EVERYTHING HERE IS INCREDIBLE. Large portions and tons of flavor and variety. Definitely stands out amongst pizza places in the area.

Nice little place. Stopped in and got a cheesesteak sandwich. Bread was nice with flavor and just a slight crunch. Meat was good a tad dry. Sandwich needed more cheese hardly any on it. Is it the best cheesesteak around no but it was a pretty good sandwich read more

America's Pie - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

I got catering from America's Pie for a brunch event and the food was AMAZING!! Everyone loved everything! The strawberry chocolate chip french toast was a hit! I highly recommend to get your catering from here :) Becky went above and beyond! read more

The Yem burger and the jalapeño crab soup are 2 of the best things they have on their menu. Check them out today if you haven't. Their menu is large and they do so many things very well! read more

Classic, easy pizza place and good food- best of all is customer service. I had an issue with a nasty DoorDash driver- fyi just call them directly don't use DoorDash, it's so much easier- and they helped me figure out getting my order without using DoorDash. I wish I remembered her name but she was so so helpful and the girl at the register too, I'm sure it was an annoying situation for them but they didn't make me feel bad about it at all and I appreciate how helpful they were. Thank you! read more

This place has great pizza and REMARKABLE service. I tried a salad there for the first time and it was pretty good but I wouldn't go running back. Big menu though. Wide variety of slices available. read more

America's Pie - Southwest Salad - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

The pizza was awful. I could have bought a frozen box of Elio's and it would have been better

Me and my cousin got a large pizza and 2 orders of fries and it was phenomenal the delivery boy was nice and he got a 14 dollar tip

Great spot. Pizzas are large. Crisp. Yummy. Sandwich's tonsssss to choose from. Seeded rolls and regular. Nice people as well, called to confirm an order last night after a question. About an allergy. Appreciated that! read more

This is such a blessing in good ol' WC. Everything is sooo good. Tonight my husband and I had taco dinners. Delicious! (Recommended by one of my patients!) We had the West Coast and Calvario tacos. (One is battered haddock, the other slow cooked brisket) Great to share! Prices are so reasonable, too! Keep up the great work! read more

Don't get me wrong I'm not taking anything away from their sandwiches, all are great esp the chicken cheesesteak, or the pizza which is also great. But...the tacos and jalapeño crab soup here are why you should go. read more

The food, the selection -- it's a go-to staple both for my family and office. We order A LOT and have never been disappointed. Delivery is quick and it always arrives hot! The menu items are extensive and I love that that offer gluten free. You have to try their tacos -- delish! Plus, they do so much for the community. Truly a class act establishment! read more

Great spot! So many different options ranging from pizza to salad to dessert. Huge menu, fast service and great value for the portion size. Highly recommend. read more

America's Pie - Chicken Salad Hoagie was delicious and huge! Foot long - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

Great food that's very consistent. Got the plain Brooklyn with extra caramelized onions and it was so good! Fast and courteous delivery from the restaurant as well. read more

America's Pie - Plain Brooklyn Pizza with extra caramelized onions - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

AMERICA's PIE IS BACK! After long time waiting for our go to pizza place in West Chester, they have returned from the Great Flood of '22! When we moved here a year ago and discovered this gem, it was like a match made in heaven for us pizza lovers! By the time we explored their sandwiches on their menu it happened... The Great Flood of '22. Long story short their place flooded from a random act of the devil himself; however, America's Pie persevered. With a very heart wrenching away message, they closed shop, picked up some mops, and got to work. Then they dried themselves off and opened up their door, more importantly their pizzas, to our little big town. Tonight I finally went back after over 3 months of waiting. I even stopped what slice of pizza to choose from, picked up my phone, and started writing this review before even TAKING A BITE IM THAT EXCITED! If you like good food, quick service, and hopefully still BANGING sandwiches, it's worth splurging the few extra bucks for America's Pie! read more

America's Pie - Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza Large extra cheese - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

The food was absolutely delicious, i had to slices if the tomato brooklyn. The workers were so nice and they are swifties so that is a bonus. And the resturant is full of Philadelphia sport team stuff read more

America's Pie - The resturant itself - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

Job ordered pizza from here today and it was outstanding! There were so many different speciality pizzas to choose from. I went with a slice of the Cali vegetarian and Philly cheesesteak. The Cali vegetarian was a 10/10 and I kept telling my coworkers to try it. It was packed and extremely filling. The pizza was full of flavor and freshness! Crust was perfection, sauce was good and I have zero complaints. I then decided to try a slice of the Philly cheesesteak because so many people were grabbing it, but it wasn't my favorite. Maybe because I was comparing it to the Cali vegetarian, but it was a bit dry and had a one note flavor. Still good and I still ate the entire slice, but i now know it is something I can do without next time. My coworkers all raved about the classic cheese, and pepperoni pizza. Will definitely come back and order from here again! read more

