I really wanted to like this beef joint. Unfortunately, it fell short. I tried both a slice of pizza and a junior beef. The slice looked good and was huge, but with no undercarriage and flop it tasted generic. The beef looked promising, with a "hole" in the middle of the beef to allow James River to pool for super flavor. The disappointing part? The beef was lukewarm warm in the middle. Unfortunate. The servers were very friendly and the ambiance was that of a classic pizza parlor place in New England. read more

See all

Stopped in for a late lunch today, we ordered the chicken parm sandwich and roast beef pita wrap, both were fantastic. Staff was very friendly and polite, changing our itinerary while in Boston to stop by a few more times, at least! read more

Excellent menu. Best roast beef around. Great pizza and steak rolls. Give the a shot you will be glad you did.

We order delivery all the time direct through Athas (not Doordash, etc). Delivery is always quick & friendly. Food always hot and fresh. Beefs are great Chicken kabobs are great Steak tip salad surprisingly good Fries a good. Rings are OK. If you spend over a certain amount you get a free personal greek pizza... so you soend that amount! I'll keep going back read more

One of my friend told me to try this place, ordered a roast beef 3 way calzone at 11am, got a text at 11:12am that my food was ready to pick up. Went to store to pick up and was told it was a few more mins. After about 15 mins I asked again if my food was almost ready as I needed to get back to work for noon. At this time I saw the gentleman in the back start to make my food. So I asked again how much longer will it be, and got the response, "only 5 mins more, it takes 7 in the oven." At this time it was already 11:40 and I had to get back to work. After having to argue with the worker that I needed to go and couldn't wait for the food to cook. They said that they couldn't do any refunds but they would deliver it. At about 12:15, the lady came to my door and rang the door bell 8 times and then slammed on my door. read more

They don't listen!!! BURNT PIZZA and charge for food you don't ask for. Smile in your face and give you burnt slices when a fresh pie is what I asked for slices from. They argued with an elderly person with me as they called to complain over 2 slices. Not going back there....treat your customers with respect....we should receive food we pay far and request....no need to argue over slices but don't look in my face grabbing burnt slices to heat in oven so l eat burnt pizza that was sitting I'm a warmer over the fresh pie I asked slices from. The other slices only 2 should've been thrown away NOT GIVEN TO ME....how disrespectful....they are burnt!!!!!!! read more

Atha's Roast Beef & Pizza - Burnt slices that had been sitting in a warmer after I asked for two out of the fresh one that had come out of the oven - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

See all

We were in from out of town and stopped by Atha's to grab some quick sandwiches. My dad ordered an Italian sub, I got a turkey sub, and my husband got a tuna melt. All were very good, but the turkey was absolutely delicious! As we were inside waiting for our food, a man ordered a 3-way roast beef. Never hearing this term before, my dad asked what it was (cheese, Mayo, sauce) and we were told Atha's has one of the best. We will have to try it out next time! read more

A return visit didn't disappoint 3 JR's. 1- 3Way 1- Sauce Cheese 1-Just Cheese All stacked, and beef perfection! read more

Atha's Roast Beef & Pizza - Jr just cheese, Perfection! - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

See all

I stopped going to Athas because of diminished quality. I tried them again last night. Delivery. I live 5 minutes away but health issues prevailed me from picking up. My rb sandwich was cold not even warm, cheese wasn't even partly warm on it. My onion rings, also cold, were half burned. Now waiting for response from company. They definitely lost me as a customer. read more

Best three way roast beef I've had and even more surprising was the Greek roast beef. It was "FABULOUS"! If you like a Greek salad you will love the Greek Beef. Top Notch. read more

This is truly a sad day. I've asked Alexa to play "Nothing compares to you" by Sinead O'Connor on repeat. Athas use to be one of the best roast beef sandwiches in all of the northshore. Today, it's not worth your time. Ordered a junior beef at 1:45pm today and a 2 slice special. Bread was incredibly stale. Beef was grey and tasteless (almost tasted as if put on the grill for a few seconds). We threw the pizza away. I noticed all new faces behind the counter, which confirms the talk that Athas is under new ownership. There's a reason I was the only person waiting for food on a Saturday. From greatness to the one of the worst roast beef sandwiches I can remember - sad. read more

Excellent roast beef and the pizza was delicious great sauce I would go back Service was fast and friendly read more

Had the medium roast beef light sauce. Beef cooked rare and butter tender. The staff was pleasant and very helpful. The onion rings were to die for. Highly recommend. read more

2 salads , 1 garden and 1 Greek. $27.00 including tip. The size was pitiful. Did not even fill the container. read more

