Place was highly recommended, but I'm afraid it did not meet my expectations. "Best Steak in town" it was claimed but only because there wasn't an Outback around! $37 for a 14 oz ribeye was ridiculous for price. Plain baked potato and mixed veggies wit broccoli that was not cooked. I've actually had better at most chains. If I were to rank Outback a 10 this place would be a 4. read more

We enjoy the ambiance of Baxters ... You can arrive casual & enjoy outside seating, bar seating, table top service, or dine in the large comfy private booths. The menu has a nice range from sandwiches, soups & salads to very decadent chef specials. The steak is one of my favorites, it always satisfies & has never wavered on quality, cut, or taste. Foods are often provided with basic seasoning and may be somewhat pleasantly bland compared to some other high end dining experiences- but you can request optional seasoning as you like. Baxter's servers are always a pleasant distraction from the usual ... They seem genuinely happy to provide service and work hard to ensure you are happy, served well, and enjoy your visit. At times, like playoffs & big events, the bar can become very crowded & loud - but the dining rooms on the walled sides diffuse the commotion very well. Reservations are recommended for larger parties and weekend evenings. read more

Food was tasty, over priced for slightly tattered surroundings and staff in tee shirts and sneakers. Was quick in and out. read more

Baxter's - American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

To be fair I ordered a carry out chicken sandwhich, way overcooked. I did read the menu....just my two cents, when most of the steaks have a sauce with them, I question the steakhouse. Let the steak speak for itself. read more

We were told if you want steak on the island go to Baxters so we did! They had a varied menu but we were in the mood for steak! Bruce ordered rib eye, 14oz, $30...I ordered blue cheese topped sirloin, 7oz, $27. We ordered a bowl of she crab soup...good. Dinner comes with salad (house-lots of fresh Romaine, 1/4 tomato, 1 slice red onion, 2 cucumber slices..tangy balsamic dressing/ husband-Caesar he said was good), medium baked potato, mixed vegs and bread. Bruce's steak seemed to have a bit of gristle and he had to eat in a way to get the tender meat; mine was thick and tasty. It took 45 min. to get our meal which rushed us to get to our 8 pm engagement. Was it good..yes, was it great....? Should we try again with unlimited time...maybe? Will we..... probable not. read more

Other's at my table enjoyed their meal, but nothing was over the top. I ordered the Thai salmon, as soon as it came out it had a smell. I tasted it, had my mom taste it and she spit it out...I would have gotten sick if I ate it. Others at my table could smell the fishiness. When the tab came they took off the salmon (obviously) but they charged us for the Cesar salad (the one that originally came with my meal) lol. I didn't even order a substitute meal. read more

Baxter's - American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Very expensive, very average/poor food. We had a party of 5 that took over hour to get the average food. We all ordered the ribeye ($31 each!). Medium steaks were overcooked, but not warm, baked potato was at least a day old and cold. Butter for potatoes was requested, never got. Two stars are generous. read more

The service was lousy, but the food was fabulous! This was my second time there, and I was really impressed with the steak diane. Yum! The ceasar salad was fabulous too! If I were staying here in Amelia Island, Fl for awhile, I'd go back too. read more

Bad Food & Rude Manager We were very disappointed with the dinner tonight. Our burger was very bland, flavorless; Salad only consisted of small plate of lettuce, one slice of onion & a few pieces of tomato; Escargot tasted like it was out of a can & the sourdough bread taste like it's hasn't been baked throughly; Onion soup, very bland; My son's Fettuccine pasta was not edible-tastes like dry grated cheese just tossed with the pasta. But worse of all was when we complained to the manager, he was defensive & said that they have the best burger in town!! Ignoring completely our comment & opinion, no apology for all the food & made us feel like we don't know anything about food! I'm an Asian foodie & know my food pretty well. His treatment of the customer was unacceptable. I don't expect good response for normal cheaper restaurant, but this a place where they charge in the upper $20 & lower $30 for their steak! The one star is for the waitress that was unfortunately the only good experience at the restaurant. I never give any review at Yelp, but I think the food, especially the manager deserve a fair review so others will be far warned. read more

