Wow experience. Good food,nice draft beer selection . I loved the prices . Great environment with Greek traditional music . Very welcoming ISADORE owner 5/5 read more

Underhill Cafe - Chicken sandwich - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food was too overpriced for how average it was. I paid $97 for two people, not worth it. They do give free baklava at the end though, which is nice. read more

I genuinely think they must get their feta directly from god. What an absolute gift of a meal. The Greek salad is everything I want and more. The moussaka was equally delicious. Just incredible food every time. read more

I love this place. I come here regularly for the avgolemono soup. Good for kids too. Isidor is always a delight :)

fantastic food and the owner is the man. free baclava was insanely good too. will be back many times

Food was phenomenal! We took the bartender advise and had the special chicken with lemon wedge potatoes! Simply Devine! I would absolutely come back for the food and the bartender was incredibly sweet. Quaint restaurant with at home atmosphere. Baklava was excellent and a great finish for an amazing meal. read more

Underhill Cafe - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is by far my favorite go to restaurant for both brunch & dinner. Isidoros, is the best!!! He creates a welcoming atmosphere and makes you feel right at home. read more

Ordered a "falafel platter," got four undressed falafel balls sitting on top of fries with no pita or salad. read more

Underhill Cafe - Falafel Platter - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The recently opened restaurant has great food and even better service. The owner, Isidoro chatted with us and made great suggestions. We were also served complimentary baklava that was amazing!! The place is small and cute with simple decor. It was a cold day and it could use better insulation. I recommend giving it a try for a taste of Greece. read more

The hospitality at Underhill Cafe is so wonderful! The owner is Greek and is so warm and kind. Ordered the moussaka which was so delicious - you could definitely taste the nutmeg and cinnamon along with the layers of eggplant and potato at the bottom. Definitely recommend! read more

Food was good, the owner said everything was home made. Portions are large. Cute small ambiance read more

See all

Fantastic food combined with super friendly service. Isidoros is a gem and makes you feel like you're dining with family. Highly recommend. read more

This restaurant is amazing. The owner and staff were all very kind and welcoming and the food was phenomena! I recommend the shrimp saganaki! read more

caution when ordering online!!! sometimes they are closed and keep site up online and take your money and don't instantly resolve or update their site to reflect their business hours. On top of that: the items on menu are not what you are served. i have a limited lunch break and was told my order was ready. when i arrived, my steak sandwich with fries had no fries. asked if they could remedy, they tried to tell me that the item didn't come with a side when it CLEARLY states that sandwiches and burgers come with fries. otherwise it makes for overpriced average food. haven't left a review on yelp in years. this was the final straw. will not be returning. :/ read more

Underhill Cafe - a menu header that does not reflect what they offer. person there tried to tell me i am wrong. i am not illiterate. - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Neighborhood corner bar. Location at the corner of Dean and Underhill gives it a more local feel as opposed to the many bars on more heavily trafficked avenues like Vanderbilt and Washington. Five beers on draft. All were macros. They have a handful of tables outside plus a counter at the window which opens up. They had the windows and doors open which great a wonderfully breezy atmosphere on a beautiful day. I had a couple beers and we shared some fries. Service was friendly and attentive. There was one gender neutral restroom which handicap accessible. read more

The food honestly made me feel like I was back in Greece. Their portions are huge too which I always really appreciate and the prices are pretty affordable in my opinion. Their service is so nice too! I felt like we were getting food at a friend's house or something like that! They even served us some complementary baklava at the end which I wasn't expecting. This is definitely a good go to for Mediterranean food! read more

We were very excited to try this place. However, one of the staff--a older man was very rude. My 2 year old was playing with his fork at the table and he came and grabbed his hand and disciplined my son, telling him not to do that. Please do not discipline someone else's kid and keep your hands to yourself. If you have a problem with my son tell me about your issue,,but do not touch my 2 year old and grab his hand, that is not your place and it is not professional. It ruined our time there and we asked for the check and left immediately. The atmosphere was not welcoming. Food was okay,but not impressed, there are better restaurants available in the area. read more