Atha's Roast Beef & Pizza - Pitiful salad from Athas - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

I'm not from the Boston area so I've never had this kind of roast beef sandwich. It's a far far better sandwich than Arby's or something like that. First, it's actual real roast beef - not whatever Arby's is. It's cooked medium so it still has color and flavor. It's delicious. By the way, I like Arby's so no disrespect intended. I can't wait to be back in the area so I can get another one. My only complaint is the horseradish is too much. It was covered in horseradish sauce. Next tine - no horseradish! read more

I'd give 0 stars if I could. Got my order wrong with no apologies and next time I went back, they did the same thing! Zero communication between the person answering the phone and people filling orders. I give them a year before they are out of business. Horrible customer service. read more

Just a consistently good beef , they are courteous on the phone, take the order concisely, the three or four times I have ordered a beef the quality is good, the quantity is copious and they are generous with the James River. Others in my party have gotten the gyro or the steak bomb and they have also had very good things to say. read more

Well-portioned roast beef. Right amount of beef and sauce. Toasted bun. One of the best in Peabody. read more

Atha's Roast Beef & Pizza - Jr - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

Not sure what has happened to this place as it always has been my go to pizza store but today the pizza barely had any sauce and seemed like an extra cheese pizza. Fries were extremely salty and roast beef was over cooked and even though I asked for extra sauce it was a bit too much and had leaked all over the bag. Food was horrible today. Probably won't be ordering again. read more

Been of a beef wave as of lately, let me tell you athas did not disappoint, ratio was perfect, beef was pink throughout, bun was hot and crisp, little butter on there ya don't think I missed that you sneaky dogs. I love James river sauce stupid fire and all but let me tell you something, I like a little kick with my sauces and athas brought that to the table. Cheese and Mayo were near perfect. I said this yesterday but this beef made me feel a way I haven't felt in years, kind of got the feeling I got when I kissed a girl for the first time. I got all lightheaded and had to take a second when I stood up, I would say it's a good thing I felt that way. Will be back for sure. 9.2/10 read more

Used to love this place. Ordered food last night that was subpar, kinda did my order wrong, but what got me was the FOOD POISONING it gave me and my boyfriend. Not gonna go into details on that but boy are we SICK. Won't be returning. read more

I have ordered by phone for pick up from Atha's Roast Beef & Pizza at 10 Sylvan Street in Peabody many times. I understand mix ups, mistakes, misunderstandings can happen in retail & in the food industry. No one and no company is perfect. But you would hope if mistakes were made that there would be some form of customer service in these moments. I have ordered in the past and have had my order wrong on their part a few times. I never come in hot or angry. I am civil and respectful. I explain the situation & ask for things to be redone, which they do. I do not live in Peabody. So, driving back to pick up my order, when they do deliver, is something that I do each time. Extra time and gas. I am never offered an apology, anything for the mistake and the inconvenience of driving back or an offer to have it delivered. Last night, I ordered food for my household totaling $60+, which is the average that we spend for each time we order from them. The traffic was awful going there and coming back last night. I was so happy to come home and enjoy my supper. Unfortunately, my super roast beef was wrong and my daughter was missing one of her salad dressings, which we pay extra for. My son's large onion, steak & cheese and our large fry, extra crispy, was soggy. I called them to rectify the super roast beef & missing salad dressing. I was told that I needed to drive back to pick them up. Frustrated and hungry, I decided to drive back. I called back a second time after I left to have them remake my son's onion steak and cheese and the large fries, extra crispy. I was never given an apology for the mistake. I was never offered some money off for the remade sub and fries. Nothing for the whole inconvenience. This doesn't end here. We finally get home to eat our meal. My daughter had ordered a Caesar salad with parmesan and feta cheese extra pita and extra dressing. She informs me that her steak tip from her steak tip (well done) was red and was hard to cut due to the undercooking. She was able to eat the rest of her salad besides the steak tip. Mind you we pay extra for the feta cheese, the extra pita and the extra dressing. We didn't call Atha's regarding the steak tip. Please note, my youngest daughter rarely ever complains about her food. She is fine if her steak or steak tip is pink or slightly red. But for her to complain says a lot. Let me add, the remade fries tasted very off. I couldn't eat them. So, I paid $64.70 for the first order & $ $21.38 for the remade order and wasted the gas (and time) to drive back the second time. We didn't get an apology. We didn't get an offer for something out of courtesy for their mistake. I have made decisions in the past to reorder from Atha's after mistakes made by them. I never call in angry as I don't want anything possibly done to my food if an employee is aggravated of my complaint. But this is how we were treated last night?! I feel this was too much for me. I have finally made the decision that going there isn't worth it. Their lack of customer service is what did me in. So, peace Atha's Roast Beef Pizza at 10 Sylvan Street in Peabody. You lost 3 customers. But here's some advice...DO BETTER WITH YOUR CUSTOMER SERVICE. read more

Food here has always been good. Online ordering is flawless and the customer front facing folks have always been friendly.

