People would be very surprised at the quality of food in this quaint restaurant next to the golf range. The spaghetti marinara was amazing....the soup delicious and homemade. The pizza to die for! It's a great spot for real home cooked food.....delicious read more

Food and service is always fabulous. Had a specially prepared broccoli rabbe and chicken dish that wasn't on the menu. Absolutely delicious. :) read more

Stopped into Andiamo's Pizzeria in Randolph for an early lunch...The Margherita and pepperoni slices were outstanding. Staff was friendly and welcoming. read more

Antimo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Margherita & Pepperoni slices - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Been here 5x at least and mostly bc it is close to our house. But NEVER EVER again. There are a plethora of pizza places within 3 minutes from there and another 8 pizza places within 10-15 minutes away and there is NO reason on earth to go to this place. Last night I ordered a pie and an appetizer and was told to come pick it up in 20-minutes. Like a fool, I listened to what they said and as USUAL the order was not ready until 40 minutes later. This has happened every time despite if they were busy or, like their restaurant, stone empty. Worse than the "waste of my time" wait was that the pizza was luke warm and the fried appetizer was not warm, not luke warm and barely room temperature but cold. That went into the garbage where it belongs. Now they wasted my time and my money! Go to one of the many other pizza options within a 10-15-minute drive to receive hot food, prepared on time and just as good or better. read more

Heard Antimo's pizza is great, so I gave it a try. I do concur. The pizza was amazing! I consider myself a pizza connoisseur and I give Antimo's an A+!! read more

Best pizza in the area: thin crisp crust, perfect homemade sauces cooked with love in the family-run kitchen, and, if you're just grabbing a slice, very generous portions at a great price. Among my favorites are the beautiful "grandma" pie and any of the delicious veggie combinations. I also recommend the eggplant rollatine dinner and the meatball sub or pasta dinner, affordable treats that helped make the 2020 quarantine bearable. Service here is always a pleasure, and dietary preferences are accomodated. read more

Best Pizza in Randolph! The owner is the best, great conversations and is very friendly. Love the wide selection of specialty pizza slices. Ingredients taste fresh, Homemade sauce and the best cheese. read more

Ordered pizza takeout while visiting family in the area. We ordered a half vodka and half margherita pie and a personal Buffalo chicken pie. The first pie was delicious! I love how they drizzle pesto on the pie to add a nice herby flavor to the pie. The Buffalo chicken pizza was alright, it wasn't the best pizza we had it was a little dry. Overall this is a great takeout pizza place! read more

Antimo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Pizza continues to be consistently good. Service is friendly. This review and previous are based on takeout / pizza only. Will continue to return to this location. Can get busy when mini golf and driving range active. read more

Good place to get some food but I would say the carbonara was tasty it was not true carbonara. More like bacon and cream. The pizza was ok and the crust was very hard to chew. The onion rings were also ok. It was an average pizza place and I would probably not order the same pizza but would give the regular pizza a try. read more

Antimo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Carbonara - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

See all

Overpriced and inedible food. Ordered Calamari and it smelled bad and tasted like it was spoilt. 2 small pizzas and an appetizer costs over 50$ which is ridiculously overpriced. Won't be coming back here. read more

My family has eaten at Antimo's a couple of times. The place is clean and you can eat inside or outside and the people, service and food were great. A few days ago, I ordered for delivery and the food (a large meat Sicilian pie, sausage roll, calamari and a large regular pie). All of it arrived on a few minutes before expected, food was hot and the delivery person was nice. Everyone remarked at how hot, delicious and well proportioned everything was. The pizza crust is definitely a recipe that I would love; whole family was talking about it. The sausage roll was very good. The calamari it was nicely done and, even though it was delivered, it wasn't soggy. We will be reordering from them. My family definitely recommends them. If you like golf or have little ones that like mini-golf, you should go next door then stop here for a bite to eat and save yourselves from the dishes. Buon appetito! read more

Stopped in here for pizza and really loved the place! I've driven past it so many times. It's right next to the mini golf in Randolph. Friends of ours said it was great and they were right! Many good pizza selections, I went for a slice with vodka sauce, pesto, and mozzarella. A little sloppy, but very good! Prices were reasonable, parking easy, and very friendly service. I'll be back to try some of those other slices! read more

Antimo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Vodka sauce, pesto, and mozzarella!! - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

First time ordering from this restaurant after reading the reviews. The food was actually really really good. You get a lot in the portion as well. There was a delay from the restaurant so the food came a bit later than we would have liked. I would still try them again I was very pleased. read more

Best pizza in the area. Sauce is stellar and such great chew on the crust. Ambiance is just ok, so come here just for pizza takeout.

