First of all, I love Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza. If I want pizza and an Anthony's is in town, it's where I'm going. That being said, this location is the absolute worst when it comes to take out. I've ordered take out 3 times. All 3 times I had an issue with my order. Forgotten Basil on a square margarita, Forgotten sauce (Don't ask me how this is even possible, but they pulled it off.) and one time a completely raw dough. Almost as if someone ordered a partially baked pie and I was given it by mistake. I won't be ordering take out from here anymore. It's a complete pain in the ass when you have a family of picky eaters and the restaurant you order from messes your order up 3/3 times. read more

My favorite pizza place in Florida...Tavola Pizza...was closed today. I decided to give Anthony's another try. It has been two years. Their customer service is AWESOME!!! Their pizza is just ordinary. I think I have had the best craft pizza in Florida at Tavola's in PSL so I am spoiled. It was good pizza but nothing compared to my favorite. read more

I know good pizza and have had the best in CT and NY. This was overpriced and burnt. A real disappointment. Crust had no flavor, topping were lifeless. read more

Gorgonzola salad, chicken wings and pizza were AWESOME!!!!!

Awesome food. The pizza here is delicious and cooked well-done which I love. I always get the Paul and Young Ron pizza. The pizza has meatballs, ricotta cheese, and your choice of sweet or hot peppers on top. Very good and big pizza. read more

Anthony's coal fire pizza is one of my families and I favorite places to get pizza. There is not one very close to my house so we don't often get this treat. I figured since we were close let's get a pizza and wings to go for dinner. When you take it home and eat it, it just isn't the same. So much better when eaten fresh out of the oven. Oh well... lesson learned. Some things just don't transport well. read more

We were told about Anthony's by a young lady (Amanda) that works there. Just by the way she described the food we knew we had to try it. We went there this evening and had the large pizza and it was cooked crisp just the way we liked it. We were served by Tim but who showed up with our pizza none other than Amanda. When we told her we took her suggestion for dinner she told Tim that he had to go and get us a meatball and a piece of chicken to try also. Both were awesome. The atmosphere was great, the food was great and the pricing was very reasonable. We will definitely be back when we visit Stuart again. read more

I love Anthony's! Its a great place to go unwind, the atmosphere is perfect! The pizza and salad is perfect. The pizza is cooked in a Coal Fired oven, which is open for all to see and smell! Don't expect a chewy, doughy crust, this is crispy and smoky tasting. Delicious! read more

Good salad, GREAT pizza. My favorite is with thin fried slices of eggplant. When I am in Stuart, I always make it a point to visit Anthony's. read more

We order lunch from the office here often. It's so good! I love the Paul and Young Ron with hot peppers, the meatball ricotta pizza is also amazing, but the normal go to for my husband and I is the lunch salad. He loves to order his with roast beef or the tuna. I like mine with either the tuna or the mini meatballs. The tuna is amazing, it's not mayo based - it has oil and vinegar on it. Best 'tuna fish' I've ever ordered form a restaurant. read more

Great variety of interesting pizza combinations. We always get the family salad which is a great way to start. The staff are friendly and helpful. Our server, David, was very knowledgeable on all their dishes and very attentive. Love this restaurant and will be back. read more

Pizza is simply delicious... May sound boring but traditional is what I get every time... the flavors and texture is perfection. Service has always been pleasant, although sometimes the hostesses come off snooty and like it hurts to smile. Pizza quality is very consistent, always knowing you're going to get the same great quality. My friends have ordered the wings and said they are delicious. Only request for change I would have is for Anthony's to get fountain sodas... hate getting a can, you can do better than that now....but will still keep coming back because the pizza is that addicting! read more

Best pizza I have ever had. I work in Stuart one day a week and make a point of ordering a pie at Anthony's. Special note: If you Don' t like well done crust, choose something else on the menu. read more

The food is great! We usually get a Paul and Young pizza with hot peppers,, 10 wings which are baked not fried and a house salad. Many specialty beers on tap complimented by a friendly, knowledgeable staff. The restaurant is very clean and well run. It's a must if you like well done pizza. read more

If you like overpriced mostly burnt crust this is the place for you. The sauce is too salty for my taste.

this is a very nice place good service and thier breads are incredible good eats the sausage sandwich is delicious read more

