York 54

I used Anthony's recently for a catering event for Family while on vacation. Tammy Ramsey was…read morewonderful to work with on the catering. Food was excellent. Would highly recommend this business.

Best prepared meals and the pastries are even more delicious. Pizza, subs and pasta dishes are…read moreawesome too. Like the North End in Boston came to York, Maine.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Classic Pizza, our most popular!

See all

The #1 Combo Meal!

York House of Pizza

3.4(70 reviews)

1.0 mi

Never seen this happen before anywhere... we ordered a small pizza, half pepperoni half plain. They…read moretook an already cooked and sliced pizza, put pepperoni on one side, threw a little more cheese on top of the pepperoni, and cooked it again. Umm... really?!?! Besides that, it looked and tasted ok. It wasn't over cooked considering what they did. We will forever miss the days when Peter and Paul owned York House of Pizza. It's never been as good since they sold it. I'm giving the current owners a very generous 3 stars.

Had DoorDash deliver. Very good pizza burger and fries! Would use again if I'm back in the arearead more

Storefront

2 chicken finger dinners dumped out (not pictured the side salads)

See all

Large pizza-pie with sausage, mushroom, onion please! EVERY visit to York.

Dante's Pizza Company

4.4(71 reviews)

2.1 mi

Absolutely delicious Detroit-style pizza. You'd expect it to be pretty heavy, but it honestly…read morewasn't the dough was surprisingly light with great flavor, while still having that perfect Detroit-style crust. Chicken tenders and onion rings for an app were excellent highly recommend! The outdoor seating area is a huge plus too. Plenty of space to hang out, and pets are welcome, which makes it an awesome spot to grab some pizza and relax outside. Definitely recommend Dante's if you're in the York, Maine area. We'll be back!

This is still unreal pizza........but I ordered via phone tonight and was told 15min upon arrival…read moreand Waiting 15:turned to 30. I understand if they'd got busy upon my arrival. If you saw me I am not going to starve.. In the end I got the good fellows with added sausage. I will say charge me more for sausage and put more on the pizza. On 1/2 the pizza my wife said she got 3 pieces ....... Charge me more. Still love Dante's. Every day makes you better and better.

Seating

Meat lovers

See all

Menu

Woody's Brick Oven Pizza

2.9(129 reviews)

3.4 mi

One of the best pepperoni pizzas I've ever had. Amazing wood fired pizza. Large pepperoni slices…read more Very tasty sauce and cheese. Anyone who would rate this place less than a five doesn't know pizza.

Ordered a small cheese waited an hour nothing special. Tons of others came and went as I waited…read morefor a simple small Cheese pizza.

Hummus Plate

See all

Margherita pizza

When Pigs Fly Pizzeria

3.9(753 reviews)

3.0 mi

The Pizzeria was bustling and noisy, but happy. Waitress very friendly. ALL sorts of beer…read moreavailable. We had simple red pizza w mushroom, sausage, and arugula. Everything was just right. To me, the Best part was the WPF Bread store on the other side. Their bread is the BEST! And here there were many flavors I'd never seen before. Plus they were having a 2/1 sale so only $4.50 per delicious loaf. I left w a granola-blueberry and a chocolate-chocolate chip. The orange-cranberry was fantastic but I thought had more sugar. The staff was nice here too. I wish the store was closer to my home! The outside area was very attractive also.

We've been here in the past and really enjoyed the pizza, which made our experience Friday night…read moreespecially surprising and disappointing. Unfortunately, the pizza was soft, undercooked, and just not good. It was such a noticeable difference from what we've had here before. We didn't finish it and didn't even want to take the leftovers home -- it was that disappointing. Hopefully this was just an off night, because our previous experiences had been much better.

Seating

Pork belly steak buns

See all

Seating

Stones Throw

4.1(266 reviews)

2.9 mi

It was a perfect day on the coast with our California relatives. Not too hot so perfect to sit…read moreoutside and enjoy the sunshine, the view and good food Very relaxed atmosphere and great staff. Full bar and mocktails. And apps to start us off. Just sit and enjoy the view. Yes you are in the street to occasionally a big truck goes by but with the right company who cares. You see the ocean and smell the salt air. Menu is good. Vegan options and of course seafood. It's up there on price both worth it. Indoor and outdoor seating and I believe they bought the building next door with a balcony area but not 100% sure. The food was great and a lot on the plate. The tacos only come with tacos. No fries or rice or side something. Was a bit disappointed but in the end it was ok. Large portions of fish and chips. And did I mention the view. Street parking is available but can be a challenge. Do you know how to parallel park? You might need to park down the road a bit and walk but you can't go wrong with a walk on the beach before or after your meal.

