I JUST moved to Blacklick from Clintonville and thought I'd check out a place for happy hour. The food and drinks were good. No complaints here- Winking Lizard always does a good job with the unhealthy and delicious bar food. The atmosphere is just like ever other Winking Lizard. Tons of televisions playing sports and some news. The service was decent. The staff was friendly and I was served promptly. What I was surprised about is how quiet it was in there. I stopped during prime happy hour time and other than myself and a handful of folks on a work happy hour (they eventually moved to a large table) it was real quiet. I'll be going back there at some point to see if that's typical. read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - Menu - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Brand new and making no mistakes. Friendly. Crowded. Accommodating. Great beer list 140+. Great food selection. The staff is super. Going to return soon. The steak and asparagus salad was pretty good. Fresh greens and even the steak was tender. What really surprised me was how busy this brand new place was, but how great the staff was. Mikahla (?spelling?) handled our twelve top and did a great job. The sound quieted down about 9:00 and we could all hear each other. Rib specials on Wednesdays. Good stuff. read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

The food was okay, nothing great. The service was horrible. We sat at a booth in the bar area. We waited about 15-20mins before anyone even came over to greet us, and then it took another 20mins before we got water. The server never checked on us after bringing our food and they weren't super busy to where he would have been overloaded with tables. I had a bug in my ranch dressing, and had to track down someone to get a new one for me. read more

We stopped in for lunch, so glad we did. The place was clean. We sat at a wooden booth and for a rare change the table wasn't sticky. The draft beer was good and cold. We had burgers, perfectly cooked, pretzels, very good, wings, my husband raves about them. The food was hot, well seasoned, very enjoyable. Looking forward to our next visit. Highly recommended read more

One of my favorite places to grab food around my house! Although I order the same food every time, which is the buffalo chicken wrap with a side of Mac and cheese (and sometimes Mac n cheese bites), it's always delicious! Usually I order to go, and the turn around time is always 15-25 minutes which is pretty quick to me. I've dined here a handful of times and always had a pleasant experience. The inside is spacious and has a decent patio area for nice weather. read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - Buffalo chicken wrap - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Everything I eat here is amazing!!! Never disappointed! My particular favorites are the white pizza and the mac and cheese wedges!

What a fun place to enjoy food with friends. My hubby and I love this location. We've been going here many times ever since they first opened. The wait staff and hosts are always very friendly and in the ball. They servers have always been attentive and happy. Every time I have gone here we always like to bring friends. Even when we aren't meeting friends we always see someone that we know enjoying the food, sports on the TVs or relaxing on the patio. The food is so good. I love the Loaded Potato skins and mozzarella sticks on the Repitizers (Appetizers) section. They have delicious wings with a variety of sauces. Their Lizard salad and chopped salad along with their steak with Asparagus salad can't be beat! You can also get St Louis style ribs, Variety of sandwiches, entrees, soups salads just about anything you would like. Their pizza is night tasty too. The atmosphere is fun, laid back and full of friendly people. If you just want to go to the bar to relax, they have a great selection of whiskey and beer to choose from. They gave a full bar and can make any kind of drink that you would like. My hubby and I have been here so many times that we can't count and we have had excellent food service and drink. Swing by here and check it out! read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - The outside patio - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

fries are horrible lack of seasoning not even salt . The burger taste like a burger king burger sat out got cold then you ate it . Plz for the love of the people go buy some spice at least some garlic salt . read more

Sat at outside bar for a bit, no one came so I left. If you sit at the bar, sit inside or they won't come to you. Last time we ate there (a month ago) the music was blaring, not like can't just have a conversation, but like painful to your ears after an hour. Had a headache the rest of the night. Food is alright (nothing special). Beer selection good. Decent place. Needs some work and tweaks. read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - Dividers in between groups at the bar or throughout restaurant. Staff is great. Professional, yet fun and personable. - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

Ordered online and did curbside pickup. Ordered bourbon chicken wings, onion rings, and nachos with beef. The wings were a nice size and the sauce was tasty. The onions rings were just okay. I like mine crispy and these were more soft breaded. The nachos were a huge disappointment. We paid over $2.00 extra for beef and I'm pretty sure it was a hamburger that was chopped up and thrown on top. It was lacking cheese and the chips were almost burnt around the edges. read more

Fun atmosphere, good food, decent prices. It's become our new go-to place! Give it a try.

Food was excellent service was great had a lunch sindey was the best thing ever thank

Went this afternoon for a meal and was pretty pleased. Daniel served us and he was outstanding. Personable and made sure we were well stocked on our drinks throughout the course of our meal. I ordered the boneless wings and while they weren't the best I've ever had, I really enjoyed them. My only complaint is that said wings were pretty pricey. Regardless, this spot has definitely become an option for me in the future. read more

Second time here in the past week, and I really love it! Fresh food and the service is amazing! Friendly staff and very clean. Tonight I had the patty melt sandwich with fries. The sandwich was just like I ordered it. (Medium well) perfect! Great sautéed onions and melted cheese. My husband ordered a garlic pizza with white sauce and spinach. He loved the crust and crispy texture it had. They also have drink specials so I had a 32oz labat blue for $5.50. It was cold and served in a frosted glass. We will definitely be back after such great experiences here. There mask mandation has been lifted if you have been vaccinated. Another reason this place rocked! read more

This is my fourth time here in less than 30 days. I travel to many different States including Texas where I paid $90 for one steak. And that's just a steak alone. Anything else you get his extra.. For the money you pay here on Friday and Saturday is an absolute amazing deal then to boot all four times it has been cooked perfectly. I even mixed it up and ordered medium rare and then the next time medium. People Get Here Now. read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - Friday and Saturday steak special - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

What a great experience tonight! Check out Erica at the bar - very professional and definitely "essential". The music was jamming and the patrons had a Karaoke moment. Diverse crowd that really vibes and that is exactly how it should be. Oh, the whiskey selection is vast and the food/service was excellent too ;) read more

They didn't have the bourbon we wanted and the wings were small compared to Wings and Rings. I would go back to try the other theme on their menu. read more

Winking Lizard Tavern - Draft beer list - Bars Near Me - Reynoldsburg, Ohio

See all

Salad was fresh and delicious. Long Island iced tea was perfect. Pork sandwich was good. Will be back.

