Big City Pizza is our go-to place to order pizza from primarily because of its proximity to us! Ordering can be done on the phone or online which is nice. When "building your own" pizza online you can choose the crust style- I always get confused because two selections are "Chicago thin" or "New York" but I always think of Chicago style pizza as the deep dish kind? Maybe I am mistaken. We ordered the "Chicago thin" pizza our last order and it's great if you like thin crust! The traditional crust I believe is the "New York" which is good as well. They have a great selection of toppings to choose from! I can't speak for their delivery because we've always picked up, however the orders are usually done pretty quickly! read more

Great Food! Sweet Service and Awesome Atmosphere! We loved it and will visit again for a pizza! read more

See all

we went to Big City Pizza in Nicholasvill,KY and found it was only a take out locatiom. The webaited noted the hours at the Hamburg location was open until 9pm. We drove all the way out there about 6:45pm and it was closed. We ended up going to Old Chicago Pizza which was probably a better choice anyway. read more

I went to Big City in Chinoe Shopping Center for their pizza week, drunken rooster. Very good pie. Smokey bacon & bourbon glaze, with chicken & jalapeños was Delicious! Cheese sticks also tasty, and a good portion. read more

The pizza itself is good and the crew is so friendly, but the website looks like it was a $50 budget or a brother in law did it for free as a college project, no place to enter the promo code specials anymore ( on purpose I'm sure) I'm Gen Z and even I gave up and just called the order in. Also why can't I substitute toppings?? You get charged like it's a premium addition to substitute from green peppers to banana peppers $2?? Ok Mr krabs read more

In search of a good local Chicago style deep dish pizza, I decided to give Big City Pizza a shot this week, having seen theme listed on a FB foodies group as a purveyor. And frankly I was delighted! The "Chicago Stuffed" pizza was very thick, of course, with a buttery crust, as is traditional for Chicago deep dish. The tomato was very tangy, more akin to tomato paste, in terms of flavor than typical pizzas. I ordered it with pepperoni, sausage, and garlic, my go-to pizza toppings. And the cheese, can't leave out the cheese. It was loaded with cheese, the kind that makes for a big stretch when you pull a slice out. Yum! They build the pizza with a homemade dough base, then cheese, then toppings, then another layer of cheese, and their hose-made pizza sauce. I also ordered the Big City House Salad, which I recommend. Pretty basic, it comes with tomatoes, bacon, and mozzarella cheese. I'm not always in the mood for such an indulgent pie, but it's nice to know where to get one locally. Give em a shot! read more

See all

Just got the new Nashville hot chicken pizza and it was so good. This place has the best cheese sticks in Lexington. Good job big city.

I ordered a pizza from Big City last week through the Eat Street app. It was convenient and I didn't have to wait long when I got there to pick it up. During Covid they are bringing the food out to your car so you have to call or knock on the door when you arrive. The pizza was just like any average pizza. Nothing to complain about but it wasn't memorable either. We got the deluxe pizza with pepperoni and sausage and a few veggies. I mainly ordered from here because it was close by. I would order again. read more

Big City Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

About an hour before closing I placed an order on Door Dash. Tracked the order for an hour and about 10 minutes before they were closing I get a call from door dash to tell me my order was cancelled. No explanation just your order was cancelled. I immediately call Big City and the manager tells me that the DRIVER STOLE my pizza!! SMH The manager remade my order and personally delivered it!! That's what I call customer service!! PLUS my pizza was delicious (as usual) read more

We liked their burger week burger. The bun was cold that was the only thing I would have changed about the burger. Probably one of our favorite burgers during burger week. The fries were a little underdone but still edible. read more

Big City Pizza - Lex Burger week burger! It was really good, wish the bun was toasted but enjoyed it! - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Craving a new pizza experience, my friend and I used to Yelp app to select Big City Pizza, and we very much enjoyed it! The bread sticks and the pizza we tried were really good! That said, the star of our visit was their Calzone - it was nothing short of incredible :-) For dessert we got a huge cookie that had obviously just been freshly baked; we ate it and it was warm; a really nice finish to an great meal. Service was friendly and quick, and the prices were reasonable; combine that with the quality of their food and I'm sure we'll be back! read more