THIS PLACE IS TRASH!!!!!!!!!!!! It took them 2 hours to get my food and it tasted horrible Only recommend this restaurant to people you dislike read more

Yelp rating system (Three stars = A-OK) Steaks are just okay. Don't get your hopes too high up. Nothing special. It's not bad but they do all this boasting about amazing steaks which is not really that true. read more

I lived on Amelia Island back in the mid-90's and Baxter's was around then. It's still there and so is the same bartender Mike. He did a good job then and still takes care of his bar guests. Reasonably priced food and drinks, but the preparation lacks a little something. Stopped in one night for a burger at the bar. For the price, it's a great deal, but if was over cooked, the tomato was all white and hard (inedible) and although I asked for onion and a side of BBQ, they didn't come with the burger...had to ask again. Went back a few days later for dinner. Then seafood platter had shrimp, grouper and scallops, but again, lacked any flavor. I know grouper is flavorless, but the Cajun seasoning was not present. Service was great on the return visit. Overall, good to stop in for drinks. Not my first choice for food. read more

We had 12 people this past New Years Eve 2017, and our server Debbie was Superb! Every single appetizer and entree came out at the same time and was PERFECT! The steaks were tender (my Filet was like butter) and very generous in size. They all had a delicious charcoal flavor. The seafood combo was very large and everything on it tasted fresh and prepared to order. The escargot was wonderful with a very crispy bread for dipping. The Ceasar salads were crisp with the right amount of dressing! I had friends come in from Florida and SC and they all were thrilled with their food. I was so happy we made such a GREAT CHOICE IN BAXTERS! read more

We've eaten here for years. The food is always good. So is the service. The locals eat here so you know they're doing something right

So we are staying in Amelia Island for the weekend and our parents got us a gift card to go to Baxters because of how amazing this place is. They recommended we get there at 4:55 pm so we get a seat at the bar as soon as it opens at 5. We weren't able to make that, however when we did arrive, there was a booth saved for us near the back. The bar was packed, people laughing and carrying on (which is always a good sign)! So we sat, ordered our drinks and the conch fritters for our app. Everything came out pretty quickly. After enjoying our app, we ordered our meals- rack of lamb and ribs ... Amazing. Both were absolutely phenomenal! I have not ordered ribs on my own and wow, am I glad this was my first time! Simply amazing! Hands down a must to visit if you're visiting the Island! read more

Baxter's - Old Fashion & Yuengling @ Baxters - American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Very busy Friday night! Fun environment and attentivee service. The burger and Steak Diane were fantastic! Prime rib was not great...tough and flavor was lacking. Everything else was fantastic. Great seasoning on the burger and flavor was spot on with the Diane sauce read more

I had read that Baxters is like an over priced Apple Bees, well that is spot on. At a table of 8 no ones meal was cooked right and it was either over or under done. I had the seafood combo and it was nothing special. Very disappointed over all. read more

Cute local hangout! The bar is very busy and the place serves a nice selection of food. I have this on my list for my return to Amelia Island! read more

My wonderful husband and I had a very nice dinner here on a Monday night. Hostess and waitress were phenomenal. The shrimp cocktail was great. We had the grouper gourmet and filet for dinner. They were both great and worth the price. I would definitely come here again! read more

Baxter's - Shrimp cocktail! - American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

I ordered the petite filet. It was average, comparable to a Longhorn's dinner. The shrimp cocktail appetizer was unappealing yet adequate. Service was fine but the corner booth they sat us at was lumpy with a very bright light right in my face. We stopped because the sign said best steak in town. I don't have any other steak in this town to compare it to so they might be right. read more

We had a nice enjoyable family dinner the other night. Server did an ok job but wasn't the most enthusiastic but she did well. We had the crab cake appetizer which was my favorite by far. I will be back for sure to have these crab cakes. The brie appetizer is great to share and the roasted garlic was a nice touch! For my entree I had the fresh grouper (blackened) with veggies and a mashed potato. I don't like salads so the waitress was able to sub a vegetable beef soup instead which was really yummy. Grouper was great and I would definitely have it again. read more

