Your Pie Pizza

Was in the area, this time with my teenager. Bryce was our server, and did well. I got Gateway…read moreGrits, teen got wings and fries. Everything was good as usual. Always worth a visit.

Driving through and saw this place with a busy parking lot, so we decided to comeback…read more Good choice. Started with the Pizza Frita. Oh my goodness. I then had the strawberry salad. Super nice. Wife had the meatballs & bread. Good flavor thru out. Place was chill as it was a Sunday. Lots of to go go orders on the pizzas. Service was good.

Inside dining

Our fav- Truffle Shuffle & cold beer! We went around 8ish, the nice metal fans and the breeze kept date night on the deck perfect!

See all

Interior

Slab Town Pizza

4.3(243 reviews)

42.0 mi

We always enjoy Slabtown's pizza, sandwiches and Schrute Farms beets, goat cheese and arugula…read moresalad! New menu with updated prices. The staff is friendly and fast. Great for families.

I've been a fan of Slab Town since it opened. I decided to order take out to share with a friend of…read moremine. We got a White Pizza to share and a Cesar Salad. The Pizza was delicious, but only had a little bit of sausage on a couple of pieces. Wish it had at least been spread out on the pizza a bit more. The Cesar Salad was divine as always. It seems to consistently be busy, even in the off season. It's pretty loud inside, but the booths are well spaced and they have an outdoor seating option. It's more expensive than I would have hoped, but definitely worth the try!

Indoor seating

Single slice pizza with ham, pepperoni and mushrooms

See all

Bar seating

Ma-Ma Dar's Pizza

4.6(59 reviews)

5.5 mi

Food is delicious. Generous portions. Highly recommend Philly Cheesesteak and pizza! Friendly staff.read more

Large meat pizza and wings. Pizza was great and reheats really well. Hot wings were tasty and just…read morethe right amount of heat. Drive 45 min to try it out. Definitely worth the trip!

See all

Cheese pizza

Chicago's Pizza

4.1(121 reviews)

2.1 mi

Stopped in last week for some dinner to go. Even during the middle of the week, they can get busy…read more Spaghetti sauce, meatballs, and cheesy bread were all great. Definitely get the deep dish, however the pizza crust can be a little dry. It needs some finishing garlic butter at the end. Negatives - salad tasted old and is kind of plain. But can partially be excused as a throw away. I know a large styrofoam container should go at the bottom of the plastic bag, but then don't set heavy spaghetti and meatballs on top of the cheesy bread. Also negative was the attitude. I know you're busy, but then don't allow orders to be taken in the bar. Not a customer in there, but it seemed I bothered them to place my order. And then I waited 30 min for my order and didn't offer any water, even though I waited at the bar after ordering. Treat every customer like a secret shopper.

Best deep dish pizza! Excelent service and atmosphere. Clean. Great food! Highly recommend.read more

Dining Room

Chicken Parmigiana

See all

This is their famous Chicago DEEP dish

Brickhouse Burgers, Pizza & Pasta

4.0(109 reviews)

13.2 mi

Service 10/10, food 11/10!!!!!! So good, place was comfy but small. Very yummy place and would…read morerecommend to anyone stopping by helen.

On a cold late afternoon , we wanted to look for something comforting and warm to be inside . As…read moresoon as we walked in we got seated immediately and it was such a comfy restaurant. We placed our order and everything was fresh and warm when it go served to us. The Mac and cheese was delicious and it has so much cheese , and big portions definitely can be shared . I also tried the pasta a la vodka and it was so good . If you're in Helen you just try this cute little spot .

Inside. August 2026

White cap pizza

See all

Dugout Sports Grill

3.4(30 reviews)

7.5 mi

The wing were great! Since we get takeout, they told us what…read moretime to be there and it was right on time.. Looks like a great place to eat, but we just always bring it home

Arrived almost 90min before closing only to be told by the nice waitress that the kitchen had…read moreclosed...so disappointed as per the reviews we were happy to have a restaurant so close to our Airbnb...we came on a Sun night to watch the NFL game...but nope, back into Helen we drove. Maybe next time..maybe not.

Tropical Storm $5

See all

Country fried steak sandwich

Domino's Pizza

2.7(7 reviews)

0.2 mi

Appreciate the fast, accurate and efficient service. We do not order frequently; yet, every time we…read morehave, it has been great!

