I've been wanting to try Starfish Scottsdale for quite some time, and we finally got a reservation…read morefor tonight. I'm so glad we did!
Before you even walk through the front door, you're greeted by a beautiful, colorful mural of an elegant Chinese woman in profile, surrounded by fish, sea plants and an underwater-inspired scene. It's a fun and unexpected backdrop that fits perfectly with Starfish's Asian seafood concept.
We arrived about 15 minutes early, so our table wasn't quite ready. The hostess kindly suggested we wait at the bar. The restaurant is divided into two dining areas, with the bar separating the front room from the inner dining area.
As we walked toward the bar, my boyfriend and I immediately noticed how LOUD the front dining room was. We continued toward the inner dining area and noticed a significant difference, the noise level was much more comfortable. We both agreed that dining in the front room would have been unpleasant, so I politely asked if we could sit in the inner dining area. Our request was accommodated, and we were seated almost immediately. We really appreciated it!
Honestly, if the only table available had been in the front room, we probably would have left and tried again another day. So if you're sensitive to noise, I would specifically request a table away from the front dining area.
Once seated, we were greeted almost immediately by our server, Jeff. He was professional, friendly and very helpful throughout the evening.
I asked Jeff which cocktail he would recommend if I wanted something sweet. I chose the Buddha's Kiss, while my boyfriend ordered the Piña Tini. My drink came with a salted rim, which wasn't my favorite, but Jeff was kind enough to switch it to a sugar rim. Much better! The Piña Tini was delicious, while I thought the Buddha's Kiss could have been a little sweeter.
Starfish has an extensive menu, so we asked Jeff for recommendations. He was great about pointing out some of the more popular dishes, which made choosing much easier.
We ordered the SoLag Drunken Noodles and Sambal String Beans to share. The Drunken Noodles were packed with flavor, savory, aromatic and perfectly seasoned with garlic, chili, Thai basil, vegetables and peanuts. The Sambal String Beans were equally delicious, with plenty of flavor and a nice combination of heat, savory seasoning and crispy shallots.
For our entrées, I ordered the Seafood Thai Curry and my boyfriend ordered the Candy Dragon Prawns. My curry came with prawns, sea bass, salmon, mussels, scallops and vegetables in a Thai green curry, served with coconut rice. It was delicious and full of flavor, although I personally wished it had been a little saucier. I would have loved more of that creamy Thai curry sauce, especially with the coconut rice.
My boyfriend also chose coconut rice with his Candy Dragon Prawns. I stole one bite of his prawns and ONE BITE was all it took! The prawn was fresh, tender and incredibly flavorful, with a delicious honey-citrus glaze and candied walnuts. Absolutely heavenly.
There was so much food that I had leftovers, which is always a win!
We were going to skip dessert, but then I saw the Mango Pudding and, of course, had to try it. Unfortunately, this was the weakest part of the meal. The mango itself was delicious, but the tapioca was quite congealed and didn't have the soft, creamy texture I expected. The coconut flavor was also very subtle. My suggestion would be to keep the tapioca fresher and perhaps be a little more generous with the coconut cream. I think the dessert could be excellent with a few adjustments.
Overall, we had a delightful dinner at Starfish Scottsdale. The menu is so extensive that there are still plenty of dishes we want to try, so we'll definitely be back. We may even come for happy hour, the selection looked pretty good!
If you're thinking about dining here, don't hesitate. The service is excellent, the food is flavorful, and for Scottsdale, I thought the prices were quite reasonable.
One important tip: if you prefer a quieter dining experience, request a table in the inner dining area rather than the front room. It made a HUGE difference for us.