Really enjoyed their pizza they hosted for a Club West event! I love that their slices are smaller, so it feels more guilt free. LOL. The crust is thin. The sauce has a little sweetness to it, which I prefer in a pizza sauce. The pepperoni was bite size and not large slice that are sliding off the pizza. Can't wait to go back and try more food! Special shoutout to Carlos for the delivery!!! read more

I wanted to leave an honest review. The pizza honestly reminded me of a New York-style spot you'd find just outside NYC. That said, it just doesn't hold up against the local pizza shops around here. There's a noticeable gap in quality and overall flavor. read more

4 Bros Pizza - pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Terrible customer service, rude employee that took my order yesterday and the pizza was overall mid asf

FourBros Pizza Parlor - a delicious guessing game Four Bros belongs on your speed dial if you judge a pizzeria purely by flavor. Their dough lands in that sweet spot between chewy and crackly, the red sauce tastes like somebody's nonna still stirs it, and they sneak little jolts of creativity onto the menu--think fried‑eggplant wedges tucked into a hero, or a white pie drizzled with hot honey that balances instead of bludgeons. The trouble starts after you fall in love with one of those twists. Walk in on a Monday craving a quick chicken‑cutlet hero--nope. "We don't do chicken on Mondays." Come back Wednesday, and suddenly the same sandwich is back...but the fried eggplant has vanished until further notice. Ask why, and you'll get a shrugging chorus of "we changed the menu" or "we're out today." It's as if the kitchen spins a wheel labeled *Fan Favorites* every morning and only whatever lands on the rim survives service. Nobody expects a neighborhood slice shop to run a Cheesecake Factory-sized booklet, but consistency on the core items is kind of the deal. A rotating special keeps things fun; an entire rotating menu turns ordering into roulette. When a pizza place can execute a beautifully seasoned, crispy chicken cutlet, keeping itregularly in stock feels like Restaurant 101. The verdict: Pros: Vibrant flavors, creative sandwich and slice options, quality ingredients, friendly counter staff who apologize (a lot) for the menu chaos. Cons: Staples disappear without warning; "We don't make that today" is practically a catchphrase; no posted schedule for what's on or off. So yes--go for the slice. Roll the dice on the specials or not pizza. Just don't build your Monday lunch plans around that chicken‑cutlet hero, because at FourBrothers, the tastiest thing on the board is also the most likely to ghost you. read more

Guys dont eat at this pizza i dont know if it was the owner or just an employee but me and my bestfriend walked in and as we were ordering our food there was a lot of huffing and puffing. While taking our order and as we were paying he rudely raised his voice when we were doing the transaction like he wanted us to hurry up and leave and on top of that didnt give us napkins no nothing not even a greeting. Very Bad Service read more

After living in Brooklyn for years I was worried that moving to Westchester would mean I'd have to sacrifice food options. While that often does actually feel like it's the case, 4 Bros is an outlier. The slices here never disappoint! Glad to be only a stones throw away! read more

Booked a hotel near the area, closest pizza next to me as I ordered 2 slices. Their hair was in one of the pizzas, the other slice? Took one bite and threw it away most sorry mid pizza I tried. Customer service? Decent, workers there aren't welcoming. read more

I've never been and had heard such great things, today was my first time and from the moment I stepped in the service was incredible, the vibe was engaging and the food was AMAZING had their special of the week "lomo pizza" and it was to die for!!! Tell a friend to tell a friend, you won't be disappointed! Most definitely will be back. read more

4 Bros Pizza - Lomo saltado pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

First impressions of the pizza is that it's very oily. Pizza is thin and the sauce/cheese ratio is good. Its quite an floppy pizza. Dough tasted good, i do detect mild yeast in dough. Crust was good, I'd give this slice an 7.4. I guess but I would come back for the grandma slice it looked so good with plum sauce. They said they have vodka sauce and plum sauce. 3.50 slice. read more

See all

Yes the pizza is great but I'm writing about the breakfast which is new on the menu. One of the bros ( there really are four) mentioned the chef is magical with eggs. And that is no lie. My scrambled eggs were light and fluffy- almost soufflé like. Oh so flavorful and yummy. Love the home fries too. Enjoy! read more

