We ate here recently and were disappointed. The restaurant was not crowded yet the parking lot was full. Parking was difficult, the employees must take up the spots. My friend's chicken sandwich was dry and nothing special. My crab cake sandwich had absolutely NO crab in it. None at all. It was a fried bread patty. I could not eat it. I asked for water because we were not given any and we never got it. I even watched the server fill her personal water bottle right in front of us. This place is in need of major improvements. Avoid read more

We found ourselves way out east over the weekend, and realized we were an hour from home and should find someplace to have lunch. We asked Google Maps what is good and nearby. We were told that Watermark was five minutes away, and people liked it. We verified that in Yelp, and sure enough, let's go. This is not the sort of place you'd find by accident - on a minor coastal road and pretty much off by itself. The parking lot was so packed that we had to give up on it and park on the road. We were told that there would be a slight delay for a table, but seeing the enthusiastic crowd, we figured it might be worth it. It was. We got a really great roomy table, and our server was a gem. Looking back over the reviews here, we got their star quarterback in Connor, who sat down at a spare chair and talked to us about what to eat. Within two minutes, we were old friends. I'm a big fan of originality in menus, and they had it to spare. I ended up with the fried chicken sandwich and Donna had the Left Coast sandwich. Ham turkey and swiss on crainberry bread. They were both delicious and too much for one sitting. Connor even offered to wrap my mayo. The vibe was enthusiastic but not horribly loud, the food was unifromly great and the service was superior. We now have a go-to place in the Riverhead area. read more

See all

Went to lunch @ the watermark with 5 other ladies. We all enjoyed out orders Service is good, good atmosfere! read more

I recently stayed in the area for a wedding and was looking for somewhere fun to get breakfast the next morning. This place had really good reviews, so decided to check it out. They had a lot of fun options, but I got the "ultimate pancakes", which had bananas and blueberries, and also ordered a side of bacon. The service was great and food came out quickly! The onlyyy thing I wish they had was flavored iced coffee, but I was happy with the orange juice instead, so it's not a huge deal. Would definitely come back! read more

Watermark of Wading River - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Wading River, New York

November 17th 2024 - Fairly packed, so be prepared. We had reservation and arrived 7 minutes after 11 am opening and a little table work but had a good 4 top/hi top at the bar. Packed by the time we left!! Connor was simply world class waiter and the bus servers and the well played one defense from other servers was exceptional. Attentive but not pesky. The food was as expected terrific. As a hobbyist food critical, I reviewed over 30 restaurants for breakfast excellence in FL The classic eggs Benedict here would.habe been a top 5 finisher in Florida. And you can get it eight here in Long Island!!!! Eggs were textbook and perfect. Ham and muffin cooked.perfecy and arrived hot with exact amount of hollandaise sauce that was smooth and silky. Other breakfasts were also great. Multi grain bread great. On dish had some burnt pieces. No.biggy. the hash browns/potatoes, we a little cool / room temp, again just some attention of delivery or kitchen exit. Place is surgical operating room clean tableware, rest rooms, floors, tables, glassware...etc like.they opened yesterday!! Truly impressive. read more

See all

Good luncheon with a lovey group of women. Food was great and the lunch even included a glass of wine. Neat clean friendly.

Another awesome experience. I had the Watermark salad with salmon and it was perfect- dressed well but not too much and salmon had the best crisp on the outside. My mom has the quesadilla and she loved it. Good wines by the glass for happy hour- including local stuff! (Paumanok etc) Lori (bartender) was very attentive but gave us plenty of time to relax and catch up - even during happy hour rush. Great local spot read more

First time here after biking with my husband and son. We absolutely loved it. Such a cute interior and outdoor seating. Breakfast was delicious. Coffee on point and service excellent! Really friendly staff and always willing to help with recommendations. We will come back this fall when we come out east! read more

We ate watermark salad to start and meatloaf and short ribs for entrees. The salad was wilted and the dressing was like a super sweet strawberry jelly. The short ribs and meatloaf were served hot, too much gravy on both, needed larger portion of veggies. Rice was boring-Tasted like microwave bag. Short ribs had good amount of fat and I could cut it without a fork. Meatloaf was soft and flavorful. The host was upbeat and friendly and our server was outstanding. He came down to our eye level to talk about the menu, make eye contact and check on us through out the meal. For dessert we had carrot cake. It tasted like a coffee shop muffin. Nothing special. Overall food was ok, but could be better especially with high priced menu. The staff was the best part of the restaurant. read more

See all

Everything! Great service. Friendly staff. Delicious food. Love going to Watermark! read more

First time we went there was a Saturday without reservations and they were able to sit us right away. However we went back on a Sunday lunch time and it was a 45 min wait so we left. Service was good. Food is ok. Ambiance is nice. Parking is a little difficult. read more