Stop by for an eggplant Parm sandwich, which I had years ago which I enjoyed. I tried it again and it had to be the worst I've ever had greasy soggy got a stomachache after eating it. read more

Delicious, fresh, thin crust pizza. Tried the margherita w stripes of marinara and pesto and the pepperoni - so good. My husband had the same and a slice with fresh sausage - just excellent. Francesca couldn't have been more courteous. Will definitely be back! Highly recommend. read more

Love our local pizza place! Delicious pies and great hard working people who help run it.

Skip over Frank T's negative review of this place- he obviously doesn't know anything about food or good service from nice people. Pizza is too thin? Take your first amendment non sense to Dominos.. anyways.. Antimo's hands down has the best pizza in the area- if your not in the mood for the pizza go for a cheesesteak- actually was better than one I had a month ago in philly. David's chocolate chip cookies available at the register - make sure to grab a few. This place is a Randolph staple. 5 stars every time. read more

The owner did not agree with my review, so he made a threat of a lawsuit, STAY AWAY from this place. I stand by my option that the food is poor and now I think the owner has issues. Rather than take it as a constructive review to make the place better the owner stooped to threats. STAY AWAY, STAY AWAY MY 1st Amendment rights say I can say this place is no good. I will not change due to threats. read more

Margarita pie is fantastic. Crust is on the crispier side which is exactly what I like, and I love the drizzle of pesto on top. The garlic knots are great too and they provide ample marinara sauce for dipping. Ordering and paying online makes pickup a breeze. read more

Antimo's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Margarita pie - Italian Near Me - Randolph, New Jersey

Good food and nice staff !!,trying their hardest through the covad to satisfy,much appreciated!!

We ordered from here for the first time today... Delivery was very quick compared to other places, garlic knots were delicious, pizza was cooked perfectly, and a good price as well... We have tried several pizzerias locally and I think this might be my new favorite! Update 3/2018: officially the only place we order pizza from. Their specialty pizza is amazing, vodka pesto pizza, thinly sliced eggplant pizza, and their regular pies are just This place is the only place in Randolph serving great pizza love it! read more

The 2 pizzas and fries we ordered were so bad we took a few bites and went out to get food elsewhere. We read previous reviews stating the food was good here so we have it a try. It is not. Cold . Cardboard. No flavor. The grandmas pie was nothing more than a cheese pizza in the shape of a square. Super bummed we wasted si much money and time ordering from here. read more

Not bad... Decent pizza at a decent price. I come here because I've been taking golf lessons at the adjacent course. It's close enough to my home but I don't know that I'd ever go out of my way to come by. That being said, if you're going to play a bit of golf, this is a great place to grab some food. My biggest complaint is that they don't have crushed pepper flake shakers on the tables (or parmesan) which is a pretty standard sight in NY/NJ pizzerias. read more

The best pizza in Randolph (and there are numerous pizzerias here). The sauce and crust are always great and they have so many options available. Try their entrees as well -- the pasta with vodka sauce, veal parm, and pasta fagioli are our favorites. read more

I never review most "in town" pizza joints because they are mostly not memorable. There was a time before pizza franchises, deep dish pizza and California pizza when great NY Style pizza reigned supreme in NJ. In the last 10 years, mostly due to the pizza wars, almost all local pizza places have been forced to cut prices and quality to survive. One day last week while at my favorite local golf driving range I see a grand opening sign for Antimo's. I decide to grab a slice after golf expecting the usual local pizza joint experience and what I got was completely different. Antimo's is "old school" Brooklyn pizza - light and crunchy crust with bright flavored (not thick sweet) uncooked tomato sauce and the right amount of cheese - the perfect NY style slice. Went back a few days later for another slice and a chicken parm sandwich and loved both again. Went back again and tried the Sicilian slice which may be the best Sicilian slice in Morris County. If you are a fan of real NY Style pizza check out Antimo's - its the pizza place that looks like a house, near the Mt Freedom driving range and across the street from another pizza place!! read more

