Goodfellas Pizzeria

112

1 year ago

Goodfellas Pizzeria - My wagon wheel pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi Julie —…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Zachary H.

4 months ago

I literally got attacked in this resteraunt and nothing was done about it. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Extremely dangerous location in the evenings, surrounded by drunks and bars.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] A drunk dude started a physical altercation with me and my group completely unprovoked in this location, and we got kicked out after an hour of waiting over it. I didnt even respond to the person, they just kept getting in my face and pushing me. The manager who witnessed me getting hit and pushed, STILL served the aggressor and his group after kicking mine out. Ive never been more disrespected in my life, but this location and its employees suck. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Zachary, we're truly sorry to hear about this experience at our Mill…

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 3

Zack Q.

2 months ago

Came on late night Expecting good warm pizza. instead got pizza already becoming cold while the service was rude and sucked, this is by far the worse food place I've been too. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Zack, we really dropped the ball on this one. Cold pizza and poor…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Chelsey H.

3 months ago

10/10. My favorite place to order a TRUE NY slice! The service and food are always top notch. So glad it's still here after 20 years

Business owner information

Alex C.

Chelsey, you're family! Twenty years strong and we couldn't be…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Andrew M.

606

254

1 year ago

Delicious New York style pizza. Huge slices. Perfect crust. Great topping options (though you get what is in the case). In true NY fashion, they'll throw the slice in the oven to reheat for about 30 seconds before putting it in the box to go. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Should note that this particular locates take out only. Absolutely no seating inside[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi Andrew —…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Robert T.

173

8 months ago

You haven't ever had a New York style slice of pizza like this especially in Lexington. The food was good. The service was great. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Ambience was just what we expected.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Would definitely recommend this place. The pizza was phenomenal. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Robert, you nailed it! There's nothing quite like authentic New York…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michael H.

8 months ago

Service was wonderful. The pizza great! Definitely stop by and order a pie..you won't be disappointed! Stop by On the Rocks liquor and grab some great local beer or bourbon! read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hey Michael! You know what's good - great pizza paired with great…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Seth S.

5 months ago

Terrible pizza. I love pizza and travel quite a bit. Was not stoked here. Service was ok.

Business owner information

Alex C.

Seth, we appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback. As…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kim W.

6 months ago

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Unique atmosphere...[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] but really excellent pizza. Buy by the slice or whole pies. The Goodfella is awesome!! Very reasonable pricing. A 16" (their medium) and two breadsticks and a cheese bread fed a family of 5! read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Kim, you nailed it! The Goodfella is one of our signature pies and…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Miguel A.

640

1252

2 years ago

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thank you for your review, Miguel! We're so glad to hear you could…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Izzie P.

109

252

2 years ago

Pics might be with bites taken out but that just shows how good the pizza is. This quite literally was the best and biggest pizza slices I've ever had. The one with olive oil instead of red sauce as a base is to die for. Staff is super friendly & nice! My sister said on weekends the line is insane with kids coming from the bars... we went on a Wednesday night and it was empty. Good vibes & good pizza all around. read more

See all

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thanks for the love, Izzie! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed your…

Helpful 2

Thanks 2

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Hu N.

134

1 year ago

Order a pie for pick up and it's the best! By the slice your experience is more variable. Foldable heaven!

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi there —…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Ben P.

156

164

2 years ago

Late Night .. After a Game... Breadsticks and a slice or 3? Good service and good enough food to bring home ... comfort pizza at its finest! read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Ben, we’re glad you stopped by for some late-night comfort pizza!…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kathleen F.

1 year ago

Grabbed a quick slice and a breadstick here and both were delicious. Plenty of slice options available and one is big enough for a meal. The service was friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend for a quick meal to take out. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi Kathleen —…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cole A.

9 months ago

Rude workers kicked off patio for no reason, pizza was no good anyways. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Kinda lacking decoration as well.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Definitely would not recommend! read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Cole, we think you must have us mistaken. Our Mill Street location…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Charlie T.

