Mama Maria's pizza was pretty fast fulfilling our online order, so service was quick. That pleased us the most. The price point is fair. The interior is kind of small, and has a few booths to sit in. When I came inside I noticed they also have pizza by the slice, which is good if you need a little something to keep you going. The taste of our pizzas was okay: not bad, but not glorious. Crust was on more of the flat side, not ready. The sauce was a tad sweet for my preference. read more

Best pizza around. Staff is always friendly. Love the "local" feel. Very prompt response to customers. Clean. Casual. You can buy uncooked pizza balls to make your own at home. read more

The best Margarita pizza around! And we also ordered a heart shape for Valentines Day...

We love their pizza and sandwiches! Pasta dishes were pretty good too. The BBQ chicken pizza was really delicious. Fast delivery and nice staff. Highly recommended for good pizza in this area. read more

Pizza, Pizza, Pizza .. this is a little out of my way, but I dont care!! I love the pizza and the fries! Top notch! Perfection every time. It also helps that Monday- Thursday they have a great deal 2 pizzas for $20, you can't get a deal like that anywhere around here, especially in the summer! I've alao had the fries, which may I add are very good! So if it's a good slice you're looking for, this is the place read more

Mama Maria's Pizza - Sicilian was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - West Creek, New Jersey

They make the greatest white pie! I always ask for extra sliced tomatoes and extra pesto on mine! I also was very impressed by their Italian sub because the rolls are so fresh and delicious. The lettuce is of assorted greens and shredded just right and the meat is fresh. The owner Marie is very nice and a friend of my nieces. Do yourself a favor and stop and order some delicious Italian food! read more

They are not consistent with their food. Not very professional. I have received two pizzas previously they were already cooked and they were just reheated which was terrible! The first one I took back and they gave me another one the same way. I will not be going back read more

Stopped in at 1pm on a Monday afternoon. Got two pepperoni slices and something like a southwest bbq chicken pizza that was absolutely delicious. Great customer service from them. Also got 8 buffalo wings that were SPOT on. Ranch and celery with it. $15 total. Will be back again shortly! read more

Mama Maria's Pizza - chicken wings and celery in a styrofoam container - Pizza Near Me - West Creek, New Jersey

We tried Mama Maria's for the first time this week. Do not let this small building fool you... Mama Maria's is BIG on taste! This is our new favorite pizzeria! The pizza is delicious and their garlic knots are superb! Every pizzeria makes garlic knots, but they are not all equal! These are covered with a delicious helping of what seems like roasted garlic. Not soggy with oil. But tasty, good sized, and tempting on that ride home! I've also had the baked ziti, served with a nice side salad and warm bread. Sooo delicious! We have 6 pizzerias within a half mile of our house, but gladly take the 15 min ride to Mama Maria's! The employees are very nice and friendly. I can't wait to try more items! A+ read more

I have ordered from here many times. Food is always good. For the first time I ordered the Meatball Parmesan Sub. It is the BEST Meatball Parm Sub I have ever had in this area since I moved here 9 years ago. When ordering ask for extra sauce on the side and cheese (if you are a cheesy person like me) read more

Yes, this little place on the side of the road CAN COOK! Don't drive by, they deliver or you can order ahead on SLICE and pick up. We have enjoyed the pizza many times. ( medium to thin crust is the norm.) Toppings are always fresh and wonderful. Today we decided to try the wings. YUM. They are definitely different than wings we have ordered elsewhere. (Different, better.) The chicken skin on the wings was thinner than what we normally get. Plus they had a delightful wonderful (just crunchy enough) coating. We ordered plain and they were seasoned perfectly. Mama Maria's is just wonderful! brake ...... brake .... turn in. Delish! :-) read more

The best pizza place I have ever been too. Amazing pizza, friendly people, and great prices. I go here once a week and it has always been satisfying and extremely pleasent. I can't get enough of mama Maria's! read more

Pizza was very good, however girl serving was not wearing a mask and after she was sitting eating gummy bears she took my piece of pizza with her hand, didn't even wash her hands or put on gloves. Not sanitary. If they put on a mask and washed their hands I would have given a much better review. read more

Mama Maria's Pizza - Outside of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - West Creek, New Jersey