Love the pizza here. I dream about the Buffalo chicken pie with tender nuggets of chicken. The chicken ranch with bacon is decadent. The margarita pies with either marinara or vodka sauce (to die for!) Or a pie half and half!! Amazing carbonara pasta too. And best value is the Monday Tuesday large cheese pie for ~$9 we always try to pick one up to save on dishes each week. Always perfect crust and thickness. I'm a pizza fanatic and lived in Morristown and lucky to have this in Randolph. It's a small place so call ahead, chill out and have patience and enjoy the pizza. read more

Vodka pie is very good and my go to. Other pies are solid but sometimes can be inconsistent (great one day ok the next).

Really good food and fairly priced. Service can be slow but if you know what you are in for its not an issue. Very cozy and friendly environment read more

Antimo's is the perfect place to grab a slice, enjoy a good conversation and eat some awesome food. They care about Pizza and it comes through with every pie. We love the fact they grill and cook the veggies a bit before throwing them on the awesome dough. We like our Pizza "Well Done" and this is our new favorite place. On top of the great Pizza, and Pasta, the staff and owners are friendly and caring. Always greet you with a smile and seem happy to be a part of the community. With three young boys Pizza is a staple and we never go wrong with Antimo's. read more

Delicious Pizza plan and simple. Visited Antimo's for a pizza and garlic knots while back in New Jersey. The location is convenient to access. They have a small dining room and do lots of carry out. Staff was friendly and quick. The pizza was great, loved the fresh sauce very and high quality cheese. I really like the garlic knots as well. Overall a delicious slice from start to finish! read more

Pizza was freshly made and delicious. Staff was friendly and courteous. I will definitely stop there again!

Great family business in our little neighbor. Love it there! Always a stop for us after sports and when I don't have time to cook! Our favorite is the meatball and onion pizza. Yummy read more

I came again for a slice. This time I had one with sausage. It was a very big slice probably one of six not one of eight. Great sauce great crust great cheese proportion. I would get 5 stars if they made me feel like they actually gave a darn that I walked in the door. read more

The servers strolled in after 12 (12 is when they open on a Sunday) & nothing was ready. 6 people were in the restaurant waiting to be helped..the food took FOREVER & the lasagna was pretty tasteless. Extremely overpriced kids menu with tiny portions. Never again. read more

Antimo's has probably the best pizza dough / crust around here. They do a good job with any kind of pie you want. The crust is to die for. Feels like NYC pizza. Used to work there in town and that was one of of my favorite places. They definitely are better than Pizza Palace, which is down the street, and sucks. Friendly staff. Will accomodate any request. I'm telling you, the crust and sauce are super legit. read more

This restaurant needs to get their act together. We placed an online order through their website (it is the pandemic). My son went to pick the order up and they couldn't find the order anywhere. My son came home. I called them and gave them the details, order number etc. and they still couldn't figure it out. About five minutes later of haggling with me reiterating once again that yes, we ordered and we pre-paid and here is the order number yet again, he pipes up, " we have your order" - no apology, no acknowledgement that for about five minutes on the phone he swore we didn't order anything. No mention at all. Like it didn't happen. read more

Amazing TRUE New York Style Pizza done right. The crust is perfectly cooked, and it balances well with hot the top of the pizza is cooked (too many pizzeria's have well cooked crust, and the cheese is not melted on the top of the pizza!). This is one of my GO-TO pizzeria's, and is a favorite of my family and many friends! read more

First time trying this eatery and I was pleasantly surprised. Note: if you order the Sicilian pizza; it is way too much for one person. One week later, and I am still eating it, but it is delicious! Great food and I would definitely order again! read more