Elite 26 All-Star

682

2140

18821

3 years ago

Good place to get a quick slice of pizza on the go. The slices are pretty large and tasty. I had the mushroom, sausage, and pepperoni slice. I would come back again. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Exterior - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Display case - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thank you for your review, Charlie! We're so glad to hear you enjoyed…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lisa H.

10 months ago

If I could give no stars I would. Horrible experience. Horrible employees. Food is usually great. However after last night ill never go back. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Poor atmosphere with the very rude employees.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Lisa, we're truly sorry to hear about your disappointing experience…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Maddy B.

1 year ago

Isabel and Jewlz are beautiful souls. Put in the right place at the right time this pizzaria has made an impression to last a life time! Beautiful! Bella!!!!!!! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - A blessing - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi Maddy,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Brad E.

516

3 years ago

This is good NY style pizza. You get your slice lightning fast. Good crust. Great ranch to go with. I'd prefer a little more topping. Overall strong choice for a quick dinner read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thanks for the love, Brad! We're so glad you love our pizza. We…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Keeka K.

576

252

5 years ago

The Goodfellas theme is my favorite thing about this place. For just the pizza by the slice, it's not a bad option. For gourmet pizza, you will be disappointed. I just moved to Lexington from North Jersey, so my pizza standards are too high. The pizza is greasy and overpriced. I ordered a medium Vinny with sausage and mushrooms ($28 pre-tax for a 16" pizza), and was disappointed by the quality. It's not terrible; the crust is good, the flavorings are decent, and the service is great, but it's not gourmet pizza. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - The Vinny with Sausage and Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Goodfellas Pizzeria - The 16" Vinny with Sausage and Mushrooms ($28 pre-tax) - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience Keeka. We…

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Payal P.

311

811

2344

4 years ago

This place is located in downtown Lexington (it is surrounded by a street of bars so it's a nice drunkin food spot). The place had some jam band music playing which was pretty cool. They definitely had a mob theme going on. The pizza crust was warm and crisp. The pepperoni and banana peppers were a real delight on the pizza as well. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pepperoni with banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thanks for the awesome review, Payal! We're so happy you could stop…

Helpful 3

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Dre M.

1 year ago

Ice cold pizza. This place is pretty bad. 0.0 review if you ask me. Just terrible pizza. terrible customer service. What a waste of time and money.. seriously stay away read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi Dre,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Taylor G.

Elite 25

142

813

2 years ago

Awesome pizza! $10.61 for a large slice, 2 ft breadstick, cheese or red sauce and a drink! Parmesan, pepper packets available too for free! Great food, Faust in and out! All the pizza the have, tips and trick ask them to get it well done meaning they heat it back up in the oven before giving it to you! read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thanks for the 5 stars, Taylor! We're so glad you loved your pizza…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John F.

2 years ago

We stopped in this past Sunday evening and each of us bought two pieces from the counter. The employee reheated them in the oven next to him. Keep in mind that this was $24 plus tip. We walked the 6 buildings back to our location to eat them. This was absolutely the worst pizza I have ever eaten. Obviously, we were given very old pizza, but paid for fresh. I have eaten at the nearby Goodfellas and it was terrific, but I guarantee that I will never return to this location! read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi John, we're truly sorry to hear about your experience. This is…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kevin A.

1 year ago

That was some good pizza!!! Like the lunch special they have. Very quick on making everything & very friendly

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily D.

