Anthony's is a small pizzeria and deli in Cheshire. There is some seating, but not enough for you to count on being able to eat there. Best to think of Anthony's as primarily take out. They have pizza, sandwiches and salads for sure. I didn't see a full menu. Their pizza is available in slices, and the selection looks pretty good. I ordered a Supreme Slice and a Steak Fajita grinder. The pizza crust was a touch softer than I was expecting, but the crust, sauce, cheese and toppings were tasty. The grinder bread was fresh. The steak was tender and well seasoned. The cheese was well melted and the veggies were pretty good. I would definitely return to Anthony's. 4.25 Stars read more

See all

Buffalo Chicken Tenders. Came Naked with only a tiny Buffalo sauce cup (definitely not enough) and NO blue cheese dressing. No effort on their part tonight. I'll go back to CJ Sparrow's in the future. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Buffalo Chicken Tenders. - Pizza Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

Two years in a row getting Anthony's to cater our youngest son's birthday party at Whippersnappers. Great food (pizza+tenders) and reasonable prices! read more

We have ordered Pizza, calzones, salad, pasta, grinders, and garlic bread from here and have loved each one. This is a great place which has a lot of competition in this particular town, so we have been really happy to see it thrive! We will continue to do our part to help it do so. :) read more

The service and delivery were great but we love thick crust pizza. On the other hand, we ordered a white clam large and it was fabulous.

My wife and I arrived irritated and hungry after a 7 hour drive with so much traffic, we were looking for a place to sit down and eat, though there are two small tables inside this isn't the place for that. They stayed busy with calls and customers coming in and now after having a couple slices I know why. I'm not even sure what slices I picked, I both had bacon on them and one was a white pizza slice, and though I was worried because it was nearly 8 pm at night and who knows how long they had been sitting on display I wasn't in the mood to go somewhere else. Fast forward to my wife and I getting to our hotel and opening up the box and taking a bite, I smiled, it was one of the best bites of pizza I've ever had from NY to Italy to Germany to all over the US. My wife had one of their chicken sandwiches which was delicious too. You could tell when I was waiting for my slices of heaven they have their regular customers and in a small town they were super friendly. AWESOME PIZZA read more

Anthony's Pizza and Deli is a take out only restaurant. They are usually very busy so call ahead. Their thin crust pizzas are absolutely delicious. They have a good selection of pizza that you can also buy by the slice. We have also tried their large generous portion subs. Their homemade sub rolls are the best. They are toasted on the outside for that nice crunch yet nice, and soft on the inside. The staff are very friendly, and attentive. I read more

See all

We have been ordering from here about once a week for a couple of years and will never order again after our last experience. One of the things we order is a pizza with no cheese and one topping. It is silly to be charged for a vegetable topping when we aren't getting cheese, so we started asking to not be charged for the topping. Until tonight, they honored that request. Tonight, we ordered a pizza with no cheese, half onion, half broccoli. They insisted on not only charging us for the topping but on charging for two toppings even though each topping was only on half the pizza. The manager argued that we should be charged for two toppings because it's "more work." Ah, yes, so much work to grab a different topping for half the pizza. Hope the loss of business was worth it to them for $3.50. We will never be back. Awful business. read more

Thin, crispy, zesty pizza in Cheshire! No need to go to New Haven proper when there is Anthony's in New Haven county.

Hard to believe it was over 4 years ago that I was the first to review Anthony's and had a Review of the Day for it. I've been a regular here since then and the community is lucky to have Ermel and family here in town. They continue to rock it with some of the best pizza around and have added ready to go meals, salads and desserts over the recent past. I got the chocolate chip cookies yesterday for the first time (along with my usual eggplant parm sub) and they are also some of the best around! Not easy to find a solid cookie but they have them in oatmeal and peanut butter cup, too. I've posted some updated pics including a beet salad I had but you can't go wrong with anything you order here! read more

See all

Best slices in Cheshire! The potato salad is so good here too! Their staff is always so friendly too!

