Decent local option for pizza, walked in on a weeknight and there were plenty of tables open but we just grabbed some slices to go. They were nice enough to cut each slice in half so my husband and I could each try. I most enjoyed the vodka grandma slice, and appreciated that the Buffalo chicken slice wasn't too heavy on the buffalo. read more

Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Buffalo chicken slice is so fire, same with the wings. Service is nice and I like the vibe of the restaurant.

Great pizza on par with NJ standards for sure. Mozzarella sticks are better than I've had at most places - more fresh and a better cheese pull! Highly recommend if you're in the area. Service is friendly and pizza was made in a timely manner. Though it's not my jam, my friends rave about the salads here! Not really a sit in place, better for takeout based on the interior. read more

Been going here a long time now the pizza tastes like cardboard and the fried calamari is awful like chewing rubber bands I almost choked on it very disappointed threw it all out read more

Pretty good pizza spot in NJ. We ordered 2 Sicilians slices , buffalo chicken and chicken bacon slices. All were really delicious. The Sicilians were extra fluffy which I loved. It's also really decently priced. read more

Stopped in here a few days ago for a couple of slices and man, they did not disappoint. I usually order two slices when I'm trying out a new place: cheese and margharita. Both were excellent! I preferred the cheese over the margharita, the dough was a little more foldable and I liked the flavor of the cheese. If I lived closer to this place I would probably stop in every week honestly. read more

Ordered catering for a birthday party and was very happy with the food and service. The order delivery arrived on time and the food was great. Pizza is delicious, 3 ft Italian hero was HUGE and very good as well. Also ordered grilled chicken caesar wraps, chicken fingers and mozzarella sticks that were delicious as well. Would definitely order again! read more

This place is always a disappointment. Pizzas are too doughy, overcooked and dried out. No taste. Prime location but definitely not worth it. Iwon't be ordering from here again. read more

Wyckoff pizza has the best salads and pizza. The salads are big enough for two or three meals. Generous portions on all food. The pizza is also really good. Order ahead as the place is always packed. Well worth the wait. read more

Excellent pizza! Staff is young and a little lost. But the boss there keeps things in line. Worth wading through a the confusion for a good slice. read more

Never disappointed. Great pizza, they don't skimp on the toppings so it's truly worth the price. Sauce and dough are fantastic.

I cannot say enough about this little pizza shop. My daughter works a few doors down, and when I drop her off, I always duck in for a slice or two. They are extremely consistent, the pizza crust is thin, just the right of pizza to sauce ratio, and the sauce is sweet, and not bitter. When ordering individual slices, they come out consistently perfect every single time I ordered a pie once, and that had slightly too much cheese, which ran in the middle, a little, but that was easily remedied by a quick duck in my oven and everything was fine again. So, if you're looking for a consistent place to have a quick slice, if you're in the Wyckoff area then this place is for you. read more

Great pizza, and that's coming from a recently displaced manhattanite. Full of flavor and just the right amount of cheese to sauce

Great service and food Especially the chicken tenders, buffalo pizza! and Cesar salad !

Have had take out from them many times. I always pick up and go when they tell me it will be ready. The pizza and dinners are always hot and the quality is very good. No complaints from me. The employees are all attentive to the customers and friendly and helpful. read more

Love the food here. The salads are delicious and the large one could easily feed two people. Their garlic knots are to die for, you bite down and get a gush of butter, just delicious. read more

Overpriced,$20 for just lettuces ,3 slices of mozzarella and a few slices of meats.do not recommend .

the chicago pan slice was dope! delicious flakey crust with a soft inside - the dough through out was a nice consistency. my bf got a house salad with grilled chicken. the balsamic vinegarette was delicious. bf was annoyed some of the items in the salad we large pieces but enjoyed the flavors. read more

Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant has the best salad, pizza, and calzones in Bergen County. My favorite salad to order is the Wyckoff Salad. The salad has fresh tomatoes, roasted peppers, sundried tomatoes, red onions, and mozzarella. The salad is topped with the best dressing I ever had on a salad. If they sold their house Italian dressing in a jar, I would buy it in a heartbeat... it is seriously that good. As far as their pizza selection, I suggest trying their Grandma pizza which is part Sicilian and part Margherita. The crust is think and crispy and their pizza sauce is sweet and savory. Try getting an end piece; it's the best part of the pie. Wyckoff Pizza also offers a variety of pizza from gluten free pizza to vodka sauce pizza. I also suggest getting their plain calzone. Their plain calzone is very creamy and filling. I love when a calzone has more ricotta than mozzarella and Wyckoff does just that. The portion is very large and you will definitely have leftovers to take home. Also, their service is very quick and efficient. I never had a long wait to be helped or served. I highly suggest this pizza shop, I have never had a bad experience. read more

Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant - Plain calzone - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Over priced to go along with all the overcooked food! When you call they dump you on hold and forget to pick back up, another time we ordered and meals were forgotten and others tasteless, the last and final time: (2) slices and a small water for $11.00! read more

Ordered the grandma pizza and was pleasantly surprised by how delicious it was!! My daughter ordered the Chicago pan pizza. I couldn't believe how big it was. You won't leave hungry and you won't be disappointed. Snuggled in a strip mall in the NJ suburbs you'll feel right at home! read more

Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant - the menu - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

I think this is some of the best pizza around. Fresh high quality ingredients makes for good pizza. Good prices, delivery, friendly staff and good ambience. read more

Last Friday night my friends and I were starving and decided we wanted pizza among other goodies so my friend suggested Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant. We ordered delivery and got ourselves a large pie, french fries with melted mozzarella and a house salad with a side of grilled shrimp for me. Everything took about 45 mins to arrive but when it did it was fresh and hot. The boys really enjoyed the pizza and my salad was absolutely delicious and the fresh mozzarella cheese I added with the perfect addition. I really enjoyed the house made italian dressing and so did my boyfriend who was dipping his pizza crust in it. I think the prices are reasonable and the food is of excellent quality. We will deffinitly be coming back to try some more of what Wyckoff Pizza has to offer. read more

See all

Place has gone downhill. My parents and their golfing buddies used to go here every weekend after 18 holes but I'll advise them to look elsewhere. I'm disgusted at a BBQ chicken pizza pie delivered to me as I type this. It is DRENCHED in BBQ sauce and I might as well have had the sauce fromt he bottle for dinner. Tip: margheritta pizza and buffalo wings are consistently delightful There is one sweet brunette girl in a green shirt there but the rest of the service is unprofessional. Ex. During one pick-up I stayed there for an extra 15-20 minutes to find that my 30-45 minute prior called-in pizza pie order was sitting on top of the oven the entire time. While I was there they gave the wrong amount of change to a gentleman. Tip on Delivery: there's a gentleman with long grey hair delivering your order. Avoid delivery and I will tell you why... I just paid $30 for a $18.50 BBQ chicken pizza pie. The delivery guy didn't have change as he pulled out 20's, 50's, and 100's. I asked for $11 back out of $40 for a $20 order. That's more than a generous tip and not to pinch pennies but he took awhile to find $10 so I settled with that amount. I won't be coming back here. They don't recognize their returning customers. Service is awful, incompetent, and unprofessional. The food itself is not worth dealing with that. I've attached photos of the BBQ Chicken Pizza Pie I had received. read more

Great pizza place. The service is perfect for a lunch hour. The waitress was nice and attentive and wasn't constantly asking "do u need anything" which personally is annoying. Today we ordered the Grandmas Sicilian slices. They were terrific. Flavorful, crust was awesome...crispy yet chewy and the tomatoes and cheese....perfect. This place is close to my job and I will definitely stop in to pick up a pie for dinner on occasion. The sit down feel of this place is still pizzeria and not super trendy and slow. Fast service. Good food. In the past I've had their garlic knots... Great; sauce...awesome, salads...large, fresh and tasty! read more

Great tasting pizza - crust is a little bit thin for my tastes and there is some oil on top of the slice - but the flavor is good. Almost perfect. Edit 10/16/2010: If you can't find parking in Ridgewood or get a reservation at a reasonable hour on a Saturday night in Bergen County, Wyckoff Pizza could be the ticket. My wife and I had the dining section mostly to ourselves, and our waitress was very good. The eggplant parm and manicotti were delish and free refills on giant fountain sodas is always a plus. They also serve a real salad, with lettuce, tomatoes, olives, onions, peppers, and a nice vinaigrette. Even the High School kids from Ramapo added ambiance. Weird. read more

Wyckoff pizza has great pizza, sandwiches and their chicken tenders are fantastic too!

