We had a great time at Village Supper Club - even braving the snow and ice to get there for our first visit! We came on a whim when someone told us about it and made the only reservation I could find that evening...the second they opened! Even so, we were not the first ones there. We had amazing seats - facing the outside. The room is gorgeous with soaring ceilings and plenty of dark wood giving very cozy vibes. Service was quite good - friendly and didn't rush us - though I know they had plenty of reservations coming in behind us. The food was great - portions large and everything delicious. Burgers to kids ice creams! Definitely worth a stop in but I highly recommend reservations unless you're prepared to wait. And if you have to wait - the bar is gorgeous. read more

Outstanding ! Can't believe we have never been here till today ! We truly enjoyed everything here , the décor and 50's and 60's music playing sets the mood. Like walking back into the 60's , a true old time super club ! Our waitress Brie was the BEST , so polite and attentive to all our needs. Timed all courses out perfectly ! The food all was perfect , my pork shank was one of the best I have had in a long time , my wife had the salmon and it was cooked perfectly ! Overall we give this a firm 5 star rating. We will be back ! Can't wait to try their prime rib ! read more

See all

I had dinner at the Club twice in the last week and was extremely disappointed in both cases due to the very delayed service and the food was cold when it did arrive. In one case it was a party of four adults and the other a party of 6 adults and two children. In the last situation the kids orderd off the kids menu and the food was not delivered until after the adults recieved their much delayed meals. We had to ask twice where were the kids meals. The restaurant is beautiful but we have given up on the expensive food of poor quality and non existent service. The Club needs to have a kitchen manager. I think the food sits while other parts of the order are prepared. read more

Ambiance was great, loved the booth and the view can't be beat. Old fashioned was delicious also. That's about where it ends. Chicken was over cooked and the rice was soaked in sauce. Kids meals came with some mandarin oranges, no option for any other side. Walleye was bland, potatoes were good. Relish tray is extra, not included, and doesn't have liver patè. We asked for dessert and were told there was chocolate cake, not flourless chocolate cake. We had seen it brought out to several tables prior to us ordering, but it was the end of the night we figured they ran out. Nope! She offered it to the table next to us about 5 minutes later! We would go back for a cocktail and to sit outside with the view, not for a $200+ dinner. read more

WOW! This place is such a gem and I think not talked about enough with the best supper clubs in Wisconsin! Having just visited the iconic Del-Bar my experience here had a lot to live up to. What they did better: *steak flavor: the NY strip was unbeatable! The seasoning used on the steak made it. Portion size for the price was amazing also. *view: looking out at the lake during sunset is magical! I didn't go on the back patio but the fireplace was going and it would be a perfect date night stop. What the could improve on: *speed of service: I've seen other reviews state this as well. Wasn't overly long but we definitely had to prompt our server to take our order and get more drinks! But if a nice slow dinner is what you prefer this place is perfect. *dirty martini- could've been dirtier!! *French onion soup- it's hard to live up to a soup that takes 3 days to make though.. Overall, this is in my top 2 for supper clubs in Wisconsin so far!! read more

Village Supper Club - Salmon - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

See all

The building and views obviously are what is the draw is here at the lake. The food however, not so much. Four of us and the meals were disappointing- steaks (ribeye) did not appear to have been of quality- chicken sandwich cold and not edible. Green goddess wedge was good. Good server but, the food service was painfully sloooow.... Come for the view, have a drink and mooooove on for dinner somewhere else. read more

We arrived at 4pm when the Village Supper club opened. Ample parking across the street. We made a reservation late so we sat in the bar at the high tops tables. We were greeted by our server who was very pleasant while telling us the specials. I ordered an old fashioned because that's what you do in Wisconsin supper clubs. We got the relish tray which was excellent. It came with a giant cheese ball which went well with the pretzels, celery, carrots and cucumbers. My wife liked the sweet pickle. Good deal for $8. I got a cup of the New England clam chowder. It was good but a little thin. I ordered Friday fish fry bluegill and my wife got the roasted chicken. The fish was accompanied by two potato cakes. It was good but I wanted more for $26. My wife's chicken was good but nothing special. I got another old fashioned because that's what you do in Wisconsin supper clubs. Ordered a piece of the chocolate cake to share but it was really small. Overall, I liked this supper club, but I should have ordered a steak. read more

See all

Retro decor was well done... server Luke was top-notch... crusted Walleye was excellent ... green beans were incredible and Boursin Mashed was perfect... Red wine Stags Leap never disappoints. Appetizer was the traditional Relish Tray... read more

