Best pizza ever the food there is fabulous and the service is also very good as well as ambiance read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - Cecilian pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Very average and very high priced. I understand inflation, but the pizza tasted no better than a .99 cent slice you get in NYC. Very expensive for two slices and a soda, was not expecting to pay $15 for the mediocre tasteless pizza, should have just went to Patsy's. read more

I was desperate for a slice of New York pizza. This place did not disappoint. It was crunchy crispy yummy all the great flavors of sauce and cheese , small little spot in new Rochelle is worth a try . The locals were coming in and out the whole time I was there eating my slice. I just wish there was those paper cups soda, fountain machines like the old days. I'll be going back tomorrow for a slice of this Sicilian, which also looked amazing. read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - A slice of Cheese Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Pizza was excellent- delivered in a timely way and much less expensive compared to local pizzerias! I will definitely continue to get my pizza and dinner from them! read more

Fratelli's Pizza review: Best pizza I have ever had! The crust, the sauce, and very nice people. I'm from Texas, and there is good wannabe New York pizza, but this is the real deal. I've been to NYC 10 times and nearly every state. Amazing--I'd give a million stars if possible! read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

The service was awesome. I ordered on the phone for a to go order. The pizza was ready exactly when he said. It was delicious. My husband and I finished all but 2 slices which we ate for breakfast this morning read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - Cheese with pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Great regular slice and amazing Sicilian slice. Very friendly great service. Nearby to our hotel only minutes away.

Some of the best pizza in New Rochelle...by really only take out. This pizzeria has been around for years. They had an amazing restaurant too! Sadly, that closed. At least we can still get their great pizza and hot heroes! Very clean! Always polite! read more

I've been going to this place for over 20 years when they were across from Iona college and now on Huguenot street and I can tell you the food, the quality, the service is always amazing!!! We order at least once a week, my favorites are the Cajun chicken pizza, penne Gorgonzola with grilled chicken and mushrooms, the house salad with that delicious balsamic dressing but you really can't go wrong with anything there. I love all the guys who work there especially Pete and Steven! They are the best not just because of the delicious true Calabrian style food but because they treat you like family! read more

Mr. Fratelli. What can I say when working in town? We eat there three times a week Killer sandwiches excellent pizza linguine with clam sauce, chicken dishes everything on the menu excellent as a matter fact I'm gonna order some right now. read more

Great NY-style pizza...but even better service. Walked-in and instantly felt welcome. Couldn't recommend more!

Best chicken sandwich for under $15 in NY. Pizza is also good! Been going here for over 15 years, highly recommended.

This al fresco pie is to die for!!! Haven't had this slice in years and it has not changed one bit!! Simply delicious. Only reason i too a star is that delivery was almost an hour and a half and the beverage was missing. Otherwise I'm thrilled, this is by far my fave slice ever... read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

amazing ,fresh, so, so good! this is my last stop for pizza and freshness! five stars in my book. I am Italian from Italy and I know good food. read more

Really great pizza! I had a "white slice" and a classic cheese slice for lunch with 2 soft drinks for under 10 dollars. It's a classic "NY" pizzeria no frills but exactly what up expect. Can't wait to try other slices! read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - Classic cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

Fast, friendly and delicious. Simply a great pizza joint. Extra points because they will make you a vegan pie, if you bring them your own dairy free cheese ahead of time. read more

I have to say that I've been coming here several times since my review from May 2015. Each and every time I have come here for pizza, it has been consistently great taste-wise. It may not seem like a big deal, but it is as some places (pizza or otherwise) have difficultly making anything consistent taste-wise/quality-wise every time. There are those who'll claim there is no such thing as a bad pizza or that all pizza taste the same - those people are clueless. I've had plenty of bad pizza and they all most certainly don't taste the same. Yeah, some people either don't know any better or just have weird taste buds. I've had pizza in quite a lot of places (cities, states) and coming here after some of the other places I've been to even more recently has made me appreciate it here even more. The service has also improved or maybe it's just me. So yeah, the parking isn't the best. If you come after 7pm, you can usually find a spot near the front (or across the street) and probably don't have to pay the meter. You can also park on a side street if need be. During the day, it can be busy during rush times like lunch/early dinner. read more

I used to love the Sicilian slices from this place so much that I started ordering it by the pie. But the two times I ordered it, it arrived with burnt cheese. The first time I let them slide because my family and I were so hungry we ate it anyway. But the cheese was so burnt it was like having just thick bread and sauce. The second time I ordered it I specifically told them to please do not burn the cheese. Did they listen? No! I attached a pic. I don't know about any of you but when I order pizza I don't expect it to arrive like that. Whenever I have ordered it inside the pizzeria it did not come like that, the cheese was nice and gooey and stringy. Why can't I get the same when ordering from home??!! read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - pepperoni and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