Big City Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

This is my go to spot whenever I'm craving pizza. Their service is amazing and their pizza is very good good. They have 3 locations in the area. One in Nicholasville, Lexington on Chinoe. and Richmond. Pizza is always hot whenever you get it delivered or pick up. They have been doing great with contact less pick up and delivery. My recommendations is the Chicago Stuff, Cheese Sticks, and the Mac and Cheese pizza read more

Big City Pizza - Cheese Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

This place has the best pizza in town. I am never disappointed. I highly recommend. The new cheese cake is amazing!

Not my favorite. Pizza was dry not enough sauce and no flavor. If you know a good pizza is then you know that this is not it. Sorry

I have ordered from here several times. The quality is definitely decreasing. Almost no sauce and skimpy cheese. Disappointing

So, after being suggested by a friend, we ordered from Big City. Unfortunately, something came up and we had to leave before we could eat. The hubs at two pieces of the pizza on the run and liked it. Today, it's going to be brunch. I've taken pictures of before being reheated. Not thrilled with how the sandwich looks. Had I eaten it last night, I'd have had to eat mostly all bread on the ends or redistributed the myself. read more

See all

Decent food and pizza, nice choice here in the Lexington area, great menu, great selection, tasty sauce and great service.

If you are looking for a good quality, basic pizza Big City fits the bill. A previous reviewer nailed it though when they said Big City was a better version of Papa Johns. The pizza is good and loaded with toppings but doesn't stand out much. Delivery took a while longer than expected but considering there was a near monsoon outside I can't complain. I am interested in trying out the Chicago deep dish on another visit since there aren't really many options in the area for a good Chicago style pie. read more

Big City Pizza - Cheese breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Probably more like a 4.5 as I was close to saying 5 stars. I had heard of a Chicago stuffed pizza in a local Facebook group but didn't see it on the menu and could not find it online to order. I called in and mentioned it... to my surprise yes they have a Chicago stuffed and it was excellent! I love Chicago style pizza and this one didn't disappoint. Buttery crisp crust with a ton of cheese, pepperoni (my choice of topping today) and a very tasty pizza sauce on top made this my new favorite pizza in town. I'll be going back for more. We also had the cheese sticks and they were better than most I've had. Can't wait to go back as I'd like to try some others on the menu like their pan and New York style but I'm not sure I'll be able to pass up ordering the Chicago stuffed. read more

See all

Hubby and I are recent transplants from Huntsville, AL We looked at online pictures and Big City Pizza caught our eye, the restaurant looked to have a good vibe. Due to some medical problems, we chose to have our food delivered. The first time we tried Big City Pizza, we had the SOHO pizza and The Bronx pizza. The hand tossed crust is pretty good. But the toppings on the SOHO seemed to be lacking. It was still good enough to give Big City a second chance. Tonight we ordered the Bronx again because the husband likes it. That's where the two stars comes from. I had the Antipasto salad and the central Park Veggie Sub. Very disappointed! The presentation of my sandwich was good. It was delivered hot and fresh and when I opened it up I was pleasantly surprised at how yummy it looked. Then, I looked inside the bread and major disappointment set in. I ate the sandwich because, well, I was hungry. It was more like bread with a hint of mushroom and I think I tasted artichoke in one bite but I'm not sure because it was just a faint hint. The pictures will show what I'm talking about. The antipasto salad could have been good but I pulled out most of the lettuce. Even with the lettuce gone, it still lacked anything special. I've had much better. I'm sad because Big City just looks like a cool place. The menu is exciting and sounds delicious but the food isn't cutting it. Perhaps this was an isolated incident because I know the restaurant business can have "off" nights. We all know sh*t happens. Regardless, I'm not sure we will give Big City a third try... read more

See all

Best pizza in Lexington, essay rated at 8-8.3. The sauce is incredible and the service is top notch.

