Came here for lunch for Father's Day a few weeks ago, it wasn't super busy for the holiday which was nice. Still waited about 10-15 minutes as they seemed a little short staffed? However the staff themselves were very polite and attentive and the restaurant gave off a classic diner feel which was nice. I got a turkey BLT which was pretty good and I was pleasantly surprised with the amount of turkey in the sandwich, I definitely did not leave hungry! I also got an iced latte which wasn't great but not bad either. I'd come back to try other options on the menu read more

Athenian Diner III - Sliced Turkey BLT - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Classic, quintessential dinner vibes were great! The staff was really nice. The food was pretty good as well! My wrap was quite large and tasty! Some people in my party ordered reubens and burgers and they all looked delicious. Not very expensive either. I'd definitely dine at Athenian Diner III again, can't wait to try different menu options! read more

Athenian Diner III - Grilled chicken wrap - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Stopped here one night after a concert. Their Reuben sandwich was so delicious! Would definitely come back if I was in the area. Good service and quick! read more

This IS the diner you want to go to. Greeted with friendly smile. We came for breakfast and the wait was minimal. The booth was clean. The menu was extensive with so much to choose from. I ordered the corn beef Benedict with home fries. So good and hearty. The coffee was perfect and the serve was readily available to refresh the cup. The customers and staff all looked happy and pleased with their orders. We will for sure be back the next time we are in town. read more

Stopped here during our drive from NY to RI. The staff was friendly and attentive throughout our visit. We ordered the chicken Al Graco, Greek salad, and chicken souvlaki, though they were out of the lamb shish kebab. The chicken souvlaki came as minced chicken rather than the usual cubed pieces, and it had a good amount of onions and tomatoes. The chicken Al Graco and Greek salad were decent. Overall, it was an okay experience though we have had better food at other diners previously. read more

Good Greek diner with all your diner classics and favorites. Service is excellent with orders arriving quickly from the kitchen. Price point is average but they do cater to those folks seeking a simple but reasonably priced lunch. The diner is literally off the exit of I-95 North or South in Milford CT which makes it a very convenient stop for travelers seeking a good quick meal when passing through. Stop by and give them a try; see if you agree. read more

Athenian Diner III - Toasted Cheese tomato sandwich and fries. - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Stopped in for breakfast and was immediately greeted with a smile--super friendly and fast service that made me feel right at home. The atmosphere is classic diner comfort: clean, cozy booths, lots of natural light, and that relaxed, unpretentious vibe you hope for in a breakfast spot. Now for the highlight: the challah French toast. Wow. Perfectly cooked--crispy edges, fluffy inside, and just the right amount of sweetness. It's the kind of dish that makes you stop mid-bite and say, "Okay, this is why people love diners." Paired with a hot, smooth cup of coffee, it made for an absolutely satisfying meal. Prices are really reasonable, especially considering the generous portions and quality. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Athenian Diner III is worth the stop. Will definitely be back--and probably ordering the French toast again! read more

Delicious! Great portion sizes too. The service was very friendly and plenty of seating. The menu has a huge variety to choose from for breakfast, lunch or dinner. I have been here several times and they never disappoint. Great location. read more

Athenian Diner III - Now thats a crock of soup! - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

"Joy to the world All the boys and girls now Joy to the fishes in the deep blue sea Joy to you and me" (Three Dog Night) Any server with the name "Joy" automatically has a big challenge ahead when it comes to customer service, professionalism, efficiency, and friendliness. Our server, coincidentally with the name "Joy", was fantastic, and she did her name proud. The Athenian is one of those garguantuan sized diners that could easily make you think you were sitting in a booth on Long Island or in New Jersey. I was there Thursday for a business lunch and thoroughly enjoyed my visit. The Athenian's parking lot is big so parking isn't a problem. The problem you'll have is navigating their enormous menu to decide what to eat. The lunch menu had 11 burgers (really 22 if you considered their 'deluxe' options), 10 Triple Decker Sandwiches, 8 cold salad platters, 6 diet plates, 10 tortilla wraps, 28 sandwiches, 3 Greek specialties, 5 Grinders, and 9 salads. So are you hungry yet? I went with a small Chefs Salad ($14.99) with eight big julienned pinwheels of turkey, roast beef, ham, swiss & america cheese piled on top of sliced tomatoes, hard boiled egg & cucumbers on a bed of mixed greens. The $14.99 serving was massive and I took home about 2/3rds of it. Growing up near New Jersehy and Long Island, I'm a big fan of these big diners that serve a big variety of cuisines and food styles. Milford's Athenian and our delightful server puts them right up there among the best of the best. read more