See all

Save your money. I used to love the old supper club with the prior owners. It has been rebuilt with new ownership. The lake view is outstanding, the facility is very nice, with outside areas to relax before and after dinner with a cocktail. However, dinner was third rate. I couldn't help but think that within a few miles, I could have had a marvelous dinner, at a fraction of the cost. Dinner for 4 was $400 with tip. I expected more. Service was ok. I won't be back read more

10/10 restaurant ambiance. Enjoyed every part of the meal from the delicious rolls to the salad with the best green goddess dressing and the fillet with the whipped potatoes and squash. Fun place to enjoy even in the winter. I'd love to go back in the summer!! read more

See all

As always another incredible evening spent at Village Supper Club. The meal was spectacular as was the service and ambiance. A LG must! read more

See all

This was my first supper club experience and it did not disappoint. This place is a 10/10 for me. We came here for a birthday dinner celebration and Sam provided the type of service you'd expect in fine dining. The food and vibes were incredible, highly recommend. read more

Absolutely amazing facility!! Such an amazing change from the original club that had that small German bar feel. This is much larger with a very upscale menu, appearance and feel. Food was absolutely amazing. We had a large order with appetizers and meals and everything was outstanding! All the staff members we interacted with were all outstanding!! Rather pricey but for what you get you would expect this. They also have a fabulous outdoor covered patio and uncovered patio with fire pits and a great view of the lake! Will definitely be returning in the future! read more

We have been dining at the Village Supper Club every couple years for 50 years. We decided to go back as we were in the area. We had not been there in several years. What a shock. The quaint, authentic Wisconsin supper club was gone, replaced by a fancy, high priced restaurant that in no way could be considered a "Supper Club". I had a ground steak burger, which was very good. My wife had French onion soup which was mediocre. We both agreed we would not return. read more

Well, we made reservations on a Friday night for my birthday and there was four of us and it was such a beautiful place. I can't even tell you the ambience if you wanna call it that was absolutely breathtaking reminded me of an old 60s lounge in Las Vegas beautiful booth they were turquoise they were you shaped they were gorgeous. They had the whole back of the restaurant was glass. There was a patio you could go onto, but it was very windy and cool that night so we did not go outside but in the summer that would be the place to go. The bar was absolutely fabulous. Huge bar probably 30 seats at it. The drinks were excellent. You could have any kind of drink you wanted even some that used to be popular years ago that you don't often see anymore. They also had lots of IPAs in different kinds of beers. If that's what you like the food was excellent. It was served absolutely elegantly. The plates were gorgeous. The servers were very, very nice and accommodating. In every way. We really enjoyed ourselves. Definitely go there if you want a dining experience go there. read more

Disappointment The good: The filet was properly cooked and tender. The views were great. The service was great. The French onion had a nice beefy flavor. The dinner rolls were flavorful and soft The bad: The asparagus looked, tasted and felt like it had been on a steam table all day long. The Brandy Peppercorn sauce for the filet tasted neither of Brandy nor Peppercorn. It reminded me of a jarred brown sauce you might find at a discount grocery store during the holidays. The only flavor that comes from it was a bitter burnt ick. To add insult to injury, you pay $5 for a thimble sized portion. They also employ some outcome-based public-school math. There is a $3 price difference between the soup of the day and French onion soup if you order it ala-cart. However, there is $8 price difference if you upgrade the same soup of the day that comes with your meal to the French onion. Just when you think that you can't get disappointed more, you take home dessert. In our case, what they called "chocolate lava cake". Words cannot fully express how gross that cake was. It reminded me of a stale dense overcooked Hostess cupcake without the filling. There was no 'lava' just some chocolate something on top of the cupcake. If you want to chill out on their patio with a beer and soak in the lake views, then this is the place to do it. If you are hungry, eat somewhere else first. read more

Amazing amazing place. Beautiful inside and out. Martini made perfectly. My pork dish was the highlight of the table. And the bread ugh the bread is a do not skip. Excited to try more off their menu! read more