My kids choice for Lexington Pizza week- holy moly pepperoni. 4 types of pepperonis. The pepperonis were a mixture of thick cut and thin - the pepperoni cups had a perfect crunch. Soooooo great! Another really great pizza place! Seriously good sauce. Y'all, can't wait to try more of their pizzas. Pizza done big here! read more

Big City Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Took my family of 4 here, 6pm on a Saturday night. No beer, that's no big deal. No wings, that's ok. No baby changing station, that's fine we can deal with it. No fountain drinks, meh that's ok I guess. Pizza came out, and we asked for plates, and they gave us 1 paper plate. 1 plate. For 2 adults, 2 kids. 1 plate, they were out of plates. A restaurant out of plates. You're attached to the same shopping center as Kroger. Go buy a package of plates for a $1.99 I mean, I get now that you're a "take out" place, but maybe say that when a family of 4 sits down at your booth. That being said, we took the pizza home and it was very good. Just... get it together y'all. Buy some paper plates and fix your fountain machine, or remove your booths altogether. That was a weird experience read more

Their pizza is fine. The problem is their timing! I've order twice and the estimated time was fast short of the production time. Each time it took over 2x the estimated 20-25 minutes. I'm sitting in the lobby right now at 55 minutes.... read more

How else can the pizza be described other than "WORST EVERRRRR‼⁉". I ordered a 16" Thin / Deluxe.... and there was NOTHING Deluxe about it. I couldn't find the Meat or Veggies after 3-4 cuts! The sauce is NOT Tasty. I don't know who may think this is Good pizza because it's not even anything I would serve to my worst enemy. DISGUSTING PIZZA ,,,, that's the best description . I only gave it 1 Star to be able to Post. This Pizza is a Negative 5 Zeroes‼ If Management has any accountability then they will reply to this & refund my $20.66 & sorry for tipping $2.00. read more

Our favorite pizza joint recently closed. We have not had pizza in a few weeks so the pressure was on to find a new place. We started here and was not disappointed. The menu has a lot of options for a small place. The NY state crust was good. Looking forward to trying the thin. We had the SOHO, a cheese pizza and an order of cheese sticks. The sauce was just a little sweet and the cheese was ample. All very good. The SOHO was well cooked with the onions and artichokes were burnt on the edges just right. We will be back and you should give it a try. read more

See all

Pizza was alright, it was cold when it arrived but the cookie was amazing. It was warm and cooked perfectly. read more

Big City Pizza - Cookie - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Seriously. Don't let this place close due to Covid. Our family wanted AUTHENTIC deep dish, and found this place. The deep dish was amazing. The Sauce was the best in Lexington, and you can tell it's freshly made. The crust was perfectly flaky, crunchy, and had tons of flavor. Oh by the way, the meatballs we're also as fantastic as the pizza. One piece of pizza leaves you happily satisfied, unlike the chain pizza places that can never claim that! If you know REAL pizza, you will love Big City Pizza!!! Big City is now at the top of our list of best pizza in Lexington! read more

The pizza is fine, but it always takes 20-30 mins longer than the estimated time they give you.

It's was pretty good! I'd go back and do it again. The garlic knots were tasty and the oil on them seemed really light and nice. The pizza was also good and we ordered extra cheese and you could tell they loaded us up pretty good which is awesome. Sauce also had a good flavor. Kind of reminded me of old school Godfathers pizza back when that chain was worth ordering from read more

See all

A hidden gem! The pizza here is one of the best in town, a small local business. When you look them up or use their app it says they only have one location in Nicholasville but they are on Chinoe in Lexington! We have tried all three crust types and the thin has turned out to be our favorite! We did not care for the pan as much as it was too doughy. They have tv's with sports and a couple of arcade games in a small space. The garlic knots are also outstanding!getting refills on your drinks is a bit of a challenge because if there is no one ordering the staff hangs out in the back and the drink machine is behind the check out. They do not keep Parmesan on the tables but they do keep salt pepper and crushed red pepper there, along with rolls of paper towels. The decor is modern and clean. We will be back read more

