Best place in town. Make everything in house, love their homemade Italian sausage. They also have an unreal house sweet and sour sauce.

We were staying in Rochester to watch our grandkids and had it delivered. We've had a couple different pizzas during other visits but this was the best we've had. It was a little pricey but we really enjoyed it and had enough left over fir lunch the following day. read more

Always delicious and fresh. Always make sure to grab a pie from here when I'm in NY. Flavor is always on point read more

Delicious pizza, very quick service, and friendly staff. No place to sit down so be prepared to take away, but the pizza is definitely worth a try. read more

Great pizza and wings, hot and fresh. Made to order, delicious as expected! Fast and easy from order to pick up! read more

I had seen a few posts on one of the Irondequoit Facebook pages praising Amico's Pizza. I had never tried them, though I have driven by them a few times since moving to Irondequoit in July. I was having a party a few weeks ago, and wanted to order a sheet pizza and some wings. So I thought it would be a good opportunity to try Amico's. I called in the order, and the delivery arrived in what seemed like less than 30 minutes. The pizza and wings were piping hot, and smelled amazing! Everyone at the party raved about the pizza. The crust was the perfect thickness, with just the right amount of not-too-sweet tomato sauce, cheese and pepperoni. The outside crust was crisp and flavorful. The wings were cooked perfectly as well, crisp, and sauced just right. Halloween night, I placed an order for myself, a small #1 pizza with Anchovies, and a small order of Garlic Parmesan wings. Once again, I was thoroughly impressed with the Pizza. Super quick delivery. Crisp, flavorful crust, just the right amount of sauce and Pecorino Romano cheese, and great anchovies. The wings were full of garlic flavor, and crisp. Overall, I highly recommend them! Especially the #1 pizza. It's like a basic, old-fashioned style pie, and is delicious without all the extras! This is my new favorite go-to pizza place! read more

Amico's Pizza - Small "The #1" Pizza with anchovies. A classic! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

My friend ordered a sheet pizza from Amico's for her birthday. It was 1/2 just cheese, 1/2 pepperoni and Italian sausage. Normally, I'm not a huge fan of sheet pizzas because I don't care for the super thick crust... this sheet pizza on the other hand, was thin like a normal pizza which I liked it a lot. The toppings weren't heavily applied, which might be a negative for some people but again, I hate when there are too many toppings and they slide off your slice as you try to eat it. Likewise, the sauce was pretty light... almost nonexistent. It wasn't terrible but caused the pizza to be a little bland. Regardless, I had 3 pieces so it was still really good. read more

Amico's Pizza - Sheet pizza. Surprisingly thin crust which I liked! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Not bad but seemed a bit dry. I'm not one to want a lot of sauce but my recommendation is to ask for extra sauce. Wings were good.

Fairly annoyed, friend in hospital, ordered pizza wings and a drink for him, gave the person taking the order the address and Patients room number on a Friday afternoon. Monday found out they did not deliver, when I called I was told "we do not deliver to Strong it's way out of our delivery area"! May have been a great idea to tell me that when I gave you the food order and the delivery address....... And then Monday was fully charged for the order " I was out a pizza and some wings"! AGAIN you should have mentioned when you were given the address if was not in your delivery area! NOT COOL! read more

From my first experience to this most current experience at Amico's it was literally like night and day. This time the pizza was amazing!! Perfectly cooked, fresh ingredients and delicious!!! I was told when the older" gentleman is there who either owns or runs the place is there the pizzas come out perfect and way better then if he's not- well l guess they were right because he was there and the pizza was delicious!!!!! read more

Amico's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I decided to order Amico's after reading some reviews - I was not disappointed! Easy to order and good prices. The delivery was quick and both items were still nice and warm!! The delivery driver was very conscientious with the contact free drop off. The fried mushrooms were AMAZING. What a yummy surprise. The pizza was also delicious. read more

Amico's Pizza - Small cheese pizza with banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

i ordered a sheet pizza tonight. without a question it was the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. There was practically no sauce, no cheese except sprinkled on Parmesan. The crust was crunchy and overcooked. i mean it honestly seemed like a pizza that had sat around for days and then reheated. I complained through the app I order through and received 1/2 back. If my family wasn't starving already I would have taken it back to the store and demanded my money back. After a hard day at work we decided to order pizza so I didn't have to cook, what a mistake! First and last time for this place! read more