If you're looking for a good drink with great views, Stones Throw won't disappoint. They have a…read morerooftop bar (open Friday evenings and all day on Saturday/Sunday), it's just located - quite discreetly - next door to the restaurant itself. The same food and drink is served there, but you'll need to communicate that with the host at the restaurant (there was some pushback from the rooftop bar staff when we came about them not being able to seat us because the host needed to make that decision and then tell them; whereas the host at the restaurant told us to just go on over). + The drink I had was good: I got a blackberry sour that was refreshing. If we had had more time, I would have also tried the painkillah' with a rum floater. And, honestly, the mocktails sounded great too! Also, their glassware is lovvvveeellly, make sure you pay attention to that! + They've got vegan options: While we didn't order food, I would have loved to have tried the vegan "crabby" cakes with cilantro aioli! -/+ The views are not unbroken: while you'll be able to take in panoramic views of the ocean, they're disrupted by an abundance of black power lines (this is not true if you're sitting in the restaurant, but you will have loads of people lingering on the sidewalk next to you waiting to be seated). Expect it to be VERY busy in the summer! I see myself returning here when it's a wee bit quieter.

Inside

Tuna Crispy Rice

See all

Carrot marg

LaPizzeria

3.9(219 reviews)

7.7 mi

We have been to this place multiple times and haven't been disappointed yet! Great food and…read moreatmosphere while watching the hustle and bustle on Main Street.

My husband placed the order for a small pizza and a garden salad, he was told that it would be…read moreready in 20 minutes. I received a call an hour after he had left to pick up the order that he was just leaving the restaurant with our order. He arrives 20 minutes later because of traffic...the pizza should be still be slightly warm. NOPE, it's not even close to being warm. My husband requested paper plates...not there either. We will not be going back. Cold pizza and warm salad. $28.

Bruschetta

See all

Penguin wants Lasagna

Ruby's Wood Grill

3.2(218 reviews)

0.1 mi

stopped by because everyone was raving about their hamburgers! they were right, absolutely…read morefantastic! Sara our server was equally wonderful' ! Mondays they are only 7.$

Calamari. Buffalo chicken dip with nachos. Calamari was ok,…read morea little cold but not terrible. Nacho dip was really off, tasted like mayonaise under a layer of melted cheese. We did not get sick. But thought we might. They have burgers, pasta and wood fired pizza. I hope these are better.

Inside

6612. Big's Buffalo Chicken Dip

See all

The outside

Odd By Nature Brewing

Amazing food and beer! Definitely ask for the donut grilled cheese and chicken and waffle conesread more

Went to Odd by Nature on a whim during our staycation. Immediately were welcomed by both Joseph and…read moreRicardo at the bar. Beer is excellent but most surprisingly was how fantastic the cocktail program was! We loved chatting with them both about their travels, love of drinks and their knowledge of both the industry and the drinks they serve. We are so glad we stopped, it made for such an awesome night and great part of our trip. We will be bringing our friends back to visit very soon!

Lobster Roll Flight

Burrito Bowl

See all

Flo's Burger

Spruce Creek Pizza

4.2(38 reviews)

4.4 mi

customer service is amazing, they treat you like a king. Food also makes you feel like a king,…read moreeverything's outstanding. great atmosphere, people, and food. would highly recommend if out with friends or family. -get the Philly cheese it's insane

Menú said white pizza online so we drove a decent bit to grab pizza to bring to the bar…read more Specifically because they had slices and my boyfriend and i like very different pizza ... show up and they have no white slices despite online saying they do. Needless to say i don't eat red sauce and got nothing ... bf said it was fine though. Please update the online menu...

Say cheese

I've been looking for an outstanding Chicken Parm Sub in the area. This one is fine.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Will P.