See all

Just recently found out about this place and let me tell you , the pizza is so delicious!! Better than any Pizza Hut, Domino's, etc. I must say though, the cinnamon knots are my absolute FAVORITE!!! Omg!! There are no words to describe how good they are! Sometimes whenever I'm craving a snack I'll go here and only grab the cinnamon knots. I could live off this place!!! read more

My daughter and I just left Big City Pizza in Lexington at the Hamburg Pavillion. I ordered a cauliflower crust Pizza with Hamburger, onions, peppers and mushrooms. My daughter ordered grilled chicken and Pineapple deep dish pizza. Our pizza was brought to our table within 20 minutes. My pizza had banana peppers, which I didn't order, but no Hamburger. The pizza wasn't cut deep enough and I couldn't cut it with my knife. I tore a piece off, put it in my mouth and spit it out. It tasted really bad. It was the worst pizza I have ever eaten. My daughter said her pizza was really bad and it made her nauseated. I should have turned around and left when I saw the server vacuuming a filthy, carpeted floor at 11:30 am. The chairs and tables were rickety and some were dirty. In the ordering area the bar was dirty. I regret spending my hard earned money here. This restaurant was empty when we arrived and only 3 different people came into eat while we were there. We are talking Monday, December 11, 2023. No holiday shoppers or business people. After trying to eat at Big City Pizza in Lexington, I can understand why hardly anyone was there to eat. It's an absolutely awful restaurant. ​ read more

So I got delivery. A order of hot wings and a 12in triple pepperoni pizza new York hand tossed. The wings came with about 8 and they were huge , but they were a lot of breading. They were so-so. I expected the New York style to be thinner than it was but it was kinda fluffy. It came with three different kinds of pepperoni which was a cool addition. Over all though the pizza was honestly just a slightly better version of Papa Johns which isn't a bad thing, it just is what it is. read more

This place has really good pizza. The atmosphere is simple and down to Earth and good for kids. We have visited this establishment several times and always had a good experience. Their salads are fresh but could use more spring mix. read more

I've read the reviews and decided to order delivery from this place. I hate to say, but we weren't really excited about their pizza when we received our order. Don't get me wrong, it was a good pizza, but it was like getting delivery pizza from one of the pizza chains (I dare not say). Maybe we would've had a better experience if we ate at the restaurant, but delivery was def not impressive as I thought it would be from reading the reviews. We may try again at the restaurant but I don't think we will be ordering delivery here again anytime soon. read more

See all

I'm a pizza-holic and this was well worth the trip for Take Out. The Hudson Pizza was properly covered with toppings, spaghetti and meatballs ... tasty w/ house salad ... fresh (always a good sign) and the Liberty Bread/Cheese sticks were hot and yummy. Only drawback ... no delivery in my area. read more

See all

Well... I wasn't impressed. First of all when we walked in there was NO ONE around. People were frantically working in the back and periodically made eye contact with us but didn't seem eager to service the dining room. There just a few clean tables and we were the only ones in there eating. The wife and I tried this place on a whim based on Yelp because we are looking for great pizza. With NYC fresh on our minds and the pizza domination hat is the Castro juggernaut of NYC this place wasn't for us. Pizza was only "ok". Drinks were "blah" in a bottle. Customer service was missing. I don't think we will be back. Someone said they did much of their business in delivery maybe hey should stick to that. read more

Decent pizza and food, nothing special, but not bad. Got chicken parm sandwich, cheese and veggie pizza. Delivery was on time, but food not hot. Microwaved, tasted ok. Probably wouldn't go back. read more

Big City Pizza - Chicken parm sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

The pizza was served luke warm to cold and had the tiniest bits of the toppings--so tiny, we couldn't even taste them. The antipasto salad was nice and fresh, and the meatballs were good. If they put more toppings on the pizza, especially as this pizza was not cheap, and if the pizza was served hot, then this may be a five star place. This is the second time we've ordered from Big City Pizza, and both times had a cold, inadequate pizza. read more