Excellent clean Greek food in a cozy cafe reminiscent of those you'd find on the market streets of many Greek islands. Treated like family from the time I walked in. Will be back soon, don't sleep on this neighborhood gem. read more

Underhill Cafe - Classic Greek Salad, Greek Meatballs (keftedes), mythos - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We love this place. The food is great - we had a gyro platter and mousaka. Will be back. :)

Had a wonderful meal and dining experience for lunch here today. The moussaka was perfectly structured, layered, and seasoned, the greek and caesar salads fresh and prepared with care, and the baklava, yogurt, and sour cherries the unexpected and perfect ending to all that deliciousness. My husband and I sat outside with our dog, and the outdoor space is well shaded and quiet on a peaceful corner. The owner is very kind and it's obvious this restaurant is the result of his love of Greek cuisine and a wish to make his guests feel welcomed and content. read more

I was not pleased with my first order from this restaurant. $22 for a greek salad that barely filled a plate AND the GYRO did NOT meet expectations either. I specifically requested EXTRA WHITE sauce. Not only did they not add extra- they put NONE., I also asked for hot sauce which of course was also not added. The hummus was tasteless but the pita was nice and warm and soft. So $40+ for small salad, weak gyro and bland hummus w/ some soft pita bread. Never again, never again read more

Delivery came very quick. Ive been here a couple of times before and know the food is good. The spanakopita is outstanding. The lemon chicken is a large portion and delicious too. One recommendation is to ask them to wrap the container with the lemon chicken in foil or use a tighter container because most of the juices/sauce spilled out into the bag. They gave us 1 free baklava dessert which was nice and thanked us for the order. Great place! read more

See all

The chips that came with our gauc were so delicious, hot, and fresh. And great service! Would recommend!

We had dinner there last night, and really enjoyed the experience. Very enjoyable comfort food (chicken capresi sandwich for me, and spinach pie with salad for my husband) and a Malbec that was delicious and not expensive. Look forward to returning. read more

The bartender told me my boyfriend and I couldn't use the bathroom after we bought three Greek Alfa beers from here. She said the owner looked at the camera and said we weren't welcome even after tipping. She mentioned some nearby party that we had no involvement in. I asked again for two more Alfa and she then denied our business. We've been to nearby restaurants/stores in the neighborhood and have never been treated like this before. Underhill Brooklyn will never get my money again! read more

Paid $18 to get this pathetic, dry meal delivered to me. Came with an unnecessarily large salad. Do not recommend read more

Underhill Cafe - Chicken Souvlaki Platter - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I'd actually rate this place at more of a 3.5 than a 4 but, well, Yelp doesn't have half-star options. I guess going off the stellar reviews, I had pretty high expectations but idk, personally I wasn't really impressed? And as a fan of Mediterranean food, I REALLY wanted to like this place (even ordered twice, just in case they were having an off night the first time). Chicken souvlaki didn't have much flavor at all and although the lamb meatballs were admittedly tender, I wasn't the biggest fan of the sauce. The second time I ordered was a bit better-- their lamb burger was pretty good, liked how the flavors came together, just thought it was a tad greasy. Stuffed grape leaves were yummy; lemon potatoes were pretty typical but they gave a generous portion. They DO give you a small free dessert and I thought that was really nice of them. read more

This place was a clear miss for us on just about every dish (of which there were several)... we're not a fan.

