Usually get takeout. The pizza is the best in town! Also love the eggplant parm. Always our go to place for pizza!

Ordered a pizza for take out. Fantastic pizza as a whole. Cooked through, not burned, generous toppings, crispy crust.

Recently moved to the area, wanted some pizza, they're the closest, and the reviews are good. Placed an order for a pep pie and a dozen wings and brought it home. I wanted to love it, but it was middle of the road at best. The pizza tasted pretty good, but the dough was spongy and chewy. Not terribly so, but just not my preference I guess. The wings however....I'm trying not to be too critical, but the sauce was anything but buffalo sauce. I ordered medium, but they were sweet and the sauce was red and thick like ketchup? I was disappointed. I'll try again someday cause maybe it was a fluke. But I'll be trying another place in town next time. read more

Wow! This place blew me away. I come to Oneonta about four times a year and usually just rely on chain restaurants and of course Brooks BBQ. Then I discovered Pizzaland. I can't remember the last time I ordered such an incredible hero (eggplant). I don't eat mozzarella cheese, so when I asked for extra sauce instead, I wasn't expecting a large cup of it. And no skimping on the eggplant. Piled high. And with the sauce, I don't recommend eating this in the car! (Note: ask for napkins). Kudos to Freddy up front. Friendly and welcoming. And if you're a baseball fan he's very engaging. Please don't miss this find of a restaurant. read more

We ordered take out and everything was quite enjoyable. Pizza, Pasta and salads accompanied by some of their homemade rolls really hit the spot. Several friends from our baseball group did the same thing and everyone enjoyed their meal. read more

Reluctantly went there again with a friend. Food has not gotten any better. Will not make that mistake again. Spent the next morning in the loo. read more

The waitstaff was a bit unfriendly. Service for us was very slow. We ordered our drinks and it took 10 minutes to just get our drinks. We ordered garlic knots and it took at least 30 mins for them to be brought to the table. There were two tables that were sat after us and they ordered, received their food, ate and paid before we even got our appetizer. There was a table that was sat as we got our main course that ordered the garlic knots and theirs came out within 5 minutes. The pizza and knots were good, the pasta white broccoli was very bland(basically pasta & broccoli swimming in butter)but the unfriendly attitude and slow service really ruined the meal for us. I would not recommend if you aren't a local. read more

First I have to say is WOW! Being from Brooklyn and currently living on Long Island I'm use too good Italian food and the food at Pizzaland is just as good as anywhere I've eaten. In area for business on a Sunday I felt like having pasta for dinner. I did some searching for restaurants on yelp and came across Pizzaland. I'm glad I gave it a shot! Although I didn't have the pizza the table next to me did, and it looked great. I had the House salad, eggplant antipasto and then the chicken parm. Although I could not eat it all I was glad I took it all home with me! Eggplant antipasto was great Chicken parm was great! If your in area it is worth the ride! I'm thinking about trying the pizza tomorrow after business meeting! Enjoy read more

So disappointed! Spent $60 on a large pie with 1 topping and 2 orders of wings. I get it...everything is expensive. I wouldnt mind if the food was good. The Mild wings were ok if you don't mind the ketchup like sauce. At least they were cooked ok. The garlic parm wings were not edible. They were awful. The sauce was very bad and the wings were hard, old and disgusting. Thankfully the pizza was edible. Will try to avoid ordering wings here again. read more

A good option in the area. I was recently on a family baseball trip and we shared with part of the baseball team at the place. The pizzas are excellent, the Buffalo Wings are incredible, plenty of parking. The service is good. I will go again on my next baseball adventure in Cooperstown. read more

We drove by earlier and they had the most flowers. We figured they cared about the food and we were correct. Fantastic pizza. Great service. Loads of people for take out. Pastas looked delicious. Salads were huge. A definite 10 read more

Pizzaland - Gorgeous flowers - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

I've been a fan of this cozy, family-owned pizza place for years, and it's consistently excellent. The pepperoni rolls and Strombolis are not only delicious but massive--you'll definitely be taking some home. The pizzas are just as good, and the friendly staff make every visit enjoyable. Great food, great vibes, and you always leave with leftovers. What's not to love? read more

Oh Pizzaland, you hold a special place in my heart. My running route consists of passing Pizzaland about halfway through, and it's just the motivation I need to finish the run. Let's be real, most of us do not run because we like it, we do it because we like food.... or at leas that is my reasoning. I would run miles upon miles to earn some Pizzland for dinner. Staff is always very friendly. Service is quick, and food is always fresh. read more

Some of the best pizza and pizza makers in the area. Their eggplant appetizer is the best A plant dish I've ever had. Friendly customer service and consistent quality food. read more

See all

I was recently in this area and just happen to see this restaurant. Gave it a try and was glad I found it! Pizza was good! Prices and portion sizes were good as well, I would definitely recommend and will come back when I am in this area! read more

Garlic knots were life changing and all the food was so good! Staff was friendly as well.

Great pizza friendly service. Portions are good. Garlic knots are not what they have been in the past they were a huge hit.

This is about their takeout pizza. The only good thing to say about it is that the crust looked perfect. Nothing else about it was ok.

The pizza was heavy but decent. The salad was loaded with onions. The sub was fresh but wasn't made as I asked.