I ordered a steak and cheese and the steak was grounded up and looked like dog food, and tasted just as bad. The feta fries I got based on recommendation were extremely soggy and the taste was just okay. If the onion rings weren't cold I would have enjoyed them more considering this was a delivery I understand to some Capacity. The Italian subs, well it's not that hard to make so not any complaints there. I don't write very many reviews but when it comes to my dinner I feel as though I should warn others before they endure this experience. read more

Friendly people that work here. Food is great with quick delivery. You will not be disappointed. Thank you.

Never met anywhere where a Greek/kabob salad doesn't have feta and onions. If it didn't wouldn't it just be a garden salad with chicken?! I called to enquire and was basically told it was my fault for not specifying. Mind you I've ordered from here numerous times and it's had feta and onions. If I wanted a garden salad then that's what I would have ordered! * update- owner was apologetic, I explained how the miscommunication could've been avoided if on the menu it just says "garden salad"* read more

Worst customer service I've ever had, don't order food on line cause if they screw it up they won't replace it and their people are RUDE , never will I shop there again and I will take out an ad telling how bad they are... disgusting read more

Food is insanely good. Roast beefs and the steak tip rice bowl are my co-go-to's. I recommend this place to everyone I meet on my job site.

Hands down the best Roast Beef 3 Way around and there is some tough competition on the North Shore. Pizza is good here as well if you like Greek pizza. read more

At 6 o'clock I called to order a small cheese pizza cooked light because they tend to overcook the pizza at 7 o'clock I called and the girl told me that somebody had taken down the wrong number and they were trying to get in touch with me I said is the pizza gonna be cold now and she said well if it is we'll send you out another one Wow the girl came and delivered the pizza it was stone cold and not only that it was overcooked so I called they said they were gonna send me another one and not 1 minute later the girl called me to tell me that I would have to come and pick up the pizza because it's too busy for them to deliver the pizza to me I said why should I be punished for something somebody else did that's not my fault that the person took down the wrong information And she said well I'm really sorry but my manager said that you would have to come and get it not really the type of customer service I was expecting to be honest with you I've given them a few chances because they messed up a few times but this is it last chance they overcook the pizzas unless you ask them to cook it light and if they're more than 40 minutes your pizza's gonna be stone cold. read more

I went there today. For the most part everything was good. I'd give the food 3.5 starts probably. That was until about 3 bites into my sandwich. My boyfriend's brother got us food. He is blonde, my boyfriend is blonde, I am blonde. When I looked into my sandwich I saw a jet black hair. I was appalled. See the pictures I attached to see! read more

Atha's Roast Beef & Pizza - Italian sub with black hair in it. - Pizza Near Me - Peabody, Massachusetts

See all

Asked for a super beef with light sauce and extra cheese and when I got home and opened I had extra sauce and no cheese.... Curious how you mess up that bad. read more

Great food the people are very friendly and the food is always perfect the restaurant is cleans and inviting

Just bland everything. Fresh homemade onion rings.... zero taste. Fries meh. Salad was basic so okay. Pizza at first tasted fine but literally after a night in the fridge couldn't peel it off the box it was stuck with so much grease. People inside were nice. Hoping they can work out the kinks. Really miss Toms which was in this location. read more

Less words are better than more. Let's just say when they found out that my order never got to their system, they did nothing to remedy the situation. Not even so much as a simple apology, or an offer to make the order then and there. The food is great here, but this was a great customer service opportunity which was missed by the staff. read more

Went a few weeks ago. Pizza was better than I expected based on these reviews. Ate there and we all loved it

good food & quick service too highly recommend for an kabob salad or wrap this legit spot

Best BBQ Steak Tip salad around, hands down. Large portion size, I always get two meals from it. The steak has great flavor and always cooked perfectly. read more

Every time I order, my food is delicious!! I'm picky and when I order online for delivery the order is always as I ordered it. They pay attention to special instructions. The delivery people are awesome!! So friendly and always say Thank You! read more

Pizza is the best Greek pizza around. But, I will say, their Greek salad is the only thing I want to eat for the rest of my life. I would be content with that. And my boyfriend is obsessed with their roast beef 3-ways. read more