Owner is an arrogant prick that should just close his business. I wouldn't give this guy one cent. Blames his failing business on the store location. Aren't you on a main road you moron. Better off going to any other deli on long island than this one read more

Great neighborhood in Lindy. Excellent customer service and top shelf items. What keeps me going back is the Sinatra hero. Eggplant, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella/provolone, sliced prosciutto, one of the top Hero's on Long Island ! read more

It's my local neighborhood deli run by two brothers who put there heart and soul into business that was about to be shut down for good by previous owners many years ago. If you know "Cheers" than you know what I mean when I talk about neighborhood deli. They stepped up and gave the neighborhood a piece of home. You will find parking out front. You can place your order in advance. Optimally staffed with local residence. Closed on Sunday because everyone needs some summer time fun. Those who walk in greet each other like long loss friends because it's a place where you can catch up with your neighbors. The food here is top quality for a deli and I for one am glad and appreciate having them here. read more

35th St Family Deli - Inside - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

See all

What great hospitality. Went here for the first time today since moving here. I ordered the turkey BLT and my boyfriend ordered the bananas foster French toast. He asked if they were still serving breakfast since we arrived around 2pm and they said they do. My sandwich was well made with plentiful amounts of meat and every other ingredient. His French toast was amazing. Definitely would recommend. We ate in at their one table they have for guests. The staff checked on us multiple times to make sure that we didn't need anything else. They offered us complimentary coffee while we were waiting. They also gave us two free chocolate chip cookies. Would definitely go back here after this super pleasant experience. read more

35th St Family Deli - Turkey BLT - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

There are many deli zone Long Island as you know and I have to say this is one of the nicest people you'll ever meet Steve and Jimmy the brothers, very friendly polite and helpful, most of their pastries and cookies and desserts are homemade, they serve breakfast all day, everything I got was delicious and the wraps sandwiches are out of the world, they got a catering menu,They were so nice they even comped a few desserts, They Are located in a residential neighborhood, they have personally rented there for 8 yrs, Many of their clientele or Local's, I came across them on social media I'm glad I did, I'll definitely be back read more

See all

I really hate to leave a negative review for a small family business but here I am. I went there this morning to get a tuna melt. Asked for lettuce and onion. As you can see from my pictures they put a sliver of an onion and not lettuce. This sandwich was $11.99. I also got 5 rainbow cookies.. for $6.50. 6.50 for these 5 rainbow cookies?!!! I asked the girl at the counter if that was right and she said yes. Unfortunately I won't be back. Sandwiches are small, not right and extremely overpriced. read more

See all

Had catering done by them on multiple occasions, they went absolutely above and beyond. I couldn't recommend this place enough. Their food is fantastic, no complaints ever. Always have that welcoming feeling when you walk in read more

Fantastic food and service. We used them for a post wedding brunch. Our order consisted of the Family Breakfast Brunch package, a 4ft BEC / SEC breakfast hero, a 4ft Chicken Cutlet hero, and the mini yogurt parfaits( so fun and yummy) In the past, from other caterers, scrambled eggs were unappetizing to us. The texture was weird or they turned green from the aluminum tray. Not these! They assured me the eggs would be good; I was apprehensive. But they were right! We really enjoyed everything. Some people packed a to-go plate and looked forward to enjoying their home fries again today. They were well-seasoned. If you are someone who enjoys more neutral home fries, without a lot of spice, you may consider letting them know your preference ahead of time. Overall, they are careful, strategic, and deliberate in how they package and present the food and it was fresh and delicious. We had enough of everything we needed from butter and juice to the french toast, sausage and bacon. They are definitely being added to our list of go-to's. read more

Went there earlier today for a chopped salad. While I was waiting, there was a guy there sweeping the floor with black gloves on. After he was done sweeping he proceeded to go behind the counter and start touching money at the register, then proceeded to grab food and cut it up all with the same dirty gloves...gross!! The girls helping were very nice, but will not be returning I actually tossed the food in the garbage when I left read more

As a deli snob (as many of us New Yorkers can be), this place meets and/or exceeds all expectations. Really friends staff, limited wait time, and the sandwiches are fantastic. Keep up the great work! read more

I missed having a deli like this in Lindenhurst. After years, this place is back to being my go to. You can tell they put a lot of care into what they make and it is my favorite for my egg sandwiches. The best bacon, a crispy hasbrown, perfectly cooked eggs and lots of melted cheese, the best egg sandwich I've found around here. They also make really good cold cut sandwiches, everything always tastes so fresh. I haven't tried a specialtly sandwich yet but I love the menu, there is something for everyone even the dessert lover. The display cases are always filled with amazing homemade desserts, from stuffed cookies, to cheesecakes, to brownies and much more. They also do really nice catering platters which you can see on their instagram page. I love this place and it is dedinitely a 5 star spot that everyone needs to try. read more

The best deli in Long Island hands down you cant let one Karen with negative review hold you back from the best food hands down best crew also owners are super friendly and nice crew is a pleasure read more

Wonderful people in this business. We ordered the most delicious cookie trays ever. It made our granddaughters party so much fun!

