Awesome ambiance & food. The restaurant is pleasing to the eye with its beautiful chandeliers throughout the restaurant and with a bar with a fun vibe. read more

If one hears again about how the chef attended the French Culinary Institute, any person involved with this group will go into hiding... the restaurant's food is basic fare of the usual suspects of hummus plates and whole grilled fish. The vibe doesnt seem to fit Rye NY and the staff does have the experience to match the pedigree of a NYC based restaurant group. Go if you want pretense served with diner inspired Greek food washed down with antiquated cocktails... you will love it... read more

First visit ever to Antique Garage in Rye. This restaurant is without question beautiful in design and decor with inside and outdoor space ideal for the Summer crowd. There is extra space for drinks in the back of the restaurant on Adirondack chairs. The hostesses are wonderful- warm and charming as you enter the restaurant and they were accommodating in selecting a table. A great smile goes a long way in this day and age of at times indifferent service. The food quality is good but perhaps not great. The starters were fine but not particularly special or memorable. The Entrees were better, especially the whole Branzini and sides are extra ($12 for fries but they were very good). The crowd is very stylish and upscale- without question the Westchester country club set. Prices are very high for all courses with $40 entrees the norm. $42 for lamb kebab. $42 for Branzini. Martinis are $24. Service from the wait staff was what I would call a bit gruff. They seem to be in it for the payday as opposed to really relishing and delivering service & hospitality. The bartenders also seem to want to be on the other side of the bar. The music selection is very good as it sets the mood for a festive evening. My wife really loves this experience as it's upscale & even glitzy. Me, much less so. Perhaps it will become more of a girls night out place with more style than substance the norm. read more

I really never write reviews but felt compelled to after last night. One thing to preface...the food was good, no issues there. Everything was fresh and flavorful. Now, the service. Where to begin.... First, we had a 7:30 reservation that I made a month ago for 8 people. Upon entry they said the table was delayed...fine, no big deal. Then they said they gave the table away because some older people didn't like the noise inside. Would have been nice to be asked before giving away the table. Even then we did not make a big deal. When we sit down and order drinks, they don't come for over 20 minutes. When we asked the waiter he said "that's not too long, 20 minutes for drinks is normal!" Seriously? When we ordered a bottle of wine? He just fills all our glasses to empty the bottle, he clearly didn't feel like refilling it for us...as in...actual service so our wine stays cold. Overall, sadly I don't think I'll be returning as the service was so bad that the positive food does not outweigh the negative service. read more

Went here to celebrate our 9th anniversary. We first had a cocktail at the bar, which is well stocked and beautiful. Drinks were reasonable and we received nice pours. Dinner service at our table was fantastic. Our waiter was extremely friendly and attentive and the food was delicious. The mezzw trio, with hummus, baba ganoush and tzatziki was great. And the light and fluffy pita was the best I've ever had! Sea bream crudo appetizer was enough for an entree, and was perfect. Entrees of grilled salmon and chicken kabob were large and cooked to perfection. This is definitely a go to place. The only drawback is that it's very loud, but in the summer with the extension open, it's likely not as noisy. read more

Loved this restaurant from the minute I set foot in it. The space is open, inviting and I'm in love with the decor and vintage furniture. My son and family were stuck in traffic and all the staff were extremely accommodating and understanding. Everything we ate was bursting with flavor, the children were famished when they arrived and completely satisfied when we left, including the adults. Every dish was fresh, simple, elegant and delightfully flavorful. I can't wait to go back! read more

Good service, fun place. My friends and I have shared good times there. The food is ok. It has a middle eastern flare to it.

Beautiful restaurant!!! Great food. Have been for lunch a dinner and every time has been a fantastic experience. read more

This is the most amazing new restaurant - delicious food, great service and wonderful ambiance. This is not your typical Mediterranean restaurant- it is a truly elegant fine dining experience. The food is made from the finest, freshest ingredients - the fish is flown in daily from the Mediterranean. This will be my family's special occasion place. I really can't say enough good things about my experience there. I am a foodie - and have to say this was the best meal I've had since I was last in Paris. Do yourselves a favor and treat yourselves to a truly amazing dining experience. read more

Atmosphere is fabulous. Food is delicious.! Very friendly service. Love the decor. Always a great meal read more

Delicious food, excellent service, exceptional ambience. Enjoyed everything about this place!

