Visiting the area and tried Pizza 1 based on reviews. Ordered medium pizza (half plain, half pepperoni) and a sausage roll. Pizza was very good, crust was tasty, sauce to cheese and topping ratio was nice - would definitely order again if we lived in the area. Sausage roll was also very good! Nice dough, sausage tender, peppers, onions and cheese were all cooked perfectly, would also order this again. Came with a cup of dipping sauce but I was not a fan -- too watery and didn't stick to the roll enough to add flavor. Would have preferred a thicker consistency. Service was friendly and fast (we ordered at the counter to go). Would have eaten there, but had to get back home. Place was clean and atmosphere was nice. We prefer to eat pizza on site as it always tastes the best right out of the oven. That said, the food was very good when we got home too! read more

Good pizza and service, nice people, pickup on time..................................................................................................... read more

Excellent pizza. Everything is delicious about it. The cheese, the toppings, the crust and the sauce are all delicious in their own right and complement each other very well. The ingredients are fresh and set the pizza apart from other places. The staff there were also very kind and helpful, and greeted me immediately when I entered. 5 stars no doubt about it. read more

Good place fora couple of slices! And the the guys that work there are real cool, even if they're Mets fans...good cheap meal!

I was working Monday night so my family decided to give me a break and order from pizza 1. What a mistake!!! I had ordered spaghetti and meatballs, extra sauce and mozzarella cheese on top. I received plain spaghetti topped in the middle with some sauce, no meatballs!!! My husband was nice enough to go to Weis and pickup some sauce for me to put on, since it was barely enough!My son ordered a side of meatballs which he received. My other son a Venezia in which he received a chicken parm with marinara instead of chicken parm either vodka sauce on garlic bread. When I called about my order I called right away and did not know about the other order, I was told the sauce probably was absorbed into the spaghetti and that he did put my Meatballs in another container!!! Who sends out spaghetti with sauce just on the top???His excuse for the meatballs was maybe the door dasher left them in his car!! What a response!! I saw how the conversation was going and it was back and forth denying everything. I should've known because he would not give his name. No mention of making the order right was mentioned only a denials or excuses. We had a large order for 6 people and he never did the right thing.!We learned our lesson and WILL NEVER ORDER from them again and neither will my friends and family!!!! I couldn't rate them a 0 so I had to give a 1. Food and Service unacceptable! Maybe their pizza is good but I can go elsewhere for good service and food! read more

Stopped in for a quick slice for myself and 2 daughters. We were able to each get toppings that we wanted (mushrooms and fresh mozzarella, fresh mozzarella/basil/tomatoes, and mushrooms and pepperoni). There were plenty of toppings on each slice and the prices were very reasonable ($15 for 3 slices with those topping which were not skimpy on). Would stop in again if up in this area. read more

Best pizza in the area. Calzone was awesome . Wonderful surprise and find. Drive by, stop in and see for yourself!

Half hour delivery turned into an hour and a half, ordered a sausage pizza of which 1/3 of the pizza had sausage. The pizza was very salty with no taste. Never will I go there again and I do not recommend this restaurant. Half star rating at best. read more

Here from out of town and found this little gem. We walked in there right before closing and what appears to be the owner and his wife were the kindest people. Once we left and ate the pizza we couldn't believe it was so good. read more

Pizza 1 - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

I ordered delivery from them. Usually, I pick up my food. They forgot part of the order and refused to send me the rest. Telling me to get a refund from the Slice app because they are too busy. Too busy. Way to busy to keep me as a weekly customer. There are many, many, many other places around here who know how to put sauce and cheese on dough. Most try to keep their reoccurring customers. Obviously, Pizza One is too busy to want my 80.00 future deliveries. They, also, didn't refund all that they owed me. Order at your own risk. Pizza One. You can rest assured that I will never be the cause of you being too busy. read more

The food was good but the service was horrible one day there is no pizza in a pizza shop which I don't understand. I tried coming back another day and they treated me as if I was a thief in there restaurant and didn't let me sit down and eat with my family unless everything was payed for. They also speak in Spanish about others that don't understand that language. I recommend this place if you don't mind paying to be judged read more

Pizza 1 is a casual pizza shop located in the Stroud Plaza. They serve up traditional & gourmet thin crust pizzas, Sicilian pizzas, calzones, strombolis, Italian pasta entrees, sandwiches, salads, and cold Pepsi drinks. The place is order at the counter and there are several tables inside for dining in. I stopped in here for a quick snack. I got a slice of thin crust cheese pizza (under $2), which was reheated in the oven. The service was prompt. The cheese pizza slice tasted pretty good, which was topped with the right amount of tomato sauce and melted cheese (slightly oily) on a thin soft crust, firm & crisp on the edge. read more

Best Cuban sandwich in Stroudsburg! The portions are great and the staff is very friendly!

