I had Addedo's Fire and Ice in my bookmarks for a while, and one day I decided to go. The establishment is open Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays with limited hours. Addeo's sells Pizza, house-made cheesecake, and their specialty is making house-made Italian Ice, and you can bring your own bottle. The owner is from New Jersey, where Italian Ice is very popular. Addedo and his wife run the establishment and do all the cooking and serving. They also own an antique store next door, so that you can shop after dinner. There is also a back area of the establishment where you can dine, and it looks like a library with various books, and customers can buy the books from the bookshelf. As I entered the establishment, I was greeted and seated right away. I ordered a pizza with half pepperoni. The pizza came out in about fifteen to twenty minutes. The pizza looked like New Haven-style pizza, and it was delicious. The crust was crispy, and the pizza tasted fresh. The sauce had great flavor and was well-seasoned. The pepperoni was crispy, and the Basil significantly enhanced the pizza flavor by adding a fresh, aromatic, and slightly sweet element that complemented the other ingredients. Also, the bright, somewhat peppery taste cuts through the richness of the cheese and sauce, creating a balanced and refreshing taste experience. The owner gave me a sample of Italian Ice: Mango and Blueberry. The Italian ice was delicious and fresh-tasting. I could taste the flavors of the Italian Ice, and you could tell it was made fresh. The customer service was excellent, and the owners were friendly read more

See all

Definitely worth trying! I remember liking it my first time. My second time, I still like it but just felt like it was alrightttt. I ordered take out so keep that in mind. The cheesecake was good but I ordered the salted caramel and I feel like they just drizzled smuckers caramel sauce on top of it which is not what I was expecting. I will say the actual cheesecake was very creamy though. All in all I'm giving this place a 7 out of 10 for now but will definitely continue to try out different pizzas and cheesecakes and report back! can understand why people rave about it I am just not sure if it's my preference! read more

This place was around the corner from an upscale restaurant I was having fancy drinks at. I stopped here to look at some dessert but as a pizza connoisseur, I decided to try a pie. My pizza wasn't ready when I arrived as I was informed it would be and I was directed by a restaurant waiter to go downstairs into a basement to look at dated trinkets. It was an experience to say the least. The place was small, dark, and full of regular attendees. The pizza crust was some of the best I've had but only with that to say . The sauce was very similars to a papa John's sauce or dominos though it was more water tasting than theirs. I went back in to get their last piece of their take on a dunkaroos cheesecake. It was just that, a take. I felt bad about myself when I left this place, the environment was dark in every sense of the word, no happy, uninviting, and the food didn't have the expected Connecticut flavor that could compete with even a Cumberland farms slice of pizza. They seemed like they were trying hard so I'll give them an A for their efforts, always. I love that the locals truly support this little place and try to keep them up and running read more

See all

Love this pizza so much. Owners are very cool and the pizza is a wonderful thin crust with some char. Just how I like it. Support small family businesses!!! read more

When open this is a must stop for their pizza and stuffed bread. Top notch. Possibly the best in Shelton. Of the five times ive attempted to order they have been open three of those times. Erratic hours prevent me from giving them the five stars their food deserves. read more

Great pizza specials, BYOB, cool fidgets available for purchase around the restaurant. Service is friendly. Love the wood fired pizza. Fun decor and ornaments for purchase around the holidays. Great to hang out with friends for a casual dinner. The cheesecakes are pretty good. The Italian ice is also pretty good. Lots of fun flavors and combos across the pizzas, ices and cheesecake. I love the breakfast pizza -something about crunchy waffle and maple syrup is addictive in a pizza. Stumbled upon a pleasant mistake of a cheesecake flavor - cranberry jalapeño, and it was surprisingly delicious ! Check their Facebook/IG for weekend specials, or ask before ordering. read more

See all

I just love the pizza and cheesecakes! I have a niched palette for pizza and my fave Eggplant Tower pizza by Addeo's is just my kind of pizza! Delish! Ohhh, and the meatballs app, homaigawddd...sooo tasty! What keeps me coming back is the friendly owners! That's the glue! Love, love, love! read more

A friend recommended I come here, she said you have GOT TO TRY the fajita pizza. So we came! It looks tiny from the inside but we were happy to see a few tables to eat our pizzas at! Pizza is way better right out of the oven. Unfortunately they were out of that kind of pizza but others sang to me too. I ordered their version of a Buffalo chicken pizza, with some high quality blue cheese on it. You could really taste all the layers and the pizza dough was sooo perfect. Charred but not too charred and doughy but not too doughy. This is the kind of pizza I seek! My boyfriend couldn't decide so he made his own and just got a regular cheese pizza with hot oil on it. He was happy with his! They really are pretty much personal sized with maybe a slice or 2 leftover from the larger size. But wait, dessert!!! Such amazing cheesecake on a variety of flavors. I got pistachio cheesecake yum. I also saw someone come in just for a milk shake. The staff there, which were also the owners couldn't have been nicer and more helpful. Great people! We will be back very soon! It's been a while since I've been excited about a pizza place but, I'm excited. read more