America's Pie - Cali Vegetarian Pizza - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

America's Pie is run under fantastic management and everything is always so delicious. I highly recommend their Thomas Wynne Sandwich-- it is definitely one of the best items from their menu. Under Covid, they are doing a great job with curbside pickup, enduring social distancing, and doing their part to keep their employees and community safe. And as mentioned, the food is always great. I highly recommend ordering here! read more

America's Pie - Thomas Wynne Sandwich - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

2nd time here. Cool vibe. Good food and chill staff. Really good cheesesteak! And check out my salad! read more

America's Pie - Nuttiest Peach Salad!!! - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

I really enjoy the food. The service at the counter is always pleasant and immediate. A top tier experience.

America's Pie, West Chester, PA, The Cheesesteak egg roll was pretty darn good. I went with The Dos Amigos and none of us were overly impressed with our sandwiches. Their name, America's Pie, indicates pizza is their focus. What I like about pizza places is their toppings are usually very good and this was true here. I got the Philly special which came with a special hot sauce which I found very tasty. The peppers and onions on Dan's sandwich look nice, big, good and fresh. Nice big menu. Don't go hungry like we did it. We had to let three people go ahead of us because we were on big menu overload. read more

See all

This rating is really about a 3.5. Went for Cheesesteaks and had a Cheesesteak with Fried Onions and Ketchup(this is my standard when evaluating). Cheesesteak meat and cheese were very good. Chopped nice and the cheese mixed in so you got cheese with every bite. Enough onions and not overpowering. The problem was the roll. It was the weak spot of what could have been a very good cheese steak. I asked where they got them from and no on seem to know. The closest I got was it was perhaps an Amoroso roll. The roll did taste like a bagged Amoroso roll you would get at the supermarket so it could have been. After seeing another couple getting the cheesesteak egg rolls and raving about them, ordered them as well. I liked them a lot. My crew thought they were a little greasy. They weren't wrong, but the taste was good in my opinion with plenty of meat and cheese. Also ordered the pierogies for appetizer. They were just okay. Looked like frozen that they stuck in the deep fryer. I wouldn't order them again. All in all a good experience. Would I go back just for the cheesesteak egg rolls-probably not. read more

We had an engagement party catered by America's Pie and it was AMAZING! Our guests were blown away by how beautifully the food was displayed. Everything was delicious from the charcuterie board to the lobster rolls. We can't wait to have another party and have it catered by America's Pie! read more

This place is my go-to for build-your-own salads! My favorite toppings they offer are the dried cherries and all of the varieties of nuts. I constantly crave their grilled chicken too! read more

See all

Disappointed for three reasons. First we ordered a mushroom white pizza and we were not informed that the portobello mushrooms were marinated in balsamic ( some people may like that but that's not us). Second quality was not what we expected. And third we do not appreciate or utilize vendors that have hidden charges (extra for the use of a credit card, especially when it's not clearly marked). read more

I waited at this establishment for my food, wrap and fries. The people behind me were served before me. I watched them put in their orders. Avoid this place on Wednesday, bunch oh lethargic staff. read more

Absolute best food, never disappointed -- such a creative menu. Such a favorite! LOVE the Balboa specialty sandwich and the tacos are SO good! read more

Hoagie roll was like chewing gum, fresh out of the microwave? Otherwise AP has good food. Very Disappointed!

A local favorite with a wide variety of options. I've only had a few sub par experiences out of a few dozen times. Pizzas, sandwiches, or wings they're all really good! If you're up for trying something different then I recommend the George pizza. read more

America's Pie - James Dean pizza - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

Food is always good. Great selections. This is a business that has always been supportive of the communities they serve!

Can't say whether the food is good or not. Just want to say this should be named "Chernobyl Pie" because of the incompetence. Paid for two of the advertised specials (2 cheese slices and a pop). Paid. Then was informed "we have no cheese." Okay no prob.... how long to make pizza? They could not say. Today? "Yes we will make cheese pizza today." Soon? "We have not started." Once you start how long will it take? "We aren't even working on it." It was as if I was asking them to do calculus. They did give me a refund - manager was nice. read more

Balboa is awesome, calvaria tacos-5 stars. Fast delivery and good food! I love their sandwiches!

