Food is great, give it a try and you won't be disappointed. Nice to have other pizza options in SP that aren't too expensive.

Great food and great service... Definitely will be my regular Italian Restaurant! Patti from S.P.

GETTING HERE: Located on Main Street in Santa Paula between 9th and 10th Streets. If you are heading Eastbound on Main Street, it's located on the left hand side of the street. REVIEW: This review is based on a pick-up order: Sadly, I do not know where to begin on this review. I have heard wonderful things about their food, in fact my friends were raving about it. So, while I had had this bookmarked for a while I prioritized getting out here asap. Here's where it turns a bit South. As I said it was pick-up order, and while there were 2 employees hustling, it was quite busy inside. Waited and waited, had called in the order, and finally was able to pay for my pizza and head out. In hindsight, I wish I would have taken a quick peek at the pizza before I left, but alas, I did not. When I got home I was disappointed. Quite disappointed. As you can see in my picture the pizza crust was burned. The entire pizza was so thin and the pepperoni was very sparce. I had higher hopes and expectations for their food based on what I had heard from others. Granted, I am hoping this is just a one-off and I will try them again, but I just wish I would have said something there in the restaurant had I known it was burned. The Garlic Cheesy Bread was tasty, but I tasted zero garlic. 2.5 stars and rounding up to 3 as I love me some bread and some cheese. My next visit will be in person and I hope it will be enjoyable. *Note: I had been here in 2017 (I had forgotten) but Yelp just ate the photo.... ;-( sad face read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Large Pepperoni; quite disappointing with the burned crust. 6/30/23 - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

See all

Such a great little spot. Dining in here is better than delivery! I love their thin crust pizzas and their chicken wings. Got a big family? Come sit at the big wooden table by the window, and watch the people passing by on Main Street. Highly recommend to get a pizza here if you're enjoying downtown! You'll love it!!! read more

Life long customer here- They have the best pizza in town! Also had an amazing meatball calzone SO GOOD!! Their sandwiches are great too! Great Vegetarian sandwich! read more

First time at this restaurant and they greeted me with a smile and the best welcome ever. I really like pizzas but I'm not a big fan of the ones near my house. I ordered a small pizza with my 3 favorite toppings. When I took the first bite, the cheese and the dough melted on my palate and I closed my eyes and couldn't believe it. The service is the best, but the pizza is incredibly delicious. It's definitely my favorite place. Next time I'll be back with my family so they can have the same experience I had. read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - My to go pizza full of love - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

See all

This was our first time here. We ordered a Tuscany deep dish pizza. We were excited to try a local deep dish pizzeria, and we were not disappointed! For deep dish pizzas it takes about an hour for them to cook. So when we arrived, the pizza was ready. The owners were super friendly and helpful. The pizza tasted delicious. It was warm ingredient for fresh will definitely be back. read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Deep Dish Tuscany - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

Best pizza in Santa Paula! They are always nice and my pizza is always crispy and delicious!

Earlier in the year, I moved to Santa Paula and I was coming to town with a moving truck and very tired and hungry after a long day of loading the truck. 30 minutes away I decided a pizza would be the best reward for hard day. I ordered a large Tuscany pizza and they said it would be ready in 30 minutes, perfect. Upon arriving after nobody greeting me or asking me while I waited at the counter, I asked the person in the kitchen where my pizza was, and they were confused asking me when I ordered it and what it was. They hadn't started making my pizza. I thought they would get right on it, but they took orders from other people before they even started my pizza. If I wasn't starving, I would've walked out right then but not knowing the area I waited, and waited. 45 minutes later, he told me my pizza was done. It was OK. A little underdone on the toppings, but I will never go back here. Rude and unprofessional. read more

Everything was great owners/staff was outstanding and welcoming. Fire oven pizza at its best, freshly make dough fresh ingredients. Not overpriced, pizza was excellent sandwiches almost too big. Dessert was great as well as long as you leave room for it. Will be back for sure. read more

Tuscany Pizzaria in downtown Santa Paula is nothing like corporate chains Pizza Hut, Dominos, Little Caesars. Instead it's an old school family owned and staffed place reminiscent of a much earlier time, specializing in Chicago Style Deep Dish pizza ever since it opened. Decor is suitably Italian, walls enhanced by quite a few posters and paintings. Even though I've lived in Santa Paula for about 20 years, I somehow never got around to visiting Tuscany until just recently when I was joined by my step son and step daughter who were very anxious to try Chicago Deep Dish for a change of pace. On the other hand I was at the opposite end of the scale by asking for a thin crust, my favorite, which they're not in the habit of serving because most people don't order it. The chef agreed to try making one, but I have to say the result was more of a "standard" crust than what I consider to be a true "thin," though all in all it was still a cut above average. Good pepperoni. The Chicago Style Deep Dish measured up to everyone's expectations and then some. My companions both loved it, and I was impressed by its hefty size and ratio of thick crust to a very meaty filling. Be advised that it takes nearly an hour to prepare and cook in their brick-fired oven, so you may want to order in advance to avoid a fairly long wait time. Tuscany had only two noticeable downsides while we were there... 1) Terrible music being piped in over their sound system rather than traditional Italian pop and classical to match the decor. The owner told us they usually do play appropriate music, but on this day there was a technical glitch. 2) There is no washroom in the front dining area. To access it you have to walk through the entire kitchen until you're almost at their back door. An awkward and inconvenient trip. All things considered, the three of us rate Tuscany's Chicago Style Deep Dish pizza a 10, while the best I can do for my "thin" crust is give it an 8. read more

