Love it here! The Cuban sandwich and Baja bowls are amazing and my husband loves the rotisserie chicken wrap! Our waitress Hilary was awesome! She provide amazing service and was so personable. Would definitely recommend this place! read more

Great new industrial look to an old outdated but loved tavern. The staff is very attentive and accommodating. Love the menu and all the options you can add to dishes. Still has lots of TV's for the sports fans..and last but definitely not least our food was delicious! The 1/4 chicken, dark meat with the $5 add on fried shrimp, coleslaw, Mac n cheese with cornbread was on the money! Rotisserie chicken is seasoned to perfection. The chicken quesadilla also was a great dish at a very reasonable price. First impressions..5 stars!! read more

I'm only giving Anchor three stars because we only stopped in for a quick casual lunch and from what we experienced cannot wait to return. Luncheon sandwiches were excellent. My chicken salad was perfect as was my wife's soft shell crab. Our server, Aly, was friendly, efficient, and knowledgeable. I have a feeling that this beautiful restaurant will do an outstanding job for dinner. read more

Incredible!! We were quickly seated and promptly greeted by our waitress, Leslie. She was so sweet and attentive. I got the Baja rice bowl with shrimp and it was so flavorful as well as a good portion. The restaurant is a bit loud, so not great for a quiet dinner if that's what you're looking for. Overall great experience and I will be returning!! read more

Service ass. Food ass. Drinks ass (even if you get a beer , how can someone screw up a beer). I rather starve then come here again. Go anywhere else. read more

Stopped here on a recommendation from a local after a day at the beach. Much nicer than we expected. Cool, comfortable seating, lots of big tvs, smelled good inside. We got the cod fish sandwich & side of mac & cheese, side salad & iced teas. Everything was delicious. Our waitress was very sweet & great service! Only negative was guy at bar was very loud but have to expect that when you are sitting close to bar. Our bill only came to $24!! It was part of their Happy Hour menu. Definitely coming back read more

Our first time here & we opted to sit outside on patio cause it was such a beautiful day. Service was great. Ordered the roasted beet & goat cheese salad with shrimp and a cheeseburger. The salad was pretty good but the dressing was very light, came with 5 grilled shrimp. Goat cheese was toasted & delicious. The cheeseburger was also delicious. A few tables around us had order the fried pickles which looked amazing, will definitely be trying those next time! read more

I've been to anchor twice now & both times I was disappointed. The first time the service was so slow. Food was ok at best. I gave them the benefit of the doubt and came back to try it again, mistake on my part. The chicken was so dry. In no time, I got terrible food poisoning. I ordered a French onion soup and a chicken dish. This is my first ever review that's not positive. My experience: Everything overall, the service, the pace, the food, the experience was horrific. Good location though! read more

Rob made me the most amazing green tea shots they had the perfect balance of Jameson and peach schnapps

I was there last weekend with a bunch of friends and I can't say enough about the place. From service to food and drinks everything was amazing. read more

Yum! First time there and was impressed enough to want to go back. Had the coconut shrimp appetizer, which was tasty. I got the open faced sloppy joe beef brisket sandwich special...the brisket was cooked well and tasted "weller". My kid had the black bean burger and enjoyed it. Only complaint was the portion of delicious fries was a tad short. Sara, our server, was prompt and friendly. We took home wings for my wing nut. Total was $51 with just seltzers. Go before the bennies come down! read more

I absolutely love everything about The Anchor Tavern. I'm originally from The Jersey Shore, but now live in far upstate NY. I first dined here in June with my sister. The chicken was to die for and I remember having several sides, but the Mac & Cheese really was classic comfort food. So, of course I'm down for Christmas & I told my sister we had to go again. She agreed and the two of us along with another sister went in for a late lunch. Again, it just blew me away. Best comfort food ever. I had the chicken wrap. Jennifer had the Cuban & Kathy had The Pork Roll, Egg & cheese burger. We all had a bit of all the combined entrees. We went during happy hour and had onion rings with a horseradish sauce for $5.00! Look the atmosphere is great. Our server Leslie was super attentive and so likable. I even bought a zip up hoodie-Love it! Whenever, I'm at the shore you'll find me at Anchor Tavern. Just go! read more

Anchor Tavern - Bars Near Me - Belmar, New Jersey

Food was good and service was good. Went during covid-19. Doors were open and followed protocols. A good place to get good drinks and food. I didn't get entrees only apps so that is why I am giving 4 stars instead of 5. Drinks and apps were a 4 star. read more