See all

I live right down the street from this place. Their pizza, first of all, is delicious. Seriously best pizza in the area, hands down. HOWEVER, they need to work on being sanitary. Literally everyone who works there handles the pizza in between touching door handles, phone, money, credit card machine, etc WITHOUT washing their hands or using gloves. What the hell? I want to eat your pizza but I don't want to suffer from a preventable illness because you are too careless to wash your hands. Capesce? read more

Great experience!! Great food, great service! Little things go a long way for me. My daughter accidentally spilled her juice, I was trying to clean it up but Kayleigh (red haired girl working the register) cleaned up for us without being asked and set us up in another booth. That may not seem like much but it meant a lot to me that she didn't make my daughter feel bad about spilling and quickly accommodated us. read more

Went here for pizza the other night. Had half sausage, half pepperoni on a large pie. It was very good. Ambiance is classic pizza joint. Get your own drinks from the cooler, seat yourself, paper plates, paper napkins, etc. One minor problem is that we waited in vain for someone to come to our table. Then my guest noticed the sign saying please come to counter for service. Unfortunately I couldn't read the sign from across the room. It would have helped if the otherwise friendly and attentive staff would have given us a clue. Highly recommend the pizza, will go back. Now I know the drill! read more

Was told the food is amazing and great price so I ordered online and was told it would be ready from 5:15-5:30. When I got there at 5:30 and they'd only put one of the pizza in until I arrived then they put in the other one and had to wait over 30mins for it and not a single employee said I'm sorry for your wait. The women behind the counter kept snacking on gummy bears and would give a costumer a slice of pizza wouldn't put gloves on nor did she wash her hands which is extremely unsanitary. When I got home the one pizza I asked for well done the crust was hardly crust it was still extremely doughy, and the garlic knots is just bread had no garlic on it and it wasn't cooked it was pure white and I had to add garlic and put it in the oven. Worst experience I've had would not come back. read more

By far the best pizzeria in my radius . And not just their pizza , their appetizers and sandwiches and entrees are always made to my liking and more, the bread is fresh with the sandwiches which I don't feel is that same at others just by the taste and texture . I'm so grateful to have this pizzeria near me overall thankyou so much and don't change a thing! read more

Really, really great pizza!! We happened on Mama Maria's by accident and decided to try a pizza. We finished the entire pie in the restaurant and had them make us another one to take home. They also deliver to a pretty good size area and we have had their pizza for my son's birthday party and a bunch of Friday night dinners as well. If you enjoy good, thin crust pizza, the kind you would expect here in New Jersey, you will not be disappointed!! read more

Mama Maria's Pizza - Mama Maria's cheese pizza with a little bit of added Parmesan cheese. Yummmmm! - Pizza Near Me - West Creek, New Jersey

The latest in a long line of pizza places to take their crack at this horrible location.. Very nice staff. Pizza is actually pretty good for the area . Sandwiches are good-- nice bread good product.. Mussels Marinara was excellent.. Salads and pasta dishes were unremarkable. Overall very so-so.. Great price points-- especially in market where food establishments tend to take advantage of lack of competition and grossly overcharge for a subpar product. Now let's hope for their sake they enjoy a better fate than those who came before in this spot. read more

Aweful experience on 5/26/18. Ordered a chicken ceasar salad and the lettuce was never washed! There was mud/dirt on the lettuce leaves (noticed this) while i was eating (bit down on sand) and then when i picked up a piece of grilled chicken I discovered a dead house fly!! Needless to say I brought back the dirty salad and brought all of this to their attention and was given an attitude and my money back. Never ever going there again!!! read more

Stopped in with granddaughters to get pizza. Asked to use restroom for girls and was told out of order. I stopped there a few times before to pick up pizzas to go and while waiting I heard staff tell customers there restroom was out of order. So for almost a year there restroom has been out of order.How can you have a place that has sit down eating with no restroom. We left there and will never go back to eat there. Pizza was good when I did get it to go. Just be careful when eating in this restaurant that you better be able to hold it and don't want to wash your hands before eating there read more

Love this place! They make the best pizza in the area , the staff are great to deal with and it always has something new and fresh on the counter. This is the type of place I will keep bringing my family to because they have enough great items on the menu that everybody will be happy. I would highly recommend this to anybody living in the area because it will never let you down. read more

Yes the "2 slices for $2.00" is a great draw to get you in the door but there is more to them. The staff is very nice & friendly, place is clean & the food is great too. Sandwiches are good and the fries are seasoned perfectly. Lots of choices for pizza & the Sicilian slices are great but they don't fall under the "special" pricing. This place is worth the stop if you ever travel down Rt. 9. Coke products as well & that just adds to the great flavor of the food. read more

The pizza is good. Service is fast. The owner is very personable. When it comes to local pizza this is my only choice.

