The pizza here was so delicious! It was so fresh and had a thin crisp to it and the slices are big. The dough is really good because I even want to eat the crust. The tomato sauce on the sausage and onion pizza was amazing. The lime ice taste so fresh and has a punch of sour and tartiness. The service is pretty quick! But the shop is very small so very much a to-go place or eat outside. That have small tables lining the windows so you could eat there if you get lucky! Would 100% recommend!! read more

See all

Lemon Italian ice was good Pepperoni slice, grandma's slice were fine Garlic knots were so good-- I could have skipped my slice and eaten like ten of those. Didn't need the sauce they came with. For us, it was a step above the basic walk-up pizza joints in the blocks around the Times Square area. Service here was nicer than in those $1.50 slice joints too Seating is limited to a few counter stools. read more

I am in NYC 3-4 times a year and whenever I find myself in this section of midtown, it's always a stop at Vito's for me. Your typical New York pizza joint-perfectly thin crust with a nice crunch. Tomato sauce goodness. Fresh ingredients! No waxy-tasting cheese at this pie place. Super affordable. Service is typical NYC---(A+) #iykyk Grab a slice to munch on while strolling the area. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My wife and I recently cruised to Bermuda out of the Manhattan Cruise Terminal. Since the trip from San Diego takes all day, and because I'm anti-redeye, we arrived in town at about 7pm the night before our ship sailed and took advantage of a decent rate at a hotel in Midtown West. Once we'd checked in, we decided to grab a light dinner - specifically, pizza - somewhere close by. Of course, we could have Uber'd to one of the trendy pizza spots in town, or to one of the iconic, long-established places, but I know from experience that no matter where you buy your slice - no matter how much you pay for it or how long you stand, lined up, waiting to order - two things are true: first, the pizza you end up with might not be as great as it was the day before; and second, when you've had about three bites, what you're eating is seldom special... it might taste good, but it's just pizza. NB If you disagree, you can fight me here, or spend your time and money to find out that I'm right. Let me know. So, since we were unwilling to make a pilgrimage and a sacrifice for what is, essentially, a tomato and cheese sandwich with maybe some protein added, we walked instead to Vito's Slices and Ices, a few blocks from our hotel. I'd found the place on TripAdvisor, the most reliable site I know for crowdsourced, food-related information and opinion. The pictured slices looked right, and the addition of house-made Italian ice to the menu sealed the deal for me. Visiting Vito's, my friends, was the right decision, because the pizza was perfect. Their hand-stretched dough, made with Caputo flour and slightly fermented, was airy, moderately crisp, and had the complex flavor and characteristic chew of the best New York-style pizzas. Their fresh crushed tomato sauce balanced sweetness and acidity, and a bit of basil added a wonderful herbal aroma. And Vito's uses Grande-brand mozzarella, whose dairy-rich, buttery flavor and ideal melt make it the cheese of choice for New York's pizzerias. Grande is less commonly used outside the region, and it's all but impossible to source if you're a home pizzaiolo like me - though, happily, since last year, I've been able to buy it at La Mesa's MammaMia Deli Market. Vito's Italian ice was tasty, too, but I prefer Philadelphia's water ice for its smoother texture and more intense flavor. But man, that slice... Considering the high-quality ingredients and masterful execution used to make my pizza, Vito's could have - hell... SHOULD have - charged me two or three times the $5 and change I paid for my slice. But they delivered great value with genial, helpful service (thanks, Lucas) and, for kicks, this all happened in a corner shop with a warm, classically "neighborhood" feeling. So now I'm thinking that if I lived in Manhattan, I might check my "it's just pizza" comment and become a Vito's regular, spending Uber money and even waiting in line for a slice. I'd be happy to be wrong. read more

See all

I just had a slice of what is good about NYC, for under 6.00. The crust was perfectly cooked, slightly charred and crispy. The sauce was sweet and what you can only find in NYC. Fresh veggies and you got yourself a slice of heaven. It was so good, that I was here for three days and ate it for dinner all three days without shame! read more

Vito's Slices and Ices is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, everything just moves smoothly -- ordering is incredibly fast and efficient, even when there's a line. You're in and out in no time, which is perfect when you're craving a quick bite without sacrificing quality. The food itself is fantastic, especially for the price. The slices are generous, fresh, and packed with flavor -- easily some of the best value for money around. And the ices? The perfect refreshing treat to top it all off. What really makes Vito's stand out, though, is the staff. Everyone is welcoming, friendly, and genuinely seems happy to be there. They create such a positive, neighborhood vibe that keeps you coming back. If you're looking for great food, quick service, and a warm atmosphere, Vito's Slices and Ices delivers every time! read more