AI doesn't work for this type business! Very very annoying to try and get a simple pizza ordered!…read moreEven when I got a real person they were surly and put me on hold and then cut me off.

Papa's Pizza To Go

4.2(48 reviews)

13.1 mi

Unfortunately the website has no clue as to the actual business hours. open, maybe?…read more Closed, possibly. So no online ordering and telephone seems to annoy the workers. That equals no order no food and is it open or closed? Still no idea.Love the food, just can't get the food.

From the outside it isn't anything fancy but it's a pizza place so that really isn't a big deal…read more Had it not been for the previous yelp reviews we would not have stopped. We were glad we did! Service and the counter was straight forward. They had coupons on the counter to the right that we used. No problem! I had a two topping large pizza ordered well done. It had black olives and jalapeños. It was delicious! The only problem was that I can't stand sit down experiences with disposable plates and to go drink's/styrofoam for water. Other than that solid pizza and worth the stop.

See all

Outside of restaurant

AJ's Pizza Pub

3.8(69 reviews)

5.6 mi

The aroma is amazing! We got the family deal - a large…read morepizza, large salad and garlic rolls. Just fabulous but the rolls were incredible! Mom & Pop style and quite lovely!

The food is always delicious here. They have a bar and music which is refreshing. The service is…read morepretty good, our wait time would be about 15-30 minutes. The waitresses are sweet and listen to what you want. The even suggest if you're not sure . We came here for lunch beige, our dish bread birthday, and date night. Their wings are so good. Right amount of sauce and crisp.

Packed Saturday night.

Ohhh! I did get a pic of a couple of wings... that garlic parm topping is the best!!

See all

The snickers chocolate cake

Mariolino’s Italian Cuisine

4.6(55 reviews)

44.2 mi

There I was, hungry, chunky, tired from white water rafting. I walk into this lovely establishment,…read moregreeted by a man with a fantastic accent and a dining room with impeccable taste. This place brought me so much happiness and joy. I got the salmon Alfredo as a test of sorts. I'm picky, VERY picky when it comes to pasta, even worse with sauces. I taste the avocado salad first. One singular tear of pure joy falls from my eye. The chicken was fried perfectly. The food didn't stand a chance against my appetite. I didn't even get to get a photo of my meal before I was violently destroying my plates (with love.) My sweet tea was perfect. Not sugar water, not overly sweet nor under sweetened. I didn't even need to ask for a refill, they just offered right when k was low. Then I tasted the salmon Alfredo. You know those scenes in ratatouille? When remy tastes the cheese and the strawberry together? Then when the food critic had the ratatouille? That's exactly what happened. It was as if the chef and waiters were ethereal beings sent from heaven solely to give my meager human taste buds a chance of experiencing pure bliss. It was gorgeous. I will be back if only to experience the beauty of such blessed Italian food. Other restaurants wish they can be like Mariolino's, I guarantee you, that other restaurants fall short.

Decent Italian restaurant in town. Pizza was ok, there are better options in the area if you want a…read moresolid pie. Calzone was cheesy and flavorful. Ambiance here is mixed as the lighting and staff dress looks upscale but it's really more casual. Come as you are is what I'm saying. Basically if you're craving Italian and don't want to drive far from Andrews this is your best option.

Dining area..

Chicken Parmesan sandwich.

See all

Love the lobster soup.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

15 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Claude S.

9 years ago

Your Pie is amazing! I brought my family in and everyone loved it!! No compromising needed here, everyone gets to build their own toppings on their own pizza. The food is wonderful. The dining area is clean and the staff is friendly and extremely helpful. If you have not been here, you need to go!!! read more

Chance P.

8 years ago

Oh man! Where do I start? You get to create your own pizza, the beer choices are amazing, and the gelato for dessert is everything I wanted it to be. The staff was very nice and helpful. We also are outside on the balcony and it was lovely. I will definitely recommend this place to anyone and everyone. read more

Alissa R.

6 years ago

I really appreciate the employees that work here and they do a good job. The food I really enjoy having food allergies suck, but having your pie near is a God send, I'm gluten free and dairy free, so the fact that I can get a pizza the way I need it is great. Thank you your pie read more

Silly G.

7 years ago

Just came in and made up my own pizza and it was Fabulous! White crust with ranch and pesto base with mozzarella, feta, parmesan, bell peppers, red onion, spinach, tomatoes, olives, garlic, and chicken. The best experiment ever. Gotta love this place! Here's what's left... read more

Jennifer B.