See all

Classic diner. The menu is vast, the staff was quick and friendly. I got a view of the delicious looking desserts but I didn't have any room to enjoy them. Service was pretty quick, little less than half the tables were sat. I ordered the monte cristo, Amy got the Moussaka, it was really good, I would order that next time! The Monte cristo had fresh ingredients and tasted good but I didn't expect it to be open face and made eating it a little difficult. Not a bad stop on the way out of the city. If you visit try some of those desserts for us :) read more

See all

"Shiny Diner" in Milford is so good. I had to write in cuz I recently ordered a tuna melt to go that was perfect. I could only eat half because I ordered potato salad instead of fries which was great too. Note, if you have leftover melt, Preheated my airfryer to 300 for 5 mins. Added leftover sandwich and cooked 4 mins a side and it was still incredible. A new favorite. Chicken rice soup is always divine. If you go for dinner, their sole francaise is amazing. (Just taste, often needs a bit of salt). And their carrot cake homemade by a gentleman there who's been making it for years is also incredibly moist. Yum. And the young gentleman/server often at desk is so nice if your friendly to him and the Muslim server with the hijab (I hate that I don't remember her name) is my favorite server--love her. Always so kind and fun and professional. read more

Athenian diner , came here for the French toast and I was blown away by how delicious my bread was so soft and melted in my mouth . I've also tried the smooth creamy fettuccine Alfredo with chicken and broccoli , the meal was amazing . More than I could finish, it was just as delicious the next day . Many grateful meal options to choose from . You won't be disappointed going here to eat. read more

Athenian Diner III - Food is delicious - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

at some diners, they have various tricks they pull to "boost" your check. This is one of those diners, unfortunately. Takes the fun out of it. and if you ask about it, it's "hey, that's too bad". Yup, it's too bad. Will never return to this diner after two "boost" incidents, and the reply is "too bad". Yup, it's too bad. Will never return. read more

Delicious! Wait staff was friendly and super fast; my sandwich was fresh and the fries were crispy (and cheesy, my fav!). Clean and classic diner feel- I loved the oldies music playing. Felt old school in the best way. read more

Athenian Diner III - Turkey club - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Nicely seasoned food, not over salted or peppered Eggs Benedict Florentine with potatoes. Portions gave me an option for breakfast for tomorrow. Server was attentive & helpful. Warm & welcoming environment. Price point was perfect. Highly recommend "Shiny Diner" experience. Gave a 4 only to inspire to always push for sublime. I don't like to bother servers, it'd be nice to have alternate sweeteners accessible to patrons. read more

Athenian Diner III - Eggs Benedict Florentine w/ potatoes - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

I rarely give out 5 stars, but hear me out on this one. The food is delicious for a diner, does not have that diner food that generically gets served. When was the last time you saw liver in a diner menu? Which was good by the way. My kids absolutely adore the fettuccine Alfredo with chicken. The service is good- very attentive considering it being a diner, slow downs might happen if it's busy but not as much. The owner is very nice. Ambiance, it's a diner.... But very welcoming. My family breakfast/ lunch spot. Getting 5 stars is just all about getting a really good experience. read more

Had a tasteless lunch with soup and a turkey burger. The burger was paper thin on a tasteless roll. The service was fair at best. I would not recommend this diner. It is not what you would expect from a diner. read more