I absolutely love this place. The pizza is amazing. The owner is one of the nicest people you will ever meet. Everyone on staff are welcoming and friendly. Everything they make is great. The portion sizes are crazy. You will not leave hungry read more

Wanted pizza while watching football during a trip to Stroudsburg. Pizza 1 was chosen due to the high Yelp reviews. The reviewers were right, this is good food. The sausage roll is so good it is worthy of making the trip to Stroudsburg alone. Soft, fluffy dough filled with melty, gooey cheese, tons of nicely spiced sausage, peppers and onions. Wow, this was good. Pizza is thin and chewy but not hard. Crispness from the oven is just right. The plaza is not in good shape but the store itself is clean and well maintained. The staff were all very pleasant and efficient. read more

So I roll in here about 10:15. I didn't check Yelp to see if they were open, but the door was open so I was confident. They actually close at 10, the staff was clearly finishing up. BUT, they were super friendly, asking what they could get me. They had one slice of plain left so I took that. They asked if I was sure, offered to make me a fresh pie, reassured me it was no big deal. Keep in mind, they're already closed. They're about done cleaning up. I decided to just take the one slice they had left. Honestly, I should have gotten the whole pie. Pizza was great, some of the best I've had in the area. And that's top notch service. Definitely coming back when they're actually open. read more

This place used to have the best pizza around - seems it has been sold and the pizza is terrible- not even sure it was mozzarella cheese - just a big blob of cheese with no taste. Why change a good thing - won't be back! read more

Tried it for first time May 15th 2022. Took my son with me. Food was great! Reasonable prices and the people working there were very cheerful and friendly. Much better value and quality than other pizza/restaurants near to them. The chicken tenders were moist and home made to order...not frozen. My pizza was the best I have had in the area. They even have the great fries our kids love as well....those crispy ones. My son loved his tenders and fries so much he took an order home for dinner. Looking forward to trying their pastas and other dishes. You can bring your own bottle as well which is nice. Highly recommended. Great value. They will see a lot of us. read more

First time here and I gotta say, they got the #1 pizza at Pizza 1. Hard working staff that makes some damn good pizza for a fair price

If you are looking for great New York style pizza while in the area, this is the place to go. We stopped in here on a whim one night and have kept going back. Great in every way, thin crispy crust, impeccable customer service. The owner will do anything to make it right by you and stands behind the product that he makes. Turns out he was the original owner of Momentos before it moved down the street and became the disaster it is now. Do yourself a favor if you are looking for good pizza at a reasonable price, then this is the place to go. You will meet a lot of the original customers who have come back now that he has re-opened this location. Can't wait for Friday so I can again go and have some of his excellent product. read more

Pizza 1 - Buffalo pizza - Pizza Near Me - Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania

Ordered from a couple pizza spots in the area but this one is it! I think it's a family owned business because I always see the same friendly faces greeting me with a smile. Not to mention the pizza tastes great too! I usually order a personal plain pie which rings up to a little under $8 - definitely ordering from here again! read more

I don't usually give negative reviews, but I went in and a lady took my order, took my charge and then took the next order. I was disguised to see that she used her bare hands to spread cheese on sandwich after having my charge in her hand. I watched them all do multiple things and then touching food with there bare hands. And when I said something about using gloves or washing hands, a man ranted and yelled for my Husband and I to leave and go somewhere else. VERY UNSANITARY!!! No thank you..... read more

We ate here monthly prior to it changing from Momentos to Pizza 1. Once it became Pizza 1 we are there weekly! I am a buffalo chicken pizza connoisseur and I cannot express how delicious theirs is!! 100% times better than it was at Momentos. Seriously, so so so good. The buffalo sauce wasn't dried up, it was juicy and cheesy and perfect. The staff was so friendly whether we delivered or stopped in to pick up. You could tell the owner took pride in his establishment and he should! Definitely recommend. read more

Pleasantly surprised! Great little counter pizza joint in a nondescript shopping plaza. The cheese was a bit salty for me but the pie had a great crust and a perfect sauce to cheese ratio. And the owner was absolutely awesome! The place had filled up with people eating pie at the tables and he said hello, thanks and goodbye to everyone in there! read more

My 1st time at Pizza 1. I was treated with open arms. I didn't feel like a stranger. Food is great as well as their service. For the 45 mins I was in the restaurant they were non-stop with customer in the store as well as delivery orders. If you're in town try to stop by for some food and generally good people who are happy you are there. read more

In one word to describe .... delicious. Best chicken roll I've ever had, and I'm from NYC. Everything was very fresh and delicious. Definitely worth every calorie. read more

This place is the real deal dog,..... the owner is cool as f*ck,. Just a little hard to understand. Food is amaz-balls! Much better than momentos ! read more

My girls and I were in town for a fun weekend and we wanted the best pizza in town. We drove over to Pizza 1 at 8 pm and we're seated immediately. Extensive selection of family-cooked Northern Italian food. We chose a chicken parmigiana dinner w/pasta and a large Special pizza. Our server was very friendly and accommodating. The food was full of flavor and delicious! I highly recommend it to visitors and locals alike. Very reasonably priced as well. read more