Food was very good. Outstanding bartender. Works her tail off. Ambiance was not that good. Run down. Entrance has outdoor seating that is in very bad shape. Does not look appealingly read more

The food is decent. The burgers and wines are good. Appetizers terrible. Bar staff is completely inattentive unless you are a long time regular, the bartender won't even wait on you. Appalling customer service. I guess they do not need the money, tips or any new business. Will not be back. Many other places across the street. Be careful who you choose not to provide good service to. read more

The menu was unimaginative, but had "safe" options. The service was excruciatingly slow, though from what I saw in the dining room, it seems more the fault of the kitchen, rather than the server. The server was upbeat and pleasant, but, I imagine, tired of apologizing. The fish sandwich was tasty. The French Onion Soup contained no beef broth, as far as I could tell, though it was a good soup, nonetheless. For the price, this is not a good option. read more

We ordered takeout as we were staying close by and still being cautious. Had the Chicken Marsala (recommended) and the Seafood Combo due to the fact the online menu had not been updated and the Gourmet Grouper not available. Food just so so. Vegetables were bland and cold and seemed to come from frozen package. Sauce gummy on chicken. read more

Great experience! Greeted by lovely hostess Kami and also by the owner! Seated immediately and drinks on the table quickly! Food was excellent and everything was just as we'd ordered! Glasses stayed filled and all needs were anticipated without us requesting!! Will definitely be back!! Steak, Ribs, Pasta, and shrimp were all delicious!! Local owned read more

Looking back, I should of trusted other yelpers reviews in regards to Baxter's. I was craving a delicious steak and for the most part received that. The booth that I was seated in was lumpy and the lighting was horrible. The server truly didn't want to be there. The food was less than mediocre. I ordered the Caesar salad, filet mignon, baked potato and veggies. nothing special about the salad (it didn't even come with croutons)or the veggies (slivers of red peppers and zucchini). The filet was cooked perfect and although salty, still quite good. I do not want to even discuss the baked potato because it was that bad. read more

Amazing! Great food and great service My fiancé and I just happened across this gem while driving. We plan to come back on every future Amelia island trip! read more

The food was mediocre at best. The prime rib was tough and tasteless. The horseradish was good. The salad reminded me of grocery store bagged lettuce with mealy tomatoes. The red fish and shrimp stuffed mushroom caps tasted like they came out of the frozen food aisle of local grocery store, plain awful. The bread was good Our waitress was good I would never go back. read more

Baxter's is one of our favorite places on the island. The service and food are great. Never disappointed. Very consistent.

Past visits were moderate. Most recent proved to be one of lackluster service. Ordered drinks at the bar and waited, waited and waited to place an order. Watched as arriving customers were served drinks. We left without ordering. Manager said it was busy. Have been at Baxters previously when the place was packed and received better service. Good luck when you will need the locals! read more

Baxter's is Amelia islands version of cheers. The majority of my time was spent at the bar having drinks and a late night snack. The bartenders are snarky yet very funny. They will be your friends remember your name and your drink of choice. Matt "aka Dexter" to the locals, and Michael "aka Doc" run the bar like a well oiled machine. As the night goes on, the atmosphere gets better and better. Ask them for a TicTac, a custom drink that Matt and Michael have mastered. As far as the food is concerned its much what you would expect from a place like Baxter's, with a few very unusual additions, the escargot are not too shabby. The burgers are the exception, standout burgers that make you grin ear to ear. 3 stars because im really cheap with my stars but also because this is a great place to grab a burger and a beer if you don't want to be "downtown" and just want a place to stop in get good service and go home. Baxter's should not be confused for a high end steakhouse, or fine dinning experience. read more

