Was in the City for a quick day trip and you know we had to have a slice of NY pizza!! I had also been warned about the $1 slice locations, so we were looking around for the right place. Lucky for us this place on the way home from dinner so we had to get a night cap before heading back to the hotel. When we walked in the place wasn't too loud but full of people enjoying their pizza. Staff were helpful, nothing extraordinary nor noteworthy, but good. We decided to get a combo pizza slice (kid loves olives...lol) and a BBQ chicken slice. I was blown away by both slices, perfect crispy under carriage and gooey toppings. I was especially pleasantly surprised by the chicken slice as the chicken isn't your normal BBQ sauce but rather a buffalo chicken wing sauce which perfectly suited the pizza! Will be back whenever I come back to the City! read more

Andiamo Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ok. Wow. No idea what I'm missing here. My $6.50 pepperoni slice and my sausage and plain slice had about a 0 points of flavor. Zero flavor. $2.00 slices are by far better then these slices! Chicken wings. No flavor at all. Would never patronize this place ever. Way too many options in NYC far better. read more

And I'm back - Yelp says it's been over two years and that's too long. Andiamo is still on point. Great neighborhood pizza restaurant with a great selection of all your favorites and then some. The service fast, friendly and enthusiastic. This is my go to spot when I'm in NY. read more

Was looking for a good, quick slice. I wandered into Andiamo. First off, service was great. The guys were so friendly. Greeted me. They were nice to all the customers in there. Made it feel like they appreciated your business. They had alot of options available for slices, but the margherita one caught my eye. They popped it in the oven for a few minutes. It came out piping hot and just pefect. It's a typical small pizza shop that sells slices, but has a ton of options and friendly staff. The inside has a few tables. An easy 5 star for me because the guys were so friendly. The pizza was great too! read more

Andiamo Pizza - Margherita Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I found this on Yelp when I got to my hotel but the wife wanted something else for dinner so I planned my lunch for the next day here. Am I glad that I did. NYC obviously has a million choices for food but I wanted a pizza by the slice as I have not always had the best of luck with pizza on previous trips. When you walk in to the small store with a few tables and a counter you are immediately greeted by the friendly guys behind the counter who seem excited to help you. Great service! I ordered three slices which for someone not from NYC meant about a whole medium pizza back home. I am not complaining. All three slices, sausage/pepperoni, meat lovers, and a Hawaiian were delicious! I ate every single bite! My favorite? That's tough. It is between the Hawaiian and the meat lovers but if I could only order one more slice, meat lovers! Bacon, pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham, what else? I know there are plenty of places to choose from but you won't regret a stop in here! read more

Andiamo Pizza - Hawaiian slice, Meat Lovers Pizza Slice, sausage & pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great service, great pizza. Nice little shop with seating and plenty of drinks to choose from. Be smart if you go here. Know what you want and choose either the finished slices or ordering a whole pie. Don't hold them up or anybody else. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Slices, only way to go.. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Extremely dirty walked in and saw two cockroaches on the floor when I told the employee they laughed and didn't care about it

I stopped in here on a whim, as it was the closest (open) pizza place to the bar I was leaving, and I would have been happy with anything hot and greasy, but was pleasantly surprised to have what is now my favorite slice I've had in NYC. I got the plain cheese slice and a vodka slice. I ate the cheese slice piping hot while walking to the subway, and it was very good. Flavorful through all layers -- crust, sauce, cheese. Greasy but not too greasy, crispy crust. 10/10! I had the vodka slice after getting back to my hotel, and it was ice cold (through no fault of the restaurant, let me be clear). I could have microwaved it, but was feeling lazy. It didn't matter, because even cold and congealed, it was great. Again -- crust, sauce, and toppings were all flavorful. Delicious vodka sauce. Crispy crust. 11/10! I can only imagine how good it would have been if I ate it hot when they handed it to me! If plain cheese is this good, and a cold slice is this good, I'd imagine a non-cheese slice, hot, would be otherworldly. I don't generally care all that much one way or another about the service nor the interior of a grab and go pizza place, but I will say, the people working here were very friendly, even late at night. And the interior is relatively spacious, with several tables to sit at. read more

