I was here for a book club with some girlfriends and the food was good! I made my own pizza, however the small size was very small. They did load it with toppings however, so that did make up for the size. Will be back! read more

Decided to come here for burger week and get away from BR. I had the Maverick (chorizo, guacamole, salsa)..wow! This burger was amazing. We also had an order of the fried green beans which came with this dijon sauce on the side that was out of this world. In terms of drinks, on Thursdays they have mugs of long islands for $7..we are talking like 32 mugs, these things were huge. From the moment you walk in you can smell the pizza, it's supposedly what their known for. I did not order one, but there was lots of it coming out of the kitchen the whole night. I enjoy the way they cut it, in smaller square pieces. I will definitely be back for pizza, as there is also a yelp deal where you get a large pizza for $10 (normally 18-21) with a check in. read more

You get a $10 off pizza deal when you check in here on your Yelp account. I wanted to try the stuffed mushrooms with maranara. They are a good size with a good filling. Beer was barely cold. Pizza was good. Nothing to make me say I have to come back again. Service was great. read more

Arni's - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Arni's had been a favorite since I was a student at Purdue, so when the location on the north side of Indy opened years ago, I was super excited. Their food is so much more than the pizza, which is delicious. They have great salads and sandwiches as well. Great service and environment at this location. read more

We had michael as our server. He did an excellent job checking on us and making sure we had everything we needed. The wedge salad was fantastic. Pizza was excellent as always. read more

Amazing staff and even better pizza!!! We live this place!!! I would highly recommend this place for any family pizza night!!! read more

See all

Went for wing week and overall had a good experience. Ordered the boneless wings and was very satisfied with the serving size. They had a wide variety of sauces. Taste was what you would expect with typical bar food and ranch tasted like hidden Valley. The pizza looked very good and we will likely be back to give it a try. The service was friendly and helpful and made the difference between a 3 and a 4 star. We will likely be back in the future. read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Picked up a barbecue deluxe pizza but $20 absolute worst pizza we have ever had we came home it was overcooked almost burnt very little toppings on it try to eat it I threw it in the trash went back out and get Burger King for dinner stay away from this place read more

We have been going to arnis for years and have really enjoyed their pizza as a family. I give their pizza a 10/10 for quality and they normally finish cooking the pizza a lot sooner than they say it will be finished. read more

Great pizza like the West side location that I use to go to all the time back when I first moved to Indy. However, I was really disappointed in the lack of attention we got from the staff. I know our group of three was there at 2:30 in the afternoon, but, it just seemed like we were a burden for the server. He may have been having a bad day, so I don't want to be too critical, but everyone in our group noticed the lack of friendly service. I'll try them again for a late lunch or happy hour once the weather breaks and you can sit outside. If you love Pizza King type pizza this is the place to pick up some pizza. read more

Fantastic service !!! We came down to visit our son who is currently a student at Purdue. And the service was superb!!! we had a large party visiting from Chicago and we had the best service considering our party !! Food was delicious and drinks !! Thank you arnies for making our experience a delight. We will return !! read more

Arni's is just one of those places where the food is always good and the service isn't all that bad either. Great place to bring the kids. I had a casual work meeting here the other day and ordered the Arni's Burger. Pretty messy, but delish! Pizza, pasta, salads - they have everything and I've never been disappointed. The atmosphere and the conversation I have with friends and co-workers are always the highlight of my visits here! read more

I'm a little torn on how to review Arni's. I like it. I like it quite a bit. Yet, I'm not sure anything is outstanding enough to push it above a 3 star rating. The decor is nice, but doesn't wow me. Same with the food. It's good. I like it. It's a good, solid, meal for a reasonable price. But it's not fantastic. Service has seemed to be a bit hit or miss at times. It's one of those places I'm happy to dine at if I'm in the area, but wouldn't travel a great distance for it. read more

