The wait is way too long. It took a while to place the order and then even longer for the order to come out and it was nothing complicated! They didn't come by to bring us more water. So go with patience. However, the food is so delicious! We found this place by accident and I so glad we gave it a shot. I had spaghetti with meatballs and their sauce is heavenly. The meatball has a wonderful flavor too. I recommend. Simple but effective! read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

Ate lunch here today and it was my first time being here. I had the margarita pizza and my husband had the steak sandwich, we had the meatballs for an appetizer. It was all so delicious. The marinara was the best part of it! Definitely will go back here for lunch or dinner. read more

I came in on my lunch break for two pepperoni pizzas & a sprite from the take out counter. I sat down on the bench across from the counter awaiting my order. Roughly 5 minutes later i saw a pizza cook place a bag on top of the pizza oven. I thought nothing of it. Some woman came in & ordered after me & she received her order before me. The white girl who took my order even walked from around the counter to hand deliver the other customer their order. I watched the girl reach on top of the oven, pull down the bag, slide it across the counter and tell me my order was ready. I stood up, walked over to the counter and said to her "wow, my order was ready this entire time and i was sitting here?" She started laughing and i said "thats not funny I'm on my lunch break" she proceeded to ask me how long was i waiting as if she wasn't standing at the counter scrolling through her cell phone the entire time, while everyone else is working. I come to this place roughly once a week because its 2 minutes from my place of employment. I will never return to this place. It took me 28 minutes to receive two slices of pizza. The pizza was luke warm by the time i received it. read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

Amazing food. But hands down, the people working are absolutely incredible. The moment I walked in, I was greeted then helped, greeted again at the register and attended to. Taking care of guests like it's your own home is the feeling I received. And even better, pizza and food we had was excellent read more

Pizza was decent a little on the greasy side. Very disappointed in the Almond Cream Cake. Almost $7.00 for a 3oz portion read more

Amici Pizza - Almost $7.00 Almond Cream Cake. About 3 ounces. Ridiculous - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

Worst tasting pizza I ever had $24. Hardly anything on it ordered pepperoni mushroom to small pieces not very good would not recommend.

Went here once in 2019 and just thought it was ok. Tried it again recently and it did not disappoint! The salad was fresh and large. The garlic knots were the best I've ever had and the pizza was delicious. Nice sit down atmosphere which can be hard to find in a pizza place. read more

great pizza if you like new york softer crust pizza. great owners and service! if you like the pasta dishes, that is a definite go to . read more

Pizza with a side of politics?!? I stopped in for lunch last week. The signs outside for DeSantis are a bit much. Now, it may not be their signs, could be the building owner. I'm just so sick of seeing politics EVERYWHERE. Your customers don't want to know or care about who you support, they just want to get a great pizza. With all of that being said, the pizza was excellent. That's all. read more

delicious food, amazing service, very cute place, and love to support a small family-owned business! I recommend the baked ziti, it's so damn good!! read more

This place is awesome. The pizza reminds me of New York. They are always quick with your order.

THIS DOES NOT DESERVE A STAR!!!!!! Being a previous restaurant owner I know what posting a review on a business can do - these are people's livelihoods it's not something to joke around about. But I must post this one - I am appalled & disgusted by what I was told by an employee. It's actually a public safety hazard. I ordered a particular pie from this location & when I got home it was not what I ordered. I called back to get this corrected & was told by the employee "that I may have received the wrong order to bring the pie back to the store so they can give it to the right customer or they can put it on the side & use it for someone else" I immediately asked for the owner of the store & got the owners son. I explained the whole conversation to this gentleman & requested my money back. The owners son was very apologetic, advised me that he would of never let that happen, and refunded my order in full. He 100% did right by me. The reason I am posting this is because WHAT IF the owners weren't there??? What if someone brought their wrong order back? I have left establishments & taken my order back to show them it was wrong instead of calling. Just the thought of me getting an order that someone else had in their possession even if it was for 5 mins then returned and God forbid given to me has made me absolutely sick to my stomach. We all know owners aren't there 100% of the time. I know I wasn't able to be! An establishment is responsible for the training of their employees & making sure, especially in the food industry that they know the rules & regulations. read more

Came in with my family on a Tuesday night and sat at a table for over 15 minutes without anyone coming to our table to take our order or bring us drinks. All the while the "host" was just standing at the front starring out the window. Terrible service! read more

We were in the area of Wesley Chapel for a errand and looked around for a good place for lunch. We stepped into this little restaurant and was met with a pleasant smile and hello. We ordered and when the food was delivered to our table it smelled amazing and looked great. We each took a bite of the dish before us and each of us said " This tastes awesome!" Service was terrific and atmosphere is casual. We are already trying to see what other "errands" we might need to come over this way for. read more

Pizza was delicious. If you like NY Pizza, I highly recommend. If you are a pizza snob, I highly recommend. You will not be disappointed.

