I'm embarrassed to say that I have never tried Bella Italia before now. This is THEE Italian restaurant I have been looking for. I knew it the second I walked in. Warm cozy Italian feel. Some delicious looking Garlic Knots behind glass calling my name. The menu was complete with all the things you would expect. The house gravy (red sauce) is what separates good Italian food. It was lunch so I opted for Hot Italian Sub. Others ordered pizza, and my wife the White Clam Sauce with linguine. All the food was phenomenal and the service was excellent! The owner came out and spoke with us. What a nice man. I felt like I was back home in Jersey at my Italian friend's grandparents house. (Except no plastic on the couches)...I cannot wait to try more and more and more of the menu. Don't be like me and wait so long before trying Bella Italia. Best real Italian food in Orlando! read more

See all

Absolutely love takeout from Bella Italia, the portions are huge and the food is absolutely delicious. The restaurant is cozy-Italian family vibes, very casual and approachable. This time I ordered the kids portion of cheese ravioli and the garlic knots appetizer. My husband got the baked ziti with meat sauce. Both were delicious and prepared quickly. It's always super easy to pickup and pay. read more

See all

Today I brought a group to Bella. Thought was 12 grew to 24! 1 Server Cassandra unbelievable. Never wavered as group grew. Drinks,food orders,refill. Never stop. Amazing. About 3/4 group was Deaf. Yes. No problem. 24 different orders. All prepared, served hot and tasty. 24 seperate checks Never a problems Robert your guys are great. PLEASE support Bella Italia we want them around a long time Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmospher read more

Bella Italia Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Casual dine in service underperforms. My much older friend wanted to grab dinner and I obliged. Bella was recommended and I agreed as I haven't been before but heard good things. I'll keep this short and sweet, the service was on point and friendly. The salad appetizer was a great portion with plenty of vegetables and the house dressing was simple but good. Now the main part: the pizza... We ordered the supreme loaded pizza and it came out freshly cooked. Unfortunately, the sauce was devoid of flavor, the crust uneventful and for some reason the sausage tasted bland. Don't get me wrong, this wasn't a horrible pie, it was a just a reminder that pizza is diverse and thankfully we have many other better versions in town. The venue has a dated feel and the customers there showed it. I would return to try another dish that wasn't pizza as it had plenty of other options. They also have wine, but no wine list. $42 tab for the loaded pizza, salad and a peroni beer. The very next day I had the large pizza and 20 wings from cornerstone and it was much better at $38. TL;DR: Great service, lots of options, the pizza underperformed . read more

Bella Italia Pizza - House salad - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Bella Italia is as close to perfect as it gets. The pizza is phenomenal, the crust is cooked perfectly, the calzones have a tremendous amount of filling, the garlic knots are mouth watering, the Greek salad is fresh, and the wine selection is impressive for this small location. Aldo and his team are friendly, attentive, helpful, and fun! It can get a little loud on a Friday or Saturday night, but not unreasonably so. A lot of regulars visit, who know each other and converse, which i think positively adds to the experience. We have been here at least a dozen times despite living nearly an hour away. Go check them out! read more

Love this place. Food never disappoints. Always amazing. Friendly staff. Comfy atmosphere.

The staff here is always friendly and happy to serve you. There is a real family feel and the food tastes like it is made with love. You can dine in or carry out and the quality & quantity will be the same. Great menu with lots of delicious options. You can't go wrong! read more

Food is always consistently good. Generous portions. Nice neighborhood restaurant. You will not be disappointed.

Still the best local place around. Everything from pizzas to entrees appetizers salad soups sandwiches calzones strombolis. It may take a little longer but it is worth the wait as is the price. The service and staff couldn't be nicer, especially Dee-Dee. Love that it's non chain keeping it simple and authentic. Please give them a try and support local businesses like this. read more

The Picante pizza is amazing , huge small calzone. Everything is so good. I wish the peppers were cooked a little more. But that's a personal preference. Would recommend. read more

We love eating here. Definitely will return and highly recommended. Pizza is always fresh

We ordered the super deluxe pizza and a Greek salad to share. A 16" pizza is definitely more than enough for 2 people and you will bring home leftovers. The pizza was thick and I love the combo of meat / veggies on the super deluxe. I love when pizza is so hot out of the oven and you can tell how fresh it was and this was exactly my experience here! We also ordered the Greek salad too which was good and I liked the dressing. The service is great we absolutely loved our waitress she was funny and sweet. It gives off very home styles family vibes here. It wasn't a quick in & out dinner but we enjoyed our time spent here. I had their house red wine which was pretty good too. We were talked into (barely lol) getting the homemade tiramisu which was to die for. We were super full after dinner but it was a nice treat for later on. I would love to return here! read more