See all

Staff is super friendly, they have a great team and were very warm and inviting, Giovanni was super helpful! Ordered pizza and wings, super delicious and made fresh. As I waited for my order, they checked in on me. Thank you for a great lunch time experience! read more

Cute little pizza joint. Very little seating, perfect for to-go. Cheese for the kids, Vegetarian for the grown-ups, and a Chicken Pesto for those who want adventure. Their crust is crushin' it. Good things come from that giant pizza oven, and that chewy thin-crust is just fantastic. They load on the toppings - the veggie pizza has multiple layers! Chunks of chicken check the pesto, and those thin, crunchy pepperoni circles add a little extra. Family-owned by people with hearts as warm as their oven. I'm curious about their Chicago deep dish, so I'll have to come back when I have more time to wait. read more

Wow, Super Impressed; This Is That Good Good!! Super quality, handmade dough, modern-stone fire oven, and super welcoming personal attention from the staff sealed the deal for my affinity for this gem on Main Street! With Pizza being my favorite comfort food in the world, I have to say that this was really really good!! I was happy to see that they were still open on Main on a weekday for lunch; unlike so many others on here... ***ProTip...Go In For The Lunch Special: 1) Sandwich OR 'Hand-Made' Medium-Crust Personal Pan Pizza + Salad OR Chips&Drink = $7.99 + Tax = $8.65! I can't wait to try more selections to be able to update soon!! =)) read more

See all

I used to visit Tuscany frequently with my family when I was younger, I visited for the first time in a couple of years and it was just at pleasant. The pizza was delicious! read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

See all

Cannolis are almost $10 each and taste very almondy. Also has too many chocolate chips that were a weird mixture of soft and hard. I am impressed with the cream filling amount going all the way through, and thought the crunch of the shell was interesting. Wouldn't get again but glad we tried them. read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

This pizza is delicious! The crust & toppings were perfect. Ordered the garlic cheese bread for the kids, they loved it. Highly recommend

I love this little pizza place. It's cute, service is always good. Consistency is always there. I love going with my 6 year old for our little mommy and me pizza dates. The fact that the owners are there working it, gives us such a better and more welcoming experience. read more

Great little local place that will be our go-to pizza place from now on. The pizza is light, not over sauced and the perfect size.

This place is terrible. Wouldn't recommend to anyone, even the hungry, ate one slice and immediately regretted everything. The service isn't even great to make up for the gross food. Undercooked and toppings seemed to not even be cooked with the pizza almost like an after thought. read more

This Pizza place it's a must try! Small cute little restaurant with 5-6 tables inside, very clean and very welcoming. We ordered a Medium pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms and it was very delicious. read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Mushrooms Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

Delicious pizza made in a real pizza oven. Family owned. Downtown Santa Paula. Give it a try.

Love the pizza here, quick! Generous with the sauce and the toppings, great crust. Really good pricing. Definitely recommend.

ordered a deep dish and It was amazing! Also staff are very friendly. I will Be back read more

We always get great quality pizza with Tuscany. The BBQ chicken has become a family favorite!

Excellent pizza and customer service...! No bathroom though. It's between a restaurant and a fast food. They have tables and chairs. Nice place on Main Street... Ofcourse lol read more

Omg, I was not expecting their vegetarian pizza to excite all the taste buds on my tongue. I have not had a pizza this good since I last visited Chicago. The more people that discover this little gem we have in santa paula, the harder it's going to be to even get an order in for your weekly pizza pie. Love this place!!! read more

I can't believe I haven't wrote a review yet. Been ordering from here for years. My favorite pizza in Ventura county. Yes, even better than the beloved 805 toppers. Oops I said it. Order the deep dish it's worth the hour wait. Excellent service and pizza. I think about this pizza more than I'd like to admit. read more

Dellllliiiicccccioooous !!!!!! Happy to have found this spot on our vacation . The small meat celebration is big enough for two people and the food is so fresh and tasty. The guy working the counter was a sweet kid and he helped us find a tasty coffee spot down the street. If we are ever up this way again we will definitely hit it up again . yummmm !!! read more

Tuscany Pizzeria - Yummmmy !!! - Pizza Near Me - Santa Paula, California

The pizza here is pretty good. The atmosphere is nice for the size of the restaurant. The service is also pretty good.

Amazing deep dish !!!! Try them all, you can't go wrong. They're the best in the west. Order an hour ahead for deep dish! Very friendly, kind service. Cannot express in words how good it is you just have to try It yourself? read more

Great food, absolutely fantastic! Food is made by a real culinary chef! They take a long time, they will say food will be ready in 30 minutes but it could be twice as long. The fruit salad was excellent when they first started, but not as good the last time I ordered. All in all , the food is really good. They have a great variety of flavors of pizza crust that you can choose from, they make it fresh. Everything is made fresh! Really good, just don't go if you are pressed for time. read more

I had the calzone and it was very good! This is definitely a spot to stop by if you're ever in Santa Paula. Nice place to sit down and enjoy your meal or order out. Staff was very welcoming with a great attitude. My family and I will definitely stop by again. read more