So the food here is really good. We ordered the meatball parmigiana and eggplant parmigiana subs and a pizza. The subs were really good. Bread was nice and fresh and the sub was made right before we got it so it was nice and fresh. This was the first time we ordered here on a Friday night. I don't think I'd order on a Friday again. Pizza definitely sat out of the oven for a good 10-15 minutes I would say because it was only somewhat warm when I got home. Usually the box is really hot when you pick up a pizza it this was definitely not the case here tonight. My other issue this evening was the young girl that helped me out this evening. When I got there she got my name and went to go check. She told me I was early in a not so friendly way. I knew I was early. Unfortunately when you order online you don't get an estimate as to how long it'll take until about 5 minutes after the order is placed. I was about 10 minutes early out of the 1 hour and 20 minute estimate I got and I knew it, but I wanted to make sure that maybe the order wasn't done early and was just sitting. When my order was finally ready, which was the time they said, the same girl put the pizza down on the counter and said your order was ready and walked away! No "thank you", no "have good evening." Good customer service goes a long way and can sometimes make or break a small business. I hope this girl isn't like this to everyone she deals with here. read more

Had an unfortunate experience at this pizza place ordered a pie went to pick it up and was given the wrong pizza. Silly me didn't check the pie I just assumed they gave me the right pie. Found out once I got home I had a sausage and mushroom pizza, when I ordered meatball and mashed potato. Upon returning and receiving the correct pie and returning the wrong one, I asked for some free cookies as Compensation. A little reluctant they granted me the cookies. I returned home to eat the pie, which i enjoyed honestly. But I found a piece of chicken on my meatball and mashed potato pizza. This upsets me because I don't eat pork and I believe they don't do a great job of avoiding cross contamination. read more

I'm glad Anthony's opened on Rte 10. It's a convenient place to get an affordable bite to eat. There are ready made dishes to choose from along with desserts. I got some pizza slices and garlic bread. The pizza was cheesy and had lots of veggies and meat. The service was good; this is a takeout place. I liked the assortment of calzones and other offerings. There's something for everyone here. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

My favorite pizza in Cheshire. Their Mr potato pizza is my second favorite mashed potato and bacon pizza after BAR. Solid sides and other pizza options. Crust is consistent and great flavor. read more

We really like Anthony's, we usually eat lunch here once a week and have for several months now. Great handheld sandwiches, the cookies are really awesome and fresh, and when they have it the potato salad is amazing. My favorites are the italian cold cut combo on a hard roll and a braised rib sandwich. You do need to make sure your timing is right. While you can order for an early lunch, many times they will not have fresh bread ready at 11:30, it won't be finished until noon. We have ordered sandwiches on a hard roll via the app multiple times and either a) get a stale roll from yesterday or b) another type of break "for free". Lesson learned, do not order for pickup before 12. read more

They are polite and they appreciate the business. They have a place you can sit and eat. The food was alright. They definitely have many regulars that they know by name. The food was fresh and tasted okay. Nothing special, but I felt safe being here like I was in my hometown. read more

A sweet little place with the finest thin pizza crust.We love the cheese, black olives, mushrooms and onions pie. Consistent and delicious.

Best pizza in Cheshire! They also have good sandwiches and stuffed breads. Very friendly staff!

Great place to pop in and get a slice or two sandwiches are always very good They also do soups and salads. I recommended pop in.

