The food is really good. This place is in a hotel so of course it's going to be expensive. The actual bar is very choppy and uncomfortable to sit at. It's a weird space and the taps are in your face at most of the openings. It would've been a better experience if they had a better bar layout and comfortable stools with backs. The bartender Debbie was awesome! read more

A quaint Irish place that has surprising good food. We had the burger, honey sprouts and vege flatbread and all were great! My wife who generally would not be caught dead wanting to eat an Irish place wanted to come back the same day. Really nice :-) read more

Tobar is a really cool place for food and drinks. Very typical of a True Irish Pub. The decor was absolutely phenomenal. Low lighting and very spacious. Definitely a place to try if you are in the Maitland or Altamonte area of Orlando. We didn't order from menu but sure to try it next time around. read more

See all

If you're staying at the Sheraton, spend money on Uber and go somewhere else. This Irish Pub is understaffed and the kitchen is producing mediocre, processed food. If you do drink/dine there, make sure to ask for your check when you order, otherwise you are not going to get it. read more

I asked for a black and tan and they didn't have a lager on tap for such. The bartender suggested another lager (not sam adams)... Magners.... yep not a lager. The one redeeming quality that they did have Fullers! Very few bars have Fullers over here... Atmosphere is nice food is overpriced. I read that in other reviews so it didn't surprise me when i got there, but i didn't buy anything either. I heard it is more upscale now then it used to be... I would love to see this place before it reopened and if it was its own separate bar not attached to a hotel i would say this place might be a good place for regulars. At least there is St. Andrews read more

Food is fresh and the theming is cool. This was not bad for a hotel restaurant, I expected far less. The shepard's pie seems to be the specialty and it's fairly good. This was a nice surprise. read more

An Tobar has a new cook. They updated the menu, which no longer serves mushy peas, and it has become some forgettable Irish pub that is even more difficult to reach due to the new parking conditions. read more

I had high hopes as I love Irish fare and it's right by my house but so disappointing. Why have an Irish pub where the Irish food is an afterthought with only 4 dishes on the menu and the rest standard sports bar food. I went with fish and chips and was still disappointed, fries were a bit mushy along with the fish, it was all most likely frozen prepackaged food. Service was not good either, no hostess to seat people even though it is set up with a hostess station and a million people were all complaining about their checks being wrong. I will not return. read more

An Tobar Irish Pub - Yuck bland boring not crispy fish and chips served in this ridiculous basket which should be holding my bath soaps. - Irish Near Me - Maitland, Florida

Tonight was my 2nd time coming here with my bro and our families. He stays at this hotel when he's in town. An Tobar is not a bad place. We always have a good time when we come here. The food does take a while to arrive to the table but better than having something that doesn't taste as good come quicker. Don't come here for a "quick bite" or if you're in a rush. Ambiance is very nice - dim lighting and very cool looking bar. My bro said the wood from the bar was from an actual Irish Pub in Ireland that closed down so that's pretty cool. The lighting was a little too dim for my folks to see the menu but I thought lighting was ok. Food - I had the standard fish n chips with a Guinness. Fish and Chips was pretty good. I thought it was a little better last time I was there but maybe not. The fries were good too - very interesting looking like fan-shape or something. Good stuff. My daughter had spaghetti which I was able to sample and was pretty impressed. So anyways, yea, it's a pretty good place. Service was good. Food was good. If you can't see well it may be too dim for you. If you're in a rush you shouldn't come here. If you wanna just relax and have a few cold ones with friends and family this is a good place to go. I mean, if Mark Paul likes it who wouldn't? read more

Nice, quite place for dinner. The place is cozy and you can have a conversation with your guests or friends. Food is pretty much Irish, but they do also have other dishes, like pasta al ragu'. Wine selection is ok; beers on the other hand: more selections. read more

See all

I revisited and they are pouring the Guinness better now. Service in the bar area is friendly but not always quick. Tables in that area are "managed" by bartenders who can get quite busy leaving the 4 or 5 kilted waitresses with little to do. I have not had the food yet, so this is still an incomplete review. The people at the next table were raving about the corned beef saying they wanted to take a sample to another bar they frequented to show them how it is supposed to be done. read more

Good food, great atmosphere, great service, only 4 stars because food is priced higher than necessary but pricing on the beer and wine is reasonable. They have one bar tender who is amazing. We had a chicken wrap - split between 2 people. They served it on 2 plates with a helping of fries on each plate and no split charge. It was very good but at $12 for the wrap, it needed to be very good. read more

Best Irish pub around - and authentic! Great Irish menu, atmosphere is comfy all the way. Drove down from Atlanta to stay at Sheraton for work for a week. I was here everyday. Daily soups are great, and chef was very flexible and willing to make/adjust/try anything to make it happen. Whiskey selection is ok, not extensive but you can find everything from Wild Turkey 101 to Russels Reserve 10 year. Staff and service are excellent. If I lived nearby, this would be my bar. read more

About a dozen of us cascaded into An Tobar and were happily greeted. We had drinks, apps. and dinner. Everything was wonderful. Service was great too. Now the dessert... I don't recall what it was called, but there was a chocolate chip cookie shaped like a small pie with hot melted chocolate inside along with vanilla ice cream. It was the best dessert I have ever had, bar none! I would go back just for the dessert! read more

GREAT service from Jason, who is just an awesome guy. Had the Shepard's pie, and while it isn't traditional (beef was used, not lamb, which is traditional...I mean, a shepard takes care of sheep, not cows!) But it was very hearty and very tasty. Perfect ratio of meat, veggie, potato, sauce and cheese. A properly poured Guinness from the actual Irish bartender sealed the deal. But then there was Guinness ice cream! Get it, it is so good! read more

