We come to this location weekly, if not every other week....always greeted well and they're good on the front line but there is way to much cross contamination between topping choices...I'm lactose intolerant and there is always cheese in the Marinara sauce witch have to point out to the line worker so I don't get any. Usually gets that way when they're extremely busy...and they swamped at times. It all gets worked out in the end and an excellent pie cones to the table...pretty consistent in the pizza making. read more

I've been to the old location many times; just went to the new location for the first time. The pasta and the chicken in the pasta was cold even though the top was melted-ish. The sweet tea container had unsweet tea. I mentioned that the chicken and pasta itself was cold and perhaps they could cook it for longer next time. I hope it's just growing pains with the new equipment at the new location. I'm pretty sure that the toppings are pre-cooked, but still, I'd prefer it nice and hot as it used to be at the old location instead of cold chicken and sauce. read more

Your Pie - Pasta bowl - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

I love this location, mainly because there's free parking right out front (always a big deal!). The restaurant itself is small but cozy, located on the corner of a shopping strip in the Skidaway area, right next to Dollar Tree. You order at the counter, and I really appreciate that they have a separate prep area for food allergies. They also bake allergy-friendly pizzas on trays instead of directly on the oven surface, which helps avoid cross-contamination. They offer gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese, plus bottled beers and ciders (though no bar on site). Overall, the space is small but quaint, clean, and family-friendly, with staff who are both friendly and knowledgeable. read more

Your Pie - Vegan gluten free supreme - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Good place for a hot tasty pizza and wings. The food was out minutes after ordering.

Not sure what's been going on here but the pizzas are going down hill. Your Pie is a go-to spot for me when I'm craving pizza, at least until my past several visits here. Each time the pizzas are under cooked and under topped. Most recently I got their seasonal peach and prosciutto pizza with added bacon. When I got it, I had to really look for most of the toppings. Unfortunately I was in a rush so I could not bring it up in house. Just check my comparison picture from their menu to what they served. I hope management does some trainings on quality control in this location. read more

Your Pie - What a disappointing peach and prosciutto pizza! Their pizzas keep going down hill here. - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

We already love your pie in Pooler, but found ourselves hungry near this location. Love the interior and various seating options. Staff was fantastic, and our pies were delicious. read more

Stopped by Your Pie for pizza tonight while in town visiting the family. We have been here a few times before and had no issues. Tonight was much different. It started out by following an employee at the restroom coming out as I was going in. Obviously she had been hitting the vape in there. Also, no paper towels so not sure how she got those hands clean. When we ordered my kids asked for a bit more cheese which we were told was $1 extra. More sauce - $1 extra - we haven't experience that at our hometown Your Pie so it was a surprise. My wife has an allergy so she has to be careful with most of the meats but her veggie pizza got some extra toppings from the meat guy without asking for them. It was from the chicken container but as you will see from the picture attached it could have been almost any kind of meat. I have never seen such a mess! They did remake hers without any problem which was appreciated. Hopefully this is an isolated incident and some improvements can be made to tighten up the ship at this location. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Another Your Pie location in Savannah I love! I will dine in here, pick up to go, or mobile order here too. This location has plenty of parking thanks to the parking lot provided which is shared with other businesses/restaurants. It is located at the very end of the shopping center. Once you pass the dollar stores you will see the sign for Your Pie. I love all of the choices at Your Pie! There is truly something for everyone. If you have an allergy have no fear. They will make your pizza separately. Just let the pizza makers behind the counter know. There are gluten free, diary free, keto, & vegan options. They have white, wheat, gluten free, & cauliflower/cheese crust options. There are also chopped salads, breadsticks, & pastas. All of which are baked in the brick oven. Just choose from the multitude of toppings and it does not take long for your food to come out piping hot to you! Beer and wine, in limited options are available too. When you enter if you are placing an order turn directly to your left to join the line if there is one. They make everything to order. It is not a quick process. But they do move as swiftly as they can. It's worth the wait! If you are picking up an mobile order/order you placed online walk straight to the register. Let them know you are there yo pick up and your name and then walk out with your food! Generally I'll do mobile orders with their app most of the time to skip the line and wait time. If you are dining in there are high tops running the wall towards the front. In the back there are more tables with additional seating. The bathrooms are all the way to the back of the restaurant. They also have a fenced in outdoor area to sit as well. Last but not least, sign up for their rewards program! It is free to join. You can earn free drinks, food, or merchandise! read more

Your Pie - Pizza box with logo - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

See all

Worst pizza I've ever had. I ordered a white pizza, which in other establishments is always very good. This was like eating dough. I felt like they left off the garlic and the olive oil because it was dry and had zero taste. So I called to say these things and I was met with a very snippy and rude manager who said that she was the one who made it and she made it correctly! She made no offer to correct it. I said is that all you have to say? Her reply was, "Yep!" I'm shocked at how rude how immature her demeanor was. I'm never going to return and I'll certainly tell all of my friends out AR Sandfly not to go there. Never have I had such bad customer service or such bad pizza. read more