Great pizza! I am from New York so very picky about my pizza. I have been living in the area for over a year and couldn't find a great pizza place until now. Love Mama Maria's! There prices are cheap, they deliver, the restaurant is clean, and staff friendly. The Brooklyn pizza is my favorite so far. read more

I had a wonderful meal delivered. Along with one of the best cannoli's I have had in forever!!!!

Beware of this place!! They charged my debit card more money after I left. Assuming it was a tip they added. I'm sure I'm not the only person they've done this to! I will never go here again. read more

I am so happy with this place. When I originally ordered delivery I was told an hour and when it was going to be longer, I received a call letting me know. I was very disappointed and they did their best and managed to meet my expectations. Thank you Mama for consistently striving to Meet and exceed customer expectations with both service , price and food !!! read more

Have stopped for pizza a number of times and it was delicious. However, tried calling in an order on two separate occasions in the last month and was quickly put on hold both times. After waiting almost five minutes, I was disconnected and called right back to be quickly put on hold again! I couldn't even get a chance to say I was disconnected. I actually gave up with waiting and ordered from another local pizzeria instead. Definitely lost business twice with their inability to take orders efficiently by leaving the caller hanging for a long period of time resulting in disconnection of phone call. read more

The 5 stars are not because it's my best friends mom's restaurant. But because the food is so so good! I stop there on my way to my aunts, when I'm leaving the island or before I go to the island or if I'm just popping in. This is because they are very reasonably priced for the quality of the food. Everyone there is like a little family making it very welcoming and comfortable. They care about each of their customers and accommodate what they need. It's a very clean environment and they just added booth seating as well. It's not the biggest place but the food and the customer service is well worth it! read more

First time ordering and the food was great we will be back. Fast service pizza was good and chicken fingers and wrap were also good.

Best pizza place in town! We come here atleast 4 times a week for slices or a sub and everything is always top knotch!

Mama Maria's has excellent pizza and the prices are more than fair. Especially since the price of pizza has gotten ridiculous. I usually stop in on my way to work and grab 2 or 3 slices, or do their 2 pizzas for 18.99 deal. I haven't found a better bargain for non chain pizza like Dominoes or Papa John's. Always good and everybody is friendly. read more

THE BEST pizza in the area. No doubt about it. Haven't tried their food yet but if it's anything like their pizza it's top notch. Quick order times and friendly staff. read more

The food is extremely fresh. We had 3 personal pizzas ( cheese steak, plain and chicken parm). Pasta vodka was excellent. Linguine Bolognese was very good... (Including the carrots) . Mama Maria wrap fresh and delicious. Mozzarella sticks and onion rings were excellent... The sauce with the mozz. sticks was fresh and delicious. The place was packed when we got there but the service was outstanding... read more

Terrible! Stopped by for a few quick slices. The waitress handled the food with her hands, threw garlic powder on it, threw it in the oven and forgot about it. When she realized she forgot, she cursed, threw it on a paper plate and shoved it in a paper bag dripping with grease. Disgusting! It went in the trash can outside. I would not recommend it to anyone. The view of the kitchen from the parking lot side door was equally disgusting, fly swatter and all! read more

I've tried every pizza place I could find that would deliver to us and Mama Maria's by far has been the best. We ordered other items that were ok but it didn't matter since the pizza was excellent. Penne vodka was good, Cheesesteak was good, chicken fingers were decent, mozzarella sticks were good and hot but the garlic knots were not so fresh. But this will definitely be our go to place for pizza from now on. read more

Only had to order once before my wife and I made it our regular spot. Extremely friendly staff and the prices can't be beat. We highly recommend the Grandma pie and Lemon Baked Chicken..... We always change our order and are making our way through the menu. We are never disappointed. read more