Good food but overpriced. $21 cocktails, $20 glass of white wine. $28 for mussel appetizer. Excellent service. Dining room crowded and noisy. Tables almost touching each other. Erroneously charged for $8 cappuccino not ordered or received. read more

Loud, unable to converse. Food bland and mediocre. Expensive without sides unless you add $12 to your bill. Beautiful design does not compensate for unacceptable dining experience. read more

Starts with uninviting staff. Music so loud you can't think straight. Dinner was subpar. And dessert comes in a refrigerated glass. Then I noticed on my bill they charged $1 for a roll to share for dipping in the appetizer we ordered.You would think they could throw that in with the prices they charge, Its a pretty restaurant. But there are much better places to eat in Westchester. read more

This place is beautiful. The service was attentive. Food was tasty. But the prices compared to the portions were offensive. Ordered the Tirokafteri( small portion of spicy feta dip, priced at $12. It was placed on our table with a basket containing 2 warm rolls. ( The dip was so small we only used 1 of the rolls) When we got the check we were charged $2 for the rolls that we did not order/ask for, just assumed it came with the dip. It's not the price but the principal. But alas, it's Rye so maybe it's just me. 3 stars because I left feeling like I had just been robbed. read more

Love this place! Amazing food in a beautiful atmosphere. Ignore those negative reviews from philistines - this is just what Rye needs - a lovely, delicious special occasion restaurant where you can dress up and drink fabulous wines and eat finely prepared food in an elegant atmosphere with attentive service. My entire party agreed this is the type of restaurant we've all been waiting for. I highly recommend it and can't wait to go back. read more

Id suggest skipping this place and driving 10 mins up to Mediterraneo in Greenwich, ct. We arrived and had a reservation and the restaurant was empty except for one party and we were seated in the very back across from the back door where they kept opening to take out the trash, near the bathroom. The restaurant was totally empty and I could probably count at least 10 empty spaces for two. We asked to move and they gave us an issue even though the restaurant was pretty empty. Very rude hostess and owner but wait staff was wonderful. Overheard hostess rush everyone seated near us and said that they needed their table soon so they better order quick. Food was mediocre, soggy and tough tasted like they heated it up from a freezer. Everything is way better and fresh at Mediteraneo in Greenwich! Mediterraneo also does not cook with seed oils or refined oils that are bad for you read more

great food, amazing atmosphere. The drinks were amazing! We went for a late lunch/ early dinner. We had the chicken and lamb kebabs, Tirokafteri, & Santorini salad. Phenomenal. Will definitely go back. read more

Antique Garage- Rye - Mediterranean Near Me - Rye, New York

Came here with my friend for dinner and had a fantastic experience. The staff was incredibly friendly and took the time to answer all our questions about the menu. The food and drinks were top notch I had the grilled Dorado, which was perfectly cooked, and my friend had the Lamb chops, which were equally delicious. The ambiance is beautiful and really adds to the overall experience. This place is exactly what Rye was missing. Definitely coming back! read more

Inexperienced and unprofessional. We we're treated poorly as soon as we arrived. We arrived on time for our 6:00 reservation but they couldn't find it. Not sure who was at fault here but with the hostess and manager both at the desk we cheerfully asked if they could seat our party of 4 anyway. the restaurant was mostly empty!! They said it would have to be for a short stay then changed that to "we can seat you at the bar." The other couple are locals and will spread the word. There are so many restaurants in Rye---) avoid Antique Garage! read more

I have eaten at Antique Garage in Rye twice now. Food is excellent, as is the service and ambience. I look forward to returning.