See all

Came here for my husband's birthday last night and had the most lovely evening. Our server went above and beyond with explaining each detail of food that we ordered to ensure that it was something we would love. She was excellent. We started off with the cheese curds that came with two types of dipping sauces- they were delish. And then we tried the deep fried mashed potato app. Very different but we enjoyed it! For our mains we obviously had to try the fish fry since it was Friday. They offer the fish fry to come 4 different ways. I had the baked and fried option and loved both. My husband said the breading on his fried cod was just too thick and didn't love it but the fish itself was really good. The fish fry came with potato pancakes, apple sauce, homemade tartar sauce and coleslaw. It was so much food! SO good. Just what I had hoped the fish fry would be. My husband also got the lobster bisque soup- and talked about it the whole way home lol it was divine. Since it was his birthday they brought out a chocolate molten cake that he could not get enough of. I had the 3 layered chocolate cake and it was the best chocolate cake I've ever eaten. The view is spectacular, the ambiance is gorgeous. What more could you want from a supper club? Can't wait to come back and try something else ! read more

Beautifully remodeled supper club/steakhouse. We made reservations months in advance (hard to come by!) and finally got to have the best meal and experience. We made sure to grab a patio drink and watch the beautiful sunset over the lake as well. We then sat at the interior bar and listened to the lovely Sinatra music while waiting for our table. There were tvs too to play the college football games this Saturday night which was perfect! As for our meal- we started with the mussels, which were in a nice creamy chowder-y broth. This was delicious with the garlicky complimentary soft rolls. We got the prime rib and boneless ribeye for our meals, and we surprisingly finished all of this scrumptious meat. Cooked and flavored so well, so it was easy to just keep eating! We definitely didn't have room for dessert unfortunately, but everything we had was exquisite and the experience amazing and romantic. read more

Village Supper Club - Mussels - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

See all

What a gem! Tucked away in a residential neighborhood on Lake Delavan, I dined here over Labor Day weekend with a good friend of mine. The atmosphere is inviting and modern, while still maintaining supper club roots. We started with the relish tray and I had the half chicken. It was one of the best meals I've ever had in the Lake Geneva area. The entire staff was very kind and hospitable. The prices are on the higher side so definitely more of a special occasion place, but I will definitely be back! read more

See all

This place brings back the true supper club feel. Lots of cocktails and cozy dining area feel. Good variety of items on the menu, as well as a very friendly staff. The menu hosts several fancy options or even a simple burger if you aren't feeling fancy. Their Friday fishy fry is quite popular as well. Bit pricey, but that is expected for a finer dining atmosphere. read more

Everything about it was great. Service,Menu and ambiance. We are going back tonight.

Had a wonderful dinner here. The ambiance was beautiful, the service was attentive and kind, and the food was delicious. I had the duck and the skin was perfectly crispy with the inside incredibly moist. I tried someone's ribs and they were quite smoky, so that's worth noting depending on preference. Others ordered the pork ribeye and walleye and they enjoyed them. Looking forward to coming back in the summer. read more

Village Supper Club - Roasted duck - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

See all

Been to the Supper Club a few times already. Made reservations very early for a table facing the lake - never got a table there...ugh.. Also their menu is lacking a good mix of entrees...not a big selection to pick from. We got the pork chop and chicken dinner .... Both were disappointing. read more

Food was excellent. We went for our wedding anniversary last night. I had the best ribs I ever had and my wife had salmon that was outstanding read more

Always tasty, ambiance is top-notch (including music), and service is great. Don't sleep on the appetizers!!! They are even better than the meals! read more

Disappointment on Delavan The food, the service, the view - at least they got 1 thing right, hence the 1 star. Service - nice enough server and she tried but too slow with everything on a Saturday night. She kept saying the kitchen get's mad when she asks for things - never a good sign. Food - Burger - cold. 2 medium filets - both cold and one well done and the other rare. Ribs - good but also lukewarm. We only paid for the ribs after speaking to the manager. View - can't beat the view, the one positive along with the ceasear salad (hard to screw up a relish tray and if you screw up cheese curds in WI, you shouldn't be in the restaurant business) After reading the reviews, I was expecting things to be slow and the food to be hit or miss (hence the birthday burger) but this was unacceptable. No food should be delivered cold. Unless they fix things, all the updating and views will be for nothing. Not rushing back anytime soon. read more

See all

This is the second time I've been to Village Supper Club, the first time was prior to the remodel and now this time - What a transformation!!! The space is incredible! Lovely lake views as well . We sat in main dining area which is a combination of booths and tables . There is outdoor seating with fire pits but did not get the opportunity to sit outside this visit. I had the Walleye which was amazing! Parking lot is directly across the street and I would recommend reservations. I am looking forward to returning! read more

See all

Beautiful supper club on Delavan Lake. Easy parking across the street. Make reservations. Staff is very friendly and helpful. Food is delicious! Try the shrimp johnue and the walleye with a spotted cow. You won't regret it! read more

Village Supper Club - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

See all

Although the food was okay, the service was abysmal. Our waiter, Luke, should find another line of work. The food FINALLY arrived COLD. Having it brought to the appropriate temperature took forever. The manager informed us that we were wrong about the service. Let's just say there will not be a return trip. Avoid at all cost. read more

Beautifully renovated with a great view of the lake and outdoor fire pits. I recommend making reservations.