See all

Food and service are so good! Nice casual local hidden gem. Only complaint is it gets very loud when it's crowded, which basically is any weekend night for dinner. Menu has a great variety of choices and everything is fresh and delicious. Specialty Cocktails are great. Not weak at all. Been here multiple times and always impressed with the food. We love nearby, so this is now part of our regular rotation of local places to have dinner. read more

When I visit Long Island I like to go to a new place each time. This place is so good, I've gone twice! The food and drink menu have so many choices and the staff is amazing. Both times I've had no issues walking in for a table. Surrounding area is so beautiful as well! read more

Watermark of Wading River - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Wading River, New York

See all

First time visiting this restaurant and has an extraordinary experience. Both the food and service were fantastic. Had an opportunity to meet and speak with the owner who delivered food to our table (and offered some future recommendations if we revisited and we will). Staff were courteous, friendly and very professional. Restaurant was small but comfortable and inviting with outside seating available. Upon exiting we noticed a small outside seating area available to those waiting on a table. As I'm writing this 4 weeks after my visit I can't recall what my dish was but believe me every dish and appetizer were worth the visit. I remember the pumpkin mule drink which was great as well. Overall great place for dinner or lunch. read more

We ordered the fried calamari as an appetizer. It was very crispy but when shared between 5 hungry people, the portion size was not enough for us lol. We definitely should've ordered 2 of those. I ordered the monte cristo which was so so delicious! It came with a huge serving of sweet potato fries and the sandwich was drizzled with powdered sugar and syrup. The perfect balance of sweet and savory. One of the servers even commented how I had made a good choice in ordering it as it was a crowd favorite. The classic eggs Benedict, the hungry man omelette, and egg sandwich were the perfect portion. The home fries were very flavorful and crispy on the outside yet soft in the inside. Reasonably priced for brunch. Staff was friendly and accommodating. It does get loud inside as the tables are close to each other. There's parking available but it's definitely hard to find a spot when it's busy. Will definitely come back if I'm in the area again! read more

See all

Never disappointed there! Great Food and service. Very relaxed atmosphere and affordable prices.

Great food and fun cocktails for Happy Hour. Bri our bartender is an expert at drinks! read more

See all

I've eaten here several times. It's a very nice place with good food. Do I need to say more? Highly recommended. read more

Absolutely delicious grilled cheese and chocolate mousse dessert. The place was packed so that is definitely tanked. There aren't many good places to eat around here anymore so it's nice to have a good meal here, thank you. read more

Excellent experience at Watermark. It is a hidden gem that I only found because of Yelp. The inside is modern and clean. Menu has good options for both food and cocktails/wine. Our waitress was incredibly friendly, patient and helpful as well as ALL of the staff. Everyone was so nice which I find unusual these days for a restaurant. It really gave such a friendly feeling. We dined with a toddler and everyone was so gracious. The staff would come over to him and interact etc. The waitress had a plain flat bread pizza made for him and brought him a kids cup. The short rib quesadilla app was great and hearty. I had the crab cake sandwich with a side salad and my husband had a burger. I love the option of a side salad! Most definitely would dine here again and highly recommend to others! Fantastic customer service! read more

See all

Very popular place . Service was impeccable,I've been there 3 times with different servers and they were top notch. The food also was great . Only problem was it gets noisy. read more

Excellent family sunday brunch with buttermilk pancakes, waffles, breakfast burrito and tuna salad sandwich. Everything was delicious and the service was great! read more

Watermark of Wading River - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Wading River, New York

Food was great. The staff is amazing. Great atmosphere. 10/10 recommend. Perfect spot for brunch, lunch, and dinner.

What a nice place. Lunch was great. Service was on spot. No place you can have a lunch with a drink. At there prices

Delicious chicken sand-which! Quick service. Beautiful inside architecture. Go here or you'll miss out on a peak chicken sand-which.

This was our first time trying this restaurant. This place is adorable. Clean, bright, the tables weren't on top of one another. The food was spectacular. I had the thanksgiving dinner dish while my husband had the swordfish. We got cheesesteak for dessert. The staff was welcoming and super nice. Our waitress Andrea was super attentive and helpful but not overly in your face. We will definitely be back. read more

Watermark of Wading River - Pumpkin beer - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Wading River, New York

If I could give 1000 stars I would. Checked every box- food, service and ambiance. Will definitely be going back.

Try this restaurant on a whim and it was fantastic! My husband, son and myself went for lunch. I had the cranberry bread with avocado, turkey, bacon, and lots of other things on the sandwich with onion rings delicious. The onion rings were crispy, and the cranberry bread was delicious with the turkey, etc.. My husband had a steak sandwich with fig jam, which was absolutely delicious and my son had a burger and fries. Everything was made to perfection. Can't wait to drive out to Wading River and try this restaurant again! read more

We hosted a party of 20 for lunch after a one-year memorial visit to Calverton. This was the perfect place. Service was fantastic, ambiance was great and the food was excellent. The pricing is beyond reasonable. I highly recommend. Small or large party, you cannot go wrong. read more

