Regrets...I've had a few . None as recent as the order I made with this establishment yesterday. I went off of the ratings and my conclusion is that there are many liars hanging around in the reviews. I haven't had a shrimp Parm hero in, it's gotta be at least 10 years. For whatever the reason I craved one yesterday and thought to get it from here. Julia Roberts voice, "Big mistake, big, huge." The bread, it was a dish sponge disguised as a baguette; flavorless, stale, dense--ugh. Shrimp had no flavor, nor did the peppers and onions...and the cheese? Apparently there's a shortage which affected my meal. I also ordered Thai chili wings. I'll say this, after reheating it in the oven, the flavor wasn't bad, but that chicken should be called jawbreaker, because chewing and swallowing it was a painful experience. Now I'm sure there is something that they sell that is tasty, which helps folks conclude that this spot is a worthy stop for lunch or dinner, but for what I ordered? I'm begging you, go elsewhere. *ordered on Grubhub read more

Armandos Pizza - Shrimp Parmigiana hero - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food was Banging. The Service was Good. The Ambiance was quick. I would definitely eat here again. The customer service is amazing. read more

Armandos Pizza - Buffalo Pizza (Large) - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Want great local pizza this is the place to check out. Have had they pizza for years and it never fails. Thanks for the great pizza read more

A neighborhood gem. I love going to this family owned pizzeria when I get home. They only take cash and I think that's great because it keeps the traditional way of dining. Their dining area does need an updated but I guess it's because of the grab and go New York style of eatery. You have to try a slice! read more

Best pizzeria in Brooklyn !! The service is great.the ambiance very welcoming very clean.Also you get fresh pizza every time they are the real deal no bullshit. read more

I moved out of Starrett since '91 but whenever I visit the family, I MUST grab a few slices of their Sicilians! It's s till the BEST NYC pizza that I have had since 1972! Their sauce is tasty, a good amount of cheese and their dough is crispy around the edges and soft at the center. It's a tasty slice from all angles! I have tried to promote them to New York Nico (hope to see him and his crew here one day!) and all NYC pizza lists. Ray's, DiFara's, L & B, Luigi's, they have nothing over Armando's and that's the TRUTH! read more

Kind servers & creamy pasta! Friendly and dynamic vibes:) I hope to eat here again Spaghetti

This is one of my favorite places in Starrett City. And the owner makes it to perfection! I made up this sandwich in my head and the owner makes it to perfection for me every time I call. I ask for the Italian sausage with onions, mushrooms and parmesan cheese it's a GREAT HERO and I could see you licking your lips right now so go ahead and call Armando's! Now, if you don't want what I get, come up with your own dish or your own pizza combo. Don't feel that you can't ask for something that's NOT on the menu cause they'll do anything to make you a happy customer at Armando's! read more

Armando's on Granville Payne avenue makes incredible pizza. The way pizza was made 40 years ago. You must try there amazing Sicilian it's like none you've ever tasted anywhere in Brooklyn. Highly recommended !!! read more

Armandos Pizza - pepperoni, sausage, and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Best pizza in town, the food is amazing. The customer service is good. Food is prepared hot and ready, if not the wait time is 3 mins which is not bad. I give Armandos 5 stars 6 if I could cause I've been eating here since I was little and never had a problem, this place is the best. read more

Armandos Pizza was super amazing and extremely affordable. Overall, great atmosphere, ambiance, cleanliness and customer service. Everything I've tried so far is solid. Team is extremely friendly and will help you with anything. Armandos Pizza - Thoroughly impressed. read more

I slept on this place because of the location but the pizza is very good. I'm only giving 2 stars because the ingredients on the Hawaiian twist pie when you order online vs when ordering in the store are different. I didn't want to spend extra money on delivery so I went to get one myself. I didn't notice until I got home with the pie that it only had pineapples and pepperoni Now like I said it's GOOD so I went back to get it corrected. The guy who took my order was nice but the guy he had to answer to was sarcastic when I was explaining why I brought the pie back. He proceeded to tell me what they did have because he said "I'm not making it again" RUDE! I understand menus change but this menu was the same. Hopefully after my encounter they'll update their menu! read more