Thanks to my coworkers I was able to try Amici's twice. I've tried a sausage pizza, white pizza, chicken wings, garlic knots, and potato ball. My favorites were the potato ball and the garlic knots by far. I'd definitely order those first. I can't speak for pizza. Being from Chicago pizza is different. I've seen pics of Sicilian pizza which have sparked my attention. Maybe next time I will try it. Amici's has been around for a while and now they have a new building. I've visited it before but my first impression was that it was extremely loud. So if I were to order on my own, I would take it to go. read more

Excellent environment, very good pizza and ok service. Garlic knots are wonderful. Great place for families after a youth sports event. Pricing is good with their value! read more

Usually a goodplace for pizza. Ordered cheese steak and half mushroom pizza at 530 on a tuesday. Told 25 to 30 minutes. Got there at 6pm. Cheese steak was ready and placed in bag. 615 told pizza would be 5 or 10 minutes, some one "messed up". Got pizza at 630. Mushrooms looked like they were thrown on. Cheese steak cold by time i got home read more

Amici Pizza - Sloppy pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

I stopped for a pizza today. it had probably been nearly a year since I was in. The owners remembered me, that' alone make an impression. I always enjoy their pizza, it's just like the pizza I had in NY. Good job guys. read more

I wasn't feeling well, so hubby did a carry out pizza for us. When he got it home it was burnt. I couldn't eat it. I went on their FB page and complained. They actually got nasty with me! you would think they'd just say "sorry" and we appreciate the feedback. NO, instead, they insulted me. read more

After much thought, I would have to say my dinner was abit of disappointment. My wife and I started with the Antipasto salad. Very unimpressive. The dressing they gave us was pure vinegar. Luckily there was garlic, cheese and salt to Doctor up. As for the Pizza, well that was disappointing as well. We ordered the Hawaiian with bacon. All we tasted was salty bacon. We had ordered double cheese and barely got any cheese. The ham and pineapple was sparse at best. Lastly the sauce was minimal and the crust was doughy. Not a fan at all. Best New York Pizza here we come!! . read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

Everyone at this family owned business is always so nice. I order from here pretty frequently and food is always hot, fresh and tasty!

We moved to Wesley Chapel last year and have been looking for a great pizza joint. We have passed Amici's a gazillion times and said "hey we should try that place". Life goes on and we had not till today. Today we took our e-bikes out for a run and wanted to grab something we could eat as a picnic lunch near the small airport off Old Wesley Chapel Road. After much brain storming I remembered Amici's which is right there at the turn off. We got the cold house sub,fries and a chocolate cannolli. It was delicious! Sub was fresh, nothing was over used and frankly for that type of sub it was perfect! I suggest adding salt and pepper but that's me. The fries were fresh and perfectly fried and the cannolli was amazing! It was so good in fact we decided to order pizza tonight. We ordered a pepperoni and bacon and the margarita pizza. I was skeptical we got the right pizza till I checked the menu, I should have ordered the Capri, regardless these pies were delicious. Not overly greasy and the crust was soooooo good. My only meh moment was the bacon, as its minced BUT that is a preference thing not a bad on Amicis thing. Great food, great service, clean restaurant and best of all Family Owned. If you live anywhere near here it is a must try. We will definatly be going back!!! Our new pizza joint, Thanks Amici's. read more

Why 4 stars? Started ordering here for work functions and turned out to be really happy. Pizza is fresh and made to order. Salads are good and fresh as well. Pricing is not crazy, but as long as they keep using high quality ingredients, I am happy to pay a little more. A little away from the high profile spots but a decent pie and cute spot. read more

Having just moved to Wesley Chapel it was time to find a good pizza restaurant. After my order was place I went to pick up the pizza unfortunately there happen to be mistake and my pizza inadvertently may have been given to somebody else. However the restaurant immediately apologized and put in another order and gave me a complementary pizza! I will definitely going back not only because the restaurant showed amazing customer service but also the pizza was amazing thank you all ! read more

I will never eat "chain" pizza again!!!!! Seriously, mark my words! Unless I'm forced to or otherwise die... This place is fantastic! I called my order in when I left work. Told them what time I expected to arrive. Arrived to them pulling it out of the oven. Drove home and within 10 minutes of coming out of the oven, my son was RAVING about its deliciousness! We're bacon and pineapple kinda people and their's does not disappoint! (Caesar salad was good too.) Pleased mom to know I have too much to do to make dinner but I'm still able to make my family happy. Thank you Amici! read more

This is by far my favorite neighborhood pizza spot! The pizza, pastas, and desserts are authentic and delicious! The staff and owners are always great! read more

My family has been visiting this pizza shop since they were in a different building down the street years ago. If you want good pizza then visit!! Order is always correct and prompt. Love this place read more

