This food was amazing! Friendly service. Great bar. The freshest cuisine in the area. Quite authentic.

If I was starving and there was nothing else to eat, I would still go to a convenient store and buy peanut butter jelly and a loaf bread. Service was terrible. Food was less than par. Ohh and they won't split your check because it takes too much time. read more

Delicious food. But be forewarned: the portions are wonderfully massive! Great value for great food.

Food is incredible, but plan on being there for a bit as service can take some time, being the place is usually packed and for good reason!

Outstanding dinner outstanding service a great experience. The grilled oysters and seafood risotto with a Cajun cream sauce was the special and both were fantastic. When traveling and I'm in the area I intend to certainly stop by again for another wonderful dinner. read more

Bella Michael's Restaurant - Grilled Oysters with garlic sauce. - Italian Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

i had a wheat pasta with one meat ball and a salad That was the best thing i ever had. Restaurant around here in the area never had wheat pasta on there menu. Your was excellent!! The waitress her name is Gabby she was wonderful waitress very friendly. I recommand my friends should go to this place. WOW! I was having so much fun with Gabby, Thank you Gabby, The service was quick. My friends love what they ordered, They said ''its excellent what they ordered. We are coming back to this place more often. Just love it!! People were so friendly and laughing. Just love it!! read more

Great little place. I visited this spot with business associated during a work trip. The building is quaint and the interior was very homey. We were a group of 8 and they were able to manage our table nicely. The coconut shrimp was big and delicious with a complimentary sweet and sour sauce. The spaghetti and sauce was standard, but the meatball had great flavor. I took my leftovers back to the nearby hotel only to wake in the middle of the night and realize I wouldn't be able to use the microwave due to their aluminum take out container. The disappointment was insurmountable.... I sadly had to throw my leftover, which was half my meal in the garbage. read more

Bella Michael's Restaurant - Spaghetti & meatballs - Italian Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Quite frankly as frequently as we go, (at least once a week) Bella Michaels has never served a meal that was disappointing. Daily specials for lunch are always delicious and a great value. Dinner specials are also great, creative with enough food for leftovers. read more

Great fish specials! Traveling & always searching for good "Mom & Pop" restaurants....a winner read more

It's nice for Oneonta, but the food is bland Italian for me. I do love a good lobster ravioli or some mussels marinara though and I have been here twice and I think like all Oneonta restaurants it's highly overrated on yelp. Anyway, the place feels rather small and had to keep my coat both times as it was cold, which wouldn't bother me at a cheaper price point. The items on the menu are hit and miss. The bruschetta was good but both my mussels and ravioli were as I said, bland, and I have had the ravioli twice now. The servers are nice, but I don't think they put but a thimble of vodka in their Bloody Mary so stick to the wines. My dad loves the place, it's not super pricey, and you don't have much choice if you are in Oneonta. read more

Good place to go for dinner with the family. A little out of the way from the center of Main Street but would drive down. The food was a little bland and needed more spices and seasonings. Wouldn't go back but over all isn't a bad place. read more

Plus side, nice outdoor dining, bar is good place to have a before dinner drink or alternative to a table for dinner. Menu has something for everyone. Downside, one thing that most people want, myself included, is service soon after being seated, bring us a drink and bread ten we can chill and look over the menu. Waited 35 minutes for cocktail and longer for bead, 45 minutes. Dinner was OK two of our dishes good the other two entrees were so so. Maybe we caught the place on an off night so I would go back and give it another chance. read more

Passing through Oneonta a couple of days ago, we discovered this gem of a restaurant on YELP. Shrimp scampi and Lasagna were excellent. Service was personable and quick. Outdoor seating area was most enjoyable. Don't miss this outstanding opportunity. read more

Food was amazing. Came from California for my sons baseball tournament at all star village. I would recommend making reservations.

Great Italian food, the atmosphere is very nice separate area for eating and at the bar staff is very personable.

Bella Michael's has tried to so hard to give our community a sense of normalcy during this pandemic. They have taken consistent safety measures with take out meals and the slow return of outdoor dining. Their food is great, and you will be treated like friends here! read more

Love this place! Great food and great service! The owners are so kind and we never feel rushed.

