Found Big Bill's while Google searching for best pizza place in area. Had just left downtown Denver and was STARVING. Google search was right on! Was nearly packed to the door on a Wednesday evening. Little, nondescript storefront on the end of a strip mall. Tons of carryout business. Dining room is nothing fancy but pizza & call calzones were excellent. Even though it was super busy, food arrived quickly, hot, and correct. May not visit again for a long time (sort of a far drive from IL) but if I am in the area, I will eat there again. & I won't park in the McDonald's parking lot! read more

Big Bill's is the only place we order pizza. If we can't go there I make it from scratch. I have been a customer for over 20 years I can't imagine a better place for pizza read more

I've passed by this place several times heading to the groomer in the plaza and wanted to check them out. Recently, my company ordered some pies from here so why not take advantage at that time. Man let me tell you, they have some good pie I've had in a while. I think the best pizza I've had was in NY so to have this here is a great! read more

Love this place for great NY style pizza. Been coming here for years and have NEVER been disappointed with pizza. My favorite red sauce anywhere. Hands down! Garlic knots are the bomb!!! Not a place for fanciness, special salads, etc but fantastic pizza shop and you can get it by the slice. read more

Love the pizza and it is always fun to go in and watch the action!! It feels like Mew York!

Always a favorite spot! Super friendly staff and everything we have tried, even aside from their pizza is delicious! The chopped dinner salad is my fav! :) read more

Amazing pizza! The best NY pizza in the Denver area. Even better customer service. They accidentally spilt ranch on our pizza and gave us a second to make up for it. Will be back! read more

If pizza is in the name, stick with the pizza! The pizza was very good. The servers were friendly and the place was pretty busy on a Sunday night. I would get the pizza again in a NY minute (sad pun). The wings were fine, salad was mediocre, and cheesecake was gritty (overcooked or cooked too fast most likely). I had really high hopes for the cheesecake...darn We will be back... read more

I've never had a bad meal here. Staff is friendly and efficient. The prices are fantastic. The entire San Antonio Spurs NBA team was eating here one night when we dined. read more

By far the worst pizza I've ever had. Cost $80 for 2 large pizzas and some garlic knots...are you kidding me? Then when the delivery finally came, the pizza was so soggy, we couldn't pick it up to eat it. The veggie pizza smelled like rancid fish, and tasted awful. I would definitely NOT recommend going to this place if you want real pizza for a reasonable price. Total ripoff for the price. If I could give zero stars, I would. read more

Best pizza we've found since we moved to Colorado. This place is a gem. The food is outstanding. The service is great. The personal attention is wonderful. The environment is interesting. Doug shared a lot of history and personal stories. Loved it! We will be back!! read more

This is best pizza in Denver. Real authentic NY style. The pasta an sandwiches are also terrific. Big Bill is also an outstanding citizen who helps his community. He and his staff are friendly and ready to serve. read more

There are certain foods, contrary to my family, if I were alone, deciding where to eat, two places I would never take myself: Italian and pizza. But Big Bills, the flavors are amazing, just simple fresh ingredients, but done right, amazing flavors going into my belly. He's around the restaurant at times, and is friendly. I even suggest Big Bills to my family as an option. Only pizza place in Denver I'd take myself to. read more

Wife and I met a couple of friends here that we had not seen in a while since we moved to Castle Rock. Service was so/so but the pizza we ordered was perfect - really. We are a little picky about our orders and they hit it out of the park. read more

The real deal New York pizza. Garlic knots are awesome. Always great service. Owner supports large staff.

To be honest, this place deserves 3 stars. I just can't believe it's sitting at 4.5 and I feel like I have to try to knock it down a peg. While I would agree that this is the best spot for pizza in SD, you must keep in mind that it's only direct competition is Pizza Hut, Dominos, and Papa John's. Being the best of this bunch is like being the smartest kid in the special ed class. Not something to brag about. Bottom line: better than a frozen pizza or mega chain pizza (if there is a difference there), friendly staff, but nothing special. If you want to take a trip for some amazing pizza, go to NY or Chi-town. If you don't want to keep things in perspective, don't yelp. read more

Since I was diagnosed with celiac disease in January we have been wanting to try Big Bill's to see if a gluten free pizza crust was even possible. Attempts at home were utter failures with the consistency of sawdust. Bill's crust (which they admit they get from another business, not home made). This crust is indistinguishable from what I remember of pizza crust. All of their pastas are GF too. I'm curious about those since the ones available at grocery stores disintegrate when cooked. The staff was also the most knowledgeable I have found about gluten intolerance. I ordered the meat pizza and the waitress reminded me that the meatballs on it have bread crumbs. I would not have thought of that. So we substituted more pepperoni for the meatballs. Thanks Laura! They carry one brand of GF beer, New Planet. When I turned down the NP because it was an ale and I prefer lagers, the manager asked for my GF beer recommendations. I said that I prefer Omission, available right across Countyline at Davidson's. The pizza was great (and my wife's non-GF pizza as well) and it was nice to go to a place that cared about the customer that much. read more

Missing Big Bill's since we moved to Parker. The best NY pizza in the Centennial (and maybe all of Denver) area!

