Place seemed nice and clean, staff was friendly. I've only been for one visit and I will update once I go back for pizza. But...!!! My wife and I ordered wings. We were definitely disappointed. First they were $35 for 24 wings. That's about $14 more than competitors. Second, they were extremely over cooked. And third, they don't offer drums only or flats only. I understand this is a pizza joint, but you offer wings, and people are gonna eat 'em. With that all being said, highly over priced, and highly over cooked, you gotta have a low score. I'll look forward to updating once I try the pizza. read more

Great pizza! We order often from this restaurant and are satisfied every single time. The staff has always been friendly and professional and the food is always great! We love the consistency! If you're around the area, check them out read more

It's worth the wait for the best pizza sauce in town. The sausage mushroom is awesome. Call an hour ahead on busy nights.

I've gotta be honest...coming from CT (and what I consider to be the best area for pizza between New York City and New Haven County), this is probably one of the best pizza places I have been to away from home. My friend and I came here after getting our nails done a couple of shops down, and were ready to have a nice lunch. For about $8.00 each, we were able to get a HUGE slice of pizza, a salad and a drink. The drinks are serve yourself (which I'm actually a big fan of). I got the meat lover's and was, in fact, in love. It is a thinner crust with not a lot of sauce but a generous amount of toppings. I got the caesar salad which was also fresh and delicious. The staff are also extremely friendly and helpful. This is definitely a solid place to stop if you need a good lunch to fill you up - or just, delicious pizza! read more

Whispering Pies - Pizza Near Me - Carthage, North Carolina

Ordered online 30 minutes ahead and waited another 30 minutes to find out they never got the order. They have no way to refund an online order. Doesn't matter how good the food is if you can't get it. read more

We ordered pizza online to-go. It must be a popular place because it was super busy when I walked in. The pizzas were ready on time, they were fresh and it was good. The people were also friendly. I would highly recommend. read more

When visiting my family have ordered take out here twice. Fantastic pizza!! I mean fantastic. Very tasty. Big pizza. Priced right. Definitely recommend read more

Service was terrible and food was even worse. A 45 minute wait turned into an 1.45 hour wait. We ordered "cheese sticks" but received mozzarella sticks and then was told by a staff member that we were suppose to say "cheesy bread." read more

Love this place! Delicious food. I rated it 4 stars because my son still prefers Dominos. Ugghhh

Best pizza in the area. Great owner and staff. Highly recommended for anyone who loves NY style pizza and sides.

Very good pizza and diverse menu. Clean interior and nice staff. We had white pie, Greek pie and marguerite pie. All were 5/5. Highly

Really good pizza with tossed crust. Staff friendly and hard working with a great owner who is the hardest worker of all. I would use the google ordering as the phones are insanely busy there but that works fine but few people know google ordering exists yet. read more

Excellent! We love their delivery services and that it's local to our area. Great pizza and wings!

We are new to the are from NJ & we are excited to have found "our pizza place"! We ordered 6 wings "Tim's Way" & a medium pie with pepperoni, everything was delicious. We look forward to tasting more of the menu options. read more

The food is barely average, and not very good. It's ridiculously over priced for the quality, quantity, location, and it's not some high end restaurant. It cost me $20 for a sub, drink, and fries that were just average tasting. Not only was my food over priced, it took 10 minutes for my sub to come after my fries, so my fries were cold by the time I got my sub. The service was not any better than the food either. It was all teenagers who goofed around the whole time, they checked on us maybe three times, and we sat there 15 mins waiting to ask for the check and a to go box. I could've gotten better food, and customer service at McDonalds to be honest. I will never go back, charging people like that might as well be stealing. read more

Very impressed by this pizza. They do excellent New York style pie. Fast service and friendly staff are icing on the cake. The lunch special is $6.50 for 2 slices and a drink till 3pm, I not a local but when Im in town Ill be sure to stop by. read more

Great pizza and food service. Garlic knots are to die for. Manager and staff is friendly. Delivery is on time and food is hot.

went yesterday & boy, was I happy as a clam !!! My cousin & I am a pizza aficionado's & this was one of the best pies I've had in awhile. It was great !! Still savoring the leftovers !! It was a huge pie, for a medium, & it was a very tasty surprise !! Staff was great, & pie was delicious !!! Thank you so much !! We will be back !! read more

Really like the pizza - consistently very good. Easy to make and order and it is ready on time every time.

In our first week living here we had WP twice! Our in person dining experience was greatly enhanced by the personality and excellent service from Luke. The pizza is amazing! Perfectly cooked crust and an abundance of toppings. I cannot wait to try the entire menu! read more

Absolutely disgusting! The pizza tasted like something from a box. The wings were rubbery

To be honest, I don't have much to say about Whispering Pies. We ordered the Zerillo minus the green peppers and there's really not much to say. It wasn't bad but it wasn't great; it was just kind of lackluster. I just felt like there wasn't a defined flavor. The pepperoni and sausage just kind of blurred together and that was it. Meh. Maybe it's because it was the last order of the night (we were the a-holes who unknowingly ordered ten minutes before closing, oops). Maybe it's because I'm a pizza snob having grown up eating pizza in NYC. I'm not entirely sure. Nor am I sure whether or not I'll be back. I've been pretty content with a pizzeria in Pinehurst but was looking for a location a bit closer but alas. I might just have to commit to the drive to Pinehurst. read more

If ur local I'm sure this place is great. If you've ever had authentic pizza from any large city (NYC, etc) then you will unfortunately be disappointed. It wasn't bad, it just wasn't great. Set your expectations appropriately and you won't be disappointed. Service ho hum. read more

I'm from Brooklyn, N.Y. and this is the closest you can get to Brooklyn PIZZA! I thought the pizza was phenomenal I definitely enjoyed it!