Good stuff. Had the dry aged rib eye. Kids had pork chops and scampi. The Mrs had tilapia over risotto. All excellent. Nice burgundy wine glasses. Great pre-HOF meal! Highly recommend (if you find yourself in Oneonta!). read more

My husband and I ate here last evening (2/15). It was absolutely wonderful. From the moment we walked in the waitress was highly attentive. she told us the specials and let us be - she left us alone just long enough to decide. We started with Mushrooms stuffed with Crabmeat and Cheese. What a wonderful starter. Then we each had a salad accompanied with a loaf of warm bread and butter. Then the entrees. I ordered the Seafood Risotto - it was packed full of perfectly cooked seafood. My husband ordered Calamari & Scungili in a Fra de Ablo sauce. We both ate every bit and will certainly make it a point to come back here.. When we arrived - a little after 5pm we were the only people there. Shortly after there were 5 other couples. We weren't rushed and actually didn't leave until a little after 7pm. What a wonderful evening. read more

Completely surprised at this place and I'm a fan. Went on the recommendation from My hotel. The place is definitely quirky its an old White House with apartments upstairs. Walking in I felt like I was somewhere between my grandmothers house and and elks lodge. I was already in so I didn't run and I'm glad I didn't. For a Tuesday the place was pretty full and very casual. They have quick pick or whatever that lottery game is people play at bars. The environment isn't fancy at all and that's just fine with me. On to food they had decent beer dogfish and such. I ordered the seafood fra diavolo and to my surprise our waitress asked how spicy I wanted it. Once the food arrived it looked and tasted great. Again I was surprised. This wasn't just Mariana with some crushed red pepper it was a legit sauce. Pasta was cooked perfectly to my liking. So long story short in the road again hotel recommends a place I have low expectations and am completely surprised honestly I'd drive back down here just for dinner read more

All-around awful experience. We're seated and not attended to for over 35 minutes. Finally placed drink order which we ended up never receiving. Kindly asked our server how much longer till we can place a food order and were told "If you think you're getting your food within an hour you are gravely mistaken". Needless to say after that statement and lack of apology our group got up and left the establishment. Would not recommend this place to my worst enemy. Disgrace to italian cuisine and the restaurant industry alike. read more

During a recent travel to upstate NY we happened onto this quaint local restaurant for lunch. Warm and inviting atmosphere, pleasant server and delicious food! The fettuccine Alfredo was creamy and hearty needing only a hint of salt to put it over the top! The broccoli rabe w/sausage over pasta was a nice change. The creamy pasta fagioli soup is what hit it out of the ballpark for me! A surprising twist of a light, creamy tomato broth with 3 different pastas! I will search for a recipe similar! If we ever happen to be driving that way again we will return! read more

Came here for dinner after a long day of (motorcycle) riding. Appears this was once a house that was converted (fairly well) into a restaurant. Reservations are available, but we were able to be seated rather quickly in the back. In short - if you get all the ingredients in your dish at the start, it will be cooked expertly and flavorful. My wife and a woman at the table next to us ordered a dish that on the menu is stated as chicken breast, mozzarella, tomato and prosciutto. Both dishes were presented w/o prosciutto, so the respective servers took the dishes back to the kitchen to have the problem "rectified". What came out from the kitchen was pitiful. An over-cooked piece of hide laying on top of the initial dish. Inedible. Not sure what was more disappointing: the chef who let it leave the server window, or the server's judgement in bringing them to the table(s). On brighter notes: Everything else was very good. Salads were fresh, dressings homemade, my dish was quite good but the tomato cream sauce was bland. I do tend to like things with a spicy kick so I'm not knocking the chef for it. This place could be a solid 4-4.5 star, but bringing out ruined proteins at this price point is not professional. read more

What a hidden gem in Oneonta. Thanks Yelp for sending us here. Great atmosphere, old school Italian spot with mega portions and awesome food. It was shockingly reasonable for the quality and portions. We will definitely be back! read more

I ordered the "chicken breast". Every other dish had a true name except for this one. The description was fresh mozzarella, tomato and prosciutto. Upon starting dinner, I noticed that there wasn't prosciutto. No problem, the waitress took my dish back to get it fixed. The meat that returned on top of my chicken looked different from any prosciutto I've ever seen. It looked sickly if you will. Well, it "tasted" and had the consistency of rubber. It was terrible. I think it was well over cooked. I pushed it off to the side. The rest of the ingredients were good, so it was fine. I was disappointed though. I was a little bit disappointed that the waitress didn't ask why I didn't eat the prosciutto, but no big deal. A woman at the table next to me ordered the same dish and also didn't receive prosciutto. Hers was "fixed" too with the sickly looking meat. I'm giving this three stars instead of one because our salads were good and my husband liked his dish. Like I said, I did like the taste of the other ingredients, so those factors increased the rating. read more

Don't be in a hurry if you come here. Servers very friendly, but took awhile and we were in here for almost 2 hours on a busy Friday night. Food was excellent; Stuffed Mushroom appetizers; Warm bread with a nice side salad; Cheese Ravioli with probably the absolute best marinara sauce I have ever had and a Grilled Swordfish special that was done to perfection. Nice wine & drink selection. Definitely will be returning here to try some more delectables from their large menu selection! read more