4 Bros Pizza - Scrambled eggs and .... - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Fig and cheese slice excellent. Regular slice always oily and reheated. Prices increased. Regular slice $4 (really? no other pizza place locally did that. ). Cestras a few blocks away (cut through the building walkway on centre) better food and prices and service with a positive attitude. 4 bros employees always look bored and annoyed. read more

Ordered the Irwin special bc it looked good. Having enough sauce is important to me and it is advertised as having extra sauce. FYI Uber Eats had a coupon for them, so use it if you see it. Anyway, it was good. Not mind blowing, but good nevertheless. Has LOTS of sliced garlic on it, in case you are a fan. Pizza was made quickly and arrived promptly by delivery. Will order again. read more

4 Bros Pizza - Irwin special with prosciutto - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

Pretty great pies! Love the vegan options too. Would go again. Service was pleasant and quick. The actual establishment had little seating so better to grab and go. read more

I hope this review encourages you to come here. I ordered two slices; a plain and an upside down pepperoni slice. I can honestly say this was some of the best pizza, if not the best pizza I have ever had. The slices were crispy and had no flop. The sauce had a perfect balance of sweetness and tanginess and the hibiscus tea was perfect. To top it off they gave me a free house made chocolate chip cookie. I can honestly say this pizzeria is worth going out of your way to drive to and I will definitely be back for more. read more

This is the go to place if you want cavatelli with broccoli rabe and sausage done the way it's supposed to be. The pasta is freshly made. It's so perfectly chewy and the sausage adds a little heat and the broccoli rabe negates all the calories. Ha! It's so delicious it's worth every single one. Tbh this dish is my go to comfort food and it's never disappointed. read more

I am originally from Brooklyn, so I really know my pizza. Finally, New Rochelle has a pizza place that can compete with Sal's in Mamaroneck and Johnny's in Mt. Vernon. This is the real deal. Always order a fresh pie with extra sauce--no slices because once the slice gets cold, reheating just does not work. Terrific pizza--just look at that photo!!! read more

4 Bros Pizza - Large pie with extra sauce, fresh sliced garlic, cooked crispy--it's called "The Irwin Special," and guess who it is named after? Enjoy!!! - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Great selection of pies. That fig and 3 cheese is the bomb! Extra crispy is my preferred and they have no problem getting it right. And i even like the funny tip options at the register read more

This place can be a bit of an enigma. Wildy inconsistent and it ranges from a decent-ish staple (3 stars) to just weird and inedible (1 star). Giving it 2 hoping that some days were just off ones for them but its so inconsistent that I can't even order it anymore so just abandoned. Had higher hopes for it and it started off so good. Such a shame.. read more

No bueno. Forget it Dominos prepares better pizza. Enuff said. Stay away. You've been warned. Go to Costco and buy yourself the bulk frozen pizza, it will taste better than this pizza joint. read more

4 Bros Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Called, not having any idea if I'd get an actual pizza, or a cracker with ketchup and cheese. Dude showed with tasty happiness in a pizza box. Hats off to all 4 bros! My belly thanks you! read more

The only sausage they have is HOT sausage and not everyone likes hot sausage on their pizza. Sauce and crust were average. Nothing to write home about. read more

We ordered several different items to try, and the regular slice was the best option out of the ones we ordered. I didn't care for the margarita square pizza or the garlic knots are. Overall, I found the crust to be bready and lacking chew for my own personal taste when it comes to NY pizza. Reminiscent more of focaccia than pizza dough imo. read more

See all

Pizza crust is crunchy. Sauce was delicious combined with perfect amount of mozzarella cheese. It was so good. Best part - fresh basil on top. We will definitely return!! There's street parking and public parking lot down the street. read more

4 Bros Pizza - Regular Cheese Pie - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Just ok... get a plain slice. Margheritta pizza was kinda hard or like old. Thought I was coming to Alfredo's. Register guy kinda rude not really welcoming. My 4 year old said it wasn't good or bad. I like the tables and that's about it lol. Seems like the teenage chefs could use a little supervision lol. read more

Amazing pizza and food! The chicken bacon and ranch entree is great. The 4 Bros Classic sandwich is unreal.