This has always been my diner of choice when meeting with friends. Too bad I have to find a new place. I met with a friend who i just reconnected with for breakfast. We ordered, ate, then sat and talked. I have to say, I have never been kicked out of a diner in my life....no matter how long we stayed! After an hour and a half the woman who was working the front register continually stared us down from afar, which made us a bit uncomfortable. Then she walked by our table several times as she looked straight at us. Finally she told us it was lunch time and walked away. It was barely 11:30 am. She came back a few minutes later and said it again and pointed to the tables and booths. The diner was more than half empty. Every table near us was unoccupied. We went to the register to pay and I told her that she was rude and that neither of us had ever been forced out of a diner before. I looked over at all the empty tables and she told said "don't look over there...it's lunchtime!" I've been to many diners in my time and never ever was forced out after 1 1/2. Needless to say, neither of us will ever go back. IHOP is the place to go! Also, if in the Bethel area, try Stony Hill Diner on Stony Hill Rd. It's the best of the best! (Especially their pastrami!!!) read more

Excellent quick and friendly service. Clean and typical diner vibe. My Moussaka was really good. Hot and flavorful. Matt's Monte Cristo was open, which I've never seen, but he said it was good. Easy right off I95 stop, I'd definitely stop again. read more

Had the feta cheese omelet which cost extra.It was over cooked and dry.The omelet had hardly any cheese in it.The only thing that made this bad meal enjoyable was the staff not the owner who shrugged his shoulders. read more

Food was good. Service was good. Our waitress had hair sticking out of her nostrils. Gross.

We were looking for a delicious meal and found one here. The waitstaff were very personable, friendly and attentive. The menu offered a variety of dishes with desserts made on there on the premises. The prices were very reasonable and I would not hesitate to eat here again. read more

Athenian Diner III - Broiled London Broil - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

My boyfriend and I have been having shiny diner dinner dates for a few weeks now. We've been going during the week when it's quiet. Service has been great each time we've gone. He usually has grilled cheese and fries or pancakes and I have a BEC on a hard roll with home fries. I love that our shiny friends don't use that weird smoked bacon so many places use, and home fries are good and moist! I hate when they are all dried out. Shiny diner is a solid option when you have a hankering for some good old fashioned diner food. read more

Athenian Diner III - BEC and home fries - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

We stopped in to grab a quick breakfast since the place we were going to still had not opened for the day. Essentially speaking it is a diner and it delivers on all the things you expect a diner to be-quick, no nonsense comfort food. I had a cup of coffee with a pancake with sausage and toast. My girlfriend had a grilled cheese with a sunny side egg with orange juice. Everything was as expected quick and delicious. Since there wasn't a crowd we felt safe and secure in regards to Covid-19 concerns read more

See all

Great friendly service. My husband had the fried seafood platter and said it was the best he's had in a long time. They serve delicious fresh bread with their entrees. Good service and friendly and very reasonable prices. read more

Great food. Great Service. So many options on the menu. I had the corn beef and cabbage. It was a special on today's menu. Everything about it was so great. The waitress provided top quality service. This diner is a great place. Bright like you would expect a diner to be. read more

When my mother and I were on our way -- traveling to Massachusetts, we stumbled upon this wonderful place by luck. And we were wonderfully surprised by Athenian Diner's warm service, fast short-order cooking, and close attention to customers. My mom ordered a custom breakfast: one (1) egg, one (1) sausage, and homemade potatoes. She said it was perfect. As for me, I ordered the challah French toast with bacon, and a cup of cappuccino. What a treat! Loved this place! If we're ever in Milford, CT, we'll be sure to stop by this lovely establishment. . . and you should too. read more

Going to work on New Year's Day and everything was closed so I stopped at Athenian diner. I had eggs Benedict with corned beef hash. It was ok, not great. Minimal service, menu with glass of water, I asked for coffee , coffee refilled in good time, breakfast to table , check. No frills breakfast. read more