Always great food from lunch to dinners and pizza. Service is always great. They go above and beyond to please everyone

Ordered pizzas for a party at Cheshire Town Pool. Everyone liked the pizza and most of us are from New Haven. They even made a gluten free pizza which we needed for someone with a food allergy. read more

This is the best pizza I have had in a long while. Yesterday was our first time ordering my family and I got the "fig it" and your traditional cheese. The fig it is the best combination of flavors, with the perfect amount of ingredients. Crust is not too thin but not to thick and my biggest pet peeve is a burnt slice of pizza but to my surprise it was cooked perfectly! The sauce on the cheese had great flavor. The staff was friendly and welcoming and if I may add my father is the BIGGEST pizza critic out there and he LOVED IT. he enjoyed it so much he said he was so full but needed to eat one more slice. Thank you for great quality pizza! read more

Well, the salads are beautifully presented in a round clear bowl, a flower on every one! The dressings are flavorful and light, never oily. Meals to go heat up as you just ordered and picked up fresh! Shop made bread-the aroma is fresh yeast, salt and the texture is crusty on the outside-you can tap it with a butter knife-wonderful sound. The inside is full of air pockets and chewy. So good. Calamari is decent although a bit light on the serving size/not a deal breaker for me. Sauce is fresh and bright! Thank you. read more

Undoubtedly this is by far the uncontested best pizza spot in Cheshire and in my personal opinion the best restaurant in Cheshire. I'll begin by saying I have only ever ordered this spot from a delivery app but I can only imagine the quality of the food is better in the restaurant and it always arrived hot and tasty. To begin, the pizza at this place is just straight up enjoyable. It is a thin crust with a light crispy and the cheese, sauce, crust and whatever toppings you choose will be of great quality and freshness. Probably most similar to a New York style pizza as it is not quite as crackery thin and crispy as a New Haven style would be, not that this is a bad thing. There is a nice flop to the pizza and it keeps a crisp bottom. Ive also enjoyed the wings as a side. To put it simply its better than many wing focused restaurants. The wings are huge and full of meat. Juicy chicken and crisp batter it truly represents what a good wing should be. The flavor options for delivery were buffalo and a citrus chipotle BBQ. Both were excellent Now the last item i've had the pleasure in having and in my opinion the best item so far. The Fettuccine Alfredo. I ordered this with chicken and the chicken arrived as a fried breaded chicken cutlet. Almost like a tonkatsu and it was excellent but focusing on the pasta it is impossible to state how good I found it. First off the sauce tastes classic and rich. The alfredo sauce tasted about as close to authentic as I think is possible to get in Cheshire. The pasta was clearly fresh and had a wonderful texture and bite to them. The other additions such as the sun dried tomatoes were small bombs of flavor that gave the whole dish a nice contrast with a little acidity. I highly suggest you get this item, even without an additional protein the pasta itself is ridiculously enjoyable. To finish, this restaurant is thoroughly impressive with every dish I have tried with not a single disappointment. It is one of the few restaurants in this area that I feel excited to try more of the menu. I highly suggest this restaurant and I thank the owners of this establishment for many wonderful meals I hope I have the pleasure in coming to this restaurant in person to enjoy the food fresh out of the kitchen. read more

Food is very good. My family frequents takeout from Anthony's and are always satisfied. Haven't sat inside yet, only had takeaway but the experience with service has been fine. Nothing special but food is always ready on time. read more

I saw a pic of their Penne al vodka in a review and it looked like they are generous with the sauce. So I tried it. They certainly are and I loved it. They use real cream. It was delicious. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - a pie with a fork in it - Pizza Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

Ordered via phone for pickup and was told 30 mins. No problem at all for early on a Friday evening. Arrived on time and waited for 10 mins before being told "10 more mins" . Again, it's a Friday night...slightly annoying but no biggie. Left there 25 mins after arriving. We ordered a Large cheese pizza, Mr. Potato extreme strings, and the Arancini. When we got home the pizza was cold. Not lukewarm, not slightly warm....cold. The Mr. Potato extreme strings were anything but extreme. Maybe extremely gross, that fits the bill. They were frozen steak fries out of a bag, a pinch of shredded cheese, and literally 5 bits of bacon. The Arancini were mediocre at best and weren't as described on the menu. The best part of the entire meal was the pesto dipping sauce. This was our first and absolutely last time going to Anthony's. Do yourself a favor, go somewhere else for a meal in Cheshire. read more