I can say this with full truth....BEST PIZZA IN NEW ROCHELLE! I absolutely love the pizza here. Always fresh and with great faces creating all that yummy goodness. I cant deny that it just may be the best Sicilian pizza I have had thus far In Westchester. Love this place and will always come back! read more

Brocc rabe slice and the eggplant slice are sick. Best in New Ro. The crust is perfect. Be right back, gonna get a third slice

I love pizza. I love that first bite that kinda burns my mouth but everything is oh, so savory, so saucy, and so cheesy, that I just don't give a ****. Mmmm, mouth watering! Their cheese slice is the closest thing to NYC pizza north of the boroughs. If you're a lover of pizza like I am, and you crave just a bomb***, NY cheese slice, this should be your go-to in New Rochelle. You know what I'm talking about: nice crisp crust, PERFECTLY seasoned marinara (It's worth mentioning that their sauce is not that sauce that is kinda sweet from basil. No, sir. Savory all the way!), and oh-so-much-cheese! Brings me back to those good ol' days of 4 am pizza runs after a night out. *Sigh* Nostalgia. Oh, and they deliver, too! read more

Take your grubhub listing down if you no longer fill orders! I had an order placed that i waited an hour for only to have the driver tell me there was no order at the address! FIX THIS!! https://www.grubhub.com/restaurant/fratelli-pizza--pasta-237-main-street-new-rochelle/1917172 read more

Food was ok. But we were rushed. Still eating our food!! & they were cleaning our table at 8 pm? Asked for some of our food back, nope. Maybe a good idea elsewhere for a family birthday event now. Will now be going elsewhere. read more

I'm not mad at it! This is great pizza! I'm a simple man. I like the crust thin, the cheese oozing, the sauce full of flavor and substance, and the crust perfectly balanced between crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. When I order a pizza, this is what I'm expecting to arrive. This is my pizza fantasy. Like staring down the aisle when those doors swing wide open and you see your Bride for the first time, when I open that pizza box I want to be overcome with the beauty and lost in that moment. Now, I experienced this when my two Fratelli's pizzas arrived. My two co-workers and I wafted in the steam coming off those pies and barely got off the picture I'm attaching to this review before we mercilessly devoured them. But don't let me deceive you. There's more to this story. TRUTH TIME: We were starving, lost in the abyss, overworked, underpaid, and we needed pizza. We were 3 men and 1 pie would not do. We got 2, but we damn near ordered 3 just to be safe. The nice lady on the other side of the phone at Fratelli's told us the pizza would arrive to our building (which is truthfully less than a half-mile from the pizza place) in 40 minutes. So we started watching......waiting.......commis-erating.........SAY IT 'AINT SO!! WHERE IS THE PIZZA?? Unfortunately, our pizza from down the street did not arrive until nearly 80 minutes after we ordered it. Of course we were ravenous at this point; barely even human anymore, struggling to retain consciousness! Anything would have been delicious at this point! We were knocking on death's door when the pizza guy answered instead, and praise the Lord for it! Suffice it to say, our experience may have been biased by how incredibly hungry we were and tainted with the dramatic suspense of our pizza quest. Full disclosure. That said, this pizza is very good. It's not the greatest pizza I've ever had, don't get it twisted, but it is great and worthy of your money. I'm not even dropping stars for the extraordinary wait time because the end justified the means and the delivery guy was some old dude who was so nice I couldn't be mad. I'll be back! I'm a fan! read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - YES! YEAH! YES! PIZZA! - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

See all

easily the best pizza place in new ro, been coming here for as long as i can remember. no other place in new ro comes CLOSE!! corner sicilian slice is my go-to read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - corner slice of sicilian - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

This is def the best pizza I have had in New Rochelle! Iv ordered A number of times and each time it's great I absolutely recommend this place if you are looking for a crispy slice of pizza with lots of flavor! read more

Best chicken slices in town....every time I visit new Rochelle I have to stop by for a slice...kinda pricey though read more

Fratelli Pizza And Pasta - Pizza Near Me - New Rochelle, New York

So I ordered a margarita pizza. Asked for crispy crust. When it arrived it was cold (I'm only 4 miles away). The crust wasnt crispy and all's I tasted was the crust because it was so thick. The mozzarella was sliced so thin I didn't even taste it and no basil! no taste !!! read more