We had the most amazing pizza tonight! The James Matthew pizza with beef brisket so delicious! We have never had anything we didn't like from American Pie, but this pizza is at a whole other level!! Definitely going back for this!! read more

Start off by saying, i am a frequent customer and usually very satisfied. Today i stoped in for a couple slices...They have a standard special of 2 slices and a drink...:It was 2 pm and after the lunch rush...i expect choices to be a bit limited...but...my wife as for two slices of sausage..."Sorry you need to come back in a couple hours when they make the pies for dinner"...I ask for two slices of plain..."sorry no plain either, all the plain slices keep disappearing today...you can come back in a couple hours when they make the Pies for dinner"....REALLY...it felt like a "No soup for you episode"...Fortunately there are a lot of Pizza places around and i got my slices...I hope this was an anomaly...I'll try again because the past service was always good. read more

As I sit her with my pants tight, my heart is also as enlarged as my stomach. I just got done the Thanksgiving Feast from America's Pie and once again they crush any cuisine they offer. I never imagined doing take out for Thanksgiving. We've always done parents or in-laws but as we know this year is different. Truthfully it snuck up on me and I messaged them the night before pickup (Thanksgiving Eve) and was lucky to sneak in the last remaining spots. The menu had a hefty amount of choices & servings in each category and the portions were enough for leftovers. Salad(1/2), Entrees(1/4), Sides(3/8). The entree category not only contained a large portion of delish and moist protein, it included gravy, dinner roll & cranberry. Considering that each meal contained 3-8 oz sides some of my family bartered for 1/2 side swaps. I was able to taste 5 of the 8 side choices by sharing and they were peppered with traditional tastiness beyond anything I could have whipped up during the craziness of a pandemic. One last perk was complete customization of each individual meal, no fighting over choosing the menu! At $25/pp it was a steal, I could have not provided that much varied food for the price let alone the time, effort and headache of shopping and cooking. There was even an option to buy extra sides($3) and 2 different desert options for purchase($5). We didn't get extra sides bc with 6 people we were able to cover all the side choices but you know we hit up both bread pudding options-AP specialties and a must when you order, beyond delicious!! The way America's Pies family atmosphere and wanting to cook for the community at every turn really helps alleviate the guilt of having the perfect holiday and all the tedious work that comes along with it. They help you get back to what is really important, time to be with your family unstressed and on budget and with leftovers to rehash all the fun you had and memories made instead of doing dishes!! Thank you Matt & America's Pie for all the amazing ideas you come up with to feed people and their families!! read more

So far everything sandwich I've ordered has been great! They have a big menu of specialty sandwiches that won't disappoint. My go to spot for a great sandwich. read more

I had a cheese slice of America's Pie at Pizza Fest in Philadelphia today and it was hands down the best at the entire festival! My husband and I braved the line and even went back twice. Perfect thin crust, sweet sauce and a ton of cheese. Reminded me of pizza back home in New York! Whatever you guys are doing, keep doing it. Excellent slice. read more

America's Pie - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

See all

3 of the 20 wings in my order of 20 wings were the finger tip. Not the drumstick or the flat, the tip. There is nothing to eat on the tip..... you are not supposed to serve that to paying customers. I felt disrespected and I know only cheap bums count the wings on delivery to make sure they get the 20 they order.. but that's me. I rate the wings 6.420/10 (the real wings they actually gave me) but I can't get past them thinking it was acceptable to serve that. No longer a supporter of this establishment. read more

Stopped by at America's Pie with some friends for lunch. It's a small, hole-in-the-wall pizza/Italian place with great prices and some dingy decor. It's got a few TV's around the wall and just groups of old guys everywhere. However, the food is great, the people are kind, and the chefs are merry, and the prices are just right as well. I ordered two slices, one was a broccoli/tomato/cheese white pizza (I forget the name, something like Holiday White or something), and the other was a Hawaiian. The slices ended up being extremely generous and I ended up even bringing some home. The Holiday White was very filling, ingredients were very fresh and succulent. The Hawaiian was a bit disappointing, just a plain cheese pizza with topping of chopped ham and pineapple very obviously shoddily put on once the cheese pizza was heated. The pieces were quite hastily put on that when I held the slice, all the topping ended up falling into the center. No-bueno. My friend ordered the Pistol Pete sandwich, which I highly recommend if you want something heavier. All in all, America's Pie is a great stop by for something to grab for lunch. It's got reasonably tasting pies and Italian food (at very reasonable prices), and I'll definitely stop by again. Atmosphere and my Hawaiiian pizza are the only gripes, and I'd give this restaurant a 3.5 star if there was an option, but I'll have to bump down. There seems to be some mixed reviews for this place. If you're going for something to hold you up for lunch, that isn't too expensive and is still quite tasty (I am not very picky for pizza) then America's Pie will do the job quite nicely. read more

America's Pie - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

We thought this place was phenomenal and gave it so many tries and once again FREEZING cold pizza. Last time there were BONE fragments in our cheesesteaks. Management has listened, but time and time again, our food is cold and carelessly prepared. I'm really sad that my pizza is currently heating in the oven as I'm writing this. read more

America's Pie - Cold pizza. We've just had so many problems...WHYYYY??? - Italian Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania