Small quaint Mexican restaurant with awesome food and hitting drinks. Had rhe pleasure of having dinner before seeing a show nearby. Started out with drinks a charro old fashioned that had me feeling nice of rhe 1st sip. Definitely strong flavored and well made. On the menu it has beer battered fish tacos but I prefer grilled fish and I asked server if the kitchen would be able to grill the fish instead of frying it and she said yes and the grilled fish tacos were superb !!! Decided to add to dinner some Brussels sprouts and they were so good. To top off an all ready FANTABULOUS meal tried the Tres Leches cake and it had the perfect hint of coconut and sweetness. Definitely would recommend Anejo for the ambiance, great food and drinks. Trust me your gonna love it !!! read more

See all

The food, service, & ambiance were 10/10. We tried the carnitas tacos, shrimp tacos, and birria tacos as well as the blanco margarita with spicy rim. Everything was absolutely amazing. I'm a tough critic when it comes to Mexican food since I'm from a Southern California Mexican family. I highly recommend Añejo to anyone looking for an elevated Mexican cuisine experience. read more

Ate here with a friend before going to see a show on broadway. We had no problems making a last minute reservation and were promptly seated. Beautiful space and music. Waitress was attentive and gave us good recommendations! The pork belly tostada was sooo good-- I also enjoyed the shrimp tacos and the churros. I had a mojito mocktail which was good but I little on the tangy side. Guac and corn were average. read more

Ambiance- eclectic and open space. Love the music- anything with Bad Bunny. Service was quick and efficient. We had the chicken enchiladas and the roasted chicken with beans, rice, and avocado. I was raised in California with delicious Mexican food. I haven't had the best experiences with Mexican food here in NYC, however I highly recommend this place. It isn't our regular street Mexican food however it's a more elevated Mexican cuisine. The cocktails are tasty not too sweet and strong enough. read more

The service was good. But the food was flavorless for mexican food. The octopus was well cooked but it didnt have any flavor. The margaritas seem like they were not shaken before pouring them into the glass. read more

Everything was super flavorful and fresh. Staff was speedy and attentive and the atmosphere very charming. Good value for the money spent on food; a definite stop for foodies. read more

See all

Ordered: Blanco Margarita (HH price ~$8) Traditional Guacamole (HH price ~$8) Tomato Chipotle Fundido (HH price ~$7): melted quesillo cheese, chipotle sofrito, and warm corn tortillas Nachos (HH price ~$8): crispy corn tortillas topped with black beans, melted cheese, salsa, and guacamole 2pc Fish Taco (~$17): beer-battered mahi mahi, poblano slaw, and lime aioli on flour tortillas 2pc Beef Birria Taco (~$17): tortilla crisped in birria oil with slow-braised short rib, salsa arbol, queso chihuahua, onions, cilantro, and consommé for dipping Aya's take: Picture this: it's the first warm day of the year and you & your friends decide to stop by for tacos & margaritas around 5:30pm on a Friday. Happy Hour is still going on (M-F 3pm-6pm) and you start ordering half the menu. The food on the Happy Hour menu is pretty solid. Everything we got was delicious with the Nachos being a major highlight for me. The Margarita is definitely smaller than their usual and was sloppily made. It's like each one I ordered was "less pretty" than the last. Just because it's Happy Hour, doesn't mean you serve something totally different than expected. Both the Fish & Beef Birria Tacos were delicious. I like that you can choose between 2 or 3 tacos per order, but each taco coming out to ~$9 is a bit outrageous even for NYC's standards. All in all, I had a great time at Añejo. It wouldn't be my go-to spot for Mexican but it was a good try with a decent Happy Hour selection. read more

See all

This location is awesome. The service is excellent and the food is even better. I highly suggest the guacamole and salsa combo. The quesadilla and the empanadas are both amazing. I highly suggest the pork tacos. They have an extensive drink selection as well. read more

Añejo is definitely a cut above the rest. I've been to many Mexican/TexMex style resturants but Lord knows, I haven't come across one this good in a minute. Añejo should never change their formula. It was clear from the crowd that Añejo is a neighborhood favorite and this is especially true for the brunch crowd. The restaurant was buzzing with folks and the energy of the restaurant was electric. It's exactly what want for a festive/lively brunch. One could imagine that regular dinner hours are just as fabulous. I say again, everything and I mean everything was superb. At this point, I must point out their sorel sour cocktail and the pork belly appetizer. I could imagine having these two items in heavy rotation at least once a week. I picked Añejo by chance because it was on my NY Resturant Week list but didn't realize NYC RW is not offered on a Saturday. In spite of this, I decided to go with it and I'm glad I did. Añejo certainly impressed me on many levels. The service, food and ambience hit all its marks. read more

See all

I need to start off with: food was amazing!! The service was quick and we were able to move our table inside and enjoy the ambiance. It was dark but still well lit, and people were gathered by the bar as well. We were greeted by a waiter who provided recommendations for entrees and appetizers. I personally ordered the Beef Birria tacos and the flavor was great. I was entranced by the seasoning used in the soup as well as the tacos. A must order for taco lovers!! Furthermore, portions were great for their price. The bean and rice on the side was essentially its own meal, but we were some hungry eaters last night. Only one downside, the chips were a little hard. But the salsa and guac options it came with, made up for the hardness. read more

See all

Cute place to grab a few agave based cocktails. Has a nice selection of artisinal Mezcal and Tequilas. Unfortunately the food is very meh at best. Hell Chilis has a much better steak fajita than here. Stick with the boozy brunch (you know why you're really here) or happy hour cocktails, and you'l be fine. read more

The tacos are packed with great ingredients. The margaritas are top-notch. The guacamole with housemade chips is great. The place is always packed for a reason. read more

Came here on a Friday evening for dinner with a reservation and we were seated quite quickly. The space was super packed and pretty loud so I'd recommend calling ahead if you can and to be prepared for that sort of ambiance! Our server was super friendly and was more than willing to help us with the menu as well as make recommendations for sharing dishes as well as just overall requests for water and extra chips. Our food came out in a reasonable time as well and we weren't left too hungry or thirsty! The corn (esquites) was really fantastic. I love the concept of corn and cheese and other spices so it made it really delicious to eat, especially when it had just come out and it was still warm. I'd eat this one fast though as it cools down quite quickly! I enjoyed the salsa and guac combo. My favorite salsa was the white one which had some sour cream flavoring. The red orange one was pretty spicy just as a heads up as well while the green was tasty as well. The guac had a good mix of ingredients which made it overall feel like a very good, diverse dip overall. The tostadas were pretty delicious and well balanced flavor wise, I would just say that it wasn't worth the price. The dish itself was really yummy and the pork belly was cooked well so i was glad I tried it, I just don't know if I would order it again. Overall, really great dinner and we left feeling pretty satisfied. Thanks, Anejo! read more

See all

fatty greasy ribeye fajita that I would not order again. $36. I should've just bought a ribeye from target and made it myself. read more

Anejo - greasy and fatty....like they added extra vegetable oil to ribeye fajita $36. I would not order it again. - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

Small restaurant with nicely presented dishes. I would recommend this restaurant for happy hour to grab a nice bite and drinks. The food was good and the service was friendly. read more

See all

Made a reservation for 6 people for 6pm Open table didn't have any more spots, but I called and they were able to give me a reservation. Side note: Happy hour is until 6pm I got the guacamole and salsa combo. The guacamole was fresh, and the server was really great about replenishing our chips! The chicken empanadas were so fresh and crispy and the salsa verde for dipping was delicious My friend had the wild mushroom quesadilla and stopped eating her tacos because the quesadilla was so good and she's rather eat that Carne asada was cooked perfectly and well seasoned The duck carnitas enchiladas was with shredded duck. I couldn't really taste the duck flavor, but it was satisfying We got a pitcher of margaritas for $60 and four of us got two glasses each from it. read more

See all

Really wonderful place with some great food and good service. Came before a 9:30 showing of Dune to enjoy some dinner and of course flan. I had heard that the flan here was to die for and it's my favorite dessert. I unfortunately wasn't able to really enjoy food bc I had just received my booster and wasn't feeling well, but wasn't going to let that stop me from having the flan. Everyone's food was great. The table had the salsa/guac chip app. It was great. Chips were thick and great for scooping. Salsas were also fantastic with some mild and some spicy. Everyone's tacos were great, both for our eyes and stomachs. The flan was a bit of a miss for me though. It came warmed up, which was the first time I had ever gotten a hot flan. Maybe it was bc I had never had a hot flan, but it didn't feel right. I feel like the gelatinous consistency works better at room temperature of a bit chill. It also had some cheese on it, that I didn't care for. That said, I thought the flan itself was great and the tequila was wonderful. I've had lots of flan, mostly regular, coconut, and some other varieties, but this tequila was probably my favorite. I think this flan would be an all-star for most people. Everyone had a great time and the service was solid. We sat in the outdoors enclosed area which worked out perfectly. It was nice to be away from the more busy inside. We were worried a bit about temperature, but it was actually quite comfortable. I should also mention that the restaurant was very thoughtful in the resolution of our dinner. Totally unexpected, but very kind. Will def be back to enjoy some tacos! read more

Anejo - Tequila Flan - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

Anejo has been on my list of places to try since moving to the Big Apple. I HIGHLY recommend going during lunch as it's way less busy. They do a great lunch special for $16 where I got a burrito, chips & salsa, plus rice and beans. The braised beef burrito and it was really good. I was also impressed with their different types of salsa. The mild was good but the spicy one was GREAT! The servers were really good as well, and made sure we were stocked with plenty of water and drinks throughout our meal. The posh dining area inside the restaurant was modern and very eye-catching with amazing decor. read more

Anejo - Braised pork burrito - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Prior to our NYC trip we were delighted to find out we were going to be there during restaurant week. We called ahead to make sure they were still participating and were told yes. When we arrived they said they had stopped participating, but he talked to the chef and they said they would honor the special. Appreciated that step. We decided to start with the guacamole. Hands down one of the best - and I've been to Mexico many times. Fresh, chunky, without a lot of junk to hide the avocado taste. Yummy and served with lovely crispy tortilla chips. My sister and I both had the margarita flight. It comes with a Blanco, Anejo, Jalapeno, and a Mezcal. My favorites were the Blanco and the Anejo, but really enjoyed the Jalapeno as well. I'm not a Mezcal fan, and found I'm still not. I had the short rib tacos, Shredded cabbage, tomatillo, pico de gallo, chipotle crema, and Cotija cheese. This was amazing. Tender short ribs, large chunks of meat. Incredible. My sister chose the carnitas - Confit pork shoulder, pickled onions, salsa verde, and cilantro. We swapped so we could each have one of each.The pork was so flavorful, one of the best tasting carnitas I've had. We were stuffed to the gills, but out came this beautiful coconut flan. It is unlike any I've had before. Passion fruit caramel with toasted coconut. It was so light and refreshing after a heavier meal. The atmosphere is lovely. They have lots of outdoor seating and inside they have a bar and several tables. It was a really nice place to sit and enjoy the margaritas and food on our first day. Will certainly be one we'll return to on our next visit. Staff was friendly and food was tops. read more

See all

Anejo is such a gem!! I was in town for work and grateful to have found this spot near Times Square that didn't feel too touristy. The ambiance was very cozy and open air which was perfect for the spring day, and our service was amazing. The food was great but the cocktails were on point!! I got the fish tacos which I enjoyed, but based on what my table ordered, it seemed like the pork belly tostadas and the beef birria tacos were hits most recommended for the future!! I loved how the tostadas were bite size, so they had all of the crunch but less of a mess than a regular tostada! Everyone enjoyed their margaritas and sangria, as well! I personally got the Mendoza and LOVED IT! I don't typically enjoy tequila, but the Prosecco and passion fruit played so well with it and made for an amazing dry cocktail! I had two and would order another if I'm ever back. Highly recommend both the restaurant and cocktail! We got a reservation for 5 at peak dinner time a day ahead of time with no issue, and it appeared they were taking walk in's. read more

See all

Im so happy I stumbled into Anejo after the first 3 places I initially tried to have a bite had 0 tables & long waits. Thankfully not only did Anejo have tables but there was no wait! The restaurant itself is small to medium sized but typical for NYC. There is a full bar that you can sit at & a few different sized table choices. I want to say its tapas style but I could be wrong but the portion size of most of the items gives that vibe. I tried the fish tacos which were pretty good. The fish was perfectly golden fried. Sadly there were out of the shrimp ceviche so I tried the Tuna Ceviche & it was decent. For drinks I went with the Mezcal Margarita (i think) & it was SPICY but I love the smokiness of mezcal. I also tried the dessert Espresso Martini & I have to say it was the best one I have had! Perfect blend of espresso, vodka & cream. I would have had another if the bill wasn't over $230. I would for sure go back! read more

Service was great and friendly! Cocktails were strong and delicious. Food lacked a little bit of depth but average. read more

See all

Amazing food, great staff! Had a party of 30 and all details were coordinated well with Liz. Thank you ! read more

Ambiance was nice, dim lights, louder atmosphere. Happy hour was decent and nachos were great. Shrimp tacos were good and better than the fish for sure. read more

Anejo - 3 Pc Fish Taco 3 Pc Shrimp Taco - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

My partner and I ate here twice in one weekend. The first night we ordered the El Pastor pork tacos and the guacamole and salsa. The food came out quickly and we enjoyed the flavor of the tacos. They were full of meat. My partner really enjoyed the salsa. We went back for brunch the next day and had the morning tacos, Brussels sprouts, yuca fried and tres leches cake for dessert. The waitress comped one of the morning tacos as she only out in one order (very sweet gesture). Everything was delicious and nice portions. The brussel sprouts had too much sauce though. But EVERYONE should try the tres leches cake... TO DIE FOR!!! The wait staff was amazing as well. read more

Anejo - Tres Leches - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

The food is good but not very authentic in my opinion and is also a bit on the expensive side but the restaurant is very nice and centrally located. read more

I absolutely love Anejo. Great vibes and great food. The chicken quesadilla here is unlike anywhere else. For roughly $14 it's super filling, and you can tell they use high quality, well cooked chicken. The hot sauce that they bring out perfectly compliments the food. It did take an unusually long time for our food to come out, so that could use some work, but otherwise me and my friends had a great experience here. read more

Anejo - Chicken Quesadilla - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This spot definitely deserves some more credit ! Went here yesterday for my friend's birthday and three of us did bottomless brunch. Such a fantastic deal, 47 dollars each for a brunch entree, bottomless sangria/mimosas/margaritas/bloody mary, bottomless guacamole and salsa (one is jalapeño!), and French toast for everyone at the table. They put a candle in a tequila shot for her which was also- amazing. I got the huevos rancheros which were delicious and my husband had the chilaquiles which were great as well. The margaritas were my favorite drink option- not too sweet and very well balanced. The bottomless is for 90 minutes which ends up being ample time. Left very full but happy! The ambiance is casual and fun, and every slot was booked for most of the Sunday. Definitely recommend this option for someone looking for a casual brunch that is bottomless and an amazing deal -book ahead of time. Check out my pictures! read more

See all

Great places. Love the guacamole with chips and their tacos are sooooo gooood! Amazing atmosphere, waitress and all the staff were so friendly and amazing. Romantic vibes insides.. slow lights for a wonderful atmosphere. Really a great place..congrats read more

Anejo - a group of people sitting at a bar - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Good for drinks and a snack but I would avoid for dinner/a meal. The entrees were disappointing. For drinks we split the Red Sangria pitcher which was refreshing and enjoyable. We split the guacamole and salsa combo -- the guac was tasty, the salsas were OK. We also split the chicken empanadas which we really liked! As for the entrees we tried the pork tacos, salmon, market salad and seafood enchiladas. Honestly, none of the entrees were great. They lacked flavor and were not cooked well. The worst was the seafood enchiladas which were mostly stuffed with bland potatoes and had very little seafood. Also, when the dish came out the plate and the sliced avocados were very hot leading me to believe the dish was microwaved. Overall I might come back for a drink or some guac. read more

See all

Overall food was good and bottomless brunch with chips and guac plus an entree was $55 so is a good deal. The actual drink was not the best and was on the more sour side (I got the margarita). If you're looking for high quality cocktails look else where but if looking for good food and a bargain you're at the right place! read more

See all

Great restaurant, great food , good combination for tapas, we ordered tacos, amd empanadas and good service, love this place read more

See all

Delicious! Came on a Monday for dinner and it was certainly busy, for the happy hour I presume, so having a reservation was nice. Seating area was tight but do-able, just harder with winter coats if you're coming that time of year. Our waitress was so kind and attentive, constantly checking on us and assuring waters were topped off and everything was alright. Happy hour deals aere amazing and the guacamole was delicious, great seasoning and quick refill on chips if needed. Our main courses came out promptly and were equally high on quality. I really enjoyed the mushroom quesadilla as a vegerarian main and the meat options looked great, as well! Dessert was good, though I didn't care for the sauces with the churros very much. read more

Anejo - Wild Mushroom Quesadilla, Tuna Ceviche, Yuca Frita - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

I ordered the Duck Enchiladas and the Brussels Sprouts for delivery. The duck enchiladas were $16. Not worth it. I was disappointed. The duck itself was over cooked and very dry. Duck is normally oily and juicy. I was hesitant to order this at first when I saw chocolate mole. I should have listened to my gut instinct lol. It did not work with the dish. The shaved lettuce, jalapeños, onion and cotija cheese and sour cream was good. I wouldn't order this again, and I don't recommend it. Waste of $16. The Brussels sprouts were $9. They came with Mexican chorizo, cherry gastrique and crispy leaves as described. It was delicious! All the flavors worked well. Crispy leaves and the chorizo was perfectly cooked. I definitely recommend trying these! Great portion too for $9. I'd order these again. Overall decent quality and order arrived hot and on time without any spills. read more

Anejo - Dry duck.... - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

Phenomenal mexican restaurant in midtown west! My friend and i got the guacamole with chips to start and it was delicious! Fresh, well-seasoned, and came with radish, cilantro, and onions! The chips were also done in-house and were seasoned with a red spice that added a great kick! My friend got the burger and said it was great! I got the chicken tacos and the rice and beans. The rice and beans were seasoned beautifully and also came topped with a crumble cheese and some sort of spicy aioli! The chicken tacos were outstanding! Seasoned to perfection, topped with cilantro, onions, and pineapples, the tacos were a can't miss! Cheers! read more

Anejo - 2 Pc Chicken Taco Rice and Beans - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food here was good, and the service was also great. The ambiance was ok -- it can get extremely loud and you'll find yourself yelling to hear someone from across the table. My only warning to female diners is to KEEP AND EYE ON YOUR HANDBAG. I had the table that was closest to the kitchen and hung my purse on the back of my chair. When we were nearly done with our meal, I realized (too late) that my handbag was stolen. Someone had walked-in, pretending to wait for the restroom, talking on the phone and walked right out with my whole bag. My friend sitting across from me didn't even notice. The restaurant manager said "this happens all the time". Is the food good? Yes. Will I ever dine here again? Likely no. But if you do find yourself here, keep your belongings on your lap, or strapped to you. Better yet, choose a table that's tucked into the center, making it harder for thieves (who are getting away with these crimes, even at nice restaurants) to steal from you. read more

Nice ambiance.. salsa verde and the spicy pineapple guacamole and chips were tasty.. my entree, not so much. I ordered the seafood enchiladas and although I'm not a fan of fish, the description said it was shrimp and scallops which I enjoy. However, they were fishy and at first bite, I considered sending it back due to odd taste. There were also potatoes which were mushy .. combination just wasn't that great. The Paloma bad margarita were okay but nothing to rave about. read more

Tina's take: 9/10 I went here for date night and it was delicious. There were many options to choose from and we started with a margarita pitcher. We did get a spicy one which we weren't aware of, but it was still good. We started with chicken empanadas which were amazing. Then for our main course we both got three tacos each. You had the option to get two or three, if you are getting an appetizer I would get two but everyone is different. The only downside was we had to sit outside which wasn't stated on the reservation, and the table was very small. I would probably come back if I was able to sit inside read more

Anejo - 3 Pc Fish Taco - Mexican Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place was disappointing. First of all, the lighting is terrible. I was using the lighting from the kitchen to see my menu. And I had to use the flash from my phone to see my plate when I received it. The portions were small for the price we paid and the food was mediocre. Two simple flavorless tacos for $16. Ahi ceviche that was sweet for some reason and didn't taste like ceviche. Drinks were great. The service was alright. Neither good or bad. Wouldn't recommend this place to be honest. read more

They refused to let us in because of my tiny, hypoallergenic emotional support dog-even with a valid ESA certificate. The place was nearly empty, but the owner was rude and unaccommodating. Came for a cute date with my boyfriend, but his hostile attitude completely ruined the night. Never coming back. read more