Stopped in for a Chicken Parm sandwich and grabbed pizza to go for the family. Probably one of the best chicken parm sandwiches I have had, hot and delicious. The family really enjoyed the pizzas as well, I would definitely recommend and will be visiting again if I am in the area. read more

Top notch pizza! Great staff - they are amazingly friendly & helpful. Accommodated our group and everyone left happy.

Service leaves MUCH to be desired. IF you claim to have "pizza by the slice" to until 3:00 but at 2:32pm you ONLY have one slice of barbeque chicken then you are NOT a quality business. This establishment has been opened and closed MULTIPLE times and now I understand why. They lost more money having me walk out today without even buying a single slice (let alone the supposed "two slice special" I wanted) than the actual food cost of a large cheese pizza. I will not be back. read more

Here's the thing about Whispering Pies..... It's not awful. It's just not nearly as good as Zerello's, the restaurant it replaces. Zerello's had really good pizza - WP's is really average. Zerello's had many really good pasta dishes and ran daily specials. WP's doesn't do pasta. Vito's pizza is better and so is So Pies. In this area of Moore Co., Zerello's was such a great addition. It was great food; had really nice employees and was the perfect bailout for Whispering Pines residents anytime we didn't feel like cooking. With Whispering Pies, I have to be pretty damn desperate to stop in there now. Such a bummer... read more

Amazing Pizza! Staff is super friendly. I really love how clean it is, plus, at lunchtime you can get pizza by the slice. Meatballs are also my favorite. Very military friendly place. read more

If you want local, NY style pizza in Southern Pines this is where I would take you. The knots are delicious and the pizza matches the price! (~$6 for 2 slices and a drink) The staff is incredibly friendly and makes dining a wonderful experience. I think they are going to start delivering too, which is going to be a big plus. For those that don't know this place has the exact same recipes as zerillo's however, the owner had to leave for medical reasons. So if you liked zerillo's you will like WPP! read more

Had the meatball sub it was awesome. Fresh meat and cheese with a great tomato sauce. I will definitely come back and try the pizza. Keep up the good work guys. read more

New restaurant (replaced zerillo's); pizza, wings, salads, calzones. Tried a slice of cheese pizza ( my litmus test for crust and cheese) before venturing into other pizzas. Very good! Salad -good; wings (garlic parmesan) - a little greasy but finger licking good. Then had a taste of wings "Tim's Way" - have to ask for them, not on the menu yet. Oh my gosh! So yummy!!! Not only finger looking ... Lickin' your whole arm good!!! Hope they add delivery. Return? Oh yeah! read more

First, the service was EXCELLENT!! :) Our waitress had this sweet South African accent and was so pleasant. Super attentive! :) Next, the pizza....the pizza...oh my gosh...the pizza is AMAZING! We had an 18inch cheese pizza just to test the crust and sauce ratio! :) it was perfect. The new management is fantastic!! I will definitely be back! Oh and the value was great! Eat local...you can tell the difference! :) read more

Cauliflower pizza crust? Absolutely delicious!! Thin crispy crust and the topping are on point. The wings were super good with a nice crispy skin and great tasting sauce. Southern Pines Brewing Company on tap. Fresh delicious ingredients and an awesome staff, we'll definitely be back for a couple slices! read more

I'm a self proclaimed pizza snob so if we order pizza it has to be good pizza or it's not happening. We live in Aberdeen and drive 20 minutes to get it. Only other option worth a crap around here is SoPies and I recently heard there is a connection between the two places (don't know for sure) so it all makes sense now. This place is great, we love it! read more

Great pizza.. great location.... Owners friendly... this is our go to in whispering pines/Carthage area

I'm so glad we found this place. Their pizza and sides are good, and prices aren't bad. They also do something I've never seen any takeout restaurant do, which is to make sure your order is correct, and show you - I've been burned by places before so many times that this is a welcome change. The vibe seems like everyone there enjoys working there, which again is a welcome change from your average restaurant. We're bound to be regulars at this place for a long time. read more

This is our favorite pizza spot! We typically get a greek pizza for the adults and the standard pepperoni or cheese pizza for the kids. Their wings are also awesome. I usually order ahead and do a pickup but it is also nice to stop in and sit outside for lunch or to come in for dinner and have a glass of wine or a beer along with the great food. Their space is always comfortable and clean with a welcoming and efficient staff. Always my go to spot for fast casual Italian dining! read more

Excellent New York style pizza! Lived in NY for years and this spot is doing a great job bringing NY style pies to NC. Very generous on toppings and very friendly service. read more

We got 3 different pizzas, two different salads, wings, and garlic knots. Not one complaint from 12 people eating. Staff was so nice and I can't wait to eat there again! read more