This restaurant is a typical American-style restaurant that, overall, is disappointing. I ordered a small sausage pizza and I was underwhelmed. I appreciate locally owned businesses and all, but, from the few times I've been there, the food has not reflected the restaurant positively. The service here is good, but it is often busy, so, if you do decide to take the risk and go for dinner here, be prepared to wait because you'll have to fight a crowd. I would not recommend this to a friend. read more

This place is over priced for what you get...this was our first time here and We are disappointed. He ordered the Reuben and it had very little saurkeout and chewy corn beef, warm cottage cheese, YUCK, I had the Turkey burger it was ok nothing to special, lack of the sauce that was to be on it and cold fries were served with it... For 25.00 I could have and should have went to Bubba's (so sorry I didn't) read more

Honestly, I've never been much of a fan of Arnis. I haven't ever been able to find one thing that I just have to have every time I go, and I really only go here if my parents/family want to go since they're fans. The service isn't bad, the food isn't bad, I just don't find many things that make me go "rah rah" for them. read more

Everytime I order Arnis I am never disappointed. Definitely one of my favorite pizza spots and tbe stromboli is very good as well. Worth it in my opinion. read more

Our table enjoyed the pizza (1/2 supreme, 1/2 Thai peanut), lasagna, and chicken parmesan. The service was alright although the server could have been friendlier. The food came out timely and was very good. We will go again :) read more

Arni's - Plenty left over to enjoy at home :) - Pizza Near Me - Greenwood, Indiana

Arni's is known for their pizzas but that wasn't what I got, maybe if I had, my review would be different. I got the bbq salad and it was ok but also definetly not the best bbq salad I had ever had. When I go back, I think I am going to try their actual pizza and see how that is. read more

Good food and great accommodations for big groups. Overpriced drinks, friendly staff.

Not the greatest "Italian food" in my opinion, but the gyro sandwich is fantastic. Being able to order carry out online through Yelp is a nice feature also. read more

Like Arni's a lot. Don't understand why they got rid of Korean Meatballs. They have Korean barbecue sauce and meatballs?

6 total members of my family went to Apple Works today and had a wonderful time. After leaving Apple Works we all decided we were hungry so we stopped by Arni's on the way back home. We were NOT impressed by this location at all. The wife and I eat at the other Arni's on 96th street quite frequently and love it. So we were severely depressed, dissatisfied and disappointed after eating here. My mom found a piece of plastic yes plastic in her Club sand which! And my wife's shrimp carbonara was awful. (Same thing she always gets up north) service was ok! Food coming to table was very slow. Just a horrible overall experience. read more

This Arni's location in Greenwood is very cozy and good for a date or a dinner with family and friends. The front seating area is especially nice - with longer tables in the middle and booths on the outsides. It used to be a Damon's; you can see the front area of the restaurant is like the "cozy" / date night half of Damon's, while the back half is more of the sports bar kind of atmosphere, but minus the trivia clickers. Arni's pizza is a unique flavor of pizza that is consistent across all Arni's locations that I have been to (unlike Pizza King, for example). I would describe the pizza dough / crust as on the salty side, and more crisp than doughy. My family likes the barbeque sausage pizza the best - the barbeque sauce is tangy and mixes well with the crumbled sausage and cheese. Salads are awesome here, and the portions are on the large size - ideal for sharing. The Arni's Junior salad is big enough for 2 people if you are also eating pizza and/or breadsticks. The reason I don't give 5 stars here is because the service at this Arni's has been consistently average or below average during my visits over the past couple years. We are not checked on by our server very frequently, and people in my dining party (7-11 people) run out of drinks and need refills a lot. The greeting and overall disposition of the employees is humdrum and melancholy. I do think the atmosphere and the consistent quality of the pizza is what earns this Arni's a 4-star review instead of 3 stars. read more

Great salads and pizza. Clean and family friendly environment. I love the junior salad. Ordering and picking up is easy and convenient. It's a go to if you want something as your standard restaurant. read more

Great pizza & always ready & waiting for me to pick up. Easy & convenient to order takeout.