I grew up in this neighborhood! So Armandos is a staple to many childhood memories! The pizza is always hot and good. Amazing customer service, always thoughtful! In the summer I enjoy going to get the Italian Icy, it's one of my favorites! read more

Armandos Pizza - Pineapple on the bottom and Cherry on top! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Having grown up in Starrett and going to the elementary school there, it was a special treat to get an 'out to lunch' permission once a week to go out with friends here. A lot of kids (myself included) had birthday parties here too. This place set the standard for me; how a pizza should look, taste, smell and what the pizzeria vibe should be. THIS is authentic, and every pizzeria I go to for the rest of my life will be gauged by that comparison and 'feel'. read more

I grew up here and miss the pizza.......boo hoo The best in the world. So many memories... read more

Pepperoni taste like a dollar slice, but they charge you at a 4 dollar rate. Not worth it.

Best Sicilian in the city get the middle slice you tell me that is the lightest airy crunchy tastiest Sicilian in the city....new school pizza places cannot make this old school style pizza anymore...... read more

If I could give it zero stars I would. For those who gave this place a good rating, sorry but you have no idea what good pizza or Italian food is. What's worse is that the staff is consistently rude and not mindful about how they speak about customers in front of other customers. Also...no disrespect intended, but if they just took the time to clean the place it would look and smell better. DO NOT BOTHER EATING HERE. I lived across the street and would drive to Avenue L to another place. Was worth it for me to spend the $4 a gallon in gas to eat there. read more

There pizza is literally the best so are the Garlic Knots but a little to greasy but still good also not open when supposed to be and there will be workers inside so never ready when supposed to be but its worth the wait kinda read more

Great pizza, hot plates and a good assortment of cold drinks. As a loyal customer before 1984, a great neighborhood restaurant that also delivers, I highly recommend Armandos. read more

Check the hispanic guy, he likes to overcharge if you don't pay attention. Pizza overpriced for what it is, $3.00 for a slice of pizza thats no where near good (3 Bros have a better slice & thats saying something). Eggplant not fresh; its frozen and flash fried. Kitchen closed on Sundays. I'd rather go out of my way to get a good pie and make eggplant parmigiana myself. Nothing is "homemade" they buy bread from the grocery store next door, and get there "pizza dough" delivered pre-made. read more

I like when they burn the crust on my pizza and I love their lunch special, pastas and grilled chicken salads...I wish the would make their crust a lil thinner, otherwise they are great take out spot The whole street has great take out options read more

I haven't eaten a slice of pizza from Armando's in a long time, but I know every time I here about this place, it reminds me of OLD STARRETT CITY, if you live here long enough people will know exactly what iam talking about. The pizza is great and the best pizza in the area. Go at the right time you can relax and have a nice conversation with your partner. Go at the wrong time you will be running out of Armandos saying to yourself what the hell was I thinking. read more

Armandos...WOW! This place is a piece of history . Great NY pizza ....really Italian !

I grew up in Starret City as well and I've compared every slice of pizza in every state I've lived in (and there's been many) to this pizza. I came home this time and not only was Carmine missing, but the service was just service not even good service and the pizza was decent. This is not the pizza I've been bragging about for years. So, maybe Carmine is on vacation and the pizzas and sicillian I ordered today was just a bad batch. But I can't give a rating on what this place used to be so... three stars and hoping that changes on my next trip out here! read more

Perfect pizza but the mozzarella sticks can be a but burnt at times lol still one of the best in this neighborhood

Great pizza dishes I've had in a long time......I love there Chicken Franchese dish. Staff is always friendly. I dont live in Starrett City but I would travel anyday of the week if I had to just for there food. read more

I stopped in here yesterday because after a "yelp" friend posted a whole pizza pie form another establishment I started to crave pizza. Seeing as how I was right next door in the liquor warehouse I said why not. I haven't eaten pizza here since I was in grade school...maybe high school. Now I love me some mom and pop pizza, however I only like it fresh out the oven and not reheated. I went inside, ordered my slice because what was available looked straight out the oven. To my surprise it wasn't fresh out the oven and had to be reheated. I was ready to be disappointed. But to my surprise it was really tasty and I even ate the crust, which I typically don't do because once reheated it doesn't taste as good read more

