Went in there on a Sunday morning for a simple egg sandwich totally screwed it up very overpriced. The price I could deal with getting home and seeing a sandwich is totally messed up not eatable. Unacceptable. read more

Strathmore Bagels are always good. Not too bready, the right outside crust and always a good amount of toppings on the salt, everything bagels etc. read more

Delicious every time! The line is usually long but move quickly showing they are both popular and efficient.

This has to be one of the worst bagel stores on the Island. Bagels are doughballs! Don't bother with the egg sandwiches. They are disgusting bacon wasn't even cooked. Just paid for $26 for two egg sandwiches that got thrown in the garage! Service is terrible, they totally forgot my order. Total disappointment! read more

I've been coming here since the early 2000s, and nothing has changed--the same old place, and the owner still has a way of sucking the air out of the room. I think his name is Rob. There's one lady who's been there forever, though, and she's incredibly sweet, with blonde hair. The rest of the staff is friendly as well. Cream cheese is amazing but bagels use to be good. I just wish they would update the place, bring back the old bagel taste and that the owner would smile once in a while. read more

This owner believes his store is on 5th Avenue with the prices he charges. A roll with eggs, lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, and avocado with a cup of coffee $18?! for a couple dollars more, I will go to a diner where the service is brought to my table and get free coffee refills. A charge of $3.50 for a few small slices of avocado. Home fries were given however they were like chewing in pebbles. Never again at any Strathmore Bagels. read more

I love this Strathmore, friendly staff, delicious bagels, love that you get delicious potatoes with the egg sandwich. I came here a couple weeks ago with my 1 year old son, it was busy but I was craving a BEC and didnt mind waiting a few minutes on line. Since it was a little busy we were there for about 7-10 minutes. Seeing my son was getting a little antsy, the owner gave him a rainbow bagel to munch on as we wait. A little thing like that just made me a customer for life. Thank you! read more

The only thing that grosses me out is the fact that NO ONE takes off their gloves when handling the food and money. That's gross.

Solid bagel joint. Line moved a bit slow this morning but the staff on hand did as well as they could. Give them credit and happy to see they are doing well as their bagels are worth it. Soft inside, just right crisp on the outside, and a good sized bagel. Sesame and everything bagels totally covered which I love. They don't skimp on the ingredients here. Oh, and buy a quarter pound of veggie cream cheese and get one free. Nice deal! read more

See all

Came in cause I wanted something for lunch. Never been here, workers were nice and made sure I got my Tuscan under the Sun the way I wanted. I was very close to closing (I didn't know) but I wasn't rushed and neither was my food. Have to try the bagels to give it 5 stars as it is a bagel place, will be back read more

We each ordered the bacon, egg and cheese on an everything egg bagel and it was everything a BEC sandwich should be! The home fries served on the side were equally delicious. The sandwich, though, 10/10 YES. Yum! read more

The owner of this bagel shop is the most disrespectful arrogant person that I have ever met. I don't know what his problem was with me, but I did nothing to him, but come in and try to get my order placed with one of his workers, and he felt it was necessary to rudely interrupt, and not only that work through me, forcing me to move otherwise, we would've most certainly bumped into each other respect goes a long way and being nice it's effortless. I don't care how long you owned your business you don't need to talk or treat anyone the way you have treated me as a customer today I am repulsed by your mannerism and you should be ashamed of yourself being as old as you are Talking down and treating someone that way doesn't matter your color, shape or size everyone deserves respect maybe you need to take a class or refresher on just that. Word of advice; humble yourself. It's not nice to go out your way to upset anyone day. read more