141

2 years ago

Food is amazing. We ordered sausage, veggie and pepperoni pizzas, breadsticks and cannolis. Everything is supersized. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There is no seating but just take it to go.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thanks for the 5 star review, Emily! We're so glad to hear you…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jenn K.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

317

167

5 years ago

I haven't been to this location in a very long time but I use to go to the one on Manchester on a regular basis . This week has been a train wreck at work. I was really craving a "taste of home" which is New York. I decided to stop by and get a piece of pizza then I saw the canollis and the black &white cookies (you can find black&white cookies in any bakery in New York City or the surrounding boroughs). You can NOT find black &white cookies at bakeries here in Lexington. Even though I was excited to see black&white cookies I still ended up with the canolli. Now in terms of the customer service, the guy at the counter could not have been any nicer . Thanks for indulging in a homesick New York , eating that piece of pizza & canolli made me miss home a little less . read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Sausage &Banana Peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pizza box . - Pizza Near Me - Lexington, Kentucky

See all

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thank you for your awesome review Jenn! It's always great to share a…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Maggie P.

1 year ago

Fantastic people, very kind individuals that genuinely care a lot about the customers, great food and once again great people.

Business owner information

Alex C.

Thank you, Maggie! It means so much to hear that our team made a…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Devan S.

266

1 year ago

Spent over $500 dollars at this location for an office lunch. Upon arrival we were not greeted. When we asked about the status of the order one of the cooks barked "we still have 20 minutes." A simple, "we're still working on it" would have sufficed. Once going back in to get the order and double checking that we had gotten everything the same guy didn't look up to answer. Very unpleasant experience. Hopefully the food will make up for the bad customer service. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Hi Devin,…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Allan B.

2 years ago

Great place to visit if you looking for some late night food. While being downtown Lexington several places were not open and I happen to stumble upon Goodfellas. Quick and ready to purchase slices or a whole pie if you're looking for that. read more

Business owner information

Alex C.

Late nights in Lexington just aren’t the same without some Goodfellas…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tanner F.

264

1 year ago

Pizza is mid. Over hyped. Taste like a frozen pizza from dollar general and the employees are jerks. Never going back

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 9

See more reviews

More info about Goodfellas Pizzeria

110 N Mill St
Lexington, KY 40507
Directions
(859) 281-1101
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.goodfellaspizzeria.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Goodfellas Pizzeria open?

Goodfellas Pizzeria opens at 11:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Goodfellas Pizzeria close?

Goodfellas Pizzeria closes at 12:00 AM (Next day) on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.Goodfellas Pizzeria closes at 3:00 AM (Next day) on Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Goodfellas Pizzeria closes at 11:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Wed 11:00 AM - 12:00 AM (Next day)Thu-Sat 11:00 AM - 3:00 AM (Next day)Sun 11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria take Bitcoin?

No, Goodfellas Pizzeria does not take Bitcoin.

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria take credit cards?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have catering options?

No, Goodfellas Pizzeria does not have catering options.

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have a drive thru?

No, Goodfellas Pizzeria does not have a drive thru.

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria serve alcohol?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria serves alcohol. Full Bar

Indoor Amenities

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria allow dogs?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria allows dogs.

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have TVs?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have bike parking?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria has bike parking.

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have outdoor seating?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria has outdoor seating options.

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have parking?

Yes, Goodfellas Pizzeria has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Does Goodfellas Pizzeria have free WiFi?

No, Goodfellas Pizzeria does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Hand-tossed NY-style slices & pies in downtown Lexington. $10 Lunch, 1/2-price 12" Mondays. Dine-in/carryout. Open late near the University of Kentucky & Rupp Arena.

History

Established in 2006.

Discover the best New York-style pizza and award-winning bourbon experience across Indiana, Kentucky, Ohio, and Tennessee. Our authentic, hand-tossed pizza has been a local favorite, consistently voted "the best" by the communities we serve. We hand-toss our fresh dough, use house-made sauces, and stone-bake every pie, serving authentic late-night slices until 3 AM.

