Wow!! The front of the house customer service is the worst I have experienced in a long time. They were so rude and uncaring and did not even offer you hell me fix the wrong order that they messed up.mind you it was so Saturday night customer service should still be to good expectations always. And fix the mistakes that were made. $35 of my $ down the drain. This is not how a business should be ran. read more

Always great pizza and service. It's about 1 of 2 pizza places in Denver that remind of being back in New York!!!

Regarding the store on E. Illiff, their pizza and wings used to be fabulous. However, the past couple of times I ordered from there the quality was sub-standard. One time the pizza was very greasy. The following time the wings were tough and overcooked and the pizza seemed like it had sat out for some time. That used to be my go-to place for pizza and wings. I'm now searching for something better. read more

Great thin crust pizza. There meatball pizzas are really good. Best I've had in Aurora

The best pizza around hands down in my book .it's where I can count on a real n York slice .

I'm a New Yorker pizza eater and seeking a particular taste. Thus far this is the Best in Colorado.

I order some pizza from Anthony's Pizza place last evening and it wasn't what I expected, at list quality went down since I had their pizza last which was about 6 month ago, price is ridiculous high, paid $144 for 3 pizza and 2 order of wings, now 2 pizza out of 3 is going to trash read more

Good for ordering on a weeknight. Nothing outstanding, but we consistently will order from here when we are looking for something quick and easy. read more

So good! Our new favorite place to grab a (huge) slice of pizza. Their pizza is wonderful, and their farmer's salad is also fresh and delicious. We've eaten there 3 times so far and it's consistently wonderful. read more

PIzzz is good, not awesome.... the price is high (almost $30 for a pizza?.....seriously?) I'd pay that much for awesome pizza, but this wasn't that. read more

love this place. went there so many days never got sick of it. great food reliable spot. will not disappoint. ah-ah-a Anthony's!

I ordered a pizza to go from here last night. I love pizza and consider myself somewhat a connoisseur having lived in Chicago and visited many places known for pizza. This pizza has surprised me. I really love everything about it. It has tons of pepperoni the sauce is spicy. The crust is delicious and thick at the ends. I can't say enough good things about it and it upsets me because I don't live in Colorado anymore so I can't have this whenever I want. read more

The food is great but DO NOT order online. It goes through 'slice' and they screw up my order every single time!!! Call directly to the store read more

My order is always delivered piping hot. The bread is always cooked well done, and so is the pizza, as long as I request it. They are very generous on the cheese & toppings. I always choose Anthony's! read more

I find it hard to believe I have not reviewed this location yet. I do frequent this spot as it's close to home and does deliver. It's situated in a shopping center surrounded by a grocery store, hardware store and liquor store. You can quite literally grab those few things you need from the hardware store, do your grocery shopping and go grab a pizza and a 6 pack in one stop. Yes.. I have done just that on occasion. I have never had any issues with this location. I will admit I have not tried anything other then their pizza. I don't need to!!! I like their pizza as has my out of town friends and family who have visited. It's the way pizza I grew up with has always been. Flour on the bottom, grease on top. There's a lot of room in this location compared to their others. I know they are trying to have a specific Décor, but it leaves the place a little on the cold side. Delivery can be a little long sometimes, but I figure if you're in that much of a hurry you can get in the car and go get it yourself. I like knowing what to expect and this location has always been consistent. read more

Maybe it was an off night but my son and I ate here tonight since we were in the area and it was not good. My slice of pizza was sopping with grease and toppings looked like they just got dumped on top and heated up. My son had pesto pasta and it came as a bowl of spaghetti with bland oily pesto sauce and hard garlic bread. No one asked how we liked it and the vibe in there was awful- the place had no music and the workers seemed grumpy. Won't be returning. .....month later ..... I am changing my review from 1 to 3 stars. After the last experience here Peter contacted me and gave us two free pizza coupons to give them another chance. We went to the location off 8th and CO this time. It was nice inside- very up to date and clean. We ordered the same pizza as last time with a salad to go. I only had to pay for the toppings and salad, so thank you Peter for that coupon. It was definitely better than the last time. We got meatball, black olive and green pepper again. Unfortunately I don't think they used meatballs though- it was more like crumbled sausage. But it was cooked better and we appreciate the offer to try again. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Giving it another try.... - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Service is good, no matter what Anthony's I go to. Their food selection is consistent and most of all it tastes consistent. They have fast service and they are definitely reasonably priced. I am not a connoisseur of pizza, but I know good pizza when I taste it, good job. Overall the pizza is good - not outstanding and most of all, my kids love it. So I will continue to go back! read more