I give it 3 starts for offering no gluten kneaded bagels, they are amazing and love they support another local business. Where I take issue is that they like to close early on Sundays. We have tried on 2 of occasions to run in a get a quick bagel 10 minutes before closing and they shouted both times that they were closed. Ok, I get it, no one likes for people to come right before closing but you say you close at 2. Close at 2 or advertise you have to be there by 1:45. So this time when we attempted to come at 1:35 we walked in and we were told that the grill was already off. Again, I get it, Sunday isa busy day and you are probably over it, but again, not the best business practice. I will say that everyone is alway nice when they share this info.. Update: I updated the review and gave the 2 stars back. I appreciate the owner explaining the situation. I'm sorry that they are experiencing this as a business and I look forward to purchasing the frozen gluten free bagels. They really are delicious. read more

Trash bucket egg sandwich. $8.00 for a sandwich that fell apart with undercooked home fries in the box. Keep your shitty home fries and learn how to make a sandwich read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

See all

The food service was great and the price is right. Staff is beyond amazing and professional. the owner is a nice guy and runs a great show, he just has to smile a little more and lose the attitude at times on the workers. Overall great food great staff just ease up boss man read more

The egg sandwich was delicious with crispy bacon. The home fries.....omg the best I've ever had!

" YEARS OF EXCELLENCE" in our community.... Pristine Clean ....friendly team.... phone orders ready less than 5 minutes!!!! we can't take the EFFICIENCY ( ON POINT)walk in tended to immediately... A-1 TEAM " execute with excellence"..... breakfast platters, lunch sandwiches, grill orders " PERFECTO" ...just one of my fancy favorites ....." work of art" !!! most served with juice, coffee or hot chocolate.... nothing but the best products "GRADE - A" QUALITY beyond price savy!!!!! we....love ...... it ..... here......... read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

See all

Staff is super friendly but not in an annoying way, it's just like genuine nice people. Food is amazing and service is very quick.

Mixed feelings here. The breakfast sandwiches were done well, orders correct a little pricey. The bagels always seem to taste old and i find it SO strange. read more

I order from Uber eats and this is how strathmore bagels treated my food. I opened this and immediately refunded my food ! When I called to complain about this lazy work they kept me on hold longer than 5 mins and didn't return to the line ! Horrible service and disgusting presentation of food ! If I can give zero stars, I would ! read more

Strathmore Bagels - 2 Eggs with Meat and Cheese on A Roll mess ! - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

See all

Filthy place, horrible service, over priced. I orders a bec this was $8.00 they forgot my juice and I waited about a half hour. read more

See all

For the nasty owner of this location. Want better bagels go to bagel basket or bagel cafe. Worth the trip and the money. I decide. To go to your location. You are expensive and not that good so you aren't much different from Ronkonkoma location. read more

Very solid. Free home fries w egg sandwiches is a great bonus...bagels are a 7.5/10 but the hot breakfast options really shine! The owner kinda a meh but staff is nice! read more

I don't usually post bad reviews, I own several businesses across Long Island, and I believe in giving a buisness a chance to do the right thing before posting, but also make it easy for customers to reach the owner. Since they don't have a website or answer Facebook. I'm leaving it on here. Purchased bagels, have no problem with service and bagels thought they where great. My only problem is the law that was broken charging a convenience fee. I didn't by a $1.29 drink and got charged I purchased $13.00 worth of food. And got charged a fee for using my debit card and I didn't even get told that I'm going to be charged for it. Charging someone to purchase something at there buisness is pretty stupid if you ask me. It's going to cost them more because my $14 a week that I'm spending will now go somewhere else. If I would have been told that they charge a fee, I would have walked out and they would have lost a sale. Pretty shady if you ask me, Definitely won't be back. Credit card processing is an annoying charge to pay, as a business owner, but it's the cost of doing business. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Breaking the law, charging a convenience fee - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

I love a fresh bagel right out of the oven and that's exactly what I got! It's also right up the block from home, so I can't go wrong!! Found my new bagel spot. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