Anthony's Pizzeria & Deli - Mr. Potato Xtreme Strings - Pizza Near Me - Cheshire, Connecticut

Great for takeout pizza. Good Pies and sandwiches. Fast service. If you want a change of pace from all the other pizza joints in Cheshire. Try Anthony's read more

Small but nice place in a small strip mall in town. There are a few tables inside but I have only done take out. Pizza is excellent. Salads and wings are really good. Many interesting sandwiches and I highly recommend the Anthony's Braised Beef...I don't eat sandwiches very often but will make an exception for this! If you are a fan of short ribs I suggest you order it. read more

Good food, but the wait times are inconsistent and the people who work the counter really need training on how run a business. But the food is good. read more

THE BOBCAT. Amazing. Pizza? Amazing, chipotle panini Amazingggggggg love this place. Very friendly people too.

OMG! We finally tried this Deli out and have returned for more. What a gem! The owner and staff are always friendly and helpful. The food is AWESOME. The pizza is superb and the deli sandwiches are delicious and creative. They bake their own breads and rolls. The hard rolls aren't your traditional hard rolls. They're much better and don't get soggy if your sandwich has sauce. Speaking of sauce, I had the Bobcat sandwich yesterday and was blown away. Tender breaded chicken with ziti and vodka sauce. Yep, not a combo that I've seen before, but oh so delicious! I'll definitely order that one again. There are a lot of great sandwich items at Anthony's, so my wife and I will visit weekly for sure. Do yourself a favor and try out this GEM. It's not fancy, just a clean deli serving up delicious sandwiches, salads and pizza, by a very friendly staff. read more

This place has great subs and amazing pizza and delicious stuffed breads. I highly recommend Anthony's for a pizza party or something catered. They're very accommodating. They have desserts, premade meals, big loaves of Italian bread that are delicious. There is no seating inside it's all to go, but it's definitely worth it. read more

Absolutely one of the Very Best Pizza Places your Tastebuds will get to enjoy!!! The Crust, the flop, the Sauce and the flavor are all 5 when your looking for Amazing Pizza!!! In Addition the Sicilian pie will blow your minds with its thickness, crunch, taste and again their Sauce, OMG!!! You expect the pizza, be very heavy when you see this huge slice, then you pick it up and it's super light and you take a bite and you're Blown Away!!! In addition their Panini sandwiches are truly out of this world, with their array of options, freshly baked bread, creative toppings, and simply just mouthwatering sandwiches! If you're anywhere close to Cheshire or wallingford, as they have two locations, you must make every effort to enjoy Anthony's pizza and their scrumptious sandwiches!!! Top-notch service, very clean ambiance, and a family business that makes you feel special every time you walk in!!! read more

The best in town! The service is always great and the pizza's never disappoint. Their sandwiches/paninis are also worth ordering for lunch or dinner. If you like a nice, thin crust pizza this is your best option in Cheshire. They also have a thicker Sicilian style pizza (shout out to my homeland) that we get a slice of every now and again. Support these folks! They deserve it! read more

Overpriced, hardly anything on a sandwich, so many better places around , I wouldn't waste my money ever buying something here again!!

Why don't you people answer your phone? When ordering pizza, it's complicated when ordering things not listed on your online ordering system, such as Parmesan instead of mozzarella Etc. please answer your phone!! read more

Very good and friendly customer service. And hard to beat the convenience and quality of meals!!!

Tried their pizza for the first time. It was delicious. Ordered a spinach and artichoke pie and there was a generous amount of the toppings. However, if you are not a fan of thin slightly charred crust you might be disappointed. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Upgraded my review from 4 to 5 stars. In the last year I have tried salads and several sandwiches as well as more pizza! Everything has been very good. The owners/family are the friendliest and nicest people. Can't say enough good about this place. read more