SFGATE Best Pizza of the Bay 2026 50 Top Pizza USA (2026):…read moreTied for No. 2 in the U.S. 50 Top Pizza World (2025): Ranked No. 10 in the world. I met my dear friend here for dinner on Friday night and it was packed inside and out. The wait was about an hour or so, even with her calling that morning to put her name on the waiting list. We walked around and had a drink next door. Plan accordingly! My friend highly recommend the Meatball Gigante. It's one giant Meatball with your choice of sauce. We got the wild mushrooms, pancetta cream sauce. The sauce is where the magic happens. You can easily dip an entire loaf of bread with that addicting sauce. The meatball is full of flavors. They menu says they limit 25 orders a day. I guess we were lucky! We also got the Fried Ricotta Stuffed Squash Blossoms. I have been wanting to try this dish. I remember my old Italian neighbor used to ask my mom for the blossoms each year. Not my favorite but it was okay. For the star of the night, we got the New Yorker pizza (gold medal winner Las Vegas) with sliced mozzarella, hand crushed tomato sauce, cup & char pepperoni, sliced sweet 7 spicy Italian sausage, ricotta, chopped garlic & oregano. The crust is perfect. You know it's legit when sauce is dripping out from the corner of your mouth when you take a bite and the cheese is still pulling away. I love it that the slices are cut big so you can fold it in half. IYKYK. I see what the hype is about! We sat outside to reduce the wait time. I would love to sit inside the next time I come back and I want to try other dishes. The menu is huge and I hardly made a dent. A gem in San Francisco!

Quite simply the best pizza we've ever had! The meatballs were flavorful, the garlic bread was nice…read moreand crispy- We took the extra garlic and put it on the New Yorker for even more flavor.

This was my first bite after landing in SF on a solo trip, and it's still one of the things I think…read moreabout most when I reminisce on it. I'm not even much of a pizza person, but it was really incredible. The dough was light and fluffy with the perfect crust, and the pepperoni was nice and crispy. Not much sauce, which is controversially how I prefer my pizza. And, importantly, not overly greasy. Waited in line about 30 minutes, another 5 for my name to be called, walked back to my hotel, and ate it in bliss. This place is a must for anyone who finds themselves in North Beach.

Thoroughly enjoyed this literal hole in the wall…read more We tried the clam and garlic pizza and a combo slice - the zucchini was a fun addition to what was otherwise just a slice of supreme pizza. I don't know what I expected from the clam and garlic slice, but the flavor wasn't overwhelming from either ingredient, however it was delicious. The team here is quick and efficient in a very busy pickup window. We took our slices for a 3 minute walk to the beautiful park at Washington Square to enjoy our lunch - highly recommend.

My partner really wanted to try it and he brought it to a birthday party! It was amajor hit and…read moredisappeared in minutes. We got the vodka pizza packed of cheese and some basil leaves. It was delicious and reslly satifsying. The food is on the pricier side for pizza. It is well worth the try!

TIME: came here around 4:20 pm on a tuesday, wasn't really that packed at all…read more PARKING: only street parking and maybe a few parking garages, but if you're lucky enough you could find some parking EXTERIOR: in the tenderloin, around other shops, kind of a small entrance from the looks of the outside. INTERIOR: small space, mainly for takeout, a few tables, but not a lot where many people can sit. mainly just a place for people to eat and hangout then leave SERVICE: just go up to the counter and order then they will call your name and you pick up from over the pizza counter where the display is. FOOD: HOT BURRATA - the sauce, burrata, and whole pizza was just fresh. loved it CHICKEN TINGA - super good but some bites to me were just a tad bit bland. would rather get pepperoni OVERALL: super solid pizza place, love the unique types they have

it's quiet in here on a weekday at lunch. order then find yourself a seat. pizza takes a while…read morebecause theyre making it fresh for you. nice interior, clean and spacious. you can even hangout upstairs where there's even more seating. the larger tables are downstairs. solo dining upstairs would work. service was kind and gave me lots of water to go with my meal PIZZA was GOOD. tried the buffalo chicken. it's more of a rectangle shape and just a good size slice. pretty filling! you will be full with just 2 slices. lunch time hours offers half pie so you dont have to buy a whole pie