Took my son here for lunch. The food was good but over priced for the portions. Medium pizza is a 10" and was $16.99. Bill was $32 for pizza, breadsticks and 2 drinks. Had to leave and go to McDonalds just to get full for lunch. Food isn't worth the $$. Service was ok but not over the top. read more

Had lunch here today with friends and as usual the food was great! Unfortunately, when I asked about the Tuesday beer special selection I was told by the waitress (Sandee) that she did not know what they were. Didn't offer to find out either. So if you're going to offer daily drink specials, you might want to make sure the staff knows what they are. read more

Great food for a fair price! While we weren't completely satusfied with our waitress and the EXTREMELY loud environment around us, we still enjoyed the food and cleanliness. Also, I was very surprised by the very lax dress code. read more

I wasn't impressed with their tenderloin sandwich but the restaurant was nice and clean.

We've lived here for almost four years and never stopped in before. The parking lot is always packed though so we gave it a try and weren't disappointed. The kids were welcomed with crayons and coloring pages, and a pack of fruit snacks. They're already won over! We needed up ordering a few side salads and a sausage/pepper/onion pizza. Salads were great- fresh lettuce and topping. The pizza was... well... what I hear Arni's pizza is. Either you love it or hate it. Thin crust, kinda floppy, cut in squares. Tons of toppings and generally tasted good, but not my preference for pizza. I prefer more dough, more well done, and easier to eat. The kids liked it though so that helps! Inexpensive, cozy, nice servers- we'll likely go back. read more

In the way of pizza, they have mastered the art. Now that I've had their pizza, no other pizza tastes right. Affordable, nice seating every time, good atmosphere, good service, I have no complaints and have been a handful of times. read more

Visited Arni's for Indy Pizza week and because my experiences at the Lafayette locations were always positive. This past visit was less than spectacular. We walked in and were greeted immediately. The hostess led us to a table and since there were multiple booths open, I asked if we could sit at one. She explained that they didn't have servers for the open booths and I told her not to worry about it. The hostess then said that we could have a booth. Our server walked by and told us it would be a minute, so we looked over the menu and saw that beer was on special. When our server came over I asked what was on draft. She didn't know and had to look at her "cheat sheet". She then listed a few beers including "sunking" with no explanation about which beer. I asked her if any of the beers were IPAs and she said she didn't know because she "doesn't drink". I asked if she could ask someone and she reluctantly asked the gentleman bussing the booth next to ours. After we were able to get drinks ordered, we ordered a few things including a 10 inch pizza since they were half off for Indy Pizza week special. I confirmed with the server that it was half off before ordering, she smirked and said yes. Our food came out just fine. Ingredients seemed to be fresh and the Arni's Junior salad was very good. Our bill came out with the pizza not discounted. I pointed it out to our server, who took the bill back and adjusted it. The whole experience was almost painful. read more

The back dining room is designed like an echo chamber. Every noise and screaming kid carries across the whole room. Very hard to have a conversation across the stupid half round booths, and over the noise. They food was disappointing, a fried hamburger on a ice cold bun wilted lettuce and mushy old tomatoes, mmmmm, served by a bored young woman with the personality of the cold bun. I got truly offended when the bill came and for three people it totaled over $40. I really feel I could have gotten better at Burger King. My tip to tonight's manager, when you look at a table that is paying the bill and the food is still on the table... Go talk to the them don't make them come looking for you. read more

Terrible sandwiches. Worse pizza. The pizza was both burned and served cold. Good music. Unfortunately, we disliked the food so much we won't be back. read more

So glad my favorite pizza place is now on the southside! Woot! Love the Arni's Junior Salads, the breadsticks, the pizzas and the ham sandwiches! Goodness my mouth is watering just writing this review! read more