Very decent Italian food. I appreciate that they were willing to change the pasta order and add what I wanted. The decor is just meh. It's in a neat old house, but when you walk inside you feel like you're in a strip mall restaurant because of the cheap drop ceiling and bland tile on the floor. Service was good. Not overly friendly at first but got much better throughout the meal. read more

My collegiate soccer team and I were traveling to Binghamton, NY and stopped at Bella Michael's for dinner! We are a party of 27 and both the service and the food were absolutely amazing! From the salad and the bread to the penne marinara, penne a la vodka, chicken parmesan and veggies, everything tasted delicious. The service was quick and efficient, and the staff was extremely friendly! We had a fantastic experience here and will certainly come here again in the future! read more

Weary travelers and starving we were, the lady at the desk at Hampton Inn suggested this place. Less than a mile down the road, we opted in. The server was so pleasant and just genuinely nice. The food was amazing. Caprese salad was good, roasted ted pepper is a nice flare for the dish, the tomatoes were not fresh or maybe just not red enough for me, but the mixture of flavors were good. The lobster bisque is the bomb.com lots of lobster!!!!!. The eggplant rollitini was great. Seafood chowder was awesome, fresh bread for soaking up the goodness. The nachos, also amazing. Can't go wrong here. In town for a funeral, so didn't think to take pictures. read more

The food and atmosphere are always great here at Bella Michael's. The Marsala is wonderful and the specials never disappoint us. The portions are great and we always have to take some home with us. I love the crab cajun cream sauce and it goes great on the side of any dish. Nothing more to say other than its a great restaurant! read more

We're passing through town and this restaurant was recommended by our nearby hotel. What a gem! Quaint and homey ambiance. Friendly and attentive staff. The salad that comes with the entrée is not your typical iceberg lettuce fare. Both the Bleu cheese and balsamic vinaigrette dressings were memorable. I loved that I could sub veggies for pasta, and what a terrific blend of non-typical vegetables it turned out to be. My veal marsala had such a rich, luscious sauce, I was tempted to use my straw for lack of a spoon to get every last drop. My husband's NY strip steak was perfectly cooked, thick, and tender. I wish we'd had room for dessert. I'm sure it would have been memorable as well. read more

Bella Michael's Restaurant - Veal marsala and NY steak - Italian Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

Excellent food! We are passing through town and stopped in. The sauces are extremely flavorful, the staff very accommodating and quaint ambiance. We highly recommend Bella Michael's. read more

One of the best eggplant parmesan dishes I have ever had!! I think I can eat here everyday. The sauce was delicious and the serving size could feed two. Wish your restaurant was in CA. East Coast Italian food is amazing!! read more

Very nice restaurant. You can't go wrong here. Service was excellent, food excellent, very large portions, and price was average for a good restaurant, all entree's were around $20.00. Will definitely go back again, they are practicing covid rules. Reservations on weekend advised. Great overall dining. Keith m. Veitch read more

Was passing through day after christmas and took a chance going in- it was amazing. Service and food - exceptional. We ate the warm bread which was delicious.... then we ordered a special appetizer of grilled oysters - then after tasting them - we just had to order another. The chef is brilliant. My husband and I both had the specials that day and were beyond pleased. My kids are picky eaters and they had enough choices to choose from- we all left happy. I live close to NYC and I come up to the catskill often and I just can't wait to go back there to eat! I hope they have the specials of the grilled fish when I go back. Oh, not to mention we were celebrating my husbands birthday and I secretly told the waitress that it was his birthday - OMG what an amazing staff - they all came out to sign with a beautiful plate decorated with "happy birthday" What a lovely place! read more

Good place to eat. Acceptable wine selection and food quality somewhat above average. I'd eat here again. If you're in town, you may want to give it a try. read more

Slow... slow..... the chowder was awesome! The owner " manager" sat and ate with her daughter and someone else. While we waited to be greeted.... then sat another "10 minutes" to get a drink. The bartender who was also the waitress had a table of at least ten in the back. But.... why didn't the owner " manager" help out??? The special was red snapper with scallops. It came out with SHRIMP??! No notice that they were out of scallops...hmmm read more

Made reservations for valentines but was placed under the tv at the bar outside of the servers view so service was poor . There were many open tables at the time so I do not understand why we were placed there, guess they don't like us long hairs.. food was ok at best. Will not be returning... read more

Delicious food and great prices. Extremely accommodating with special dietary restrictions. I ordered the meatball park and it was huge. I could not finish it. It was delicious. All the soups were homemade and phenomenal. The service was prompt and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

This place is a real find. Excellent food, great service, and wonderful ambiance. Food amazing, and price is extremely reasonable. Generous portions, both food, and drinks. All in all, 5 out of 5 stars. read more

See all