Our 2nd pizza here, this time carry out for family. Thin crust sweet tomato sauce and ground up meats. Terrific! Wish I could've dined in to enjoy the 32 oz Friday drink special Long Island tea $7, but more important to join family! read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I love the options this place has! Salads, pizzas, sandwiches. They have so many different sauces. Their junior salad is delicious! The chopped turkey and mozzarella is so good! My favorite pizza is call white wedding, I believe. It has an Alfredo sauce which is amazing. It's good for groups, lunches and dinners. read more

My chili was cold when it was brought to the table. Not a good omen. I had it with a side salad. When it was served hot it was fine, but later that afternoon I just wasn't feeling well and I knew why. "Meh" is a fine description. I'm nopt from Indy, so I won't be back, but even if they had them in LA, I likely wouldn't return. read more

Buffalo Chicken Pizza is awesome Listening to the incredible annoying bartender Justin however, has me coming back far less frequently read more

It's so nice to sit at a bar and see the employees genuinely like each other. I got the salad with their home made vinegar dressing and absolutely loved it. I am a huge fan of their pizza and that is what keeps me coming back, but now that I found this dressing, may be what I come back for next time. read more

Ate at Arni's in Crawfordsville 6/22/2015 Horrible experience. We got the nachos with chili which is prepared in a microwave. Blah! The a cold Stromboli XXBlah!! The pizza was ok at best. Fresh crust with reheated toppings. I had to insist for a refund for the nachos and they informed me that is just the way that they make it. finally the cold Stromboli, they said they could microwave it for us. Over thirty dollars for food prepared in a microwave. We will never go back. I don't see how they make it with this kind of food preparation. No stars........ read more

Ordered from here recently. We decided to use Door Dash. We ordered the supreme pizza, Ava Rose salad and 1/2 order of breadsticks with nacho cheese! Everything was delicious! Although, I never got to the breadsticks cause I didn't beat my husband to the door read more

I'm originally from the Lafayette area and grew up going to the original Arni's with my grandma. They do just as good of a job her! Great wait staff, outdoor patio is dog friendly and the pizza and salads tastes as I remember them! read more

Not happy that I paid over $13 for pizza and coke that made me sick for the rest of the day

Pizza is awesome!! Love the pesto pizza. So different and tasty. My son loves the buttered pasta. The desserts are great too

Upon our arrival, there was no host/greeter - around 9 PM Sunday night, October 28 - restaurant was virtually empty - only one other table with patrons in our section - the largest in the restaurant. Server had the attitude that she was doing us a favor by being there - impatient, not overly forthcoming in answering questions, and throughout our meal, slow to return to our table and check on us - at one point sitting at a booth with an employee who was supposed to be sweeping the floor - she had a broom, and the floor was filthy. Ordered a house salad, which was riddled with mostly under-ripened tomatoes that should never have made it to the plate. Additionally, chunks of lettuce and the end piece of a green onion (garbage) that also should never have been served. I asked the server if she thought those pieces, now on a separate plate, were appropriate to serve. That she paused and actually thought about it instead of saying the obvious, no they should not, and I'm happy to bring you a fresh salad, spoke volumes. For some reason, the dressing had to be brought separately, causing a longer wait. Our pizza was stiff and not terribly flavorful. When addressing all of the above to the "manager," including showing her the plate of refuse passing as salad, all we got was excuse after excuse; no apologies; and when our bill came, I had to tell them the salad should have been taken off the bill, which it was, finally. Overall, not a good experience. My daughter, a Purdue student, and I, had an equally unpleasant experience at one of the Lafayette restaurants about a month earlier. In this case, two strikes is out for us - and this is a restaurant my wife and daughter liked. read more

The worst pizza I ever had., I was quite surprised with everyone saying how good it is? Frozen crust?, Or pre packaged?, & What's with the way it is cut., Burnt in a couple areas. read more

Best place on 96th St. to grab a salad or some pizza to go with all the beer you're probably gonna drink. Friendliest staff and great service. :) So fast your pictures will blur!! Thanks Arnies! read more