4 years ago

This place has amazing pizza and my daughter is a picky eater and loved it. The kids dinner was well priced and she loved being able to play with dough and watch her pizza being made! read more

Michael H.

6 years ago

the food was good and very good service the people there are also super nice. Nice little restaurant for any couple, family or anyone can go to read more

Melanie A.

8 years ago

Great place! Food is cooked to order. Salads are just lettuce, but food is very good. Owners are super nice. We love it.

Trista B.

7 years ago

I love being able to decide what I want on my pizza and I love the fun cheese alternatives! We adore Your Pie!

Greta R.

7 years ago

Never had a pizza I didn't enjoy from here. Always delicious. Staff has always been very friendly as well.

Frances W.

3 years ago

I love choosing my own toppings. They can do 1/2 and 1/2 if we want different toppings. Also good gelato's

Richard G.

6 years ago

Quality product, good customer service. Clean place, nice atmosphere. Not cheap, but it is good.

Nina R.

4 years ago

Love the food! Staff is always pleasant! ------------Filler because I have nothing much to add

Mary J.

6 years ago

Friendly staff. Lunch specials are a great deal. Pizza is delicious. Definitely recommend!

Amy P.

7 years ago

Love this place. Pizza tastes great! They do gluten free for me that's super important

Jaden S.

6 years ago

there're food isn't the best, but it is very kid friendly.

Your Pie Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Your Pie Pizza also viewed

Nacoochee Village Tavern & Pizzeria

3.8

(521 reviews)

Food was pretty good, we had GF pizza with the house bread. The pizza wasn't bad but the bread was…read moresubpar. The service was really slow but our waitress was friendly. It's a loud place with a nice outdoor seating area. Only one bathroom.

This place was off the beaten path. Mainly because Helen has a lot of restaurants next to each…read moreother and this one is about .6 miles away from the shops starting. Parking: plenty and bathrooms inside. Sign out front said to sit anywhere and we were helped immediately. Fast, efficient, and easy service. So kind and so helpful and quick to offer any help making items gluten free. I heard them walking several people through their orders as well. As someone who has to eat gluten free this was an especially good pizza. It was a crunchy, thin crust but wow. Amazing ingredients and this pizza was amazing. Ceasar salad dressing made in house and perfect amount of peppercorn! They were so nice and the whole trip was lovely. I would highly recommend.

Brickhouse Burgers, Pizza & Pasta

4.0

(109 reviews)

Service 10/10, food 11/10!!!!!! So good, place was comfy but small. Very yummy place and would…read morerecommend to anyone stopping by helen.

Atlas Pizza

4.1

(492 reviews)

All I can say is WOW! My daughter and I came here on the recommendation of an employee at an…read moreantique shop nearby. We were told that there is sometimes a wait for tables and I can understand why! We arrived around 3:30 pm so we were able to get in right away. Our server was attentive and friendly. We both got sandwiches rather than pizza and they were soooooo good! I got the BBQ turkey sub, which included turkey, bbq sauce, caramelized onions, cheddar jack cheese, and bacon on a hearty, tasty French bread sub roll. The flavors went together extremely well, with a touch of sweetness. My daughter got the meatball sub and was over the moon with the size and taste of the meatballs. It's a fun place with local art in a historic building. I highly recommend it!

Went for a quick lunch date on Saturday. Staff were super friendly and we were sat immediately! The…read morefood came out fast and was so good! It all tasted so fresh! Would definitely recommend!

Vendetta's Pizza, Pasta & Grill

4.3

(37 reviews)

Our group of 5 went in for a late lunch on Saturday afternoon. We were greeted right away and…read moreseated. When we arrived it was fairly empty but later several tables filled up. Open, lots of natural light and nice decor. Bryanna out server came right over and took drink orders while we decided on appetizers. We opted for the fried calamari and the spinach/artichoke dip. Calamari was perfectly cooked. The dip was not as thick as I normally see but both items very tasty. Entrees were also well made. These are lunch portions pictured which no one was able to finish. lol. Dishes were well seasoned, pasta al dente and delicious overall. Service was great. Bryanna checked on us often, was very efficient and offered dessert even though we were unable to partake. We all had leftovers to take home. Check out this local spot if you're in the area.