Our waitress Kelly charged me extra for a side even with free refills and to add onto that she was just rude. read more

Athenian Diner III - While dining at the Athenian diner I was charged for a refill. The waitress was blatantly rude to me and my table. - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

Excellent brunch today at Athenian diner in Milford. It is always a pleasure to see a restaurant fully staffed, clean, organized, and with a wonderful selection on the menu made from fresh ingredients! We had the Florentine omelette and the vegetable omelette. Both were cooked to perfection. The service was wonderful and we were in and out in a timely fashion. Keep up the great work Evie! read more

I used to call this place the "silver diner" growing up because it is basically an all mirror building right off of 95 on the Boston post road. Service is always friendly and quick. There food is traditional diner options. I would rate the quality of the food as decent and the portions are to be as expected. Pricing is very fair and there is lots of parking. The interior seems a bit run down and needs some modern updating. Basically if you're looking for diner food this is a great spot to stop at to get a quick meal in. read more

Athenian Diner III - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Rude waiter, disrespectful. Interrupted our conversation without an "excuse me". Delivered our juice and coffee and when asked for milk, he looked like he was being bothered. Came back with the milk on a dish and unceremoniously slammed and I mean SLAMMED it on the table and left. We gathered our belongings, detailed what occurred to the front cashier, offered to pay for what was served and we bounced. We went to Pops up the road. read more

Pleasantly surprised. Went for dinner on Thursday night. The chicken orzo soup was pretty okay. The wings we enjoyed. Hubby had the chicken scarpariello and it looked and tasted really good. I ordered the Philly cheese steak triple decker which was very tasty. Couldn't finish it so hubby finished it later on he found it was really good. Decided to go back last night. He had the Greek salad with anchovies. He enjoyed it! The grape leaves were good he said. I had a chicken and rice soup which was ok. I also had a mushroom omelet. No flavor. Didn't like how the mushroom smelled. We took wings to go, a small Caesar salad and the Philly cheese steak sandwich. The wings weren't cooked thoroughly like they were the night before. I don't want to see pink in my chicken. Salad was fine and so was the sandwich which we had for breakfast. All in all.. a pretty decent diner. read more

Great food and staff. Our weekend breakfast stop. Can't say enough good things about the staff. They are amazing. Food is excellent and the ambiance is a true finer experience. Love it. read more

One of the better diners I've been to in the area. Manager James is very nice. Excellent baklava! Everything we had was good. read more

Athenian Diner III - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

POTATOE SALAD is a must. Its not something you ever really hear these day but seriously , Its a must. These day places brag about delicious sandwiches , which they have the bufallo wrap, the patty melt, The ruben with pastrimi , the meatloaf sandwich., the onions rings are great and daily souos are yum.. but The humble winning that really get your attention is the potatoe salad.. next time you order one of the great sandwiches. Opt for potatoe as your side, you will thank me.. ..Give me a thumbs up after you try it , it wont disapoint .. read more

See all

Stopped on the way back from daughters college, food good, service provided by Mike attentive, food came out quick and prices were good, what else can you ask for? read more

Athenian Diner III - diners sitting at tables in a restaurant - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

See all

Stopped in here tonight for a quick dinner before going shopping. Believe this is some kind of a chain restaurant . The food was good and we both ordered breakfast eggs hashbrowns and toast everything was fine. read more

Athenian Diner III - Diner - Diners Near Me - Milford, Connecticut

We had terrible service never saw our waiter but once or twice. They are understaffed and have gone down hill. My meal which was a simple chicken dish arrived 25 mins after my friends. My meal was terrible and a mess like it was heated in a microwave. They made no attempt to apologize for the 25 min wait and the poor quality of the food. They didn't even care in the slightest. I warn anyone not to go here find a good diner. read more

The food is always delicious and affordable, and most of the time the service is excellent...really depends on who your waiter is.