Bella Italia Pizza - Super deluxe pizza - amazing! - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Family atmosphere, cordial waitresses and good service . Pizza is amazing , wings are awesome.. outstanding place. Visiting from Miami, we will come back for more.. read more

We love Bella Italia! It is family owned and the servers have been there forever! It's a quaint little restaurant with a family feel! We get the Garlic Zeppoli's every time we eat there. Little puffs of fried dough soaked in fresh garlic and butter. So good! The pizzas are great and the chicken Parmesan is fantastic. Bella Italia is our go to restaurant when we want a great tasting pizza! read more

Ordered well done pizza and it wasn't. Asked for Ziti but got Penne which wasn't on the menu. Minor shape difference but tell me it was Penne. Past was over cooked, no texture to it. Too soft. Service was good. Won't be back. read more

This place reminds me of the Italian shops that I used to go to on New York before I moved down South!!!! The place is small, intimate, and the staff is SO very friendly!!! The food is outstanding as well! The Owner , "Aldo" , makes it a point to visit every table and check on his guests !!! Try it........... you'll love it! read more

I've been getting food here for years and it's always delicious! My kids love a meatball and pepperoni pizza while my favorite is the Bianca. They also have awesome salads (antipasto is my fave). You have to get zeppolis with every order! The garlic and the dessert version are equally awesome! I usually pick up our food to have at home but I have eaten in the dining room a couple of times. Cute little place with kind service and some great pasta and meatballs! read more

Great food and service. Love their sauce on spaghetti. Beautifully decorated and staff was very pleasant

We very often order pickup from Bella Italia and every time it ready on time, prepared well, delicious and an extremely fair price. The garlic zeppolis are SO good and the Stromboli is so much food. Great dine-in deals. read more

I can't believe I've never reviewed Bella Italia! I've tried different things here over the years. The best thing about this place is actually the atmosphere and the employees. The staff here really make you feel welcome. The owner, Aldo, is such a nice guy and remembers his repeat customers and their usual orders. All of the other team members I've encountered have also been really kind and helpful. The food is prepared fresh and is good quality. I'm not a huge fan of their pasta dishes with red sauce, but I'm very picky about red sauce so I don't count that as a negative. I love their wings! The wings are large and well prepared. The pizza has an amazing crust. I recommend ordering a fresh pie! They do pizza by the slice, but it's so much better fresh in my opinion. Recently, we ordered a large pie with extra cheese and mushrooms. It was delicious! I'd have liked maybe a little more mushrooms, but it was still a good pizza. Another thing here I really love is their beef patties with cheese. It seems random coming from an Italian restaurant, but they are soooo good! Our town has a lot of great spots for pizza and Italian, and Bella definitely will continue to be among the ones I frequent due to good quality and fantastic customer service. read more

Bella Italia Pizza - Medium wings - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Bella Italia has some of the best pizza in my part of the city. It's always good! In fact, I've had their subs, calzone, and pasta - everything is always awesome. 5 Stars all the way and highly recommended. read more

Great local Italian spot. We've been 3 times now and the food is always great. Portions are bigger than you expect so it's well worth the price. read more

Great service, great food, great prices. We eat there regularly and always enjoy it. Love their lasagna. Eat their spaghetti often. The pizza has a great chew and the sauce is tasty. read more

Bella Italia can do no wrong. Lol Tried the Bruschetta and Calamari this time along with the Chicken Picatta. Bruschetta was flavorful, bread was toasty, and had good size mozzarella pieces in it. Clalamari was served with the rings and tentacles and it was cooked well. Chicken Picatta was perfectly buttery and lemony. Our server was quick and attentive. Love the small mom and pop feel of this place. They were packed this go around! read more

See all

Decided to pick up Bella Italia for dinner the other day to take home. We ordered the Stromboli with all fillings except for mushrooms and we also ordered their chef salad with everything on it except for banana peppers. On the phone they mentioned that it would take 25 minutes for the food to be ready which was correct. We arrived to pick up the food 25 minutes after placing the order. From first glance the salad looked pretty good and the Stromboli looked decent but like it was lacking filling towards the ends. The salad was excellent with a vinegar-oil type dressing provided on the side. The Stromboli was good, where there was actually filling in it. Unfortunately about 1/3 of the Stromboli had no filling in it and was just bread. We will be back here to give their pizza a try but I don't think we would order the Stromboli. We also would order the salad again soon. read more

We ordered in pizza from here for the first time a few weeks ago. Pizza tasted great and fast service. I did like that the Pizza crust had a crunch. Good sauce to cheese ratio. Sauce was a little to much on the sweet side for me but if you prefer a sweeter sauce and less acidity then this is your spot :) read more

Love Bella Italia so much and we can not wait to visit when this COVID mess is over. We really appreciate the support Aldo provides for the community. Love supporting this small local business. read more