These guys are great. In comparison to common take-out slice pizzerias that dot almost every street corner in westchester this place seems pretty superior to the ones I frequently go to. The crust is perfectly thin, yet still substantial enough to give a taste of the delicious dough these guys make. Of all the slices I tried the broccoli rabe and sausage was the winner- though all of them rocked. Also, of all the sicilians I've had, their's is the best I've tried- due to the crunchy olive oil crust on the side and bottom of the pie. The guys that run it are incredibly friendly and nice. As testament to this, the last time I went in to pick up a regular slice and a broccoli rabe slice at the end of the day, they gave me 2 plain slices, the broccoli rabe and a sicilian and didnt charge me any extra! I didn't notice until I got home. These guys are awesome! read more

Pizza here is very good and thin. My mom has a regular slice and I had the eggplant. It was very delicious but 2 slices and 2 drinks were $11. I don't know if I came in on a bad day but I felt the environment was slightly strange. The worker just stared at us eat our pizza and watched our every move the whole time. I would love to have another slice but I. D.o.n.t know if I would sit inside again. read more

When I moved to New Rochelle 15 years ago we discovered Fratelli. The food was and still is amazing. This has been our go to for take out until today. I called and order our dinner for delivery. When we got it one of the dishes was completely wrong. I ordered plain pasta with butter sauce only to get a dish with shrimp and chicken. It was my daughters meal and she doesn't eat shrimp or chicken. When my husband called the guy who took the order to tell him our order was wrong, (who I think was new) he lied and said he read the order to me over the phone to confirm it. He blatantly lied. I know what I ordered. His attitude was rude and basically too bad so sad. We spent $70. My husband pointed out how we have been long term customers but he did not care. All we wanted was pasta with butter sauce- what we ordered. We have never encountered something like this before. I am so sad to say they have lost our business. 15 years of loyalty gone with one idiot taking orders. read more

This place went really down hill. I used to travel to come get slices from here and was rarely disappointed, but recently they have lost they're touch the pizza Is like something you would get in a middle school cafeteria save yourself the time and go down the block pizza centre!!! read more

This is the one and only Italian spot PERIOD. Lived here for years and have tried other places only to regret it. Best Chicken Scarpariello around and the Grilled Chicken Penne with Gorgonzola Cream is a must order item - I order both, every. single. time. (and I don't share). Meatballs are pretty good along with their baked pastas, the pizza crust is crispy (tomato sauce is simple with no extra BS), and the sandwiches are killer - grilled chicken with hot peppers please. This is not a half-&ss fast food pizza shop. Order AHEAD OF TIME (30 minutes) and it's completely worth the wait. read more

If you judge a book by its cover, you will probably just walk or drive by & not realize you just passed up the best pizzeria in New Rochelle. There are no menus inside because everyone knows what they want. Their Sicilian is one of the best I've ever had. The entrees or sandwiches are always fresh & piping hot. If you want to take it a step further, the kitchen is so clean that you could eat off the floor. As an owner of a retail food business I can tell you that you just don't find too many places that are this clean. So to sum it up, go try a slice, or two, or three, or more. I guarantee you will not be disappointed. read more

Just had Chicken Scarpariello for the first time! OMG awesome floured chicken fillets sautéed with sausage hot cherry peppers and diced potatoes in a wine lemon butter sauce! Incredible! I love their pizza but this was so tasty! read more

Sicilain slice best in westchester. And possibly the world. GOOEY. Although I've heard of other slice joints that serve a good sicilian, this one is always on point. Puffy crust that makes you want to dip in a soufflet cup filled with olive oil (which i regret to say ive asked for. They graciously indulged me). Great sauce too. read more

Best pizza in New Rochelle hands down. I've only gotten there plain pies so I cannot attest to anything else. I'd suggest picking it up, as seating is limited and delivery is VERY SLOW. Large pies run about 13-14 bucks but are well worth it IMHO. read more

Cajun Chicken Pizza and Eggplant roll for the win. The hot sandwiches and chicken scarpiello are equally as amazing(if not more).

Amazing food. Best pizza around. Loyal customer for a decade. Never ordered anything I haven't loved!!!

This pizza joint is next door to Fratelli's italian restaurant. The restaurant is actually quite good despite it's strip-mall location - don't be put off by that. Go anyway. The pizza place is pretty good, too, though not particularly outstanding pie. Just good pizza, which in the NYC area is not hard to find. read more