We ordered brunch and a 3 foot hero for Easter. The food was excellent and the presentation was fantastic. The owners and staff should be commended for catering such a great meal. I would recommend this deli to everyone. I have now found my go to deli!!! Great job. Thanks. read more

Fantastic deli off the beaten path. Had the Italian and it was excellent along with some of their stuffed cookies which were fresh and delicious . The owner was super friendly and the place was clean. Highly recommend stopping in. read more

Very Rude to customers. I would not go to this deli. They are also well aware of their rudeness and they said and I quote" buy your sandwiches somewhere else we don't give a fuck" well enjoy folks. read more

Mmm mmmm mmmm.... Is really all I need to say. I just moved to the area, so I have been trying to find "my deli" stopped in for an Italian... it was incredible the lettuce was so fresh and cold it absolutely made the sandwich. They were quick kind and got me out in no time. They have all kinds of other little snacks foods that I will be trying next time! read more

This is a great well run deli ,with good food and a friendly staff ,I just saw a review saying that they are rude ,I don't think so ,that person must suck as a customer and they weren't gonna stand for it, I really admire them for that. SCREW NASTY YELPERS !!!!! read more

Love this place, my go to deli! Jay is the best always extremely personable. Sandwiches are always delicious!

Such a hidden gem. Definitely my favorite deli. I used to live right around the corner from there now I moved to west Babylon and I miss this place so much! I'll go out of my way to get a breakfast sandwich. This place is irreplaceable! read more

Average deli. I have high expectations for delis especially in New York and I was underwhelmed by this place. Won't be returning.

If you're looking for the best egg sandwich / lunch sandwich in the island this is your spot. This little hole in the wall spot leaves me beyond satisfied every-time. The owner/ chef Steven is a sweetheart and is willing to go above and beyond for his customers. Not only are the sandwich selections made with love but you can pretty much order anything you want and if they have it, they'll accommodate it!! From his unique pastries to the fresh salad case this deli will leave you wanting more!! Not only if the food to die for but the workers are truly dedicated to serving you with stellar service and a happy smile in the morning. Definitley try this deli for your morning bec & coffee, your lunch sandwich, or to cure your sweet tooth cravings.. you will not be disappointed I promise !! Great job chef Steven you are one of a kind read more

Can't say enough about this gem of a place and people. Incredibly friendly and every single thing in there is incredibly delicious. The name says deli but the food is far superior to many restaurants I've been too. Thank you for still delivering the goods during these most difficult times. As a healthcare worker myself, I appreciate you guys still serving the public. Cannot recommend this place enough! read more

there sandwiches aren't fresh, was just a little disappointed with what i got

Very unorganized, ordered weren't smooth and sandwiches were often made wrong, granted slightly wrong but wrong none the same. They are not customer friendly. Used to go all the time not anymore. read more

Great local deli. Had breakfast. Very fast friendly service. The baked goods are all done on house

I absolutely love this place! The service is fantastic and the food is incredible!! They have stuffed cookies which are OUT OF THIS WORLD. I mean a rainbow cookie inside of a chocolate chip cookie? How could you go wrong? Definitely 5 stars and a 10/10 for me read more

Clean atmosphere. The 3 employees were very friendly. Even the cook poked his head out to say hello. They have a great deli meat assortment. Everything looked fresh. My egg sandwhich was perfectly done. The coffee was hot and fresh and made to order. They have a wide selection of beverages, desserts and alcoholic beverages. They even offer lotto! Great place. read more

35th St Family Deli - Yum! - Delis Near Me - Lindenhurst, New York

Order yesterday through the Grubhub app. The experience of grubhub was horrendous came 2 hours after ordering and the order was completely wrong. Let me tell you though Jimmy is a great man and went above and beyond with fixing the situation! His sweet wife even came out in the rain to replace my order. I will continue to go to them for all my deli needs just never through grubhub read more

Best bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich in town for a good price. Coffee included in the AM. Friendly staff. Everything is fresh and homemade. Would definitely recommend. read more

Wonderful deli! We recently had them cater our after party for out of town guests to my sisters wedding and the food was amazing!!! Macaroni salad was delicious! And we had Italian and chicken BLT heroes. Our guests were raving!!! They even came and set up the food for us while we were at the wedding so when we arrived there was a beautiful presentation ready to be served!! We highly recommend their delicious food and professional, above and beyond, service! read more

This place goes above and beyond with their selection. Between the creative and delicious specials that come out everyday, the quality of food, and the attention to making a beautiful presentation. My take out from 35th street deli looks better than the plating when sitting in a restaurant! And tastes better too! The chef is friendly and skilled, it is clear he wants you to truly enjoy the creations. The breakfast platters are packed and clearly made with love (those home fries and French toast are unmatched), and the desserts are so fresh and decadent! read more

When they took back the deli from the idiots that owned the place, I couldn't have been happier. Love these people!

My buddy owns this little spot and I was just able to see it for the first time. He puts out a product there that is second to none! If your in the area it is definitely worth the trip! I literally came 2500 miles to try it out! Awesome food! Thanks Steve your the man! read more

This deli is amazing! We go for lunch a lot and never disappointed. We used them to cater a birthday party and they were fantastic. The food was delicious and the guys working were so nice and helped us pack up the car. They even gave us a toy helicopter to give to the birthday boy, it was so sweet. Definitely recommend! read more

Horrible egg sandwiches, they use fake American cheese! Don't know the difference between a over easy and a fried hard! (There both the same to them) There selection of two liter soda is regular Pepsi and cherry Pepsi! Lunch sandwiches are pitifully cheap but are highly priced, save your money and go elsewhere! I live in the neighborhood and have given them several tries. Disappointed repeatedly. Gave them several shots because I've worked in many deli's myself over the last 30 years and know sometimes you have problems with help, vendors etc. But it's jest not to be. Hope they close soon, maybe someone who knows what their doing will take over. Would be nice to have a GOOD neighborhood deli like we used too. read more

I grew up around the corner and I always loved going here for breakfast. The staff is incredibly friendly and nice, but the prices are way too expensive. Today I picked up two bacon egg and cheese sandwiches and it cost us $9.78 for them. I can go to anywhere else and get 2 times the food for that amount of money. I'm very disappointed and will not be coming back. read more