Anything you order will be good and plenty of it. The staff is always friendly and helpful. We have gone for years with different groups and always accommodating as to seating arrangements. Their caprese salad is the best in town. Eggplant dish is good. Servings are large. Pizza excellent. Ask for extra Italian seasonings if really like strong flavor. read more

So wonderful to have this great place so close to home. We grabbed lunch for 6 of us and it was perfect! The portion are big and the flavor is bursting. The food is always hot and fresh. If our are looking to feed a lot of people for an affordable price, this is your go to. The owner and the staff are kind and caring and always wanting to make sure you're happy. Please continue to support locally! read more

A cute place that's very unassuming from the outside. We were searching for an Italian place to go to because I have been craving some spaghetti. We did a quick search for Italian places in our area by using our ZIP code on Yelp. This place popped up as being nearby by our house since we live in the Conway area. When we headed in we were greeted right away by the waitress / hostess. She was very friendly and brought us menus and asked for our drink orders as soon as she came up to the table. She saw me looking forward to drinks on the menu, and was quick to go ahead and recite off the list of available beverages so I didn't have to keep looking. They have a variety of options from sodas to beer and wine. For food they offer everything from pizza and calzones to main entree pasta dishes. I decided to go with the spaghetti carbonara and the husband had the meatball sub. Everything is made fresh so it did take a little time to bring to the table however it was worth it for fresh food. The carbonara was very good and had plenty of pancetta and bacon I wish that it had peas in it as well. The entire place was really clean and well-kept and several people came in and out to make to-go orders while we were sitting there. It's obviously a popular place with the locals. The garlic bread we ordered for an appetizer was probably my favorite thing. Overall: A- Great fresh Italian food. Decent pricing. read more

See all

The food is excellent and dinner portions are huge! Service is good as well as friendly. No pretense here, this is a storefront restaurant with a busy pizza trade and takeout business. There is good value here and it has a neighborly vibe. read more

A small place that is usually empty inside, but the food is top notch, from the salads to the garlic bread to the pizza and Strombolis themselves. read more

Service was good, friendly. Guest #1 ordered Calzone- bottom was burnt Guest #2 ordered spaghetti with clam sauce Sauce was very bland read more

Pretty disappointed with this restaurant. I first went there with friends and had a great experience. But my most recent experience has turned me off completely. My wife and I decided we wanted good Italian food, so we called up Bella Italia and I put in a delivery order. I gave them my address and my order, and they gave me my total and told me I would pay the driver. About 30 minutes later I get a call from someone (presumably the delivery driver) who asks to verify my address and then proceeds to tell me they couldn't deliver to me because they don't deliver to my zip code. Someone from the restaurant started calling at the same time so I clicked over and talked to them. They also said they were unable to deliver to my zip code because it was too far. The distance was 5.5 miles. I was highly confused because the person who took my order verified my address and zip code and never said anything about the distance and they allowed me to wait 30 minutes while they made my food before they raised any issue. Their website also mentioned a deliver fee of $1 for delivered under 5 miles which would lead one to believe they deliver beyond 5 miles. I was offered no apology and they offered no solution. It wasn't until I asked if they had prepared my food and started to inquire more about my options that they said I could come pick it up. When I showed up, I wasn't offered an apology or even a discount and I got my food home only to realize they screwed up my order. Unhappy former customer. read more

I absolutely love coming to Bella! Pizza is one of my favorite types of food and I have some of the best pizza in town. They're strombolis are very good and their chef salad is awesome and huge as well. I only complaint is that I find them a little expensive in comparison to other similar style restaurants, however it is worth the extra price and I still always come here read more

Ohhhh how sad. Things are soooo bad they've begun using livestock dishes and cheap plastic plates of which you might expect to see at a dollar trees type store. Had I not asked for a plate, I would have been expected to eat off the metal serving plate. The utensils (especially the fork) were soooo flimsy that while attempting to keep the plastic plate from sliding around the table the fork bent. I took a napkin and straightened it a couple times. read more

Bella Italia Pizza - Things are soooo bad they've - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

True to form NY style pizza. The pizza was delicious, the crust was perfect, the sauce was tangy and applied in the perfect amount, cheese was cooked perfectly, and the toppings were of good quality. Delivery was also fast. The garlic knots were really good too. I will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Best Italian Restaurant Food is excellent, service is by far superior to any restaurants I have experienced (and I have experienced a boat load). The restaurant is beautiful and very welcoming. Every visit is a positive and delightful experience. read more

Bella Italia Pizza - NY strip with potatoes and mixed vegetables- excellent - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Yummy pizza and wings. Always really nice and welcoming. Also the Strombolis are great, filled to the max.

Wonderful food and staff is amazing !!! Everything is delicious and authentic. Definitely a favorite!