*** Sorry, I meant to post this for the Beach Street restaurant, not Mission St. ***…read more======= This is my 2nd time having tasty, crisp pizza at this restaurant. I love having the Ellen pizza and a beer each time I visit. This time, I ordered the Ellen and the Mushroom pizza. The mushroom pizza was on the "sweet" side. Next time, I'll just order 2 Ellen pizzas! They are baked perfectly and each piece of pizza has wonderful baked perfectly crust! LOVE the Ellen pizza most! The mushroom pizza seemed like it was very sparse on ingredients, never again. I always ask for crispy but not burnt. I also take my leftovers home in a nice "to go" box for evening snack or lunch the next day. Service is fast, friendly and efficient. Thank You for the yummy pizzas each time! See you next time! :0)

Exactly what we were looking for! Chill spot, super laid…read moreback vibe. Order at the counter and sit situation. We ate too fast to get any photos. Pesto ricotta pizza was superrrr good! Hot honey was good but maybe a bit heavy on the honey side. Meatballs were great. Salad had a copious amount of croutons (yum, mix with leftover meatball sauce!). Vibes and food are great! Grateful Dead/ Jam band merch all around. Will definitely be back! Thank you

Cozy and delicious! The pizza is exactly what I like in pizza, thin and with creative flavors…read more Inside, you have tables in an area that is cozy and it's very well decorated. We ordered 2 small pizzas for four people. The only downside is that you can't do half one flavor and half the other. You have to commit. The service is friendly and kind. Would recommend if you can reach consensus on what pizza you want . Some of my friends did say that the meatballs were delicious (I just wanted pizza), and they would have wanted the bottom the pizza to be more toasted. I didn't have that issue so again it's all about preferences. They also, offer non alcoholic beer!

Celebrating my gal Samantha early birthday. "Happy Birthday"…read more IL Casaro Pizzeria & Mozzarella Bar Server - Pedro, was very quick and helpful with choosing amazing dishes for us. NV Sparkling Lambrusco, Modena Insalata Romana Polpette Al Sugo Lumache Al Pesto Such a fun place and there pretty red oven baking all the pizzas. Love the Italian style furniture. Great seating in door and outdoor. A must visit.

Ambiance: I really liked the indoor seating! They also have outdoor seating but it was a little too…read morecold and not as nice. They were able to seat our party of 8 which worked out perfectly. Service: Our server was great! He even gave us a suggestion of adding tomato sauce to our pizza, which I really liked. Food: I will say I have had better Italian food in the city. But that doesn't mean their food isn't good! I enjoyed the pesto pasta and Quattro Formaggi pizza. Tasted more blue cheese than goat cheese in the pizza. Pesto pasta was nice. Definitely would recommend asking for chili oil. Don't have too much at once though, it is spicy.

Delicious quick slice of pizza after watching the niners game. Right in the heart of hayes valley…read more Ordered and got served our food real quick. The place is small but there's seating outside and near the area. I had the SUMMER SQUASH: pesto, garlic, ricotta, mozz, pecorino and my friend got the pepperoni. Both were delicious. The pricing isn't too bad either for what we got.

Ordered the Salsiccia 28 inch pie and it was SO GOOD. Super flavorful and hits THE SPOT. I loved it…read moreso much. I ordered the pizza to go and had to wait around 20 mins and it was very worth. The sausage on the pizza was super good, the only thing I wish was for the jalepeno to be spicier and thicker with more jalapeño flavor. Overall would definitely get again!

We've ordered from here a few times now. They only offer one pizza size, large. It's a good size…read moreand they do a very nice thin crust pizza. We get a few custom toppings. Usually Green Peppers, Red Onions, and Black Olives. They do a very nice job with it. The service is very friendly. They are busy, so if you are picking up yourself plan to wait a few minutes. But it's worth it. The ambiance is kind of cool. They have fun booths that remind me of an 80's roller rink. It would be a fun place to share a pizza or two with friends.