I finally got 2 of my coworkers to go to Big Bill's NY Pizza for lunch today and we were all blown away by the pizza and service. I grew up on the East Coast in New York so trust me when I say, I don't take Pizza lightly. We ordered a large Meatball pizza and it was to die for!! In addition, the service was beyond amazing. Our cups were always filled and our server was beyond friendly. My buddy got eggplant on a quarter of the pizza and we were originally upset as we were fearful it would contaminate our meatball. When it arrived, we were so jealous cause the combination of meatball and eggplant were deadly and I picked a few stray pieces from his side. If you are pizza aficionados, and truly are looking for NY style pizza done right, than look no further. We will be back with more coworkers next time for sure. read more

Good neighborhood pizza place. Handmade, not pre-formed dough, pizza. All of the traditional toppings and Italian dishes. A line at the door; close sitting quarters. Reasonable prices. Friendly staff. Nothing fancy. Parking in the lot can be tight. read more

Been coming here for over 10 years and had such terrible service tonight I left. After being sat at a table, 2 other tables who arrived after my party were served and we were ignored. We got up and left. Will not be back for a long time... hopefully Big Bill realizes the incompetent teenage servers are turning away loyal customers. read more

Garlic knots are good. Pizza was not that great. The sauce was funky. The best pizza is Papeaus. Bill was friendly but they are using the east coast schmuck to push pizza on these poor unsuspecting sheepish people who think Dominos and Pizza hut are real pizza. Im from the East coast too and know this isn't even close to east coast style. Mabye better luck next time.. Lets see how long it takes Yelp to delete my profile again since somebody is telling them to delete any critical review read more

Great pizza and wonderful service. Every server was asking if we needed anything. Got right in and received our meals within 10 minutes.

Tucked into a nondescript strip mall in Littleton, Big Bill's NY pizza is a magical place. As the name would suggest, Big Bill (a veritable giant) creates incredibly authentic NY style pizza and tops it with that classic "foggetaboutit" attitude (yes, they have T-shirts to match). The atmosphere is neighbourly and kid-friendly, while the pizza is pure decadence. If you don't trust me, just drive by on any odd evening and count the number of pies carried out of the place by wide-smiling customers. This stuff is pure goodness, and if you haven't had it this week, you're missing out. read more

Big Bill's NY Pizza is ah-mazing! A friend recommended it, so we thought we'd give it a shot. Oh. My. Gosh. I'm so glad we did! The people are friendly, the prices are reasonable and the atmosphere is loud. Personally, we like loud, especially since it drowns out our 2 and 6-year-old ; ) We now order take-out pizza every Friday night from there. Yummy! read more

I'm so glad my buddy brought me to this place...while also mad that he never told me about this place before now. No big deal, but I snagged the last slice. The service was very good, very polite people, and just there for you, but in a good way. The garlic knots are outstanding! Who cares if you have a meeting the next day and have to talk to people-they're that good! And the pizza, well, I finally found a great slice. And it has the perfect amount of grease, fold it in half and eat. Big Bill even dropped off the pie and told us, 'mangiare!' All in all, I highly recommend the place. read more

Not kids friendly. My 2 year old was reprimanded by an older waitress for taping the bottom part of the bench he was sitting on. He wasn't being loud and I had already told him to stop, but he is 2 and it takes longer for me to ask him to stop than for him to forget. After asking me how my meal was she turned to my son and in a condescending manner told him to stop being loud. The kids next to us were older and their voices carried a lot more than the noise my son was making. She gave me a weak apology and took the opportunity to excuse her behavior by saying she thought she was being kind. Based on previous reviews it seems like I just got a bad waitress, but I'm not going back here read more

OMG! Their pizza is so crazy good. I have no self control and tend to eat a whole medium by myself. Nom Nom Nom!!!

I think this is the best pizza place in the Denver metro area. If not, then who is? The dough is fresh and the sauce, cheese and toppings are really good. This place is worth a try if you are in the South metro area. read more

Best pizza ever. Love the atmosphere & food. Wait staff are efficient & happy. The group at register for takeout are the best. Great experience read more

The real deal. Garlic knots bombing it, the pizza, in charge. Place that feels like home, only with a lot more grease and NY memorabilia.