All kidding aside. I am a lifelong italian chef from NY. I have eaten the best pizza new York has to offer . THIS PLACE ROCKS. I am not a brick oven or gourmet pizza type of guy . I love a good crust, excellent cheese and a flavorful carefully constructed sauce.. The pizza at pizza 1 is a showcase of what pizza should be. I am forever impressed by the quality and the prices at this place. I literally sat down and ate half of a sicilian pizza tonight, the food is THAT GOOD . read more

Best pizza in town at this point... quality cheese, great crust! So friendly, it's the best! Sandwiches and hot dishes are also very good.. owner is there creating some yummy food!! I also hear great comments from others in town read more

Pizza1 is like one of Stroudsburg's hidden treasures. Kinda whole in the wall, but this place is a good old fashioned family run pizza place. Nothing like a plain slice. If Palumbos didn't feel like opening tomorrow I still know where to go for a good old school slice. read more

So disappointed. We ordered from here on a multi-family trip ($165 worth of food) based on the 4.3 stars we saw. We got a message that the order was almost ready so we went to pick up. On the way another message that the order was ready. When we got there the garlic knots were not done so we waited 20 minutes for them while the rest of the dinner got cold. We ordered via Slice app and none of the comments were paid any attention to (like NO MUSHROOMS on the pizza...) We ordered 2 different kinds of wings (24 each) Neither one had any sauce on them whatsoever and came with no dressing/celery. The perogies where just fried - no sour cream, no butter - and hard as bricks. The pizza toppings looked like someone just threw them in the middle of each pizza with no effort to spread them around at all. In the end the only thing worth eating was the garlic knots. I hope this review prevents anyone else from thinking they're worth over 4 stars and choosing them over any of the other options. read more

If you are in the mood for pizza in PA this is the place to go.. The owner is such a nice guy & The pizza is fabulous.. It's also very inexpensive!!! We had pizza, wings, and French fries. Everything was delicious. When I come back to PA I'm coming back to this place. Thanks Tony. Until next time read more

I am giving them 3 stars but I need to say- the food is very very good. The pizza especially is amazing. My last visit, I ordered baked ziti and there was multiple pieces of plastic in it... ouch! Good thing I caught it! read more

We've been ordering from Pizza 1 since they opened, and let me tell you, they have never disappointed. Pizza is great, but so is everything else on the menu. Chicken fingers are real chicken cutlets, like my mom made. I've placed several catering orders with them, and they've always been a delight to deal with. Great prices and rave reviews from our guests every time. I'll only cater through Pizza 1. The staff are also all so nice and accommodating. Place puts Momento's to shame. read more

i tried to get it delivered to my house park avenue, less than 2 miles .. total amount over 24 .. the guy over the phone was rushing me from the beginning having like a bothersome attitude couldn't even finished what i wanted .. i have got pizza from here before to my house but this it was too far the same location ... that is the problem with local business in small towns I tried support those but in cases like this, it is very discouraging.. i guess they making plenty of money ... buy it won't be not longer mine read more

We have been looking for a really good pizza place in the Pocono Mountains. We have tried pretty much all the joints up here with no luck until now. The crust is truly a new york study, crispy on the bottom and perfectly melted cheese on our Margarita Pizza. The wings were great and the pepperoni pizza was great also. read more

En route to Long Island...my wife's home...for family business. The reward for all the travel?? New York Pizza. Enter the NOREASTER of 3/2/18. Stopped on I-80 behind miles of carnage by 12:30 PM. Booked a room from the car on the spot. Took another hour to make the 10 miles to our Hampton Inn here in Stroudsburg. Killed the whole afternoon but started getting hungry. Many places are shut down. Power outages abound. 8 PM. We want pizza. Pizza 1 answered the phone! And delivered one large pizza for $14! Conditions must be horrible. Listening to the wind from our hotel room you'd think there was a hurricane. I gave the guy $28. Perfect NY pizza. Thin. Crisp. GOOD cheese. PERFECTION. I'd eat it every day and twice on Sunday. I can't decide if I'm more impressed with the ridiculously inexpensive and PERFECT NY pizza, or the fact that they delivered in this storm. These guys would have my business for life! read more

I'm a Momento loyalist, WAS a loyalist, until I vowed to never return. Upon finding this gem, Pizza 1, I thought I was going to be in pizza limbo. Penne Vodka, incredible! Pizza, excellent. Chicken Parm, wonderful! Pizza 1, you have a new regular customer and I recommend this fabulous place to any former loyalists with whom had enough of waiting for wrinkles to be ironed out. Thank you for an enjoyable meal. My family is over the moon. I'd give 5+ stars except for the hour and a half delivery wait. I live less than 2 miles so I was quite surprised BUT IT WILL NOT affect my elation, hoping it was a minor glitch due to its newness. Thanks Again Pizza 1 read more

The best pizza ! They treat you like their house guest ! Amazing ! Child friendly Thank you ! read more