We had an amazing experience here... 5 girls went in and had the best server (Katie) who made us feel so welcome and gave us so much good recommendations. The food was DELICIOUS and the drinks were even better! Fast service and seriously most the welcoming people! read more

The decor and feel of the place is awesome! We enjoyed the food, particularly the quesadillas and sliders. Unfortunately, the band's music was obnoxiously loud! We sat in the furthest booth and still could not hear each other. I wish that they had the bands play a tad softer. read more

Amazing. Everything from the chicken to the side. Ribs are fall off the bone. Definitely one of the best restaurants in Belmar. I will be a regular customer here. I recommend this 100% a must try read more

I cannot say enough good things about Anchor Tavern. There was a wait so I grabbed a drink from the bar. Deb made an amazing spicy margarita and was so personable. It was genuinely to die for. I was quickly called for my table where Jenny was my server. We started off with the crab and spinach dip (amazing). I had the rotisserie quarter white chicken with mac and cheese and peppered bacon brussel sprouts. They were divine. As was my service. 10/10 read more

We were sitting at a table directly in front of the bar, watching a Mets game, when without seeing if anyone else was watching, the Bartender changed the game because a new Customer asked for it. Less than 5 minutes after telling a different Customer she couldn't change it because people may already be watching. read more

I have the Asian salad with calamari and Dan the bartender made the best mojito I've had since I was in Puerto Rico!

I have been to this restaurant on numerous occasions. I've always had good meals. I really like that the sandwiches come with a choice of fries or a side salad. I love the chicken burger. I also like getting the quarter chicken white meat with two sides. I haven't had any of their appetizers and I'm not a huge fan of their desserts. My overall favorite, though, is their baja rice bowl with chicken that they sometimes have on the special menu. I enjoy sitting outside when the weather is nice, though sometimes the traffic is noisy. I go there on weeknights, so it isn't too noisy. read more

I recently visited Belmar Beach, NJ on a day trip with my wife. After leaving the beach we decided to eat at Anchor Tavern. I was very impressed with the location, availability of parking, service, and the food! We started with the fried pickles and my wife ordered a chicken salad sandwhich; I have the Anchor BLT. We also had an Asbury Park IPA. Everything tasted great and we received top notch service from Samantha our server. Just before leaving we both went to the restrooms and the whole place is super clean. Highly recommended spot! read more

This place was recommend by a local, and it was a good spot for dinner. My fiance and I got there and were seated quickly outside. It was a nice evening, so it was really nice to chill out there for dinner. It definitely has that shore vibe to it's atmosphere. The beer list was a decent array of craft and national sections. I also am happy they have PBR in cans, but wish they were pounders. Our waitress was very nice and attentive toward us. The food was your basic bar fare, but was very good. I decided to get a pork roll sandwich since I am in northern part of Jersey. It was a very good sandwich with a good amount of cheese on it. This is a good spot for some good food and beer. read more

I'm a Belmar local and I have to say the Anchor has the best hummus in town. Great outside bar and seating and the bartender Dominic is a great guy and is a pleasure to speak with. My family had a great time and I would encourage everyone to stop in and say Hi ! read more

Updating my review came back for dinner our server Nicole was was very pleasant and attentive food was very good also.

Marginal food/menu. This is probably a great Summer night spot. Had the salmon. Overcooked. Sweet potatoes premixed. Burgers looked good. It is what it is....blah. read more

Love the Happy Hour... good selection of $5 apps and they usually have specials. Had blackened Salmon bites... delish! My husband and I both love the chicken wings, chicken tostadas and the list goes one. Good music for Friday HH, Jamie Brown. A weekly Happy Hour for us! read more

In the past, I would have given them a 4. We have been going here for NFL games and lunch/dinner for years (since they opened!). But within the past year, Anchor has unfortunately gone downhill. Our past few experiences have been quite poor. One night it took over an hour to get our food from the time we ordered (a medium burger and the quarter chicken dark meal). The issue seems to be with the kitchen. Since then, the kitchen frequently gives us incorrect orders. Last night, they delivered my husband's wrap with chipotle mayo when he asked for none (gallbladder issue) though the waitress had written it down when she took our order. His new wrap was made correctly but on one of the last bites the chicken was sour/rancid. He stopped eating immediately and didn't touch his fries after that. We alerted them and they did remove it from the bill, we paid and left. Luckily he hasn't gotten ill. But we won't be going back. We'll have to find a new place for NFL games, probably Bar A down the street. read more