We arrived for lunch with our 16 month old son. The hostess informed us a high chair would get in the way, so we would need to use a booster. She then led us to a booth, which we could not safely attach the booster seat to. There was also very little foot traffic, as the area we were seated in was nearly empty. After waiting nearly fifteen minutes for our server, I informed her we couldn't use the booster, which she took without asking if we would like a high chair instead. Needless to say, we left at this point, so I can't comment on the food, but the service was incredibly disappointing. read more

I went to Purdue and have eaten at the original Arni's location many times. This location takes the great pizza I'm used to and puts it in a spacious, comfortable space that makes the experience that much better. Arni's is probably my favorite thin crust pizza and this location delivered 100%. The pizza was good, the service was good, the night was good. Amen. read more

Just blah. Too overpriced. Our service was really poor. No drink refills - we were eating ice!! The server never was visible to even ask for more. It was very apparent they were not invested in our dining experience. Kids meals were standard fare. I had the chili Mac - how do you make chili that bland? I did not finish it. My hubby had shrimp tacos - two small tacos that were sauce heavy and maybe 1/4 cup of sweet potato fries - the kids got more food than he did. It just wasn't pleasant at all. For $60, I expect WAY more than what we got from food to service. Sorry Arni's, not coming back. Should've just done drive through and saved $40!! read more

Worst pizza I have had since the last time I ate at Pizza King. Service was ok and I feel was pricey for poor quality. Got 1 Star because can't give a zero. read more

Great service! Great pizza! Italian sub is soooooo good. Salads are also delicious. Menu is larger. No way you won't find something you'll love :) read more

I enjoy the Turkey burger and sweet potato fries but the mgmt needs work. If you get there after 8 they are removing condiments from the table, turning chairs over and sweeping the carpet. I guess they're trying to chase me out. Message received. Even though they are just around the corner, I won't be back for a while read more

Yeah, I got nothing here. Just not much separates this from any other chain, pizza was ok, salad forgettable. Now I know.

5 stars today... Jr was perfect( all 3) deluxe pizza was perfectly made from the cheese to the crispy crust. Service was excellent never had to ask for anything and all needs were anticipated well. Restaurant was not especially busy minus a few parties... Too bad people; missed out on a great meal time. read more

Excellent food and great service. Are go to is the pepperoni amd mushroom pizza. Chopped pieces of pepperoni on that thin crust pizza...YUMMMM! My fav pizza place in Indy! read more

Good pizza and pretty good service. They have other foods there but we go there mainly for the pizza. Great for big families or big parties. Plan to go back frequently! read more

Best pizza in Greenwood. Menu is huge, could eat here everyday for a month and still not have tried half the stuff on there. Deserts are great as well. read more

Love the grilled tenderloin. We order takeout from Arni's regularly, and it is always tasty, fresh, and fast!

Will definitely NOT be going back to this place. The waitress had the personality of a rock, the place was so loud and noisy we couldn't enjoy our conversation, and the management did absolutely nothing about the noisy obnoxious children who were completely unsupervised by their parents. The food was mediocre, at best, and took forever even though they weren't that busy for a Friday night. My husbands hamburger bum was literally ICE COLD, like it had just came out of the freezer, my reuben was so soggy I had to eat it with a fork, and my daughters buffalo wrap was dripping with grease. As we left we passed several servers, and two managers and not one of them acknowledged us or asked if our experience was okay. We will not be going back there ever again. read more

Never ate here before but needless to say it was worth it !!! Angela was an absolute amazing waitress and made the experience even more great. Definitely recommend to anyone looking for pizza and salads !! :) read more

The Arni's junior salad is the best! I always order with thousand island (on the side).. Comes with a slice of garlic bread too.Pair it with 1/2 a Stromboli and you'll be a happy clam! read more

Great food at a great price. I am a fan of the Maui Zowie Pizza.

Three stars because of the pizza & wings (which are great) & the really good service. We've ate here 3 times, & besides the pizza & wings have tried the lasagna, chicken Alfredo, fish & chips, & Stromboli. All were mediocre at best. Edible, but nothing you'd go back for seconds for. Did get the chili nachos app & those were good. Also have decent drink specials. read more