I have been coming to "Amico's Pizza" every few weeks since they opened their E. Ridge Rd, location in 1981! Always enjoyed their pizza. Unfortunately, two of their questionable hires--delivery drivers, no less--have likely guaranteed that I will never be a customer again. Last night, as I was arriving to pick up an order, TWO delivery driver vehicles BLOCKED THE ONLY STREET ENTRANCE, leaving me stuck in the right lane with traffic behind me. I laid on my horn to get someone to come out and move their car, but they just ignored me. Finally, after about 3 minutes (!), I swung my front end out and parked on the lawn behind both vehicles, got out, and walked across the grass into the shop. "Thanks for making me almost cause an accident out there," I told the guy behind the counter and his two knucklehead confederates. I got ZERO attention! I paid my bill and left, only to have one punk harass me on the way out. Not wanting an assault charge on my record, I just kept walking. Needless to say, I will NOT be buying anymore pizza at "Amico's." Nice way to lose a 43-year customer! read more

Amicos is my favorite local pizza place. Prices are solid, pizza is good. Nice crust, sauce cheese ratios and onions are finely chopped. They also have cup n char pepperoni and their wings are pretty good. Large Pizza and 20 wings for $30 is a solid price now a days too. Wings are good if not worlds best and they are pretty quick. They have a weird set up to get in and out of and a lot of stairs for a take out place. The location is actually the worst part of the place really. read more

i have not had take out pizza from Amico's in literally years. Mostly due to the fact that I love making my own pizza. But recently I have gone gluten free and decided to try their cauliflower crust pizza . I must say this is the very best cauliflower crust I have tried ( and I've really tried quite a few) Efficient delivery service and delicious pizza. Family-run long standing Irondequoit business. Highly recommend. read more

Amico's pizza is the best pizza I've had in irondequoit. Moved to spencerport and still go here just for the pizza. The wings are the kind that's covered in really thick sauce and the blue cheese is good unlike other places. Come here for good pizza no nonsense read more

This is Rochester pizza at it's finest! I've lived away from the area for close to 10 years. Everywhere I've gone I have looked high and low for anything comparable. Spoiler alert: nothing comes close to real deal Upstate NY pizza!! I've been visiting Rochester for the summer and we had several lackluster pizzas. All my former favorites have seemed to have gone downhill or closed altogether. Then I remembered the amazing pizza my Dad used to get when I was growing up. Lo and behold...it's still in business and every bit as delicious as I remembered. Every part of it was perfection! Thin crust that is crispy, chewy, and airy. Light base of flavorful sauce, the best cheese, and big chunks of sausage. Oh my....how can I possibly go back to what California considers "NY pizza"?? If you see me shoving pizza in my mouth, please don't judge. read more

In the food industry, having a delicious product matters; However, just as important, consistency is a must if you want to keep any customers that you earn with one excellent meal. Our entire family have been ordering from Amico's for years. Every single pizza (and there have been hundreds) has been absolutely delicious. The ingredients are top notch, they are generous with any toppings we request, the balance of flavor is fantastic, and every single pie taste as good as the first one we fell in love with. They are happy to cut your pizza in slices or squares, per your preference or, and I am happy to see that the same people who were preparing my pizza five years ago are still making it now, and it is as delicious as ever. So to recap, delicious matters, but consistency matters just as much and Amico's always delivers on both. read more

So I lived in the city Clinton Norton area for 20 years always got my pizzas from Amico's. Move to the Eastside 1995. Unfortunately I have been back to see Dave until today. Order two pizzas one veggie for my wife and one pepperoni for myself absolutely the best pizza that I've ever eaten and that's coming up against an East side legend in TK's. That's even forgetting about the price I had two mediums with three toppings each and they were $32 total plus tax. I will make the trip from now on from Macedon to Irondequoit to eat Amico's pizza frim now on. Absolutely no comparison to any other pizza I've ever had, Dave you're still rocking it! read more

Love the pizza and wings! Friendly staff, very accommodating with special requests! Love their meatballs too! Way to go Amico! read more

We enjoyed Amico's for dinner last night. I am surprised we've never ordered from here before given the proximity. We went with a standard pepperoni pizza and I really enjoyed it. The sauce was a little sweet (I tend to like it more savory) BUT it was not too saucy. I like a pizza that is more crust and toppings and easy on the sauce so I was happy! The crust was of a good thickness and consistency. Maybe it's a little bland... But it makes for great blue cheese dipping. What was the best part? The cheesy, cheesiness!!! Even better on a day two oven heat up... Crisping the edges of the cheese on those inside pieces. I'm really all about the verse and Amico's definitely pleased!! I typically don't eat wings, but I tried them out. They had a sweet and sour sauce. It was good, but comparable to most places. Again, I'm not a wing fan so take that with a grain of salt. read more

I'm new to the area and was craving pizza, a co-worker suggested this place so I thought I would give it a try. The flavor of the sauce is good but the pizza is very flat and greasy. The wings were ok. The medium sauce tasted a little on the sweeter side. All in all I wouldn't order from here again. It just isn't the style of pizza I like. read more