A new place for me , I came here to meet my daughter who lives in Gainesville and wanted something…read moreItalian so our first time here. Quaint, nice ambience service was fantastic. Menu was very Italian, some traditional dishes I'm sure to the owner as well as they were red sauce, which is standard on mini dishes. . This is sangria only so no beer or liquor, which was a little disappointing but does not affect the review. I survived and got a beer later.!! We all ordered with the mixture of pizza to my chicken pasta, tortellini, and shrimp fettuccine. All were well-made, the pizza really stood out with a great crust and flavor. My chicken presented well but was really lacking seasoning but nothing a little salt and pepper didn't correct. Shrimp fettuccine also seem to lack seasoning, but I tend to look for a little more aggressive seasoning before tasting.. Plates were nice portions, even had to get two to go boxes, including half the pizza which we enjoy later.. if you're looking for Italian, this was very good. Very family, friendly and service was impeccable.. Highly recommend!!

Papa Johns Pizza

3.5

(19 reviews)

The Cornelia Papa Johns has been a staple for our local veteran organizations. This location gives…read moreveterans a 1/2 off deal on all orders. We appreciate that very much! The pizzas are always great and the staff is friendly. I highly recommend this store!

Pizza and cookies were good. We didn't like the wings. Everything was delivered hot and quickly.read more

Jersey Mike's Subs

4.2

(16 reviews)

If you would have asked me what I thought of Jersey Mike's Subs, I would have told you that I have…read morenever been there and, frankly, I don't care for my sub sandwich affairs. However, this endeavor pleasantly surprised me. The building not crowded at all, given that it was a random Monday in September, and the service was pretty quick. Our sandwich maker was very nice and they didn't do anything like touch the coins and then the food and it seemed pretty clean. I ordered a kids veggie sandwich and she looked at me kinda weird but I'm over the age you would consider a child so... My sandwich was amazing. I ordered jalapeños along with the regular toppings, and the provolone cheese balanced it out with superb technique. Highly recommend. TL;DR: Pretty good, but better when your SIL is in labor and your grandpa is about to have heart surgery

After placing an order in the app, I had to wait an additional 15 minutes past the time my order…read morewas supposed to be ready. The sandwich itself was a sloppy mess. It looked like something from subway it was so bad

Itala Pizza

5.0

(4 reviews)

Finally an authentic pizza place in our area! We ordered the Milano - Meat Lovers pizza (added…read moremushrooms) Americano salad and a slice of limoncello cake. The pizza was absolutely delicious! And huge! The salad was fresh and dressings are made in house. Also large enough to share. The dessert tasted fresh as well. Their pricing is higher than your typical chain pizza joint and worth every penny for the quality ingredients and amazing food. See you again soon Itala

Best Pizza north of Alpharetta. Blows everything else out of the park. Staff is awesome, I believe…read morethe main guy is a man and he's always working, very friendly and welcoming. Not a huge staff, and great hours. The vibe is great. They care about your pie and you. Dave portnoy come on! Need more Gelato flavors

Mellow Mushroom

4.1

(249 reviews)

It is a great place to meet friends and enjoy a pleasant experience with superb servers and…read morebartenders. A very relaxed atmosphere where everyone knows your name. Meet new friends, reconnect with old friends or be a hermit.

We heard it was the best pizza in Gainesville so we had to try it. Nestled downtown on a block of…read morecolonial style buildings occupied by various businesses. The atmosphere is welcoming and casual with abundant seating indoors and outdoors. I love the different seating areas, the bar, dining room, booths. We were seated right away and our server Olivia was very friendly and accommodating. She recommended the Holy Shitaki pizza and we added the Mighty Meat & Pacific Rim to complete our order. The flavors of the pizzas were fantastic and the dough delightful. We also enjoyed a chocolate cookie for dessert. My daughter's favorite was the Holy Shitaki and we did regret not getting a large order. We will definitely be back for it. Overall 10 out of 10 recommended. If you're ever in Gainesville stop by Mellow Mushroom. It will not disappoint!

Max's Lakeside

4.5

(39 reviews)

Came during the 4th of July weekend, and was just blown away by the place. Our waiter, Marcus, was…read morefantastic, even giving recommendations on drinks. The pizza we slit was the best I've had. The flavors perfectly balanced, light, and crust, crispy.

Staff is excellent, great drinks appetizers and pizza. Our favorites are the shrimp scampi,…read moreburrata caprese, the Greek salad and the Arugula & Prosciutto pizza. Great place!

Dairy Queen Grill & Chill

3.0

(11 reviews)