Arni's - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Nice ambiance but not going to get my repeat business. I hear the pizza is good but opted for penne Mediterranean because I was in mood for pasta It was clearly over seasoned and the chicken salad my girlfriend had was sent with blue cheese dressing instead of ranch. They kept sending out blue cheese dressing and we finally left irritated with a sample of dressing. Several family members agreed it was blue cheese. True Italian food is light and zesty and service is friendly. I love little Italy in NYC, Cleveland, and Ferruci's of Florida but Arni's will never see my family again! read more

I'm definitely an Arni's fan. From the funky looking, gotta touch'em walls, to the pretzel bun, to the pizza. Yum! the pizza: Chicken Bacon Ranch, all the way. I enjoy taking new people with me, we inevitably have a good time, with good food, typically decent service, at a reasonable cost. Their Pasta Palooza makes me happy and who can ask for more than that? read more

It's been a while since we have eaten at Arni's. New menu. Mostly the same food. We had salads and pizzas. It was good. Lettuce fresh and salad had flavorful items on it. Pizza was also good. It's more of a party pizza than a pizzeria pizza. But it had lots of toppings and was tasty. Drink special was a $7 Long Island. Gigantic drink. It was not a top shelf drink. But you definitely get a deal. We will return. It was pretty good. read more

Great pizza! The Arni's junior salad is dynamite! My wife recommends it to me every time and I usually pass. I've been missing out! Get the Alfredo sauce with your breadsticks! Original BBQ is the pizza I met my wife on our first date and would recommend. read more

I love Arni's! Really, really good pizza and friendly service. A very nice patio area, and they're open really late. Their menu is large and varied. Don't overlook the salads, they're generously sized and most of the dressings are homemade and delicious. My personal favorite is the celery seed dressing. The mushroom appetizer is another favorite, it's so good it's hard to order anything else. Family friendly and fairly priced. read more

Came here to get a Togo order and tried calling ahead of time but no one answered. So I decided I would go in and try placing an order. Went in and waited 10 minutes at the host stand to place an order. This was two plus hours before Closing. Disappointed with the lack of service. read more

I had some food delivered via DoorDash and absolutely LOVED the wings and thin crust pizza. The pepperoni / bacon pizza I got was full of toppings, the sauce was very tasty, and the crust was crunchy with lots of flavor. And the wings... ohhhhh the wings. SO good. Large wings with a great flavor - I'll be ordering extra sauce next time. Again, highly recommend!! read more

Love the Arnis Junior and pizzas. Good bar option. Convenient takeout counter. Good for families too.

I'm tired of all these damned specialty pizza places. So when I go you better bring it. This wasn't bad but wasn't great either. The crust makes these pizza places and theirs is just okay. Again not bad but I wouldn't eat there again. And I was told the garlic cheese bread was the best ever. Not even close. To be the best the bread has to be toasted, crisp and the cheese on top has to be just a little crisp on the sides. And tasting the garlic would be a plus. I could melt cheese on wonder bread and have the same effect. read more

We actually stumble upon this place when we googled map "Pizza". I was very surprise Arni's got some delicious pizzas. It's greasy enough that makes the cold beer taste crispier. My husband said this is actually better than Pizza King! Oh boy, coming after small rural Pizza King. read more

Came in on a Saturday at 3pm, cool and rainy...apparently with a number of other people all at once. All staff seemed to jump right in to provide quick and efficient service. Kudos. Mini-cheeseburgers tasty for sure. Aidens Big Show pizza was delicious with a sweet tasting sauce on a crunchy thin crust. Side Caesar Salad was fine, I personally enjoy a thicker Caesar dressing. Very fair prices. read more

I love Arni's!!! The food is always consistently good! Their pizza is amazing, but we were here for Indy Burger Week and their burgers (for just 5$) were equally as amazing! The staff is very friendly, the restaurant is clean, and the atmosphere fits the vibe of the food. Nothing too fancy, but wonderful food and family friendly! Highly recommend!! read more

Great pizza and super people at the pizza counter. Always friendly and service is always exceptional. Outstanding customer service !!! Keith Molter read more

Pizza is always delicious. Top shelf LIT was definitely overpriced at $14.00! Service was friendly and efficient.