Some wich's may be great. The Philly large with fries and drink not so much. Fries limpy undercooked and Philly onion and green peppers soggy and not carmelized. sirloin steak more like steakums. Yes a lot of food but pricey at just over $20 with a suggested tip for the lack of taste. read more

I came here for the 2nd time since they opened on Monday 8/18/2014. You can consider Which Wich to be the Mavericks of Sandwich making. You think it and they can most likely make it. The choices are endless here. I as well had a chance to meet the owner today, and I'm impressed, the man stands behind the quality of his product as well as his team's performance and that commendable in any book. As far as the Williamsburg Which Wich team goes, the staff is on point! Friendly, Fast and Professional. Now to the best part.... THE FOOD! As I said before, there are a ton of choices here. If you want to know just how far they will go to make the most awesome sandwich you've ever thought up, just see what I ordered: 10.5 inch Chicken Pesto on Wheat -bread hollowed out -bacon -avocado -added lite Garlic & Oregano -Tomatoes -Spinach -lite balsamic vinaigrette -Carmallized Onions -Mozzarella and feta cheese -Lite oil Best new addition to Williamsburg this summer! read more

See all

The food is good. Customer service?? Horrible! As soon as you walk in your greeted with music blasting over the speaker. I placed an online order so I had to yell my name and order. To the employee. The employee's response was "Huh" ? Want to know why? Because in addition to the loud music HE HAD EAR PODS ON! Then he tells me to wait for my name to he called so I stood right in front of him for 20 minutes. So I would not miss my name being called. Turns out he never even called my name just place the food to the side. The manager came and asked and I need assistance. I gave them my name. And the food was sitting right there. I told the manager why would you have me waiting here 20 minutes if the food is right in front of me? He said oh yeah go get a milkshake and walked away. Way to go which which. Way to go! read more

We purposely drive 25 miles one way to come here. We love the variety of sandwiches, but more importantly, we LOVE the fries with Wich Sauce. Angelina helped us as soon as we came in and was extremely friendly. She was nonstop with preparing the food, cleaning, and replenishing the bags, towels, etc. My wife was so taken by her work ethic that she had to go ask her for her name. read more

Great service and food. Sandwich was delicious and fries were crisp! Thanks Jasmine!

I tried my first Which Wich in California & absolutely loved it - so I was beyond excited when they started construction for one in Williamsburg. Love the idea of ordering on paper bags. I usually get a roast beef or buffalo chicken, they've always been good. They have 3 size options which is nice, the medium sized one is perfect for sharing. I also tried their Oreo milkshake which was very good - a medium was huge & I couldn't finish it. Inside is nice. Lots of people working, I feel like it was over staffed but hey, what do I know? read more

Love Which Wich!!! Sandwiches are so good!! My favorite is the grinder!! My husband loves the Wicked. Definitely a good place to go if you love subs!!! Also their shakes are the bomb dot com!! read more

Just stopped at Which Wich on our way up to Fredericksburg. My mom and I have never been here before so we weren't sure how to order. The owner came out and explained everything to us and was super friendly! Definitely a plus!!! We didn't have to wait long to get our food. It goes down an assembly line. Also my mom and I kept talking about how good the bread tasted. We are already talking about coming back on our return trip. Also it is great to accommodate many people. Different vegetarian and vegan options. read more

Used to eat here all the times. Meatball sub gone off the Italian menu. The app is limited utility as far as family use goes. Great to give you points, not easy to redeem. Couldn't give me my free drink for checking in on yelp because I already paid for the sandwich. Quick to say no to every question, no smiles at the counter and I'm not coming back. read more

Large turkey sub and had to go looking for the turkey. Realize food costs are up but if you are going to raise prices and reduce portion amounts you should at least make customers aware. Poor. read more

Love this sandwich place. Everyone is always friendly and they make your order fresh.