Food was ok overall, except chicken was undercooked and we had to send it back. They told us it was the injection of spices that made it look pink. Whatever. This place bills itself as a rotisserie place, but the salmon and chicken both needed more time on the spit to get crispier. Sides and burger were good. Service wasn't so hot. It took a long time to get food. Although we ordered a burger, no one brought ketchup. We asked twice, then I got it myself. They had a "free spin" offer on Yelp but when I tried to redeem it, they said they can't find the wheel anymore. You'd think with our undercooked dinner, they might have found a way to fulfill on a deal they advertised, but no. As I am writing this, the waitress stopped by to let us know the replacement chicken, which we are taking to go because everyone is done eating, would be on the house. Good move on their part. This place has potential, but they need to work on the experience. read more

Great rehab of an old bar. They are concentrating on their rotisserie chicken, which is absolutely delicious. I believe they use cumin which is not gonna be for everyone. I ate there twice and both times the chicken was perfectly cooked. Now for the negatives which was pretty much everything. Of the 4 sides I've had none were worth retrying. I can't believe the gravy has been tested by anyone. It's watery and tasteless. I hope I can change my rating and they fix things read more

Ive been there once before but for a short time. Yesterday we went for Happy Hr and sat outside with Erin as our bartender. She was so good at her job she made us feel right at home. Unfortunately it was a little cold so we ended up inside with Mailynn, another great bartender. The drinks were great & the apptzs were $5.00. Cant go wrong here. We will definitely be back. One suggestion: you need better music inside and outside. Thats the only thing missing during Happy Hr. and it really makes a difference to people out for the day looking for a fun place to hang out. read more

Big disappointment. Exactly whats expected from a large company owned venue. Chicken undercooked and cold, stuffing tasteless. Burger cold and small, taste was unremarkable. Server was pleasant but clearly had too many tables to be aware of the many missing items that were ordered. Host staff clueless and flippant. Take your business elsewhere, there are plenty of better places that know how to serve good food pleasantly. read more

My fries were pretty good! But honestly, my burger wasn't very good. I'm not gonna say it was terrible, but I wasn't very content with my meal. Not to mention that my burger took a very long time to come out. If you really need to eat in this specific area, then this place is decent. But honestly, not that this place is awful, but I think skipping this place would be a wise choice. read more

Great place to relax and eat. The staff was super friendly and the food was good. Happy hour on Saturday's is a plus!!! Perfect location!

Sunday night dinner, great bar food, reasonable priced. Soft shell crab sandwich 4*, Cuban sandwich 4.5* (big sandwich enough to share for 2), make ur own burger blu cheese, caramelized onions & mushrooms cooked perfect medium 5* OUTRAGEOUS.... substituted cream of spinach for my fried for $1 up charge (well worth it), ps: ordered steamers for app 2* just not worth $12 for 12 steamers that were mediocre. All in all fun place, great atmosphere n service. 4* overall! Sunday night 7:30pm not crowded at all! LOTS OF BEER TO CHOOSE FROM read more

Great food here too. My wife and I went out here Friday and Saturday night. We are locals and we love this place

they did a great job renovating this place. really excited to see what the outdoor area is like when its finished, i think it will be a hit. menu looks delicious, like everyone has said rotisserie chicken is their thing. only thing i had were the wings. they only offer one flavor of wings. high grade, meaty wing cooked well, but had 0 flavor, disappointing. needless to say, thats only one item on the menu, ill definitely be back to try the rest. read more

Last night we came in with a bunch of people for a 30th birthday surprise and had an amazing time! The manager, Brandon, was so accommodating and the back bartenders were absolutely great! We love Anchor Tavern and will most definitely be back. Top notch service and excellent food and atmosphere! read more

Slooooooooooooow service! Waited 30mins before the bartender came to take my order. Good food. Clean place. Great location. Just slow...really really slow. read more

During my last visit the waitress brought over a draft beer with a dead fly floating in it...I don't think I need to say anymore. Went here over the summer and it was great. Went back 2 or 3 times since the summer and it's gotten worse each time. Shame read more

My burger was actually cooked to a perfect medium, and the service was excellent. I saw about 700 appetizers I wanted to try so I'll be back, especially considering the prices are reasonable. Overall, this is a welcome addition to Belmar! read more