See all

This place is so good!! The perfect dinner that was close by and I loved it! The garlic knots are the best knots I've ever had! Customer service is great, the place is small but cozy! Definitely must check out! read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - White Slice Sausage & Onion Slice Three Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The good stuff! Thin, crisp crust topped with great sauce, the best mozarella cheese, the and best cup pepperoni. I think I detected a hint of pecorino romano cheese. Cooked to perfection. Fast, friendly service with food service piping hot. There is a small counter and some chairs. I think this is mostly a take-out and delivery spot. You'll smell the enticing quality just walking by. read more

See all

Ok so we were doing a NYC Pizza slice tour day and started with Vito's. I'm not sure if this was the best idea. Usually you want to save the best for last but after Vito's, we found ourselves comparing everything else to it and this spot might quite possibly be the best slice in the city. You MUST get their Margherita slice and Grandma style. Both are packed with flavor, slightly different in a good way and super super fresh. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Grandma & Margherita slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

What an old school pizza place ! I love pizza so I had to stop here and give it a try. They sell it by the slice as you see in the pictures. They have a nice assortment of different pizza already made, and you can order four pizzas as well. I opted for a slice of pepperoni and a slice of plain with extra cheese. I loved it so much. I had to order another slice with extra cheese and a Pepsi. The counter staff was very helpful and very friendly and welcoming and let me say this place gets jampacked and I only have a few seats at the window probably around 10 give or take and you're standing elbow to elbow so that speaks volumes about this pizza shop they're putting out some good slices The prices are really good. The pizza is off the wall highly recommend. The inside is nothing fancy like I said there's a couple two counters where the windows are so you can enjoy a couple slices of pizza while you stare out the window people watching . I look forward to stopping back here before leaving New York City. Thank you for some good slices of pizza. read more

See all

We arrived to our West side hotel very hungry from just flying in. Our hotel rep suggested a place in Times Square, but I knew better. We walked a few streets up and an avenue over and we were in HEAVEN! Vito's Slices and Ices did not disappoint. We had a regular slice of sausage and onion and a grandma slice. OMG, so good! And that's not just because we were hungry. The sauce on the Grandma was so zesty. The regular slice tasted just like a NY slice of pizza should taste - SO GOOD! I would have loved to have enjoyed one of those delicious looking garlic knots but we needed to save room for our next feeding a few hours later. It was too cold to order an ice, but we'll definitely come back to enjoy one of the fun flavors they offer. Lots of people dining in on this day and we squeezed ourselves into the counter seating. We are totally going back to Vito's and we are DEFINITELY recommending Vito's to friends! read more

See all

Both, the pizza and Italian ice, were delicious! They made a half pep, half sausage and onion for us. So good! The cashier, was very friendly and accommodating with the half and half request. Chill vibes, good music while we waiting for our fresh pie, big windows to people watch while you wait. Highly recommended!! read more

Really good gluten free pizza! Cozy mom and pop pizza spot. Would come again. The gluten free pizza is sicilian style so it's thick crust and spongy in a good way. Great service and limited booth seating. read more

See all

I was staying at a near by hotel and just needed a quick pizza slice to hold me up till dinner with friends. I was in a hurry as I needed to login to a meeting soon. I spotted this place at the corner of my hotel. It is a small place, no tables but you can eat at bar level on stools around the edge of the place. It was packed with many people picking orders to go. I picked the white slice with ricotta cheese and basil. It was a large slice with lots of flavors and packed with cheese. They were quick and ordering process plus paying was very convenient. read more