Went there for an early dinner around 5 PM on a Saturday. The eating area was dirty everywhere like the place was not vacuumed wiped down or mopped since the lunch rush. Once we figured how to order we got our food and they never made our French fries. So that was another 5 minutes extra to wait after we said something. Got the cheesesteak and could only eat less than half. Really cheap meat, tasted like Arbys or worse. I guess this business appeals to college students, but for anyone else I can't see the appeal. read more

I'm a big fan of Potbelly, and this place takes it to another level! I had the muffuletta and it was great! The bread was good and the topping selection was huge. I just wish that I could visit again to try the lettuce wrap option! The only thing that was confusing was the ordering system, but the cashier was pretty patient. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Perhaps good for meat eaters but surely not for vegetarians. The salad version of the avocado was chopped lettuce and avocado. Wake up, vegetarians have not sacrificed their taste buds. Quite the opposite, in fact! read more

Sorry didn't do it for me. Gal was nice explained the rules and we put together our order. The cashier had a speech impediment because of all the rings/bars on her lip. It was ghastly to look at as well. The bread was toasty and tasty the fillings skimpy to say the least. Ten dollars for a "large" that looked like a 12" subway. My daughters five dollar kids lunch was a teeny weeny sandwich with apples and carrots ?? Five bucks and you can't throw in a bag of chips or a cookie? You have to pay extra for those? Really ? Woo hoo kids get "dessert" a token for a 1/4 handful of m & ms. Which the cashier forgot to give to me , I had to ask for it . They give you $.50 discount if you bring your cup back and order a sandwich and drink. Wait wait? I'm saving YOU the price of a cup and all you can save me is $.50? Um..... no! Not going back. Skip to firehouse subs or Subways. read more

See all

First tried which wich in Houston a few years ago. Loved the concept. Custom-made to order sandwiches with choice of meat, toppings, etc. and a wide array of options. When my wife and I moved to Charlotte, we definitely went to which wich often too. And if you compare them to other sandwich chains: subway, firehouse subs, jimmy johns, potbelly, etc., which wich can definitely hang! The sandwiches are delicious. I think what sets them apart are the sandwich options. They have the usual deli meats, but have a variety of more creative sandwiches like surf and turf, gyros, etc. I'm partial to the surf and turf, but I've tried some other varieties. (A couple of days ago I had the gyro! Very tasty) The sandwiches are great, and you can get them with chips and a drink. Prices are pretty comparable to the other sandwich chains too. This location was great. I've been to this location 4x and the staff was super friendly each time. It's clean, I got my orders quickly and the food was great each time. I would definitely recommend which wich if you're crazy a quick sandwich. read more

I've been to this location twice and so far so good. I will say that I probably won't frequent it as much in the near future as it is about an hour's drive from my house--but it has nothing to do with food or service. I became familiar with which wich while living in Colorado. There are quite a few locations out there. So imagine my delight when I found out one would be opening somewhat in our area. They have MANY, many different sandwich options, all of which can be customized to your liking. There are also salad options as well. They offer a skinny version of their sandwiches--not sure what that entails however. I've always ordered the cuban which wich, which...lol...is very delicious. I can't tell you all of the options I add because that is where I change it up every time, but you can't go wrong with the olive salad (or dressing...whatever it's called on paper), onion straws and pickles. Yum. Is it authentic? NO but it's my sandwich so don't judge me. Service is pretty friendly and both times I went the service was fast based on just a handful of people in there at the time. This location is very clean as well. One of the workers informed me that the guy who owns this franchise plans to open at least 10 more in the Hampton Roads area. Let's hope this is true as I would love to keep coming to which wich--hoping they open one either close to my job or my residence. Overall, great sub place with many different options. Can be a little pricey but consider it a treat once in a while. :) read more

Ok another recommendation from Katie the world traveller. We had no idea what or why but just went. Seemed very clean and fresh; orderly and not a kaotic looking place. We both just stared at the menu wall and finally flagged over an explainer. OK I get it. Grabbed my paper sack and marked my order... ya know chose which wich I wanted. Kimberly got the rueben and I chose roast beef double meat. We liked it! read more

Which Wich - Which Wich of Williamsburg - Sandwiches Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Fun idea - pick your own sandwich and out were tasty but it's kind of robotic in what you get. Not enough love in the sandwiches. But a good quick lunch for sure. read more

Have only been here once but really enjoyed it! Liked the different way they have you order. Lots of sandwich options and reasonably priced. Enjoyed the amount of meat and toppings on the sandwich. Looking forward to trying it again. Friendly staff and delicious food! read more

See all

Like subway, but much better. Also, extremely polite staff, clean facilities, and a unique vibe.