See all

SWEET HEAVEN, MARY, AND JOSEPH... We just finished at the Legends of Fear night and wanted some dessert. Cheesecake sounded great so I said why not. The owner offered us some icey.. SWEET GOD... YOU DONT UNDERSTAND. I never had intentions on spending more than 10 dollars. I ended up getting lemon, blackberry, apple pie, sweet potato marshmallow, pumpkin pie and 1 more. 3 different cheesecake slices and 1 plain pie. I ended up spending over 60 dollars. It was so worth it.. you can feel the flavors bursting through each bite. I'm not a icy guy at all but to buy over 7 to go tells you everything. It's 20 mins away from my home but I'm definitely coming back to show love. Awesome spot. Can't wait to dine on. read more

See all

Surprised this place isn't more well known! Really great pizza. Very New Haven-esque, but even thinner than the usual. Wood oven, interesting toppings. Cool owner. Also, a bunch of nick nacks and books and such for sale. It's like an apizza mini flea market. read more

So so good. We got a bunch of different pizzas, all were excellent. The dill pickle is to die for. Can't recommend this spot highly enough, just great. read more

Vibe vibe and flavor! This place was gold to find on Yelp being from out of town and looking for good late night pizza! The owner is behind the counter and cooking I think with his wife? The music is loud and great while at the same time making for a perfect date. I went in craving pepperoni pizza but couldn't avoid the creative combinations on the menu. The owner takes such pride in his craft it feels like an honor to eat there and then we were given a sample of his home made Italian ice. Minds were blown! It's out of this world!! The apple pie flavor!! Must try this place if you're in the area! read more

See all

Fire: If you like thin crust pizza this is it. Menu is straight forward with 3 specialty pizzas on the back that change periodically. The pies are only 12in which is a personal pizza as far as I'm concerned. Right now it's still under the radar but when the word gets out it's going to be hard to get a seat here (very small front end). Ice: The Italian ice is perfect, it's claimed to be all natural and you can definitely taste a difference compared to other places. The flavors are present just enough to keep you wanting another bite instead of the overpowering flavors at other places. read more

My family and I recently held my son Luca's 20th birthday party at Addeo's. I looked like a genius for choosing this restaurant on Center Street in downtown Shelton. While the atmosphere, service and owners Johnny and Kelly were awesome, the star of the show was the food and Chef Hill. His thin crust pizza is amazing, the best we have found in the states after living a dozen years in Italy and eating the real thing often...the baked lollipop chicken legs marinated in oregano, garlic and olive oil are addictive...and a new take on eggplant parmigiana as thin, individually sautéed slices each with a light touch of tomato sauce and mozzarella in a miniature iron skillet is out of this world! Don't wait for a birthday party or other special occasions to give Addeo's a try. You will go back for more and spread the word. read more

See all

Really good pizza and ices. They have a thrift shop downstairs. Board games and BYOB!

Do you like thin new haven style pizza? Thin like Bar, Sally's and Pepes? Then this is the place for you. Paper thin pizza that is delicious. Currently they only have take out and a couple outside tables. They are working on the dining room and hope to have that open sometime in October. It's only one size pizza which is about the size of a small, and because it's thin one person can eat an entire pizza. They have the usual toppings and then weekly specials. I had a special, which included veggies from local stone garden farms. My other half hade hot oil with pepperoni. Loved it. Very friendly service and the owner was very nice.They also serve Italian ice, cheesecake, and milkshakes. They let you taste the Italian ice flavors prior to purchasing. We loved it here and will be back. I hope you will try it too and support local. read more

Addeo’s Fire & Ice - Desserts Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

Pizza is great thin crust friendly peopled Cheese Pizza's best around I like thin crusted and burnt on the edges read more

The people there are awesome. The cheese pizza not so much. But I got one of there specialty pizzas of the week and that was super awesome. read more

Addeo’s Fire & Ice - 12" Pizzas cheese and the 17th hour - Desserts Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

Can't say enough about this place. Everything we had was amazing!! Real. Fresh ingredients. From the crab cake, eggplant, pizza to the Italian ice & cheesecake. Owner is a nice guy and an amazing chef. Nice to know there are still small businesses out there that actually care about the food they are serving. read more

Great place! Phenomenal pizza if you are a thin crust fan. We tried the specials that were offered. The fickle pickle and the shaved steak queso were both excellent. It is BYOB and they had some great music playing. It is not a place for large groups just yet. They are opening a dining room in a few months) read more

creative and delicious!! cool vibe and byob... must make the time to visit.. check their hours though because they are limited in days open...8 read more

Great pizza!! Individual size. BYOB the owners are very nice and interact with the customers.