Oh the childhood memories I have from enjoying pizza with garlic knots and a soda fountain Coca Cola at Armandos Pizza. I love Armandos Pizza. Every time I visit New York I make a special trip to Armandos. It's something about their pizza sauce, sort of a sweetness that keeps me going back for more. Its family owned and operated and located in the Spring Creek Gardens shopping center, formerly Starrett City, off of Pennsylvania Avenue in Brooklyn. Check them out if you're in the area cause the pizza is just that good! read more

T'was good. Been there before, and will go there again. No more Dominos unless absolutely necessary. Definitely not when at home.

My brother always orders me pizza from here and I ALWAYS love it (buffalo chicken and pepperoni slices) so when my boyfriend wanted pizza I decided to dine in and check the place out for myself. I got a plain slice and my boyfriend got a pepperoni slice. We both decided. On the spot that this was our official joint. End of story. 5 stars. Good pizza. Good service. Chill vibe. What else do you want? read more

Here I am sitting in my house five months pregnant, I called the armandos pizzeria on November 20th roughly at 8 PM. I am in fact im a regular customer to this pizzeria. Me and my daughter come eat here all the time after school. It's now about 9:25 PM and I have not received a phone call nor has my delivery been made to my home. I called the pizzeria but got concerned when I kept getting the voicemail. I walked my pregnant ass over there and to my surprise the lights are off everything is cleaned up and I have no fucking dinner. It's extremely disappointing for a regular to have to go through this experience. This is an abomination because all I have is stinking tuna. This Armando's pizzeria is obviously under new management because I've never ever had this problem five years living in the area. I am 1000% disappointed and I would like to share it all with you. Fuck these new guys and bring back the old ones. read more

I think I was harsh with my previous one star review, so im revamping it. Overall the pizzeria is bellow avarage but clean and edible. The pizza quality did change from the way it used to be years ago. This used to be one of the best pizzerias in Brooklyn. read more

I love this place's pizza. I'm so glad its close to home. I try to go here with my bf whenever I can. I also like the garlic knots, the pepperoni and spinach rolls are good too. Just make sure you dont go during after school hours. read more

I tried a lot of places in Manhattan and Brooklyn and I say this is some great Pizza. Has nothing to do with being good for Starrett City, it is good all around no matter where it is. Great Sauce. The guys behind the counter are about as Brooklyn as they come. All the way from the accents to the suspicious attitude when I asked him what the address of the place was. "Aay, Wuddyuh need da address faaw?" I doubt he would have accepted it was because I wanted to Yelp the place. Totally separate from the food, the uh neighborhood, well go ahead and plan your visit for the day time. Maybe a sunday afternoon when everyone's gotten all the killing out of their system from the weekend. read more

Excellent original Brooklyn pizza, I've been eating slices from here for decades.

The service of this pizza shop has sadly declined. Forget ordering for a pickup because on a number of occasions they have messed that up. They gave my pie away to someone else, admitted that I was before the person and rather then being apologetic the staff, like a bunch of kids, argued with each other as to who was at fault. No one apologize for the mistake and inconvenience it caused me so I walked out. My family and I who are regular customers will no longer be going there. They are many other options available. read more

Good old fashioned pizza from back in the day made fresh today. My childhood memories flow whenever I stop in for a slice. I even get the grape drink! read more

I grew up eating this pizza, and I decided to order some today, what a mistake. The pizza was clearly reheated, burned on the bottom and was delivered cold. What a waste of money, and to think I waited for them to get an A rating again (their rating was a B/C for so long) I didn't think I was going to ever eat there again. If you must have pizza and find yourself in Starrett get something frozen from the supermarket, this place just isn't what it used to be. read more

When it comes to a regular cheese pizza it just an average pizza but i do enjoy their, i guess you call it special slices, i do love the buffalo chicken slice and the bacon one but my all time favorite is a white slice and thats the one slice they never Have, like Ever! Decent pizza, penne vodka is good. They staff is nice and theyre adding more to their menu. read more