First time here. I was originally planning to drive to Brady Street and visit Sciortino's, but then…read moreI came across Scordato's. I'm glad I did. Food: I found all the classic Italian bakery treats I was hoping for, including cannolis, cream horns, and an assortment of cookies. Rather than trying to decide, I asked the person behind the counter to put together a selection for me. I mean, how can you go wrong? It's all good! Service: There were a few people ahead of me, but it didn't take long to reach the counter. The person helping me was pleasant, although not much for small talk. The entire visit took no more than five minutes. Easy breezy! Atmosphere: The storefront features large windows that let you see inside before you even walk in. They also bring in plenty of natural light, making it easy to browse all of the bakery items. The display cases were well organized and easy to navigate, so it was simple to get a good look at everything. After getting home and sampling my assortment, I realized I don't always have to drive downtown to Milwaukee to satisfy my Italian bakery cravings.

I have seen Scordato advertised on Facebook and I finally got there! Great selection and friendly…read moreservice!

I LOVE C Adam's bakery. They've been in the MPM as long as I've been alive. Their cookie dough cake…read morejar is to die for. Their brownies are always delicious, too. They are reasonably priced, especially in this era of expensive pastries. Service is always very friendly!!

I love this bakery located in the Public Market. I've been here many of times and have tried…read morevarious desserts from cupcakes, cakes, macarons, cake pops, and cheesecake! I have never been disappointed by a dessert but their cheesecake, cakes pops, and macarons are my favorite! The staff is always super friendly, quick, and welcoming. The display is big and lit so customers are able to see the different goodies and they have flavors that rotate so it isn't the same desserts every time. Very cute place!

Been here several times, and I try to stop in whenever I'm in the Brady Street neighborhood…read more They have a wonderful selection of classic Italian cookies, making it hard to leave empty-handed. This visit, we picked up a small box of assorted cookies. We also got a couple of cupcakes that we planned to enjoy right away. Mine was Chocolate Turtle and the other was Carrot Cake. Thankfully, they had napkins and forks available, which came in handy. Both were delicious. The service has always been excellent, with friendly people behind the counter who make each visit pleasant. Sciortino's is a must-stop if you're looking for delicious Italian cookies and other bakery treats.

Friendly staff and very tasty pastries! I shopped here with a friend and the AC was very nice to…read moreget away from the heat outside.

I was sticker SHOCKED by a dinner totaling $27. Believe me it was a normal size to go container…read more Like one dinner is $27, in a typical to go container. The food was mid. Was mad the whole weekend. Be prepared for $5+ cupcakes. The cupcakes were amazing but again small for over $5. It is very hard to find a decent soul food place in Milwaukee.

I almost missed trying this place because of some 10+ year old reviews, so be aware of that when…read moreassessing this business. I was incredibly impressed with a caramel cake I purchased. It was truly wa sone of, if not the best, caramel cakes I've ever had. I am very critical of baked good because I am a baker myself. She does a masterful job of developing and balancing flavors without her desserts being overly sweet. The texture of her caramel is silky and the flavor was decadent. The cake was the perfect balance of the appropriate moisture and density, especially for caramel cake. I had no issue with my customer service. The prices were more than I was expecting but when I tasted her cake I understood how they are justified. I am eager to try more of her treats. Kudos!

At first, I was not feeling very positive when I walked in the door, and there were two employees…read morewho turned their backs on me as I was the only one there. Didn't even greet the customer which kinda left a bad taste in my mouth. But then, everything switched when I received my order of delectable desserts! Everything is made fresh and with care they just need to work on their customer approach. It is a very important selling point when you greet customers when they enter your establishment. Make them feel welcome and acknowledged as a human being. Thank you!

Seriously- THE BEST carrot cake cupcakes. So good, I ordered some for hub's birthday. A big, big…read morehit.

We ordered over the phone for pickup, and the process was quick and seamless. The staff was…read moreincredibly friendly and took the time to answer my questions about the menu. The sandwiches were affordable, fresh, and delicious. I highly recommend adding a Danish and a side of coleslaw, they paired perfectly with the sandwich and rounded out the meal. The restaurant has a cozy, hometown feel with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. We'll definitely be back!

Today is March 26, 2026 and it is Brewers opening day! I decided to stop here for some cookies for…read moremy family and friends. The staff was really really nice with the ambience as soon as you walk in the door you could smell the ham delicious.!!

The last time The Cake Lady made us a cake was for our a gender reveal in 2021, and here we are…read morefour years later, she has now made a birthday cake for our son! Cecelia is so easy to get in touch with and communicate the vision. It's as simple as filling out the contact form on her website. She was quick to respond and request a few additional details about the cake we were looking to have made, including size, filling, and flavors. We went with a small round cake for 8-10 people, and I sent over a few photos of what I had in mind for the 'Cars theme.' I paid the digital invoice that came through via email, and picked up on our requested date. Easy as that. Oh and of course my son and all of his friends loved the cake!

I have visited the cake lady for birthday cakes and specialty cookies. They always turn out…read moreabsolutely incredible! The cakes have been exactly to my vision (or even better than what I wanted) and very delicious. I highly recommend for all of your baked goods needs!

James Moran, the proprietor of Moran's Pub in South Milwaukee, recommended Bakehouse 23 to me. The…read moreestablishment offers an exceptional selection of baked goods. I particularly enjoyed the Heath Bar Brownie, which was delectable and complemented perfectly with a cup of coffee. The Heath Bar Brownie's exceptional quality has prompted me to indulge in it on two consecutive Fridays. I eagerly anticipate exploring the other delectable offerings at Bakehouse 23 during my next visit!

This bakery is so cute and adorable. We walk our dogs here on the weekends, and the bakery gives us…read moredog treats for them. Everything we have tried has been incredible, and whenever we buy items to share with friends and family, they are amazed. We bought a bunch of items for a white elephant exchange and it was the most stolen gift! The staff is friendly and patient and I am so proud to have this bakery in my community!! I cant share them enough!!