I did a little research and found The Pizza Shop, which was well rated and in the area I wanted to…read moretake my date. I was planning to order a whole pie, but since it was our first time there, I wanted to try more than one kind. Thankfully, The Pizza Shop was happy to accommodate. We ordered a pie that was half Cherry Pepper and Pesto and half White Spinach. My date and I really enjoyed both pizzas. I don't think I've eaten a lot of cherry peppers in my life - they are spicy! The Pizza Shop doesn't mess around - their pies are huge. We ate two slices each and I grabbed a box for the leftovers. The atmosphere is noteworthy: there is a pinball machine and the music is a little bit loud, but we were able to have a conversation without much difficulty. I would not hesitate to return to The Pizza Shop.

A friend from high school gave me a choice of five restaurants in the West Portal and Ocean Avenue…read morearea, and I naturally picked That's Amore. We ordered the Garden Pizza and the Chicken Garlic Pizza. The Garden Pizza had a light, fresh flavor, and I loved all the vegetables on it. Both pizzas were delicious with thin, wood-fired crusts that were perfectly crisp. For dessert, we shared the lava cake with ice cream, and it was so good! Definitely the perfect way to end the meal. We came on a weeknight around 6:00 p.m. They also do a lot of takeout, so it's clearly a neighborhood favorite. A fun little touch: water is served in repurposed wine bottles. Be sure to check out the secret menu and secret dessert menu displayed inside--you might find something extra to try. I actually picked That's Amore because I attended a Yelp Community event there earlier in the month and was really impressed. That was my first visit, and I knew I wanted to come back. I'm glad I did. Recommend!

We were really excited to try this place and actually drove about an hour just to come here, so…read moreunfortunately our experience was extremely disappointing. When we arrived, our waitress didn't seem very knowledgeable about the beers, but honestly, that wasn't a big deal. My boyfriend ordered his pizza while I was still deciding what I wanted. His pizza came out very quickly, which we had no complaints about. The issue started when we had barely been seated for about 15 minutes. I went to the restroom, and while I was gone, the waitress approached my boyfriend while he literally had pizza in his mouth and a full beer in front of him and told him, "My chef said to charge you." He was confused but said okay because it made us wonder if they were closing. I checked the hours, and they weren't supposed to close until 10 PM--it was barely around 9 PM. I HADN'T EVEN ORDERED MY FOOD YET. I was still planning on ordering my own pizza, dessert, and a drink. Instead, we suddenly felt like we were being rushed to pay and leave. What made the situation even more unprofessional was that she left the payment device at our table for Apple Pay and then actually left the restaurant. She was the only server we had seen around, so we were basically left sitting there with the payment device and no server. We eventually had to get up ourselves to find someone so we could ask for boxes and return their payment device. No one had even asked whether we needed boxes, wanted anything else, or were finished ordering. My boyfriend didn't even finish his beer because at that point the entire vibe had changed and we just wanted to leave. We had driven an hour specifically to try this restaurant and were genuinely excited about it, which made the experience even more disappointing. I completely understand if a server's shift is ending, but there is a professional way to handle that--especially when customers are still actively eating and one person at the table hasn't even ordered yet. Someone could have simply explained that her shift was ending and introduced whoever would be taking over our table. Instead, we were made to feel like we needed to pay and leave. Unfortunately, the service completely overshadowed the experience. We really wanted to like this place, but being treated this way after driving an hour to come here was extremely disappointing and unprofessional.

Service is outstanding! Pizza is fire! Everyone's so nice here! I would highly recommend this place…read moreif you're looking for a late night pizza with impeccable hospitality‍

This place makes fantastic pinsa! Service was so friendly and quick! The owners are an older…read moreTurkish/Persian couple (hope I remembered that correctly). Seems like they are a local favorite. Inside is small, but decorated very well and has great lighting. All the pinsas we ordered were so yummy. Crust was a fantastic texture (great thickness, a little chewy, and crispy)!! Flavors were all great! We got a Diavola pinsa too (not pictured), which is a customer favorite (for good reason)! All the ingredients were just fresh and yummy. Everything about this place was exceptional and they deserve more love and support!