Good food. However they quit their 'curb side' service of bringing ordered food to cars. Their food is okay, but without that additional service not worth going to. read more

Bought 2 large pizzas one with pepperoni and one with sausage. Both were cool almost cold and the sausage had an average of 4 small pieces of sausage per slice. Time to look for an alternative pizza house read more

one of the worst and most unexpected experience I've had. called in my order and was told ready in 15mins.... showed up and told i have no order, i live less than 5 mins away yet the manager was so rude and disrespectful to say i must have called another location. he offered a low level of service, i distinctly have the call i placed and to where yet he was rebutting. the decent thing is to rectify the situation not provide service of such. after this experience i would rather drive to the other closest location in palm beach than here again. and i did say palm beach, because he was rude enough to suggest i may have called another location. read more

After traveling to Martin county HS for a basketball game we decided to get a bite to eat. We decided to try Anthony's coal fired pizza because we had heard so much about it and boy it did not disappoint. We had a wonderful server named Christine who walked us through the menu and gave suggestions. We ordered arugula pizza and a meatball and ricotta. My daughter had a chicken sandwich. EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS!! The service was spot on and we even though an hour away, would come back any time!! read more

Returned again -- and again had a great lunch -- the right kind of lettuce -- chicken actually cooked for your entree salad -- not just warmed up -- and a great mix of ingredients -- even the wife was impressed -- and I had a great chicken sandwich instead of my usual tuna -- we have to go back more often!! read more

Awesome lunch! First time eating here. Would go back again. Atmosphere great, pizza with long hot peppers and wings were delicious. Good craft beer selection. Reasonably priced. read more

Not as happy this trip, but still would go back. Service was ok, other than the fact that the little gal who brought our broccoli rabe to the table (she wasn't our server, but I guess you'd call her a runner) accidentally sloshed some of the way too much hot liquid in the bowl on the BF's thigh. Luckily, he had shorts over shorts and no harm done, but there was no reason for all of the muddy cooking water to be in the bowl anyway. Yuk. Pizza (Pauli's pie, since there was a Paul in our group-ha) was decent. Too much meat, really. Arugula salad with burrata was the best thing we ate, I think, but should have ordered dressing on the side. Loud and bustling on a Wednesday evening. Quiet when we first got there at 6, but filled up quickly with all ages of happy pizza eaters. Good place to go to relax and share the food around the table with family/friends. Seemed kid friendly, although that isn't a draw for me . . . read more

Cassidy was incredible, made eating here go from a 7 to a 10 out of 10. Very pretty, very polite, very professional

Fantastic thin, crisp crust with amazing flavor...the salad was excellent too. By far the best pizza any of us have ever had.

We've been here several times and love this place. If you're looking for fast, friendly service this is your place! We got our favorite Cauliflower roasted pizza! Never disappoints! read more

Best pizza we've had since we arrived from up north in January.The service was very friendly.Our server took great care of the 10 of us, on what was a very busy Monday evening.Pizza is thin crust. It is very crispy. They don't scrimp on the toppings.Sauce was perfect.Family style salad was great.Will be going back often. read more

Delicious coal fired oven pizza and great service. Can't wait to come back for more.

One of the finest pizzas I have ever eaten. Also the eggplant marino was delicious. The wait staff was efficient. The atmosphere is music and flatscreens in a close seating arrangement or at the bar. read more

This is amazing pizza. The atmosphere when you first walk in is warm and cozy, good selection of wines to go with dinner, wonderful staff, I just can't say enough about this place. You have to try it! read more

Love Anthony's Pizza. At other pizza places, my bride usually complains of the shortage of toppings. Not at Anthony's. When you order a pepperoni pizza, you, by golly, get lots of pepperoni. Crust is thin and crispy as we like it. Huge selection of both bottled and draft beers. Service is generally very good. Just wish I could get a side of pasta. read more

The pizza was good and the service was good. Everything was a bit pricey. BUT, beware the waitress's' hard sell on the "special" they have on a glass of wine. The cost - $9.00, well above what it was worth and certainly not deserving of a restaurant that is hardly gourmet or fine dining. As a matter or fact, all drinks (beer and sodas included) were very expensive. Be sure to ask for prices before ordering. read more

"Good Pizza, Very Good Wings." Great place for wings if you don't want them smothered in sauce. These wings are smoked and served with grilled onions. Pizza actually is wood fired. read more