0

1

0

13 years ago

Awesome food, and great, friendly service! Finally a great alternative to all the other boring pizza places in town . The menu is always changing, with fresh ingredients and new ideas. A really great place to check out for lunch or dinner! Perfect for those moments when you can't decide what to eat. Whether it pizza, soups or sandwiches, Jason (the owner) always has something that will strike your fancy on the menu. Highly recommend ! read more

Brian W.

0

1

0

12 years ago

We live in York, Maine and are always looking for a great place to go for a quick bite to eat in a relaxed atmosphere. It's small but the food is outstanding. I had a TUNA sandwich that was the best I've ever had, and my daughter, had a cheese pizza that she loved. The staff is also very cognizant of food allergies, and was incredibly respectful of my daughter's food allergies. We will be back for sure!!!! read more

Yvette A.

0

5

0

9 years ago

Great restaurant and awesome food but waitress is TERRIBLE!!!!! We stopped in yesterday and recognized her from Ricks restaurant down the street and was disappointed because of how rude she is. She will critique absolutely anything you order and makes you feel bad for what you order. I will absolutely order takeout at the York 54 but will not come back because of the horrible service. read more

David W.

1

9

0

9 years ago

Probably my favorite place to get lunch in town, as I was reading this to my wife she told me she posted that too so listen to us its delicious. The sandwich bread is freshly baked and quality ingredients are used. My go to is the ABLT (avocado). In the winter I normally get a soup with a side of fresh bread. read more

J E.

0

1

0

12 years ago

Great, fresh, imaginative-but-not-weird food. There are always great specials, including delicious soups and pizzas. Our favorites include the ABLT sandwich, the blue cheese pizza, and the 'perfect 10' pizza. The staff is always friendly. This is a definite 'must try' restaurant in York. read more

Amanda W.

1

14

1

9 years ago

One of my favorite lunch spots. I work near by so I have not dined in, but I always do take out. Food is very delicious and flavorful. Jason, the owner is friendly and accommodating. We work near by and have had many people use them for their private parties. read more

Mia S.

0

3

0

12 years ago

Honestly, can't get better than York 54. People, food, location, experience...all the best. Try any special of the day and you'll love it! We'll go back as often as we can! Special shout out to Christina! Enjoyed the chat! read more

Pat W.

9

2

5

13 years ago

Awesome pizza, very nice bartenders and waitress, soup to die for, amicable owner, and some of the best wines you can get for 5.00 to 6.00 dollars. Try the William Hill and Bridlewood, nice. read more

H R.

157

65

1

3 years ago

We love this place! Both the food and service are fantastic. We told the whole family about this spot. If you're in York, it's a must try!

Madelyn H.

0

6

0

3 years ago

Great food and great people! My coworkers and I love coming here after a long day of work and enjoy ourselves always

Timmy T.

1

11

0

12 years ago

Pizza and buffalo quesadillas are awesome. Best gourmet pizza around. Much better than 'when swine fly'

Ernest I.

87

33

0

9 years ago

Never seen such a rude waitress in my life. WOW! Won't be back. Stick up butt needs to be removed asap.

Maureen B.

0

20

16

11 years ago

Great pizza! Thin flavorful! Fresh ingredients! Great staff! I live local my number 1 choice. read more

Bill C.

22

38

4

12 years ago

The pizza is very good here but my favorite thing is the sandwiches.

John H.

0

2

0

12 years ago

The super sausage and Margarita pizza were superb!!

York 54 - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed York 54 also viewed

Dante's Pizza Company

4.4

(71 reviews)

Absolutely delicious Detroit-style pizza. You'd expect it to be pretty heavy, but it honestly…read morewasn't the dough was surprisingly light with great flavor, while still having that perfect Detroit-style crust. Chicken tenders and onion rings for an app were excellent highly recommend! The outdoor seating area is a huge plus too. Plenty of space to hang out, and pets are welcome, which makes it an awesome spot to grab some pizza and relax outside. Definitely recommend Dante's if you're in the York, Maine area. We'll be back!

This is still unreal pizza........but I ordered via phone tonight and was told 15min upon arrival…read moreand Waiting 15:turned to 30. I understand if they'd got busy upon my arrival. If you saw me I am not going to starve.. In the end I got the good fellows with added sausage. I will say charge me more for sausage and put more on the pizza. On 1/2 the pizza my wife said she got 3 pieces ....... Charge me more. Still love Dante's. Every day makes you better and better.