As a half Italian, growing up pizza was a staple and even though what my Mom made was not the best, it sure gave me an appetite for pizza that has continued and I have sampled pizza all over the country. I was told about Big Bills, read the reviews and it seemed like a "must try". So, yesterday, I called my brother and asked if he wanted to join me for lunch at Big Bill's. It is a bit of a drive from where I live, but damn, it was worth it. As we entered, I told the waitress it was my first time here and that I had heard many great things about the place. She was very friendly, said she had worked at Big Bills for 6 years and it was the BEST. She took our drink order and returned in a few minutes with our sodas and large plate of what she said were Knots. She said as we were first timers we should try them. We did, and they were great, tasty and the sauce was just right. We then ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and green pepper and a couple of chopped salads. The salads were very good (could have used some olives, pepperoni), but certainly acceptable. Then the pizza arrived and it was GREAT, crust was nicely done, sauce was tasty, toppings were fresh, the entire combination was outstanding. We finished half and asked to take the other half (in two carry outs). Not only did we get the pizza but we each got and order of knots to take home. The entire bill was about $30. The staff were all great, cheerful, friendly, enthusiastic and they all seemed to love the place they worked in. I need to go back now and try about 2 dozen other menu items ( I look at other tables and everything looked really good). This is my new favorite Italian place and even though it is quite a drive, I will be happy when I leave. read more

Fantastic pizza! We got the large Sicilian Combo and it was huge!! Tasted amazing and was loaded with toppings. The servers and host were excellent! Attentive and more than happy to give their recommendations. The whole restaurant has a great vibe with cool memorabilia on every wall. 5 stars for sure! read more

I just moved to the area and was afraid of not finding excellent NY style pizza. My fears are over! The prices are very reasonable, they have a huge menu that includes more than pizza and the service was great. We went at 5:00 on a Friday evening and were one of the first of the dinner rush. By the time we left, maybe 6:00, the place was full. The garlic knots and sausage pizza will be my go to for along time to come. read more

Overall good. Great service and good quality food. We've eaten at Bill's several times but never ordered pizza. We ordered the large veggie pie with pepperoni on one half. The double cheese (standard) was excellent but had to be eaten with a knife and fork. The crust was too thin and became too saturated to fold and eat NY style. The antipasta salad was large but disappointing. It was sloppily made, and obviously just thrown together. The lettuce, meats, and cheese pieces needed to be chopped much smaller. Pieces were too large to eat. We love black olives but not a half a can of them that were thrown on top. read more

Big Bills...Everybody knows they have great pizza. The garlic knots are great too. The service staff is always great. We had sausage and mushroom lsat night and it was so good....i'm still thinking about it. read more

When I went to New York for the first time I tried to find some really good NY style pizza. I tried a couple of areas but nothing seems to beat Big Bill's NY Pizza in good old Centennial, CO. Big Bill's is probably the best pizza place I've been to. Not only is the pizza good but the salads taste fresh and the menu offers other great selections if you or not in the mood for pizza. The environment is also great. Not to load, relaxed and great service. read more

This place's pizza is what I would describe as "pretty good." It is a fairly good attempt at NY style. I had 2 slices. One had pepperoni and salami (my favorite combo) and the other had jalapeno and garlic. Both were decent. Crust was good (maybe a little on the crunchy side for my tastes). My chief complaint with the slices was that they were a little light on the sauce. I don't like a lot of sauce on my slices normally, but there was almost none on this pizza. I also tried the garlic knots. Not a huge fan of these. They were more like garlic balls or garlic puffs than garlic knots. They tasted ok, but garlic knots they were (k)not (yes, I know how stupid that was). Under $20 all told for 2 people's lunch is a good value. read more

After hearing about Big Bill's Day of Giving where all his profits for the day were given to charity to commemorate 9/11 we decided to take part. We had a dinner salad and an antipasta salad to start. I usually think of antipasta as a meat and cheese only affair so I thought we would be sharing both but what came to the table were two very large iceberg lettuce salads one with pepperoni, salami, and cheese on top. The antipasta was enough for both of us so we brought the other home. We also ordered a large napoletana pie that was very good. Just the right amount of sauce and cheese on a thin chewy crust. Not a monstrous pie but tasty. The event allowed you to order what you wanted and then decide what you wanted to donate. Our bill came out to almost $30.00 and that's what we donated. Way too far away for us to travel on a regular basis but when we're in the area, we know where a good pie can be found. read more

I wouldn't call myself a pizza connoisseur but this is by far one of the BEST pizza places I have eaten at since moving here (not that California has good pizza or anything either). But the pizza at this place speaks for itself. And yes! The garlic knots are AMAZING!! You have to try this place if you haven't yet. You won't regret it. This is a definite once a week stop for me! read more