I love this new neighborhood spot. The space inside isn't big so it's a cozy spot. They take reservations over the phone and have high chairs. They are very kid friendly and the waiter automatically offered plastic cups for the kids. They were very accommodating with us putting our stroller next to our table. We ordered the octopus, saganaki, Underhill pizza and their lamb special of the day. All of it was delicious with my favorite being the saganaki. They have a giant screen tv before the bar so could be a good place to come watch games and sports. I believe they also host events in their space as we came once and they were closed for an event. I loved our lunch here and would come again! read more

See all

3 stars for service 4 stars for food Occasion: Getting dinner with a friend on a Saturday night outdoors. Ambience: Started out with a semi chilly night, they do not have any heat lamps or outdoor lighting. Service: Started off nice, but as the night went on and they had to handle their takeout options, they started to forget about us. Eventually, we ended up waiting a full 15 minutes just to get takeaway boxes as we froze outside. I even had to call the restaurant because they literally did not visit our table this entire time as we were waiting, then the waiter had forgotten multiple requests for takeaway boxes and it was a whole ordeal checking out. Food: The spanakopita was a huge slice - well flavored We got a lamb gyro platter with fries - these were pretty well flavored, nice slices of meat, large portion size Lastly we got the pasticchio dish - a Greek comfort food - almost like a Lasagna - this was also pretty great with creamy sauces and rich flavors. This came with a soup that was green and unfortunately flavorless, so we set it aside. The salad was pretty standard but pretty large. Tips/Takeaways: -Probably better for takeaway -Food is pretty great - lamb gyro platter, spanakopita were highlights for me -Service/outdoor dining in the cold was not great read more

Decent Greek food and nice staff! I am vegetarian and had a falafel platter, it was healthy and wasn't greasy at all! They have couple of seats on sidewalk if you are planning to stay! read more

Underhill Cafe - Glass of wine during corona - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This Greek restaurant in Prospect Heights has blown me away. It is located on Dean St. The decor is delightful. The windows add a very nice touch. My boyfriend and I enjoyed our table at the window as we ate dinner. It is a family established restaurant with excellent service. Everyone is very friendly. We ordered the Lamb Keftedes, Sesame & Honey Saganaki, & the Underhill Lamb Burger. All were delicious. Our favorite was the Sesame & Honey Saganaki. The fried cheese with the honey & sesame seeds with tahini herb purée is amazing. It is a very well rounded dish. We will definitely come here again and again for it! The food tastes very fresh, and the house made pita comes out very warm. I can not recommend this place enough! My boyfriend and I already have our sights on what try next time we are there. read more

Underhill Cafe - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This Greek place is (kinda) on fleek but not entirely. I was driving by when this eatery popped up on my Yelp radar. I didn't have time dine so I decided to do takeout. Underhill Brooklyn is at the corner of Underhill and Dean street. Even though the place is on the smaller scale, it's spacious enough to accommodate small groups (tables can be placed together). Decor is modern and simple. They have a nice bar area with bar stools and a television mounted on the wall for happy hour. Beer and wine menu selection is somewhat minimal but choices are easy. Staff was very welcoming. I was presented a menu along with a smile. Staff also said they have happy hour special ($2 off beers) as well if I decided to stay. Everything on the menu looked exotic and attractive but I selected three items to experiment with: zucchini croquettes, grilled halloumi and grilled chicken skewers. Menu prices are up there so just be prepared to break out a few dollars if you order expensive food dishes. I was pleasantly impressed with the flavor of the food. My favorite was the zucchini croquettes. The zucchini croquettes are not the breaded kind but a square-shaped appetizer that is flavorful and packed with rich seasoning. It's a bit mushy and better to eat it with a fork. Grilled halloumi was interesting. It was kinda salty but overall tasty. It's basically semi-hard, specialty cheese that can be fried or grilled. Unfortunately, the disappointment was the grilled chicken skewers. Maybe I was expecting something else but I didn't like the texture of the chicken. It was a grayish colored (maybe it was dark meat?) and rubbery. I just couldn't eat it. Now the pita bread...oh yeah. It was delicious, soft and fresh. Oh yeah, lol. I was just eating this like no tomorrow. Pita bread was the bomb. Overall, this place provides quality Greek food but I still need a few more visits to really decide if it will be a fav. I definitely want to try their salads and salmon. read more