Me and my boyfriend just recently moved to the area and decided to go here for dinner after work. Things started out ok when we were seated it wasn't the greatest service to start out with but nothing crazy. We ordered our food and we both got the gourmet burger. It came out pretty quickly but the restaurant wasn't packed so it didn't seem unusually fast . As always I cut my burger in half to make it easier to eat and as soon as I separated the two half's it was nothing but a raw burger. The bottom bun was soaked in blood ! I stoped my boyfriend from taking a bite of his and asked him to cut open his and it was exactly the same if not worse ! I call the waitress to our table who walked by twice already and didn't make an effort to ASK us if our food was ok, I had to call her over as she was walking past the THIRD time. I showed her the food and she said " oh those are a little to medium rare " and I looked at her like she was crazy and replied " no this is a raw burger " . She tried making it seem like this was normal so I quickly corrected her because my boyfriend and I or anyone else could have gotten extremely sick from this! So she brings us new burgers but at that point I had lost my appetite and the rest of our time spent there we sat waiting around to get any further service and our check we had to waive her down to get anything . The whole time we never got to speak to a manager or got any apologies or anything just a check and a " thanks for coming " . NEVER again will I eat at this restaurant! Disgusting! They acted like this kind of thing was normal. read more

Baxter's - American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Great dining experience for my family! We very much enjoyed our dinner at Baxters! Our group included our boys ages 5 and 6 who were perfectly happy with their meals! The service was excellent - very friendly and helpful. Decent wine list and my filet mignon was cooked perfectly! read more

Seemed like a good place when looking at the packed parking lot on a Tuesday evening, but its clearly the type of place where the bar is loaded with regulars. I personally do not have an issue with that but some might. Pretty basic surf and turf type place with pretty good prices. Only issue was myself and who I went to dinner with both got very sick and were up throughout the night. Not a place I would ever reccommend. read more

Food was sub par for pricing, but the ambiance was nice. Friendly service the few time wait staff visited the table. Got charged extra for a meal we didn't order. Not worth the trip of the island. We will know for next time! read more

Baxters was very good and very accommodating for our large group. I had the surf and turf, filet and lobster tail, which was all perfectly cooked and well priced at $39. I heard no complaints from our large group. Nice spot to get a good meal off the resort. read more

Great service. Steak way over done, asked for medium got well done. Soft drink was flat. Salads and starter came out at the same time. Carrot cake was very dry. I will give them another chance just no time soon. read more

Brought my wife and kids here for Mother's Day and had quite the poor experience. I was torn between a 1 or 2 star rating but after reading some of the ridiculous experiences others had here regarding billing and poor customer service that seem to be common trends at Baxter's, I gave it a solid 1 star. My wife doesn't eat meat, which isn't much of a big deal. She placed a simple order first and mentioned she would want the mushroom soup and a side of vegetables. Before the waitress finished taking our order, she (wife) had switched it and said she would rather have the vegetable stir-fry entree. When the food all came out, there was no stir-fry, just a small sad cup of vegetables. When we mentioned the stir-fry again, the waitress acknowledged that she had misunderstood and put in the order. That was not even the problematic part. After we were all done about 20-25 minutes later the food came out and my wife ended up pretty much eating by herself on Mother's Day. When the check came, it still had an order of vegetables, and now the full order of stir-fry. Now, if I jacked up someone's order, you should better believe I would comp or partially comp something. But that didn't happen, my wife asked for the vegetable side to be removed which I felt was going way out of our way, when we shouldn't even of paid for a full entree or at least half. Something! The tab was adjusted and no further consideration was given to the entree. If the place had absolutely great food, I could deal with paying a little more but this wasn't the case. I make a way better chicken Marsala then I had at Baxter's, and the ambiance is really poor and outdated. It's like they purchase everything from an estate sale from the 50's. Even after this, I gave the waitress 10% cause I feel like a pretty bad person not tipping someone. We all got mouths to feed and bills to pay, but she didn't deserve that. She deserved 0%. And it was my wife who convinced me to give her anything at all. Hope she realizes the low tip is a product of her service. Accommodate customers and provide a good experience, and they will likely be back. Not this place though...Nothing to praise about at this place. Recommend this restaurant institute the read-back if you don't understand someone's order, or to ensure you have everything right. It's overpriced to begin with, and nothing is that great about this place. As a local, signing off. read more

This is one of the friendliest bars in town. Everyone knows each other --and strangers too. Mike and Kay, the bartenders, are amazing. Drinks are ample and after a while they will know your favorite. Food is very good and reasonably priced. If it's a casual fun and friendly atmosphere you're looking for, this is your place. read more