We had ordered door dash for the first time. We have never ate at this restaurant. I got sent a Mold Filled apple juice. I was throwing up and everything. We called because I showed my work. They said they contacted door dash to refund our items and never did. They apologized but never gave us our money back on door dash. Very disappointed. It was a kids meal. Please make sure you check your children's juices before letting them drink it. read more

Awesome sandwiches! Great bread. Greeter was pleasant! She was cleaning a table. "Explainer" of process was kinda like "Bueller caller" from Ferris Bueller, cashier was super sweet. Cooks never look you in the eye or acknowledge you (who cares) The sandwich. Wow. So yummy. So good. Bread on point. Meats so tasty. Just a great darn sandwich. (Process to order a little arduous but it's their schtick) read more

They sure were busy - but service was reasonably quick and friendly. The provolone cheese was nothing to write home about, but the olive spread lent a nice extra flavor to my sandwich. A fresh and tasty sandwich at reasonable price. I'll definately be back! read more

I tried it for the first time. Get there early they get busy.I had the Cuban sandwich I highly recommend it. The meat was cooked thoroughly . the sandwich was awesome the bread was perfect. I had this sub at Jason's deli they can not touch which wich. I will definitely be back. read more

Which Wich - Sandwiches Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Ham and pineapple with ranch was the perfect combo. Getting the sun heated took it to another level. The heated egg salad sub was great. Ordering by writing your order in a bag ensures you get the right order. Subs came out quickly, too. read more

Which Wich - Community comment board - Sandwiches Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Be extremely careful when placing an order, especially if you utilize DoorDash for delivery. Ordered 2 sandwiches. One was correct, but completely flattened and dialed in excessive mayo. The 2nd in the order was completely incorrect. Sent a Tuna Salad sandwich instead of the ordered KrabSalad. Called and spoke to the Manager on Duty and was told I had to reorder another sandwich through a DoorDash. Took an additional hour to receive. Lodged a complaint through Corporate website and never received a response. Obviously, they are not concerned about Customer satisfaction. read more

Lots of different hot and cold sandwiches to chose from. Just about all of it can be custom made. I had the gyro with fries and it was great. Try the house chips. They have a peppery taste to them. I liked the nice airy atmosphere they gave the place. Gotta come back to try some more combos. read more

Which Wich - A worker came up to us and explained how this all worked. - Sandwiches Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

First impressions are important. The cashier treated me as if she was in a rush. My order was wrong, the sauce in my sub was only in one corner of the sub instead of spread across. The bread were two separate pieces making the meat fall off. One egg in a sub too little. The soda was nasty. This place in my book gets two thumbs down. I won't be back! read more

Love this place!!! This is the best designed sandwich establishment I have ever been to. The food is delicious and they have a nice variety. Shakes are a little costly, but otherwise the prices are decent. read more

See all

So many great sandwiches! My go to is always the Reuben and I like to add those fried crispy onion straws and pickles! I've also had a BLT here and the chicken salad. The chicken salad is personally not my favorite but other people rave about it which is why I tried it. I also have tried their milkshakes too and that is definitely a nice treat to add to your order! read more

Ordered a Reuben and got home to find a philly cheese steak in my bag. Sandwich was good, but NOT what I wanted and didn't feel like driving back. I shouldn't have to check my bag to make sure order is correct...that's their job. read more

So good!!! I had the Brunchwich..the meat was so tender and curious about how does a sandwich shop know how to cook an egg better than a breakfast joint (long story), but great job guys! Could definitely taste the love, thank you! Sorry I didn't get a picture I had to dig in right away and couldn't put it down read more

I love Wich wich and their drink cups are awesome I wish they had a better rewards program though and more locations.

We always eat here when we come to Williamsburg. Great place to get subs. Easy location to get to.

Here on vacation and stopped by for a quick lunch. Very tasty, a nice portion and I love the hot cookies! I got the gyro and it was almost too much, but sooo good. Very interesting ordering technique but it keeps the line moving and the wait time is very reasonable. read more

This sandwich shop knows how to please all sandwich eaters! With bread or with out, lots of topping choices and lots of meat. The crinkle fries were hot and fresh! Wish We had these back at home!!! read more

Very confusing at first to order but the lady was kind enough to come around and help me. The bread was amazing, very rare to find the particular bread they use. The sandwich in whole however, was very bland no flavor. And they were very light on the Mayo. The meat and cheese was disproportioned on each side so one side had more than the other. Great for families and gatherings. Try it. read more

Great sandwich. Slow to let you know your sandwich is screwed up snd eventually another will be made. Fresh, toasted, will return next visit to Virginia. read more

This location is the only Which Wich I've been to, but they've sold me on the brand. I enjoy the experience of ordering a sandwich, it's unlike most sandwich shops and sets them apart. Their variety is also awesome, there's tons of combinations to choose from. Their staff has always been friendly and they prepare my order fast. They also handle to-go orders called in or submitted over the app well. read more