If you don't have a reservation, lots of luck. Good food,service and ambiance is at this place! Opened at 4:00 on Saturday and arrived on time, seated immediately. What amazed me was how you the staff was and how courageous and efficient they were. Luke our server very knowledgeable and tentative! Newly renovated dining area very spacious and surprisingly quiet with a nice view if you are lucky enough to get a window seat (we made reservations and requested window seating) Now the food, outstanding and huge portion, well presented and delicious! It was extra for the relish tray but a very good trade off. My wife's Old Fashion was top shelf. Desert was not on the menu but our server had it down tack for us! Multiple stars for this Resturant in Delavan! read more

See all

The ambiance of this delicious restaurant was superb. The service was great and the food was even better. We sat at a hightop near the bar and had a view of the gorgeous lake and its sunset. I love the fact that boats can drive up, park, dine and leave. There is also a great outdoor seating area. I recommend making reservations in advance. I ordered the muscles and they were outstanding! It was a bit pricey. I definitely recommend this restaurant for everyone! read more

Delicious dinner and drinks. Started off with a Wisconsin classic, brandy old fashioned sweet. The bar was beautiful and the staff were friendly. Sat down at the table and ordered the New York strip, with the squash soup. The soup was the best squash soup I have tasted!! Especially with the garnish on top. The steak was done perfectly - medium rare, and the potatoes paired very well with it. The classic supper club setting was so relaxing! It wasn't too loud, and the server was friendly. Already looking at availability to make another reservation!! read more

Village Supper Club - New York strip steak - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

See all

Disapoinment in Supper Clubs. Although the steak and mussels were on point, the french onion soup was so sad. No taste, so bland, even dumping salt in the soup did not do the trick. Being a french onion soup condisour, I was so bummed! The Hob Knob in Racine still holds best soup ever! read more

Any reviews prior to January 2024 should be ignored. This is a completely new restaurant. The decor, service, ambiance, and food make for a fantasitci experience. The only downside is the difficulty getting a reservation and a parking spot. We had Friday Fish fry; the bluegill, and the cod (both fried and broiled) All were delicious. The mussel appetizer was outstanding and the relish tray included, among other treats, heirloom carrots. The wine selection is decent and the bartender made the best Cosmopolitan! Thank you to the new owners for saving and bringing new life into this lakeside gem! You did everything right! Can't wait to return during patio season. (and the bathroom wallpaper is a fun touch. kudos!) read more

See all

Average restaurant. Burger was bland. Sweet potato appetizer was ok. Fish dinner no flavor. Very bland food.. they recommended ribeye however we didn't try it. Sent My girlfriend the wrong wine. Server was not available. So manager came to our table and also sent the wrong wine again? LOL...go figure. The ambiance is very nice however on the lake. I'd make it a steak house myself. Perfect setting for it. read more

The blonde bartender outside is extremely rude, she was ride to the older ladies behind us swell. Or 2nd drink we got from indoor bar, the guys were much more pleasant. Do better, I can spend my money elsewhere read more

Village Supper Club - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

Our server Andrew and his assistant Hunter were just incredible. They really made the night. We started off rough when we came in and asked to sit by windows and were told we have reservations for windows and we had reservations too. Reluctantly at best they sat us by windows. The boys saved our night. Let's go to the food. I'm allergic to tree nuts and noted it on our reservation. We ordered a relish tray and the cheese came topped with almonds. I was totally disappointed. Andrew asked to switch ours but we took care of that ourselves. There is no substitute for cheese with almonds. Again I used green goddess dressing and moved on. Steaks were great. Cooked perfect. Mashed potatoes were not great. I would not get them again. Overall beautiful restaurant. Front of house needs to match the service of wait staff. Expect slow service. Enjoy your dinner. It is worth it. read more

We love the Village Supper Club! The Friday Night fish fry is awesome you have to start it out with the relish tray. We tried to dine there at least twice a month because of the service and quality of food. read more

Village Supper Club - Great place to have a relaxing cocktail either before or after dinner. - Seafood Near Me - Delavan, Wisconsin

See all