Had the Grandma pizza a few weeks ago. They are new so I think they are working out the kinks: at first I couldn't get through on their phone line, when I finally put in my order and went to pick up they were a bit behind on pizza orders. All things that hopefully will get smoothed out over time. But strictly commenting on the pizza, it was excellent for Westchester (my favorite grandma pizza is in NJ). Despite one of the folks assembling the pizzas not being masked when I went, I will likely go again. read more

Love the ambience and the pizza definitely a go to if you're in the area!! Great service too

Bf was down from Yonkers the other night- got a burrata pizza w meatballs and loaded knots! Holy good God! All was so delicious! Food came hot and on time, friendly driver and great guys at the restaurant! You're not done hearing from me bros! read more

We had to stay home for Easter this year and decided to order out. Their eggplant rolletini and chicken parm was amazing!!! I always order their pizza. Never disappoints! You definitely need to try 4 Bros!!!! read more

We just tried to give them another chance tonight to grab a quick slice. As we were walking from the parking lot to the corner we noticed the employee dude in blue was smoking outside, continuously coughing and spitting in the gutter. How could you possibly be doing this outside your business that handles food? Although I'm glad he did, showed their standards. read more

Super tasty love them slice is a good size Good food come try it come you wouldn't regret it read more

Place was empty and the staff was on edge. Will not go there again as the place isn't doing too well with business and taking it out on paying customers. Stole a few sodas cuz the pepperoni pizza was so greasy I had to press some napkins on my slice. These cats are not friendly nor are they pleasing to look at while eating. Save your money and look elsewhere for read more

Exceptional pizza. Large slices. My favorite pizza in New Rochelle. Come and try. You won't be let down.

Really good pizza. Do takeout. Terrible music if you're over 25. Garlic knots need more flavor.

What a find. Love this place. So happy I found it. Good vibe and food. It's a corner spot and open doors. Friendly staff and good pizza /pasta options. They have a full menu! Enjoy it read more

I don't know what's wrong with these people writing lousy reviews...I thought the pizza here was great! To say Domino's is better is a pathetic attempt at a joke...I've worked at Domino's and can tell you first hand that their pizza is crap. As for the complaint about there being hardly any sauce, well that's your own fault. When you order a pizza, you're given all kinds of options...like extra sauce, extra cheese, etc. Everyone has different tastes, therefore it would be impossible to know what your tastes are unless you make a request. As for me, I ordered my pizza with extra sauce and well done and it was fantastic! read more

Yummy pizza spot with a ton of delicious options! I'm so picky when it comes to be pizza due to my dislike of that overwhelming dried basil taste some places tend to have, but this pizza does not have that at all since it is clearly all fresh ingredients only! High quality stuff and will definitely be ordering more pies here in the future. read more

Irwin Special w/ added pepperoni, small. Yummy sauce and crusty ends. Staff was amazing and friendly which spills out to their desire to make good pizza. read more

4 Bros Pizza - Irwin Special - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Ordered today and was very disappointed. I got pasta with garlic and oil. It was extremely dry, no oil and Luke warm. Had hardly any taste. By the time i got it on to the plate to eat it was cold. Ordered regular bread and garlic bread which is homemade. It came little burnt, nothing great. My brother ordered chicken Parm sandwich which he didn't care for, said it was spicy. He would never order again. Ordered two pizzas there before, they were ok. Both were warm not hot. By the time you got to the second slice it was cold. Very disappointed in this place would not order again from here. read more

As a native New Yorker I am very picky when it comes to pizza, in my area I've found a few really good pizza places however most of them are just average, I'm spoiled because I used to live right next to my favorite pizza place but now I finally feel like I've found a great place within walking distance. I frequently look for pizza places I usually just go in a grab a few slices so I did that here, there used to be another pizza place here that I tried a while back and was unimpressed so when I found this place on Yelp I was surprised to see the location, I got two plain slices for my wife and I not expecting much but I was wrong! A thin slice that wasn't too small, right amount of crisp and dough, amazing sauce and cheese, also the right amount of basil, I was so impressed that a few days later I ordered a meatball marinara square pie and it grew my fandom even more, you can tell they use high quality ingredients, their menu has a lot of great items that I look forward to trying at some point! Keep it up! read more

4 Bros Pizza - Meatball marinara square - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York