Pizza is really good. Wished they had a large so I could stuff my face more, but I'll definitely be back!

The best pizza in the valley. Thin with burnt edges. Just how pizza is supposed to be. Owners go out of their way to make you feel welcome. read more

Just ate at Addeo's for the first time tonight (in a snow storm). OMG, the pizza was fabulous!!! I loved it! It reminded me of pizza from Rome. Thin crust, great sauce (tasted like home made and very flavorful) and brick oven cooked to perfection. This was my first time here. It's very easy to miss, as it's not obvious from rd. They need better signage up front. This is my new favorite pizza and very comparable to our favs in New Haven. What a gem. It's very tiny, but the owner said they will be expanding soon by taking over the space next door for a dining area. I highly recommend this place if you like thin crust and charcoal on the edges. Great flavor!!! read more

It was my first time here, they have a cute (in progress) dine in area. The owners made you feel super comfortable and made us feel just like we was a guest in his home. Now let's talk about the pizza! Brick oven pizza thin crust cooked to perfection. I couldn't have enough we definitely be back! read more

Addeo’s Fire & Ice - two pizzas - Desserts Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

Best pizza around. Finally got to try it and didn't disappoint! Small seating inside so not good for a crowd. Burnt on the bottom but devoured every piece. Pizza is done in 5 minutes in the Fire Oven. You are welcome to ask for "light" if you're not into burnt crust. Kids will probably want it "light". Definitely a must-try!! read more

The pizza is delicious here! Recently ordered the Jane's Addiction and Hot Rod, both were amazing. Really loved the fig balsamic dressing on the Jane's Addiction. Can't wait to try the rest of their pizza options. read more

One of the better pizzas in Shelton; very thin burnt edge crust; one size 12". Just pizza, Italian ice, ice cream and desserts. The Sauce has a lot of flavor and they don't skimp on the cheese. The cheesecake and carrot cake were very fresh and delicious. Friendly service. Cute little place only a few tables/seats. read more

Addeo’s Fire & Ice - Menu - Desserts Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

Best pizza in the area. Tried the jalapeno pizza and a cheese pizza. Both were excellent. Desserts were delicious as well. We were treated to the apple Italian ice. The owner took the time to come over and welcome us. Loved it. read more

Great food and homemade desserts and the owners couldn't be nicer. They have a cool little side room to sit in and BYOB while you eat their thin crust pizzas, cheese cakes and Italian ice! read more

The BEST pizza around! Having moved to Shelton a few months back, I've been trying to find my favorite pizza spot & I think we have a winner! read more

Hey everyone! My name is Sara and I've had this pizza delivered before, but it was 12:30am and I was starving. I don't eat fast food and Addeo's Fire & Ice was open and I had no idea it was literally right around the corner from me. I will never use UberEats again for Addeo's. Anyway, walking in, it's definitely a chill vibe and on one of their walls, it looked like people would sign their names or leave a little message which I think is awesome. The place was very clean. The lighting was very welcoming and beautiful. They actually just put up a brand new HUGE TV that was crystal clear and I didn't want to leave. The menu is just perfect. You have your choice toppings for pizza or just a regular cheese pizza which is what I went with. It was the perfect temperature and the owner introduced himself to me. Great guy, very friendly and professional. I believe it was his wife at the counter who initially took my order who was also very friendly and professional. I could see in the back the fire brick ovens. I thought this place was just pizza, but found out about all of these fresh desserts made daily which sounded amazing. They also have Italian Ice! You can BYOB and grab a milkshake they make fresh. Now, let's get to the pizza. I love my pizza thin. Always have, always will. I will post the photos I took, but the pizza was so amazing. The cheese and sauce was a perfect amount. Of course, I will be back there and I highly recommend to check this family business out! The best pizza I've ever had in Connecticut is right here!! Enjoy the photos!! read more

See all

Love their pizza! Thin crust with slightly burnt edges and I've had some unusual combinations with their specialty pizzas that were awesome. Love the fact that it's BYOB. Oh... the home made cheesecake is amazing. Next time I'm in town..... it's a food destination. read more

The pizza was crust was good, thin and the sauce was good. The cheese was real, not like the rubbery cheese that doesn't even taste like cheese that most pizzerias in CT use.. read more

What I love about this place is not only the AMAZING food, but the kind staff. We spent about an hour and a half in the restaurant, and had such a great time. Specialty pizzas are amazing, and the desert pizza hit the spot! read more

The pizza is amazing. The staff is the best. The Italian Ice was the best I've ever had. And the cheesecake was to die for. I hope they do well here! read more

Absolutely love this place , everything i get there is awesome , the pizza is super thin and crispy and ao much flavor , great place