After a very disappointing NY pizza experience at L'industrie Pizzeria, my bar for NY pizza was set LOW. We had just finished The Edge Experience, and were now looking for a place to get a quick bite before an earlier dinner later that evening. I really wanted a redeeming NY slice to end our family trip to NYC on a high note. Initially, I had thought of Joe's, but I HATED the thought of dealing with the line of tourists and lack of seating. We ended up visiting Vito's Slices and Ices nearby Hudson Yards. This was possibly the best decision we made. There were lots of slice options, and I thought the menu was very reasonably priced. I shared the margherita and pepperoni slices with my boyfriend, and my parents shared the upside-side Sicilian slice and grandma's pie slice. The pizza here was a million times better than L'industrie! The tomato sauce, while a little messy, was fresh and sweet - just the way I like it on my pizza! The dough could have used a bit more integrity, but the crust was very memorable for me. Chewy with a nice crispy exterior. I would 1000% return to Vito's. This was one of the best things I had on our trip. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The pizza was ok. The place clean. And the service was not to fast :) .. but I like it

I stopped in this 20+ year old slice shop a while back for a slice. It was a bit warm inside, and it was pretty crowded. I went with a mushroom slice, which was a bit over $5, which sounds expensive, but as the mushrooms weren't the typical bad canned ones you find in most pizza spots, I didn't mind the stipend. It took a little while, and the slice was piping hot. There was a pretty good crisp to it, and there was a good amount of cheese. The sauce was excellent, with a touch of sweetness but not too much. I guess the only complaint I could make was that it was a tad greasy, but hey, not bad at all. Would recommend it when you're in the area, and I would go back for a grandma/margherita and to try their Italian Ices next time I am in the neighborhood. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Mushroom slice. A bit over $5. Very tasty - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Visited 3 years ago and still thinking about how good the slice and ices were. Cannot recommend enough!

Just wow. Came here to get a craving fixed and it did beyond that. Pepperoni hit the right spot. You must try the Grandma!! Service was great. Its a small spot has a few bar tops available read more

See all

I saw this spot near my hotel and decided to try it out. Plenty of options to choose from and staff were very friendly! I ordered one slice each of the Margherita and the grandma. The Margherita was good, but the grandma slice was excellent. It had the perfect amount of tomato sauce and a nice crust. Prices were reasonable. read more

I got this spot on Grubhub and it wasn't bad! Unfortunately, the app didn't update us on the delivery so it was left out for a while and got a bit cold. But, the portions were good, solid pizza, and good price! read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

We were hungry after flying all day then checking into our hotel. We didn't want to walk too far in the cold. This place had good pizza and about ten seats at bar tables looking through windows to the street. They had a huge variety of drinks and desserts. I love NYC. read more

I've tried a few pizza by the slice companies each time I come to NYC. This was a good one, it was better than one I tried the other night about 1/2 a block away. My son and I got 2 cheese, 1 pepperoni, and 1 margarita. I forgot to take pictures of the others but they were great size and great quality. Service was super quick and we took it to go. They actually have FCFS seating for about 10 people inside if you do want to go in and sit though. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Margherita Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Very solid slice for a decent price. Cost a bit more at 3.80 for a plain and 5.10 for a pepperoni but it's worth it. The crust is crisp and holds shape, and the flavor cheesy but not greasy and there were pepperoni evenly spaced throughout. There was a short wait but nothing unreasonable. Good slice to pick you up on the way to a show. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Serving up New York style foldable slices and Sicilian style slices, Vito's packs the house with its prime real estate near the Javits Center. This place is nonstop from making pizzas to heating slices, to taking orders, to clients piling in. And had it been warmer, I'm sure the ices would've been in demand making the line even longer. read more

See all

Great pizza by the slice and homemade ices, too! A bit of a wait, but it's worth it! A few seats inside but lots of folks take their slices to go. read more

Been coming and coming. Would have to say this would still be one of the better to best pizzerias. Oh, for sure recommend the pepperoni slice or the Sicilian pepperoni they got that curl pepperoni one of the best super tasty crispy crust thin crusted perfectly done. The place is not very large, a couple of seats around but more of a grab and go. NYC pizza shop. Service is always quite fast and oven is hot. I hope it never changes. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

After seeing the great Yelp reviews and the line inside, we knew this was the stop for our New York pizza. Service was friendly and the food came out pretty quick. Definitely something to be said about walking down the street with a hot slice of pepperoni pizza. Would recommend for anyone in the area. read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - Menu - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ayyyyy, vegan pizza! I think they could find a better vegan cheese but honestly I still loved the vegan pizza. It allowed me to experience NYC pizza and I understand the hype. My mom got a regular pizza and she thought it was really good. I appreciate y'all for having a yummy vegan pizza option. A million thanks as someone with a dairy allergy. But also, there's better vegan cheeses out there, might be worth experimenting. read more