Great pizza, made so perfectly. I asked for crunchy crust, crust wasn't burnt but perfectly crunchy. Not too much ricotta. Ample toppings Fast delivery read more

After having a really bad experience at papa johns on chambers and alameda in Aurora. I decided to try Anthony's pizza off Buckley and illif. I was not disappointed, this actually tasted like pizza. Service was great and fast. This will be my pizza place from now on. read more

So annoyed. I was told my wait would be about 10 minutes and ended up Wasting about half an hour of my lunch break waiting for ONE piece of pizza that looked like it was just thrown in the bag. Not a whole pizza. Not even two slices. A simple slice with a few toppings. After about 20 minutes of waiting I heard someone up front ask about my slice and a cook yelled out Ah Man as if my slice wasn't even started. The pizza was all folded over and thrown between some plates, toppings not even on the pizza. Went back in and got my money back. Customers who ordered after me got their slices before me. Just literally a waste of a lunch. Didn't have time to even get anything else. Smh get it together. read more

Pizza is always good at Anthony's. The service was good and the salad was on point. I had a great experience.

Best pizza in Colorado, it's juicy filling and thin, my Fiancé introduced me to this place and I can't get enough of it. We both love the big slices but I also ordered a 12" pizza for myself and it was so juicy and tasty, definitely the only pizza place I will be ordering from. I also went to the restaurant and ate in and may I say the place is clean and the bathroom was spotless. I was very impressed the service was good and the lady was very friendly and polite. read more

Cardboard pizza. Loved it the last time we had it maybe a year ago. This time we had it it tasted like cardboard and canned sauce. Won't ever go there again. After two bites we threw the entire thing away. One bite by me and one by my husband and all we could think about is how we wasted our money. read more

I really like Anthony's and eat there often. My favorite pizza is sausage, but I can't eat that there, I really dislike the sausage that they use. Other then that I am a fan read more

Ordered Pizza online at 5:15, said it would be ready at 5:50. Called to check on it an hour later, it was out for delivery. It was raining so we gave it some leeway. Another hour later we are arguing with the manager that we were supposed to pick it up. Unreal!!! Now it will take unto Wednesday ( 5 days ) for a refund to our card. Thanks Chris at Buckley and Iliff for arguing with what used to be regular customers! Totally incompetent team working there. I have to give at least 1 star but I give this location negative 5 stars. read more

While I'm happy that they actually deliver to my neighborhood, I'm completely dis-satisfied with my last order. I was told it would take over an hour to get to me (I was told 75-90 minutes), okay, whatever. When the food finally arrived (2 hours later) it was ice cold and my calzone order (I ordered pineapple, onion and Canadian bacon) was actually pineapple and pepperoni which is not a great combination. Also, they forgot the 2 sides of ranch which I paid for, and god forbid I wait another 2 hours for ranch. I was told by whomever runs the FB page to leave a yelp review, so here I am. If you want slow service, the wrong item or no items at all, please order from Anthony's, otherwise, go elsewhere. read more

My family and I go to Anthony's quite often. The food is good and usually the service is good, but it was not today. The waitress was rude and she didn't listen to my mom. Not only that but she was still talking trash while we were in there. Lose your attitude lady! read more

Amazingly enough they have good wings, we just tried randomly with out pizza one night and I was impressed! Their pizza is great!!! This is our go to place for a good pizza. The size and quality is good for the price and the delivery guys have always been very nice. The pasta is pretty greasy, and we didn't particular care for it. But it's not a deal breaker bc we always had great pizz read more