This pizza is really awesome!! I've ordered from them several times, each time there pizza has been phenomenal! These last few times, we ordered their Keto pizza crust and it was delicious. They are fast, friendly, and have never messed up our orders. I definitely recommend to everyone!! read more

Amici Pizza and Deli is heartwarming taste of New York or Philly in Wesley Chapel. The staff is unbelievably friendly and not in that "it's a customer we need to plaster on a smile and muscle through type way," they are genuine. These people care not only about the product, but the customers that enter their sanctuary for the tastebuds. This is always a good sign. An even better sign is the food itself. Their thin crust pizza is amazing to say the least. I have had it with several toppings now and would recommend any. I love pizza, and what makes this place better than most is the fact that they are not only local and a non big chain, but the pizza is not greasy. My favorite item on the menu is not their pizza, but the Strombolis - these people know what they are doing. They are the closest I have ever seen a restaurant come to what my mom and aunt make when I grew up. The best is their Philly cheese steak stromboli- reminds me not only of my mother's, but of Philadelphia. Try this place out. It's a great place - your family or date will thank you and your tastebuds will as well. read more

I've been enjoying their delicious pizza for about 10 years now. I'm a huge fan on their dough. Something about it just sets it apart from others. They've recently moved into a new, larger location. We were greeted by a young, friendly host who sat us right away. It wasn't terribly busy on a Thursday evening. However, the new location was very echoing. I did notice a small sign saying they were working on the noise level. From our table we saw the busy kitchen with lots of dough being thrown around. After watching for a bit I realized they were slammed with to-go orders. After searching their menu with too many yummy meals to choose from like eggplant parmigiana, lasagna and such, I went with a calzone. It was delicious as always. I'm not a huge cannoli fan but hear their cannolis are some of the best around. You'll have to see for yourself. read more

See all

delicious pizza and everyone is always really friendly! love that this is right in my neighborhood.

Very pleased with this place! Although we only ordered carry out, our short visit was very pleasant. We ordered a small pepperoni pizza and it was finished within less than 20 minutes. While waiting at the bar area, we were given water and got to watch how the pizzas were made. Very friendly workers! Prices are quite fair. Pizza was delicious! read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

I'm definitely in the minority. We did door dash to try the new Amici bc we heard nothing but good things. I don't eat pizza so I always order sandwiches if offered. The chicken philly was the worst sandwich I've ordered locally. Please go try Woody's and get back to me. The marinara they include which is weird for a Philly doesn't help. They use ground tasteless chicken bits and not enough cheese to be considered worth the $8. Disappointed does not describe it. Considering I have heard this is the best pizza in town - ummmmm ok. Our pizza was fine. It was not blowing my mind. Nothing special at all. Cheese pepperoni thin crust. I did try it to make sure I wasn't being a total anti-pizza brat. The wings were good. But not special. Sorry Amici. I know you're reopening and local and all of that but you have good competition in Woodys and New York New York especially when it comes to sandwiches and pasta. read more

I can only comment on the take out service from Amici's seeing as that's what we used, but what a great experience it was! When we went to pick up our order, they were very busy, but despite that they had our pies ready in just over 20 minutes. They took the order quick and efficiently and, upon arriving to pick up our order, greeted us promptly, cashed us out, and even checked our order and showed us each pie to assure that everything was done correctly. This is just a little gesture but definitely means a lot. The pizza is AMAZING and will be our new go to place when we visit my mom in this area from now on. I am excited to try out the rest of their food and their dining room service. read more

See all

Great Lil Italian place right in Wesley Chapel. They have the best NYC style pizza in the area. Another item they are known for is there awesome garlic knots which are always made to order fresh... read more

I have honestly been going here since I was a child it is my favorite pizza on this planet. They also have fantastic service and desserts. Over all this place is worth every penny. if your in the area definitely come in an eat. they are also really close to the outlet mall and I always drive that way to avoid the traffic that gets backed up around the highway. read more

Mediocre food with terrible service Maybe it's an off night, but we wont be back again. read more

Amici Pizza - Stuck in the corner behind a party of 15. Can't even leave without asking someone to move. Waited 10 minutes for someone to take our order. - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

We've been waiting for them to reopen. Had a Hawaiian pizza and husband ruined it by adding bacon. It made the pizza too salty. Crust was good. Sauce was tasty. Had antipasti salad. The dressing was just a cup of red wine vinegar. Spiced it up with all the condiments on the table. But then then we discovered these little Italian cookies. Oh my.....I am speechless. Pro tip: off hours are best. We arrived at 3pm on Saturday and parking lot was packed. We will be back to try again. The pasta entrees at other tables look delish! read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

We LOVE Amici Pizza!!! Everyone is super friendly and the food is absolutely AMAZING!!!