Cauliflower Crust is not bad, all veggie ingredients are fresh. Pleasant vibes and friendly service. read more

Your Pie - Cauliflower Crust (extra crispy) - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

After eating lots of seafood on our trip to Savannah we decided to get a pizza for our last night. After reading several reviews on Yelp & Google we decided to try Your Pie. It feels a lot like "Blaze" but it was clear that they have higher quality ingredients. We had salads & pizza. The salads were fresh & crunchy. The pizza was not bad - it needed a few more minutes in the oven & to be turned, so that it would be crispy. Because it was undercooked & not turned some of the pieces were slightly doughy. The kids who work here weren't rude - but definitely not well prepared to work with the public. Not personable or friendly. Overall it was kinda "meh" .... Not bad ... not amazing. But just okay. read more

See all

The vibe of the restaurnt was very chill and the service was amazing! The pizza was great for 2 people and was plenty to share. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza had the perfect combination of cheese and sauce. read more

Your Pie - 10" cheese pizza with banana peppers and green peppers - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

I think Your Pie generally has good pizza, they use quality ingredients, you can order your pizza with the ingredients you like,and it comes out hot and ready to enjoy; that is if you are eating in the store. If you order carry out, be sure to check your pizza before you leave. I drove 14 miles (round trip) only to get home and find that the pizza I received was not even close to my order. A waste of my time and money! read more

I came here twice and still loving the pizzas. I ordered for takeout and my order was ready in a short period of time. We got the Nat Pizza, the Lineage Pizza, and a custom pizza with chicken, spinach, mushroom, bell peppers and onions. I haven't tried the pasta yet but I am sure it is delicious. I almost tried the gelato so I will save that for next time. read more

See all

Can't say enough good things about this concept and this location, in particular. The staff is courteous, helpful, friendly, offer great suggestions, and always thank us for coming in. If you've never been, it's a great experience. You come in, choose your dough (white, wheat, gluten free), followed by your sauce and toppings. This is where you can go crazy and have some fun. I like to get ranchy-marinara or Alfredo with cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, spinach, beef, bacon, basil, and garlic. Take advantage of the meal deal and try their a-maz-ing gelato. Several flavors to choose from and they'll let you do taste tests before settling. They've recently redone the place and it looks great. Plenty of seating, very clean, lots of choices, fix your own beverage, and a nice outside porch. Definitely put this on your list of regular stops on Savannah. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

My wife and I were out in the "Sandfly" area the other day and went to Your Pie for lunch. It's located in a little strip shopping center at the intersection of Skidaway Rd. & Ferguson. I'm not usually a fan of quick-cooked very thin pizzas, but this was excellent. You pay a single price and select all the toppings you want. They also have a gluten-free crust and make a distinction as to whether it's just a dietary preference or if needs to be baked separately for Celiacs. And they also have vegan mozzarella and plant-based meats for those who are abstaining from animal products. As an added bonus, they have a variety of draft and bottled craft beers available. They even have a very good gluten-free beer from Spain (Estrella Daura Damm). Definitely not something we were expecting basically out in the middle of nowhere. read more

See all

This is my favorite local pizza shop! Always nice and crispy and they have the best ranch! read more

Your Pie - Lineage with ranch on the side - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Nice staff and facility, but I can only speak to the take out. The pizza just isn't very good, especially considering the price. Not much of any flavor in the crust which is an odd consistency. Seems to occupy a flavorless space between chewy and crispy. The thin and very mild marinara sauce does little to help, and the toppings didn't seem to be given much consideration either. My gluten free companions were even more dissatisfied and couldn't take more than a few bites.....a few very expensive bites. Not for us. Surprised this is a franchise thing. read more

We are new to Savannah and saw this place and stopped. Glad we did because we had a great experience. Staff was nice and it's like "Blaze Pizza", you build your own and they have gelato!!!! We would definitely come back! read more

Your Pie - Build your own! - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Love Your Pie! Sandfly location is our go-to because of location, but we do like the downtown one too! The pizza is delicious and the crust is always nice and crispy! The only hiccups we've ever experienced is an occasional mistake when we've placed to-go orders and we were missing a topping or two. The staff is always very friendly, and the restaurant clean. We eat Your Pie at least several times a month. It is fresh, delicious and super convenient!! read more

The 2 ladies that work here were less than friendly and not very helpful. It was more of an annoyance that we were there. Had we not been starving I would have went somewhere else. The concept is similar to chipotle just with a pizza concept. The pizza spots in Jacksonville it what ever you want on you pizza for one price. This place up charges there extra cheese and meat they deem premium. Cool extra $1 each. My son got a kids meal which is a 5 inch pizza, kids drink and a choice of gelato or apples. The decor and ambiance is pretty cool. It was hot and stuffy inside probably would have been a better choice to sit outside. Over all the food was great, service was lacking. read more

See all

Came in for a late lunch. I was greeted right away. Ordered a personal 10" pie and a drink. Pie was cooked and served quickly. Thin crust pizza was delicious. Definitely would come again when visiting this area. read more

I've worked my way through the pizza menu and they are all good. Your choice of crust: white, wheat or gluten-free. You can create your own or choose one of their very delicious creations. Fresh ingredients, made to order. They offer a good selection of beers. The salads are basic but the ingredients are fresh. I am not a fan of the gelato...it was gritty and powdery tasting. All else is a go though. This location is clean inside and they also have patio seating. Some of the staff is very no nonsense and others are engaging but they are all good at what they do and helpful, especially when you order at the wrong location online . They called and canceled at the other location and made my order at this location for me. So sweet. I recommend this location. read more

your pie is an excellent restaurant chain but this location is horrible. I have been here several times and never ...never I was satisfied with both the service and the customer service. I ordered a Ischia and the girl working at the toppings put just mozzarella and not tomato I had to remind her that the pizza comes with tomato and instead of apologize she answered "I was kidding"... really?? I requested and paid Pepperoni as extra topping... I got 5 slices. The pizza was over cooked and almost burnt. On my way out, I asked an empty cup for some to-go water.. they said "no". totally unpolite. STAY AWAY read more

Bland sauce and not enough of it. The keto crust was ok, but overall this was a disappointment. Probably a good place if you need to feed fussy kids, but Chef Boyardee must have created the sauce recipe. read more

the people there were very nice and kind my food was ready in like 5 minutes and I just lI've that

We eat here often and live the fresh pizza made exactly how we want it. Our young son enjoys the food and especially loves the gelato. I have read other reviews which talk about the staff, we have found good service some times and not so great other times. Probably my biggest disappointment is the bathroom, it needs some remodeling in order for it to look clean but honestly also just needs to be tended to more frequently. We have never been disappointed with the food and it is seldom busy. I also wish they filtered their water but most places do not. All and all we enjoy coming here and will continue to going forward. read more

See all

Have passed by Your Pie since moving to this area of Savannah and had a desire for Pizza today. Tried Your Pie. Served only "individual pizzas" - 10 inch more or less in diameter. Works out to about 1 and 1/2 slices of a normal sized pie. Can't be hungry and expect one to be satisfying.' Flavor was okay but not enough to put it above average. My suggestion is to find a better pizza restaurant. read more

We come here every week. The food is great and the wait staff fantastic. Great change of pace from other pizza restaurants. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Great, quick lunch stop. The Ischia was delicious with tons of fresh ingredients. I can really appreciate it when a pizza place doesn't skimp on the basil. Whole group loved the food. Resturant was clean and wonderful staff topped it all off. read more

By far, the best this side of the Southside! The staff is very respectful, courteous, and full of spunk. This place is clean and very welcoming to those that don't care to be around ignorant people. Sorry... oh, did I mention that it's prices are "very reasonable"! This place beats out the Bryan St location! read more

See all

I was looking for a simple slice of pizza. Nope, so I had to go with their small pizza. Happy I did! Very nice thin crust prepared with ingredients that I selected! And I could eat it on the side porch which is shaded by large trees. read more

I've ordered twice now hoping to give a second chance since this restaurant is one of the only with a cauliflower crust, they've left off every ingredient except the 5 slices of pepperoni, and it's been ice cold both times. Perhaps they make ahead of time and leave out I don't know but it's never ever fresh. read more

I'm a big fan of the Hippie but all the combinations are interesting. I'm not sure when extra items generate an up charge but some do. The gluten free crust is amazing and among the best gluten free I have eaten. I would return here. read more

Went there today and there food is amazing. I had the chicken panini. Last time u came it had black oven crust on it and it was nasty. Well they made up for themselves this time. I got a free salad with my savannah menu card.... they took less than 5 min to deliver the food so that is great because I was on my lunch break. read more

See all

This was a great happen by! We were looking for somewhere for lunch and saw Your Pie. Little wait at lunch time, I had a panini and my husband had a pizza. Tasted great and had lots of options for the make your own, like artichokes and pineapples. Gelato was pretty good as well. read more

The beer selection is amazing for a neighborhood pizza joint. Their pizza and panini creations are the best. They are just missing hot wings. read more

Your Pie - The kids love it - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

There pizza is made fresh and it comes out very quick. It is a little pricey but over all the pizza is very good. They said they haven't changed their gelato size but it definitely got smaller. It is a great place to eat and I love how you can bring your dogs and eat outside. read more

Local pizza at its finest! Very clean with very nice employees and great service! Will return most definitely to eat great tasting pizza. read more

Your Pie - Awesome as always! But we tried something new for lunch besides the usual. On the healthier side and great taste! - Pizza Near Me - Savannah, Georgia

Very decent pizza Cold environment. It's a McDonald's of the over priced pizza industry.