Underhill Cafe - Takeout flow (clockwise): zucchini croquettes, tomato, pita bread, grilled haloumi and grilled chicken skewers with a dip. - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Truly delicious food, im generous portions. Two dishes--the rusk salad and crispy Brussel sprouts (with pistachio!)--were favorites, along with the special lasagna. But everything was enjoyed and eaten. Ordering over the phone and window pick-up was super easy, and the person taking the order was patient with and helpful to us, as "first timers". Also very much appreciated the care the restaurant took with their social distancing and best-practice protective covering. We will definitely be back. read more

Amazing delivery food. Fresh ingredients, clean, tasty. The pita was still warm when it got to my house. Affordable good and healthy food options. Thanks for the complimentary mini baklava! Definitely will be my go to for affordable, healthy and good food during this next lockdown. read more

Underhill Cafe - Baklava - Greek Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We've been waiting for what seems like over 2 years for this place to finally open and I'm so glad it finally did! We finally have a Greek place right around the corner! Give me pitas, olives and tziki sauce and I'm a happy girl. We came here for brunch, which I'm sure isn't where they shine as their dinner menu looked a lot better. Never the less, I ordered a classic eggs Benedict but Greek style of course. And by Greek I'm mean they sprinkled the eggs with feta cheese and served with a side of pita bread, which I loved! There was also a side of (I'm sorry to say) very bland hash browns. My boyfriend got the burger with fries that were seasoned to perfection so I'm going to say maybe they just forgot to season my hash browns? The brunch deal is pretty good with a main brunch dish you can have bottomless drinks for an extra $17 ( including mimosas, Bellinis, beers on tap and coffee/tea) but it only lasts an hour. It's okay though they were pretty generous and totally worth it! They also have an amazing happy hour during the week that lasts until 5-9PM! Can't really complain there! The place is really nice and has TVs to keep everyone entertained. We'll definitely be coming back! read more

See all

I just love this place! I called today to order my usual shrimp pita. Apparently, they switched up the menu recently and no longer have it listed. However, the woman who answered the phone was incredibly generous and offered to make it for me anyways. Just some old school hospitality and tasted just as good as I remember. Also, their pita bread and eggplant dips are unbelievable. Arguably some of the best Greek food I've had. read more

BRUNCH! We were looking for a local brunch spot that was relatively close to the Botanical Gardens and decided on this venue. Mediterranean-fusion styled brunch. $17 for brunch item plus one free brunch-drink and coffee/tea = good deal. I think for an additional $12 you could have unlimited drinks for an hour. (def check out the specs). The restaurant was not all that busy but the service was kinda slow. Not sure why. I normally go for the eggs benedict but had eggs in the am sooooo I ordered the french toast with jelly and nutella. Felt they were a little skimpy on the nutella and jelly but was otherwise tasty. My friends enjoyed their entrees which were served with pita bread, goat cheese etc(Mediterranean feel). Overall: not a bad brunch place to visit, esp if in the area. Wouldn't make this a destination spot though. read more

See all

Love, love, love this place! If I lived closer, this would be my Cheers. The staff is kind and accommodating. And the.. FOOD! Delicious! The portions are very generous (I would suggest sharing), and the ingredients are fresh. We've had the spanikopita, the dips, pretty much all the salads and I'm a sucker for the chicken souvlaki. It's a cozy and welcoming environment and they'll often play Greek music too. Highly recommend giving this place a shot. You won't be disappointed! read more

This place used to be the bomb when it was Greek! They are opened as an American comfort food fare and still offer lamb gyros and "Greek salad." However, for $40 my Greek salad had lettuce in it and two very small pieces of feta, and the lamb gyro was literally two pieces of lamb with a white drizzle of some sort with nothing else that came with fries and a plain side salad. Sadly not worth the price tag or the fare. The guys are super nice and threw in a piece of cake but it's sadly not the same quality as it was prior. Wish it would go back to Greek!! read more