Love this place, which opened during the pandemic, and it's been a welcomed addition to Wading River. It is at the start of the North Fork. It's like my Cheers, where everyone knows my name and is a friendly, family run restaurant. Camille, who is one of their primary bartenders, makes everyone feel like family, when sitting at the bar. The food is solid and comforting. Try the short-rib quesadilla, which is offered on the regular menu and daily happy hour times. read more

Pleasant atmosphere. Good service snd excellent food and drinks!!! Tried restaurant on a Friday night. Nice crowd but got table right away. The service was excellent and thoroughly enjoyed the food, a special that night. read more

We decided to begin our brunching adventure at the Watermark.  It has a rustic, clean, cute decor, farm to table atmosphere.  As I write this review, they are playing great Elton John music.  The waitress was amazing.  We asked her for a local fish market recommendation.  She went above and beyond, asking other coworkers for suggestions where to make our purchase.   The food was good.  We both had omelets with side of potatoes and multigrain bread.  The potatoes were not our style but the omlets were great.  If we could make one suggestion, it would be, that you go  the bathroom before you arrive or be prepared with an N95 mask.  We say this because there is only one bathroom per gender (whatever that means these days).  We noticed a highly intoxicated female who exited the bathroom and required assistance leaving the restaurant.  After her departure, the next person to use such bathroom briskly exited stating "I just can't".  We'll let you use your imagination to surmise what happened in there.   All in all, we had a very nice experience and the menu appears to have a lot other very nice options.  Highly recommend stopping in, if you're in the area. read more

Bon G and I were last at this location when it was Michael Anthony several years ago,. Upon arrival we were greeted by Nick, very welcoming and asked if we were walk ins or with rezzy. Fortunatly we had had rezzy for 7pm and were seated a nice private table... Connor, our server was on point and appeared at our table immediately. We conversed and reminiced having been there before and now returning as Watermark. Everything looked basically the same and the Service and Food was still wonderful although different...much more laid back and affordable! We started with cocktails; Bloody Maria and a Bourbon Manhattan...both Excellent! For appys we had Bucket of Mussels in a great white wine and garlic sauce...came with incredible toast for dipping! For Mains, Bon had the Sea Scallop Special which was like Butta! I had a delish Sliced Prime Rib sandwich with a special horseradish sauce they made up for me...was Marvelous! We had such a nice time and Connor was terrific and made sure to check up on us regularily! Cant wait to return to try other menu items!! read more

See all

What an adorable and lovely place. The service was great. The bartender was such a nice woman. The jalapeño poppers were sooooooo good!! The quesadilla and flatbread was tasty. Great Happy Hour menu with awesome prices. We were very pleased. Love that it's a neighborhood gem. Will def be back!!! read more

The watermark for me is a destination dining Place. After all I live in Syosset. The 50 minute drive is well worth it. The service is great and the food even better. I highly recommend the bloody Mary. read more

See all

Celebrating the hubby's birthday on a Saturday night. He made the reservation which was by phone so I asked him if he'd mentioned the celebration. He had not so I said something to our waitress right away. When it came time for dessert I assumed they would recognize him but it didn't happen and then we saw someone else receive a birthday candle and a few of the staff members singing to them so we were left feeling like maybe we should've mentioned to the host instead? Our dinners were nice sized portions, our Boys enjoyed the calamari appetizer. The bottle of Malbec was not very good. Mexican coffees lacking enough Kahlua. The water refills and removal of the dishes was very attentive. Overall nice space with lots of St. Patrick's Day touches for the month of March. Cozy quarters, we were there towards closing so even though we were seated right in the middle of the space it wasn't overwhelmingly loud. Would probably return. read more

Came here after apple picking. All the tables were full, so we sat at the bar. The bartender was super nice and friendly. Mimosas were light and delicious. The food was good. The mediterranean salad was delicious and fresh, the add on salmon was seared and seasoned perfectly.. Would definitely visit again if ever in the neighborhood. read more

See all

First time at Watermark. After reading yelp reviews tried it on Sunday afternoon. Sat at the bar, Nick the server and one of the owners with his dad was very accommodating. Food was excellent, service very good. Had the turkey loaded BLT and the portobello sandwich, both very good. Mushroom soup of the day also excellent. Definitely worth coming here, look forward trying it again for dinner. read more

Watermark of Wading River - Loaded BLT with turkey sandwich with side salad. All food is fresh & delicious - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Wading River, New York

See all

Food was amazing and so was service! The ambiance is very nice as well! A very nice place for dinner

My wife and I literally drove around for an hour trying to decide where we wanted to eat. I suggested Watermark several times because it was a new restaurant and I wanted to try it. She kept shooting me down but finally agreed! SHE LOVED IT!! Great food, great menu and great service, AND pricing was reasonable. I had the Stuffed Cabbage special and she had the pan seared salmon with rice. We shared a crab cake app (decent for a non Maryland crab cake, I'm really spoiled) . We'll definitely return. read more

Watermark of Wading River - Pan Seared Salmon with rice - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Wading River, New York