Want a quick slice on the go in Hell's Kitchen. Vito's has a solid grandma and cheese slice. Fresh toppings and always an array of slices ready to be eaten. One of the better pizza joints in the area. Fast service and decent amount of seats for a quick bite. read more

See all

Vito's is IMHO the best slice shop near Penn Station. It is a tiny joint located on the corner of 36th and 9th Avenue, which sells both slices and entire pies. The crew at Vito's is efficient ut friendly, hustling to keep the piping hot slices moving. Their pies are very thin, even by NYC standards, and feature a delicious crust. The sauce is well balanced between bright tomatoes and hints of both basil and garlic without being overpowering. And the cheese is delicious with the right amount of "cheese pull." The small place has an old school but fun vibe, and is very reasonable, charging less than $4 for a high quality slice. read more

See all

Amazing slice. No beer sadly. Right around the corner from my hotel. Crust was excellent too. read more

Phenomenal pizza! We saw this pop up while searching for pizza nearby and had to go after seeing the positive reviews. The shop is small but it was PACKED for people waiting to get some slices, that's how we knew it was going to be good. There are a variety of slices to choose from, but we went with the margherita. It was crispy, full of delish tomato sauce, fresh tomato slices, basil and cheese. It was one of the best slices we've had in the city! We will definitely be back! read more

this has been my roommates and i's go-to pizza spot for the past 2 years. the slices are delicious, they smell incredible, and they are pretty cheap. love the grandma slice!!! staff is really nice too. read more

I liked Vito's. The rest of my crew, not so much. What I liked... Sicilian ice was great; light with a crunchy, flavorful. The regular cheese slice and pepperoni were good too, just not the classic "New York" style that my fam was looking for. Personally I like that Vito's is a little different. Service was quick, slices were reasonably priced imo, and i enjoyed the old pictures, old barstools, and the historic vibe. I do recommend if you're in the area and looking for a slice -- go with the grandma's Sicilian read more

I tried this place as it was close to my hotel and I really enjoyed the pizza. The location was nondescript and looked like many other NYC pizza shops. It seemed clean and well kept. The server was nice and pretty on par with servers at other restaurants. The pizza had great taste and a slight crunch which was quite nice. I knew the pizza had to be good when I saw police officers enter to order food. Definitely check this place out if you need a quick bite. read more

See all

Really great GF pizza. Super thick and filling. It was my first meal in NYC and very memorable.

My first NYC slice and wow, it did not disappoint. I forgot to take photos of my slices because I got too excited to eat it! We got the pepperoni Sicilian, white slice, and Italian sausage onion slice and a strawberry ice. There's nothing like enjoying a piece of pizza and dessert on a gloomy/rainy day. The service was wonderful and the ambiance itself made it a fast casual place to eat, the type where you just eat and enjoy pizza without talking so much. Overall, the pizza is a winner here and this place is highly underrated in my opinion! 5 stars! read more

Vito's Slices and Ices - White Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The hustle and bustle of nyc and Vito's slices and Ices on the corner of W36st & 9ave, small spot with a few tables and chairs to eat real quick or take out on the run. Found this spot relatively easy, lucky when we arrived, no one was online. We quickly order two cheese slices and two pepperoni slices. Service was ok, I wouldn't say friendly but not rude either, just typically New York service lol Pizza: Thin, crispy but the cheese slice was ok, average, had better cheese slices in Queens tbh. The cheese slice needed some more cheese and some flavor. Now the pepperoni slice was a hit!! Everything was on point with the pepperoni slice, good amount of cheese, sauce, flavorful. Wish I got two pepperoni slices for myself. I would come back here to try the Sicilian pepperoni pizza tho if I'm in the neighborhood. read more

See all

Ordered a round Pepperoni and a Pepperoni Sicilian slice. Each one was quite substantial and a good amount of pepperonis. The round Pepperoni slice was cheesy on top, great firm dough, and so good it made passersby indulge in ordering their own. The Pepperoni Sicilian was much thicker with a toasty base that was very satisfying to take a bite from.The pepperoni here is somewhat thicker cut, creating a dome-like pepperoni slice once cooked making them much meatier in appearance and taste. Not a lot of seating area so many stand outside, lots of foot traffic coming in, very fragrant so that you can smell the pies before you see the shop. Staff work very quickly and get orders out within minutes. read more

See all