Amico's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Great crust, sauce is tomato-ee, topping distribution was oddly uneven as stated in a previous review. Wings were cooked well but lacked flavor for being ordered Medium read more

Wow just had the worst pizza of my life. In what world is a mushroom pizza supposed to strongly taste like garlic white pizza. Owners daughter was rude and they wouldn't resolve it. read more

Amico's is by far the best pizza in Rochester. There's a reason they're been in business for so long. The classic tomato pie is delicious and you can't go wrong with the eggplant parm pizza. Adding delivery now gives it another big plus read more

My first order from here, recently moved into the area and have found my pizza place. Wings were crispy and the garlic sauce very tasty. The thin crust pizza was crisp with excellent tasting toppings. It stood up to reheating in my oven very nicely. Great food read more

Favorite pizza of all time! Good amount of cheese, tasty sauce, chewy crust that's substantial without being greasy, and delicious homemade sausage. We are proud to have such excellent pizza in Irondequoit, and have converted many of our friends to Amico's because it's the only pizza we buy. read more

The Amico Family not only creates great pizza but supports the community with heart. Mr. & Mrs. Amico own not just a fun pizza place, they possess a piece of Irondequoit. It would not be the same without them. Yesterday I picked up a pizza to celebrate an occasion. It was special to me. Dave took the time to celebrate a little with me with a great conversation and a really great vegetable pizza. I am grateful! read more

Times have changed and so has Amico Pizza. This is not the same Amico Pizza that was on Waring Rd. Pizza was just okay.

Been enjoying Amico's Pizza for years and years! David does a great job and is always there!. Pizza and wings are always fresh and delicious. Ingredients are quality, tons of cheese and meats. Had the white garlic Saturday night, best Gallic Pizza EVER! If you haven't tried it your missing out! Keep up the great work David! read more

I wish I had gotten a chance to try out Amico's pizza, but within the first half minute of our phone conversation the employee got incredibly rude. I couldn't hear him over the din in the background so when I asked if he was asking for my address he very sarcastically responded "well uh YEAH I'm gonna need it if I'm going to deliver it to you!". I understand slinging dough is hard work, but you've gotta at least not be outright rude in a customer service job. Maybe I'll give them another try but tonight I'll be eating some Cordello's! read more

Best pizza in Rochester NY by far. They always get my pizza exactly right. Staff is really friendly. A must visit if you are ever in the area and want a really good puzza. read more

This Amino pizza place has fast service and it's only 20 minutes. but the hub didn't have enough.

The best buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had. Whenever my family travels through the area we pick up an Amico pizza and bring it back to our hotel room. A trip to Rochester is not complete until you go to Amico! read more

They would not deliver less then a mile wow I own my own home they treated me like ghetto sorry but I have a problem when people discriminate because the area you live in its sad and unjust I would never recommend someone who's made his monies from people who he's scare d to deliver too read more

This was my first time ordering from Amico's and it was very unsatisfactory. First off, the pizza is so tiny!! A small pizza is smaller than the size of a regular dinner plate!! I could not believe my eyes when I opened the box. It was so tough and hard to chew. It did not seem fresh at all, some of it was burned and it was just so very disappointing....especially for the price! The mozzarella sticks were cold upon arrival and they looked, and tasted, like they came frozen out of a box from a cheap grocery store. Needless to say, we were beyond disappointed with the food and will not be placing any future orders with Amico's. Sorry to say, but it's some of the worst pizza I've ever had before (just being 100% honest). I would not recommend this place to anyone. read more

Ordered delivery from Amico's after seeing positive reviews. The pizza came in around 40 minutes. We had a pepperoni pizza and an order of hot barbecue wings. They were tasty and well cooked. The pizza was also good and I enjoyed the consistency of the crust. The sauce was also different than any other pizza sauce I've had. My only complaints are that it is a bit more expensive than other pizza places and I wish the food was warmer when it arrived. read more

My mom and I moved to Irondequoit in the late 70's, and Amico's (At Waring road) has long been a favorite. I remember the first time we went, it had the atmosphere of a bakery. On walking in, the scent was heady and almost overpoweringly good. While I was sad to see the Warning road branch close, the East Ridge road branch is still serving up an amazing pizza. I can easily say that Amico's is my favorite pizza in Rochester. Since we moved out of Irondequoit, the nationals and other local shops are more convienant, but they can't match the crust, or the flavor. I can only hope they keep going strong for generations to come. DonS read more

Had Amico's pizza at the Hampton Inn at a function they were sponsoring. Traveling from Ohio,I must say some of the best pizza I have had. When I return to Rochester area and want pizza I know where to go! read more

Dave has been cooking some of the best pizza in Rochester for decades. Great wing sauces, great pies, and great value.