Ever hear of the expression "dressing up an old lady"? You'll find it here in the flesh. My friend and I ordered an egg bagel and a poppy seed bagel, both of which were far less dense than what a real bagel should be, a sure indication a proper boiler is nowhere in sight. Baked hard roll anyone? But the cream cheese selection is quite good, cleverly disguising the forgery underneath a mountain of flavor (at least they can't be accused of being cheap on the toppings). The garlic/herb spread was excellent, as was the ever-so-rare vanilla/raisin/walnut (warning: it contains sugar). Their tea selection is lame, so welcome to a Lipton world - quite pathetic in this modern age of choices. Will I be back? No way. There are better options close by. But if you are 100% clueless about what a great bagel is, by all means stop by and indulge. read more

Strathmore Bagels - Cant't eat all the cream cheese? Join the crowd! - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

This is the best bagel restaurant in the area! Professional friendly service. Food and coffee is outstanding! read more

Strathmore Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Selden, New York

See all

Staff is great; friendly and efficient.... Bagels are consistently fresh... egg sandwiches and Omlet's are always good.

Place needs to be cleaned, sit at a booth and look in the case or the floor ceiling just very grungy. Not talkin about just a wife down needs a deep clean at least once a month. read more

Very bad. They did not listen to my order which was for a bagel with butter. Instead I got a bagel with cream cheese. So annoying!

I'm in this store probably once a week over about the past year. Their egg sandwich and home fries combo is phenomenal. I also specifically look for Martina when I come in, I love her! read more

no matter what i've ordered from here, it always comes out great and exactly how/what i ask..besides the food being really good, the staff is NICE! can you believe it !? never once have i heard or seen an attitude..just smiles and politeness read more

One of the best bagel shops in Long Island! Love their sesame and egg bagels. Soft drink selection is good too.

Just put cold cheese on my egg sandwhich and barely cut the sandwhich. Horrible quality

This is the best bagel store in town! Food is always delicious! Very clean store and friendly customer service! The workers know how to move through a line fast, and they always get the orders right! Definitely my go to bagel store! read more

If I could give this place 0 stars I would... The staff is so RUDE. 1. my BF ordered and then they went one their way, didn't even acknowledge me or that I wanted anything. 2. I finally ordered, not even fully and she walked away in the middle of me ordering 3. The menu SUCKS, you don't know the prices to anything because it's all chicken scratch 4. A BEC on a bagel is $4.69... With egg whites it's up to $6.50... No one tells you that! Spent a total of $30 for 3 bagels... I had lox and cream cheese on a bialy for $10... It's extra to get a different flavor of cream cheese... My total should have been about $18 and cost me an EXTRA $10 for BULLSHIT THINGS!! Food wasn't even that good for their ridiculous prices. I will NEVER be back to place again. Summary? Prices are RIDICULOUS, the staff and service are HORRIBLE, and the food SUCKS. DO NOT GO HERE!!! read more

Third week in a row I have tried this bagel store. And third week in a row the sausage on my breakfast San which was almost still frozen in the middle. Horrible service. I figured I'd give them another chance but yet still the same result even after telling them the problem read more

Bagels are good..but that's about it. You can't charge some surcharge / convenience fee for using a credit card..not allowed in NYS! They also don't change gloves after handling money/use the register. This is a problem with most places in Suffolk... read more

As others have said... decent sandwiches, kinda annoying they force the whole meal on you and don't really tell you that when you think you're ordering a basic bec, I was excited to get a coffe with my sandwich then they rang me up... almost ten bucks, yeah you get home fries too...but that's not what I asked for, they should offer the mean instead of just ringing you up for it, some people aren't thaaat hungry and just want a sandwich. As for the bagels.... stonybrook is sooo much better, the ones at this location are always well done and dried out bc of it, I recommend getting it toasted with butter to enjoy it bc by itself it's very dry and overdone, it doesn't taste right with cream cheese. I go here for the convenience but there's better places, it's a shame bc the other locations are great but this one only seems to share the name and price point (pricey AF), the bagels are the same flavors but completely different in look and taste. It ain't terrible but it has no right being as overpriced as it is read more

I like how the breakfast sandwich came with home fries and the lady who helped me was nice - that explains the stars . Food was extremely overpriced 14$ for a sand which "free home fries" and a Snapple. read more