Spruce Creek Pizza

4.2

(38 reviews)

customer service is amazing, they treat you like a king. Food also makes you feel like a king,…read moreeverything's outstanding. great atmosphere, people, and food. would highly recommend if out with friends or family. -get the Philly cheese it's insane

Menú said white pizza online so we drove a decent bit to grab pizza to bring to the bar…read more Specifically because they had slices and my boyfriend and i like very different pizza ... show up and they have no white slices despite online saying they do. Needless to say i don't eat red sauce and got nothing ... bf said it was fine though. Please update the online menu...

Pizza Market

3.5

(59 reviews)

HUGE large pizzas. Three of us could barely eat one. Excellent flavors, friendly staff. Highly…read morerecommend.

I've tried a lot of pizza places around this area and Pizza Market is the best! The 20" pizzas are…read morehuge and loaded with toppings. And, they taste great. I also had an incredible grilled chicken salad with bacon. The bacon was real and in chunks. The chicken was a real chicken breast cut into chunks. Very impressed with this meal. Pizza Market will be a new go-to. Plus, love the convenience of ordering online. So much better than many of the other, more expensive places.

Gigi's Pizza

4.2

(25 reviews)

Great food and service. I Recommend the sandwiches. Food overall in good!…read more Great lunch place!

It's okay, but I'm a fan of tasty crust with a chew, and Gaslight has a much better crust…read more We ordered the BBQ Chicken pizza, and it was good, but we've had better.

York House of Pizza

3.4

(70 reviews)

Never seen this happen before anywhere... we ordered a small pizza, half pepperoni half plain. They…read moretook an already cooked and sliced pizza, put pepperoni on one side, threw a little more cheese on top of the pepperoni, and cooked it again. Umm... really?!?! Besides that, it looked and tasted ok. It wasn't over cooked considering what they did. We will forever miss the days when Peter and Paul owned York House of Pizza. It's never been as good since they sold it. I'm giving the current owners a very generous 3 stars.

Had DoorDash deliver. Very good pizza burger and fries! Would use again if I'm back in the arearead more

Meserve’s Market

4.9

(21 reviews)

Decided to finally check this place out after driving by this all the time. We were very impress…read morehow close and quick it was. The service was great! The food was delicious and has a generous serving, pizza was a little chewy but that's okay! We will order again!

Food freshly made and a great variety of pre-made salads, pizza slices, sandwiches and sides. Small…read moremarket items in store. Lots of outdoor seating with some picnic tables covered. Took less than 20 minutes to get freshly made food.

The York River Landing

3.4

(452 reviews)

the food was FANTASTIC!!!! and so was the service!!!! I really don't understand why the reviews are…read moreso low. it was the best food I have had in a while. the waitress was super sweet and kind to my kids. and there's ice cream outside! Out of all of the places I. The area on the seacoast, this beat them all. And I've lived on the seacoast my entire life.

This review is for the ice cream - THAT'S the real treasure!! (The actual restaurant is an…read moreexperience to avoid, for me has never been pleasant). Would be 5 stars for the ice cream, but can't recommend the restaurant. One of the BEST ice cream spots!!! Great view, great seating, corn hole, decent portions, excellent flavours, plenty of parking... It's so ideal!!

Nik & Charlies Pizzeria

3.7

(87 reviews)

I love Nik & Charlie's for their Greek salads, gyros, Italian subs, and more. Great ingredients and…read moreservice! Will, Tracy, and the crew know what's up!

Tracy and Will are fabulous! They treat you like family. The pizza quality is excellent. They make…read moretheir own dough, sauce, and cut the cheese. The restaurant is immaculate and they are fast.

Anthony's Food Shop

4.3

(329 reviews)

I used Anthony's recently for a catering event for Family while on vacation. Tammy Ramsey was…read morewonderful to work with on the catering. Food was excellent. Would highly recommend this business.

Best prepared meals and the pastries are even more delicious. Pizza, subs and pasta dishes are…read moreawesome too. Like the North End in Boston came to York, Maine.

Badger's Island Pizza

3.4

(57 reviews)