Andiamo Pizza - NY Style Cheese Pizza Slice, Vodka Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Best slice of pizza you can get after midnight and up until 5am, can't wait to go back to NY and have another slice read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Pie Pepperoni black olive - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I recently ordered from this pizza place after seeing so many positive reviews, and it really lived up to the expectations. The crust was just right--crispy on the outside, soft on the inside--no sogginess at all. The sauce was well-balanced, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Everything came together in a really satisfying way. I'll definitely be ordering again and would recommend it to anyone looking for a solid, well-made pizza. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place lives up to its reputation. One of the best pizzas I have ever had! Great taste and friendly service. A must-visit.

It's good. It's not 5-stars, but it's not 3-stars (OK), so 4 sounds about right. This place has really good reviews so I made the walk over to check them out. A small place, well lit, only a few tables inside, on the corner too. Overall I was pretty pleased, but not overly impressed or excited. The service here was good, they were talkative and friendly. I would definitely go back here. read more

My review is skewed as I haven't been to NY in a few years but when you have a craving this place answered. Two slices of heaven thank you read more

Andiamo Pizza - Slice of pep and meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Great places opens late night. They have a great offer two cheese slices and a 20 ounce of soda for 799 check it out. Their colognes are also very thick and juicy. Pizza is good. Calzone is ok, at best. Needs more sauce read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

we got pepperoni, meat lovers, and buffalo -- buffalo was the most memorable tasted like hot cheetos jalapeño chicken. i liked how it was thin and quick service, especially open on memorial day after the knicks nba game read more

Andiamo Pizza - tres - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

100% quality New York pizza. They have a full menu of other stuff but I was here for the slices. I was not disappointed! The thin New York slices and the thick squares are both excellent! They also have a ton of flavors. I only scratched the surface and intend to explore more. read more

Andiamo Pizza - An absolute unit of a slice. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Look, just go here. This is a classic "order a slice" spot. They are friendly and professional and the pie is delicious. I had a Margherita and a pepperoni and sausage slice both were delicious. Would definitely come back 10/10 read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pick a slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The place is in a perfect location. It's like their pizza is just made with zero love. Just greasy thrown together pizza for profit. It's like they didn't see that floppy pile of mess they served me. I just wish it was better. read more

Quick, easy, and just what I needed late at night! Had a chicken parm slice and green peppers + pepperoni slice. The slices were warmed up nicely. Only a couple tables, but the place is clean and comfortable for grab-and go pizzas. read more

Not as good as the photos or reviews suggest IMO; the pizza was surprisingly bland from dough to sauce, lacking flavor and crispness, and even the folks behind the counter seemed disengaged, chatting among themselves while taking orders. Plus side is there's ample seating. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

My fiancé and I order a pizza last night through DoorDash to be delivered to our hotel. I left a review and picture of our pizza and no one reached out. In the picture I am attaching was how our pizza was delivered. It was raining last night and it looks like part of it may have fell in a puddle and got the box wet. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Dropped pizza and corner was wet with water - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is still so lively even after 1:30 a.m. I picked up two slices - huge, with a thin and crispy crust, absolutely delicious and steamy hot right out of the oven. The guys working at the counter and in the kitchen are incredibly kind and warm, you can really feel the great vibe read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I was extremely disappointed with my experience at this establishment. The staff, particularly the male employees, were not only rude but also condescending. As I was taking a moment to ask my 4-year-old what she would like to order and figure out my own choice, one of them made an inappropriate remark suggesting I should have more children--an unprofessional and completely unnecessary comment that left me uneasy. Beyond the poor service, the food itself was underwhelming. At $6 per slice, I expected far better quality, but what I received was mediocre at best. With so many outstanding pizza spots in the area, there's no reason to waste time or money here. I won't be returning, and I wouldn't recommend it to others. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Quick, cheap and delicious! Good pizza doesn't always mean there has to be a line around the corner. This pie shop has a variety of options that you can order by the slice so that you can try more than 1. The thin NY style slices were large and scrumptious , but the thicker rectangular slices were not a hit. The thicker ones were pretty dry and had the consistency of styrofoam, so I wouldn't recommend those. There was plenty of foot traffic while we were there of people grabbing slices to go, so pizza stays coming out fresh. read more

See all

Super quick delivery! And so tasty! We were in the mood for hot sandwiches and added the slices of pizza. Everything was so good and the pizza slices were perfectly crispy. Yum! read more

See all

Good, not great. Not much else to say. Good spot to check out if you're nearby but wouldn't go out of my way to get it. That's all.

Sicilian Pepperoni 5/10 Regular thin sliced pizza 6/10, Crust is chefs kiss, sauce is mid, cheese is ok but needs more pull. Service is fast and straight to the point. Place is clean and organized. read more

Ordered pizza after our flight got delayed and didn't land until 1am. We were starving and thankfully they still delivered! We had traditional cheese and pepperoni. Delicious. read more

Food- 1 slice was a 4 star and other 2 were about a 3 star. Solid pizza but nothing crazy. Service- friendly and no complaints. Ambiance- a few seats for late night eats. I came at 3AM after landing at the airport. I was very hungry and the pizza did the job. read more

I love that at 3 AM. I can order a beautiful upside down Sicilian pizza for less than $30 delivered-and it was wonderful. The sauce was on-point. pizza was light yet crispy -just great. That is why New York City is the best city in the world. It came in like 20 minutes beautifully. Very happy with Andiamo. read more

The team here was very polite. Pie was awesome. Had the meat lovers, did not dissappoint. Crust was thin and light and crispy. The flavors of the different meats complimented each other well. Highly recommend this place. . read more

Andiamo Pizza - Meet Meat Lovers Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Super friendly service and easy to order. Plenty of seating and good choices for soft drinks. The pizza was very good. Fast and hot! read more

Andiamo Pizza - Meat Lovers Slice Pizza and New York Style Cheese Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing slices! Very pleased we stopped here. Located super close to our hotel but I would travel here for slices. The crew was welcoming. Place was clean. Prices were great. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The lasagna and vodka slices were insane (in a good way) and this is coming from someone who doesn't care for pizza. Also they were playing fire music. My only critique is that I'd recommend carrying other "zero" drinks besides the Snapple and Coke. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Sausage pizza is the closest slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This restaurant was right around the corner from hotel - super convenient and the staff was friendly. We ate here twice on our visit to NYC The first time we had the Sicilian upside down and it was delicious. The second time we pointed to a pizza that had chicken and red onions and asked what kind it was. They told us BBQ chicken so that what we ordered. When we got back to the hotel, we looked at the pizza and it didn't look like the one we pointed to. While it was good, it wasn't what we were wanting to order. Still a good pizza though. read more

Andiamo Pizza - Upside Upside-Down Sicilian 18" Pizzadown - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We were looking for some good New York pizza when visiting the City and stopped into Andiamo's based on prior reviews. We're glad we did. Here is what we found: - We were so hungry for good pizza that we ordered a full pie (for my wife and I). We ate half of it in the shop and took the rest back to our Airbnb for later (which was excellent microwaved the next day). - The Margarita pizza was really great! - The shop is a little small and was a bit crowded the evening we came in (probably made more so due to the rain), but we found a place to sit and the tables turned over quickly. - We liked that the guy who took our order remembered us, and brought the pizza and plates directly to us at our table. Bottom line: Andiamo's did not disappoint! read more

Andiamo Pizza - Margherita 18" Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Came on our first night in NYC we were hungry lol . It hit the spot ! The pineapple and ham was my favorite !!!! Good cheap quick eat if you're in the neighborhood for sure . Quick service read more

I asked if the offered vegan cheese even if to make and said no. So whatever advertisement they had for vegan or non dairy cheese is incorrect read more

In our recent trip to NYC, Andiamo Pizza was near our hotel and was among the top rated Pizza spots. My husband and I ate there twice while in the city. Pizza was good and comparable to most good pizza spots in NYC! The customer service was nice, there is limited seating to dine in and the line can get long quickly. The place is not a fine dining location, however it is a good spot for quick good pizza. read more

Great selection of pizzas, super quick service. The shop is bright, clean, and casual. Very good for a slice.