Brought a baseball team for dinner with about 20 very hungry players. Jen was our server, and was amazing both with level of service and ability to help a big group and all our food and drinks. I highly recommend going here! Food was amazing read more

Pizzaland - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

We were finishing up at All Star Village and really wanted some pizza. We quickly drove over as we saw it closed at 10- wanting to see if we could place an order to go. We walked in the door at 9:29 pm and it was as if you were in a movie and the music came to a screeching halt. Two servers looked at us and walked away in the opposite direction. They were talking amongst themselves for an uncomfortable amount of time. So I asked, Would you like us to leave?" One of the servers asked if we wanted to sit and we answered, "No, just wanted to ask if we could Order some food to go." We were then told that their manager said they are closed and "would we please come back another night." Unfortunately, it's not likely. I understand coming in 30 min before close might be inconvenient, but I have to imagine being that they're so close to All Star Village, they might expect AND WANT some late dinner business- ESPECIALLY after the year restaurants have had. We try very hard to always give locally owned businesses a chance but Pizzaland left a bad taste in our mouths without even having tried their food. Fortunately or unfortunately, McDonald's was down the street and still taking orders. read more

Has been hit or miss with quality in the past. Tried again & ordered extra cheese pie & antipasto for take out on a Friday night. Was great this time!! read more

Pizzaland - Antipasto - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Delicious Italian-go back to choice. Esp. their eggplant parmigiana. Special pizza is our favorite.

Sometimes ok others not . Sauce is not as good as it used to be. And the meatballs not as good as they used to be

By far the best pizza place in town. Good food and good service. Portion sizes are big. We always have left overs.

Don't order their Chicken Marsala. Not sure if it was chicken. Had to ask for a steak knife to cut it. The Marsala sauce was out of a can, maybe Chef Boyardi. The garlic bread was hot dog rolls with butter smeared on it with a little bit of garlic powder. Our water was served in paper cups. Won't be back for another beating. Never been anywhere this bad. read more

I'm typing this as I sit here waiting on my pizza. Have been waiting about 35 minutes to get a medium pepperoni pizza. Took 10 minutes to get drinks for 4 people. We are 4 of maybe 10 people in the restaurant so they aren't busy. Right now, they get 1 star because this place is slow slow slow. Will revise with more info after we get our pizza. Revised- pizza arrived after 50 minutes or so. It was good but I wouldn't go back knowing I had to wait. I feel it's overpriced as well. $16 for med pepperoni pizza. $3.25 per additional topping. $2.50 for soda and no free refills. Gonna keep it 1 star. read more

We were staying over before a visit to Cooperstown to see the HOF and wanted some pizza. Pizza Land sure delivered for us!! The pizza was absolutely fantastic, with a great crispy crust all the way to the middle, and plenty of toppings to satisfy our appetite. Two of us couldn't quite finish a large, so we have lunch tomorrow! We split a salad before the 'za, and it was basic, but very good. While we didn't order any of the pasta dishes, we saw a few being delivered to other tables and boy, did they look great! Huge, too! Definitely bring your appetite, or a bigger pair of pants, and enjoy. While the interior decor may not look like much, the food and the fact that it was pleasantly full of locals should tell you that it's worth the effort. Wait staff was super friendly and very helpful. read more

This place was the best Italian food. I have had. The portions are huge and for a great price ! Lonnie and Winny are amazing servers. We were greeted with kindness. I got the stuffed shells they were to die for. The garlic knots are AMAZING. My family also got raviolis, chicken parmigiana and 2 other pasta dishes which look very good. I would definitely come again too bad I do not live in the area. read more

I really love the pizza and garlic knots here. I grew up in laurens and have fond memories of going here for dinner every other thursday night. Now we live in seattle but this is the first place we go to eat when we come back. Always have the garlic knots! read more

Love this go to place when I am in the area visiting family - from the standby favorite plain cheese pizza to eggplant parm!

Terrific selection of pizzas, pastas and sandwiches. Friendly staff, clean rest rooms and pleasant atmosphere! Love their calzones...Yum!!

Best pizza ever all the food we ordered was really good so bad we lived in Texas if not this would be my dinner place recommended 100%

Best pizza in Oneonta! Also their Stromboli is delicious and could feed you for a week! Their baked lasagne is also super. Love this family owned place have been a patron there for over thirty years! Also they have best meatballs ever. They're even better than mine! read more

Top notch food and service. A family I will always trust. Grew up in the area and always a great experience eating here.

Great service! Food was fantastic. We started with eggplant appetizer with wine spritzer, others had beer followed with pepperoni pizza. They were all excellent. I highly recommend this place. read more

Traveling thru the area we came upon PizzaLand. The place was clean, the waitress pleasant and helpful. We ordered Chicken Marsala and Lasagna. The portions were to say the least Huge. The food tasted great and leftover Chicken Marsala to savor again the next day. Hope everyone visiting this area checks out this restaurant. read more

Went twice within a three day period because the pizza was absolutely perfect the first visit. Second visit, still good but the crust was burned underneath adding a flavor that did not compliment the excellent sauce and gooey melted cheese on top. Service was excellent both times and we would certainly go back again if we had an opportunity to do so. read more

Despite its name and its unappealing facade, this is, hands down, the best pizza you will ever have!!!! Absolutely amazing!!!! Only wish we lived closer so we could experience it again and again! If you're going to be at Cooperstown All Star Village, definitely stop here! It's just around the corner, reasonably priced and soooooo delicious!!!! read more

This place is a staple of the Oneonta pizza culture. Never disappointed with the food, staff is friendly and efficient and the owner Bob is just the nicest guy around. Tell him Piper sent you for a big smile. read more