Went on a Saturday night..seated right away...not really all that busy. Complimentary popcorn that you can go up and serve yourself in paper bags to bring back to your table. Our server Daniel was super friendly and attentive. I ordered the western burger and subbed the steak fries for mac and cheese. The mac and cheese was on the drier side..it was just okay. The hamburger was cooked exactly as I had ordered and the bbq sauce and all the toppings made for a tasty burger. The menu appeared to be pretty basic bar food. The frozen margarita ordered at the table was on the weaker side and wasn't all that flavorful. Overall no complaints with anyone's meals. read more

See all

This place keeps skipping all my songs when I play then on their Touchtunes machine. None of them were even vulgar, in fact, none of them had any words to begin with. This is horrible because I paid the money to hear my songs and because an old group of people wanted to hear their songs, they asked the bartender to skip all of mine. TRASH!!!!!!! read more

Note to my east-side neighbors: never, EVER go here. We've been to countless Winking Lizards in both central and northern Ohio, so we were excited to have this one open near us. We chalked up the slow service and mediocre food on our first visit to opening month kinks that needed to be worked out. However, when we have it a second chance today we were sat and then waited for over 15 minutes without so much as a server coming by to take our drink order. Hostesses and other wait staff walked by a number of times, and not once did someone ask if we had been helped. We finally decided to find dinner elsewhere (which isn't a choice made lightly when you've got a hungry 22-month old with you). Skip this place... or at least find one of the legit locations, like in Cleveland. read more

My first time here last Saturday food was very good. Had the spinach artichoke dip and it was amazing. Will definitely be back!

I've been coming here for a while. The service is great. The bar staff has always been wonderful. This place can get busy during happy hour. read more

Went to the Winking Lizard and wasn't thrilled. Heard great things about the place and I was unimpressed. Same kind of food that exists in all the other places of its kind. I love Caribbean jerk sauce but this wing sauce tasted like thanksgiving dinner in a bad way. Got it on boneless wings that were dry and cold. I didn't even bother to ask for something different or have them heated up. I also got the 4 slider burgers with steak fries and it was something I could've done at home. They were dry and fell apart in my hands. The server was nice and attentive for the most part. I'd prefer to never go back. Just my opinion though. read more

Attentiveness of bartenders could be better. It shouldn't be too much to ask that the bartenders stop by each patron at the and check in more often to see who needs service. A patron shouldn't have to flag down a bartender to get a drink or a food menu after over 10-15 minutes of sitting down. Food and beer tastes good. Attentive service could improve. read more

Great Long Islands! I've never had a bad experience! Good burgers! What else do you want me to say?

A great gathering spot for happy hours, especially if you love beer. The beer selection is impressive. I wish they had more gluten-free beer options (not cider), as well as more veg and gluten-free food items. The food menu is bar food, heavy on the meats and fried foods, nothing fancy. My friends absolutely love the wings and variety of sauces and heat levels there are to choose from. read more

Winking Lizard has long been my husband and my's favorite spot. They consistently have the best wings at a great price with a great atmosphere and friendly service. All of this was confirmed when I contacted Winking in the hopes they could cater my small COVID wedding. I received a prompt, eager response almost immediately and had the pleasure of working with the General Manager, Paul. He helped me create a limited menu our guests would love and personally saw to it that we were delivered hot food right on time. We had an order for about 25 people and every single box was labeled so we could easily distribute it and NOT ONE thing in the order was incorrect or forgotten, even down to extra blue cheese sauces. Not to mention this is all within days of the store re opening after the pandemic. This demonstrates exceptional service, attention to detail, and care for their customers! read more

Ugh. I'm a Winking Lizard veteran. Peninsula used to be my haunt, and I've hit the Crosswoods location in recent years. If I'm trading Crosswoods for this hot-mess location, I'm getting a raw deal. It's small in here, they don't have enough tables. It's freaking loud, you can't hold a conversation without yelling. The food was mediocre at best -- my fries were barely warm and were soggy as all get-out. It's not a typical winking lizard experience. Perhaps they're working the kinks out. Pass, y'all. read more

Love this place! It has been our favorite since they opened! We got takeout for Mother's Day. The order was perfect and even carried out to our car. Can't wait to go back again soon. read more

As if the Winking Lizard wasn't the BEST place already and if I haven't been doing the Beer Tour since 2008... it's now 2 miles from my house ! read more

I never write reviews but I am now done with this location. I've been here several times and always get drinks and a to go food order. I've now waited an hour for a salad and the place is empty. I got a grilled cheese last time and it was literally uncooked. I've received really good food here but it's way too inconsistent for me to keep coming back. I promise I have given too many chances. SMH read more

I have been here a couple of times and I'm never dissatisfied. Customer service is great and the food was phenomenal.