Consistently inconsistent. They have no problem delivering $75 worth of burnt food to your doorstep. Check the food while the driver is still there. Tastees Pizza in Hawthorne is better than Wyckoff Pizza and is only 5 minutes from there. I just learned Tastees will now deliver to Wyckoff and North Haledon too. read more

See all

I ordered 2 slices of pizza one being BBQ chicken pizza and the other bacon ranch pizza I asked for a side of BBQ sauce and they had the nerve to charge me $0.80 extra for it I think that is wrong after I just spent $8.18 and got a slice of pizza that has BBQ sauce on it. And I paid with credit card it cost them more money to swipe the card then they made on the sauce. Not very happy about that all the years I have been coming here have I never been charged for it and the guy said well who ever doesn't charge u is doing it wrong read more

Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

Ordered delivery from here while at a friends in Midland Park. We ordered over $100 worth of food, and they got everything right and delivered in a timely manner. The buffalo chicken salad was delicious and HUGE! Everyone was very pleased with the quality of their food. read more

of course i ordered from my job on my day off, can't even go a day without eating our food. i love trying new meals and substituting the meat out with veggies! the cooks get it exactly how i like read more

Wyckoff Pizza and Restaurant - california club wrap subbed with eggplant, and a whole wheat wrap (vegetarian) - Italian Near Me - Wyckoff, New Jersey

The blonde girl wearing a powerhouse sweatshirt and pink clip was extremely rude and disrespectful towards numerous customers. Her attitude and tone was not welcoming. While waiting on line, she rudely told us to move out of her way and murmured ugly comments under her breath. As more customers came in her demeanor completely changed and she was moving in and out of the way of the different customers, without having an attitude. read more

This is our go-to place for takeout pizza. We like the Grandma pizza, Buffalo wings (we both lived in Buffalo for about 15 years), and house salad. Their house salad is, without question, the best value around. We've had some of the other items on the menu and some were better than others. Last time we got a cheesesteak pizza and it was tasty, but the crust was soggy. To be honest, it might have been better cold the next day. :). If I could give half stars I would give it a solid 3.5. If they could get the consistency down on the Grandma pizza I'd give them a 4. Sometimes it's just right, other times they miss the mark (usually in quality of crust). read more

I ordered from here for the first time yesterday, and I definitely won't be returning. I ordered a house salad with tuna, and I've been suffering from food poisoning ever since. read more

Above average pizza (with remarkably lovely crust - and i'm not a crust person) and good service. My parents swear by the other dishes as well, but I haven't yet had the pleasure. Nice house salad dressing too - light but tasty. Limited seating - about 10 tables. read more

Visited here the last two weeks on our Friday lunch breaks, as it's a good option for not being able to eat meat on Fridays this time of year for most of us. Last week I got a whole wheat salad slice. I liked how I could pick off the mozzarella since I'm no cheese fan when trying to stick healthy, but it was very bland. The dough/crust, usually my favorite part, was thin and tasteless. Today I got the Veggie Panini. I was aggravated that I didn't see it had cheese, but able to pick most of it out. Had no garlic mayo, but the panini was still good. Disappointing they couldn't do whole wheat. Next time, I might as well dive into two Sicilian corner slices, since they look tasty. read more

I'm pretty critical when it comes to pizza, but I must specify that I'm more interested in specialty pizzas, and when a place offers a nice variety, my review is always swayed. Wyckoff pizza delivers! The display case always has up to 10 different pizzas to choose from and I'm always thrilled when they have a BBQ chicken pie. Their grandma slice is really good and they're spot on with their Chicago slices. Unfortunately their buffalo chicken slice is a bit underwhelming and their veggie slices aren't the best. In terms of the staff....angry teen girls all day, every day. They're not rude at all, but, they're always in a bad mood haha. I mean it doesn't bother me because they do their job fine, but its a funny thing to notice. Wyckoff pizza is definitely on my top 5 in terms of bergen county pizza. Also they take debit cards with no minimum and no flack! read more

I was pleasantly surprised. I was expecting really bad pizza and salads and this was not the case. Aren't people happier when they come in with no expectations in life. The pizza was good stuff and the salad was great. I saw some people came in for just the salad. This is a no thrills place but does the job. I was also coming from some of the worst food in the world in East Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania so I had very low expectations coming in and I was thrilled! read more

We love Chicken Murphy- a NJ original. First ordered it at Aldo's in town. So, we needed take out- ordered it here at Wyckoff Pizza. Sorry but you missed the mark- no cherry peppers- green peppers were not cooked- and the potatoes tasted like from a can. No spice at all. It's a good thing that the sautéed broccoli and salad were ok as the main dish failed. read more

This place is terrific. Outstanding pizza (their robust selection of specialty slices is impressive!). I had their sausage & pepper hero which is also great. Love this place, don't change a thing. read more