Don't trust Reservation system though the web site says Called three days in a row in early afternoon and no one picks up. I know it a new restaurant but they need to get it together No star read more

Very Noisy, food is nothing exciting. Over priced and service was poor. Would not go back. read more

Do not go there. Too crowded and too noisy. Service and food ok. We asked for a different table and was told no even though there were other tables available (until we left). read more

We been waiting to try this place but couldn't get a reservation for dinner. Was it worth the wait, nope. It is so loud that you can't have a conversation and everyone is on top of each other but the worse part is the rude waitstaff. The way they speak to you is shocking. It is like you are bothering them when you ask them for something. I had one roll his eyes at me as I ordered cause I asked if I can substitute the fries. Food was overpriced and subpar. read more

Testing an elegant furnishing. Very attentive service. Menu is extremely limited and the prices are extremely high. A special events place. Very busy bar, that can be quite noisy at happy hour. read more

People must go for the ambiance because the food was mediocre at best. We ordered the hummus for an appetizer which was lackluster - I've had better from whole foods. My friend ordered the seafood pasta which she said was just ok. I ordered the lamb shish kabob which tasted like something I could have gotten at a street fair. If you want to try this place, know you're going for the vibe and to sit outside or at the bar and have a nice cocktail because you definitely won't be going for the food. The prices were also on the high side. Service was attentive and solid. read more

Food was very fresh but very expensive! Salads are great, and desserts are better! Vibe is fun, (train is a bit loud) but overall it is a fun place! read more

Beautiful restaurant. Food was good. Service was excellent. A bit pricey. Lunch for two was close to three hundred dollars with with tip. That's an expensive lunch. read more

The food was ok. However "ok" the food was, however, could not at all compensate for the poor service, amount of time waiting, and poor hospitality. Seriously, I had to call the waiter over multiple times to ask if the kitchen had forgotten about us. His response was something to the effect of "I don't control the kitchen. I'm the waiter. Don't blame me, please." We had a 7:30 reservation for 2 on a Tuesday night--hardly a peak time in Rye, and we waited 45 minutes for our appetizers with absolutely nothing on our table except our original place settings and water. Our waiter avoided eye contact with us despite passing our table multiple times. There was no apology for the inordinately long wait time, nor a simple offer of some bread for the table. About 30 minutes after the appetizers, our main course finally arrives. The whole fish for 2 is presented to us and then disappears out of our sight for about 10 minutes for it to be filleted. A huge platter is then placed in the middle of our tiny table with no serving utensils. Finally, we receive some utensils with no offer to remove the platter after I serve the fish to my husband and me. We had to ask for its removal so that we could have some room on the tiny table. There was a complete lack of caring or any feeling of hospitality. The whole experience was completely disappointing. It seemed to me that neither the kitchen nor wait staff knew what they were doing. We will not be going back. read more

No idea what those couple bad reviews were taking about!!! Food was fresh, healthy, and prepared masterfully. Staff was working hard, food may have taken a little long, but who cares?!?! The atmosphere was elegant and tasteful read more

Fine for dinks food is good not great. Definitely not worth the price. Service is sloooooow.

Food and service were great. Branzino was cooked perfectly and the atmosphere very inviting.

Delicious food. Great service. Love the atmosphere. Everything we ordered from the cocktails, to the apps, to the entrees were all amazing. We will definitely be back. read more

Food and drinks are great decor is top notch ! Love the atmosphere ! Very nice waitstaff

The music was so loud we couldn't hear the people at our table. The price was too high for such average food. They were not accommodating when I asked for something other than potato with my entree. Strict no substitution policy, which does not take into account people's dietary needs. This was our first time and last time there. read more

Came for brunch! Fun and relaxed atmosphere. Would definitely go back. The staff was friendly, the food was good. Will be back for dinner next time. read more

The ambiance is amazing to all the little details. Food and service is amazing definitely coming back again.

The staff is amazing and the food is incredible. I went with my partner and had a fabulous time. It's absolutely beautiful inside.

Great experience--just what the area needed! I came with my partner for his birthday, and we had a wonderful time. The grilled octopus and baklava were the highlights of the night. Definitely coming back! read more