Great, cheap place for a greasy lunch. The pizza is made pretty quickly and brought directly to your table, so you can sit down and hang out with friends while you wait. I've only had the thin crust, which is terrible for you and delicious. The large drinks are LARGE (in the Texas meaning of the word). I probably eat here 2-3 times per month. read more

I hate to be this person.....BUT it's been a reoccurring problem at this location & after my attempt to first solve the problem with management failed I figured I'd leave this review. First off-the pizza is awesome! I moved to CO from the Midwest & have had a hell of a time finding some decent pizza & Anthony's solved that for me! The problem: pick up orders take over 40 minutes. No matter the day no matter the time and the managers response to a complaint is "there's nothing I can do for ya". This is a general manager at that. When I explained I didn't have this issue at their other locations his only response was that he was a general manager and couldn't help me. I worked at pizza places for 4+ years throughout high school & my undergrad years in college & never once told a customer I couldn't help them. Overall A+ pizza & D- customer service. read more

Great pizza with great service we Anthony's we have never had any problems they always treat us the best

Pretty good ny style pizza in an open relaxed casual atmosphere. Cheap and delicious and they have the spices and cheese at your table if you want those. Also offer beer and maybe liquor as well as fountain drinks and pasta. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

We had a wonderful night, the restaurant was packed on a Friday night around 7pm, but our waiter Doug who had a diamond with an eye in the center tattoo on his right arm, was absolutely amazing. He was clearly slammed but made sure our drinks were full and our orders were taken! You're awesome Doug! Thanks so much for your effort! You did great! read more

As a native New Yorker (born & raised in the Bronx baby) coming to Colorado is cool since I prefer the cold to the dead heat. Since pizza is my favorite food, I am always in search of a place that will satisfy my New Yorker pizza cravings. I am GLAD I came here wow the pizza was SO GOOD I can still taste it, yum!!! Hit the spot right on and the New York pictures on the wall made me nostalgic of my home sweet home. This will be my spot for the next 3+ years that Colorado will be home. Take it from a New Yawka- this pizza is amazing! read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Absolutely delicious - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Anthony's is a very good pizza parlor they have great pizza great sandwiches great calzones good salads. read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

Franchise does not have to equal ordinary &/or low quality. You can taste the freshness in the food at Anthony's Pizza. I LOVE their pizza. I find the proportion of cheese & sauce to be perfect & the crust has a great flavor & thickness. Their pizzas are also quite large so lots of leftovers! I usually have them deliver & they have always been good about delivering within the promised time range (usually within an hour). I'm trying their pasta & calzone for the first time tonight & looking forward to it! read more

Pretty good. Delivery was very speedy- I made the delivery driver wait on accident, thought my husband was already home and I was in the shower-oops. Pizzas were still hot and yummy, but I wish they packed us some crushed peppers and parmesan. My only dissapointment was that I assumed the basil would be fresh, as it was pictured on the homepage of the Anthony's website. Instead my half of the pizza was covered in old, bland definitely not as tasty, dried basil. :( read more

Anthony's Pizza and Pasta - The basil I was hoping for... - Pizza Near Me - Aurora, Colorado

See all

Mmm nice and greasy fold in half ny style pizza. Can't go wrong here. Try the 18 in pizza for dinner and for tomorrow's breakfast. For lunch I usually get the 2 piece, 1 drink special. I'm out of there fore $8.00. Sitting down and ordering the pies is the best option. I usually wait 10-15 mins for the pizza to come out. Nothing glamorous, just good greasy pizza. I usually soak up the grease though. Leftover pizza tastes good cold and reheats well. read more

Of all the pizza-delivery options in SE Aurora, Anthony's is head-and-shoulders the best!!!! Crust is great and the cheese and toppings are top-notch!!!! Yum yum!!!! read more

Very good pizza!! And nice staff... I bought a large slice, salad (with a lot of toppings) and a drink for $6.85+tax. I will be back!!! read more