Great food went there for St. Patrick's Day and I had a real blast live music was really good service was fast and regardless that it was packed and the food was cooked really well I will be coming back again for drinks. read more

Went here for dinner with my girlfriend tonight. I ordered the Shepherd's pie for $ 17.00. They brought it out in a salad bowl. It consisted of about 1/4 pound of hamburger and an ice cream scoop of sweet mashed potatoes; no sides or bread were included. I feel very ripped off. A customer at a table about 10 feet away was yelling the F word about every 30 seconds. I asked the waitress if any of the staff was going to say anything; she said "this is a bar, people get drunk". read more

This is attached to the Sheraton in Maitland Service was slow getting started but now is moving along ok. read more

Beautiful restaurant with tiny portions. The upside is that it's in the Sheraton and can bill to room for SPG. Dinner was great, but it was a kid's portion. read more

Very average bar. It's supposed to be an Irish bar but it doesn't feel like it. Went there for a networking mixer. I didn't realize it was Irish until I took a hard look at there bar area when someone ordered a whiskey. Nothing horrible happened but nothing great either. It's a very forgettable place. There are so many better Irish bars in close proximity. Unless I was stranded at the attached hotel, I'd never come here again LOL. read more

Ordered a burger. Took 30 minutes to come out. Sat under the heat lamp most of the time. Until the bartender had time to go grab my burger. Our drinks were warm. They hard to remake two drinks because there was mold in one and a bug in a other. read more

I had visited here in the old days before they shut it down and really liked it. I like the new reopened version as well. A fun place to come and have a drink and maybe a bite to eat. The atmosphere is relaxed and cozy. read more

Don't drink the tap water, everything else here is fine. Burger was pretty decent, bacon was delicious. But don't drink the water

Visited tonight March 15th. After paying $10 to get in the door, we took a table and could not get service. 20 mins to get someone to get our order. All the time the same manager walked by our 2 tables / 11 people numerous times without ever stopping or making eye contact. Obviously oblivious to anything going on in the room. Upon receiving my first drink, I immediately ordered a 2nd. knowing full well it would take some time. When time came for that 2nd black and tan, I had to go searching for the server. This is when it really occurred to me how bad this place was being managed. The server was assigned one side of the bar, not a small bar, and tables at the other side, our tables. No wonder she was having difficulties. Around this time we decided to go somewhere else. But wait, 1 hour of torturous service by design of oblivious management, and we still had to pay $10 to get in. I decided to bring up my frustrations to the manager that continuously walked by us when we were not getting served. He offered a round on him. Really? Did he think we wanted to spend anymore time in this place. When he realized this ridiculous offer offended me, he walked away. Isn't a managers job to resolve issues? This man walked away. He did come back to point out to me he didn't have to put up with an upset customer. Avoid this place until they can assure the public they have brought on a staff of managers that know what they are doing. read more

Had some $4 happy hour specials. The mini shepherds pies were yummy. The wings are so so good. The mini pretzels with cheese was really fresh and delicious. The chicken fingers with spicy bbq sauce were NASTY! Cute place. Nice experience. Good prices. Good beer. read more

Just not good. Weird menu. Had fish and chips. Tacos. A really wide range of food from different cultures. Seem confused on what kind of restaurant they want to be. Service super slow and not great. I had to ask 6 times for condiments and finally got up and got them myself so I could eat my lower than average food. Bottom line go to another restaurant. read more

This is better than expected for hotel restaurant food. Came in here on a Saturday evening and it was very quiet. We were grateful for the quiet after a long day. Staff was attentive and the food came out very quickly. We had the edamame dumplings (yum!), the fish chowder (excellent), a house salad (fresh and good), shepherd's pie (very tasty comfort food), and fish & chips (passably tasty, a bit oily, mushy peas an odd novelty). Apple tart a la mode for dessert was short on apples and long on thick doughy pastry shell. Locally produced IPA on tap was awesome. Overall we enjoyed the meal - not award-winning but still enjoyable and hit the spot. Ambience is sports-bar meets theme park version of an Irish pub. Very comfy multilevel place with a few screens showing sports, the bar is very pretty and the booths are cozy. read more

This place is located in the Sheraton that I stayed in for two nights. I figured I'd give it a go since I had a buzz and needed some food within walking distance. The staff were nice and prompt. The bar is decently designed. The beer was cold and fresh. I ended up going with a bison burger that was pretty dang good, it was topped with fried onions and jalapeños. The reason I'm giving out four stars is because most of the items in the menu were reasonably priced so I thought the special would be as well. NOPE! I payed $22 for that burger! WTF? I guess I should have inquired on the price, but I couldn't imagine it being that much. Lesson relearned, never order a special form a restaurant until you know the price. I think special should have been written somewhere on a chalkboard with the price like most restaurants do. read more

Debbie was very sweet! Relaxed and fun atmosphere. Ample seating options. The decor is fun. I will definitely come here again!

Really excellent food and above average service. If they're busy, the service is a little slow. Their reuben is the best I have had. Great beer selection and really nice atmosphere. Speed up the service and you get 5 stars from me. read more

The food was very good and the service was acceptable ( I say acceptable because she was not as attentive as, say, me getting my dinner right after I am finished with my appetizer attentive). The atmosphere was very casual and easy going, enjoyable as hell :) read more

Its an Irish Pub! Want to have a drink and some chow and a good time with good people, you found the place!

Decent menu and the food is pretty good (for a hotel bar), but service is exceptionally slow and the ambiance is dark (befitting a traditional pub perhaps, but it would be nice to let in more of the Florida sunshine!). The bar has dividers along it between every ~6 seats, which makes it much less social and more difficult for groups. read more