More Info

Health Score

Ask the Community - Goodfellas Pizzeria

You might also consider

Kentucky Native Cafe

Awesome place; you enter through a greenhouse area and kind of follow the trail, sometimes stopping…read moreand wondering " is this a cafe" "maybe we are in wrong area " Another couple behind us said to keep on moving to the back, keep on going and voila this beautiful forest area opens up with tons of tables all randomly placed for dining. There is the ordering line and just a headed up they don't serve meat products. All dishes are vegetarian. You get to select 2 from the list for a meal ( as they are smaller portions ). They have some great dishes and savory tastes. They have beer and wines available; nice selection but not abundant- but when you have good selection in the first place you only need a smaller list. The hummus appetizer is awesome and great with the focaccia bread but I'd get at least a double portion bread right away. The porter was very good! If you're in Lexington stop here for the experience and some good food and drink!

Atmosphere 10/10. Everything else is MID! The line stays incredibly long and I was surprised to see…read morethat as they ran out of items and wiped them off the board, they didn't replace those items with anything else but still continued to serve a VERY LIMITED menu. The food was okay. Nothing to write home about. Especially for the hype and the line you wait in. Service is okay, kind of friendly and was incredibly slow to get food out. After waiting for 20-25 minutes we stood by the kitchen window to wait for our food to come up, we overheard people coming to pick up food and being told they were out of items they ordered and to choose something else... from the already VERY LIMITED menu. I was struck that they were allowing orders to go through for items they didn't have.. Anyways, the couscous salad was great. The lox and kohlrabi salad was mid with soggy bread. The pretzel was decent. Seating in the garden was viby - I'm assuming this is why everyone hypes this place up. Overall very pretentious. Walking around the greenhouse and seeing the plant prices is LAUGHABLE. As a gardener, these prices are insane and you can certainly find great plants at a much better price elsewhere. Again, pretentious. I've experienced their garden seating so I don't think I need to go back when visiting Lexington.

Bavarian pretzel with rhubarb soda and wild rice soup and maple glazed potato salad with a sparkling lemonade. Delicious!

Where you order

See all

Canopy

Vinaigrette Salad Kitchen

Tasty but seriously overpriced. They cater to the hamburger office workers that can afford an…read moreexpensive lunch for little value. The lemonades are tasty but they claim local food while using the same restaurant suppliers as everyone else

First time trying vinaigrette..I have to start off by saying how amazing the customer service was!…read moreThe gentleman helping me was super friendly, offered me a drink on the house. I tried the coco mixed with the basil lemonade. 10/10 drink selection, refreshing and light. Wide variety of in house made lemonade selections. I got the bluegrass blackberry salad. Portion was HUGE it could have easily fed 3 people. It was very good! I live out of state but will definitely be returning. Lots of options to mix in the salads and proteins also. They don't skimp on the veggies, and weigh out the greens.

Acapulco Caesar! Maybe there a couple of bites taken out of this before I tried to make it pretty again.

See all

Carson's Food & Drink - On Main

This has become mine and my husbands favorite place for celebratory dinners. To start, the staff…read morehas always been extremely nice and welcoming and helpful. The atmosphere is amazing. And of course, the food! Seriously some of the best meals I've ever ate. The nachos are out of this world, highly recommend. The steaks are all perfection. My kids loved the fried chicken when we brought them along. My beverage of choice is the blueberry lemon drop, it's delicious! And then the bread pudding for dessert is another absolute must! I only have one complaint about this place and it's their parking lot, don't love the gravel lot since it can get messy but everything else makes it worth it and then some.

This place is awesome! There isn't another place in Lexington where you can count on consistently…read moregood food like you can here. They never miss. Whether its brunch, lunch or diner its always been great. Oh, and make sure you get a bloody Mary. One of the best I have ever had, and the bacon on it is to die for.

See all

Pearl's

4.1

(132 reviews)

0.1 mi

Pearl's Pizza! Amazing! The pizza menu is diverse and unique which I am always looking for. 4 of us…read moregirls went. We split 2 pizzas and a breadstick. We were all happy & full after. I tried the Zillamina "Spanish Rose Wine" (rosè) & COL DI LUNA Flora Prosecco. Rosè was my favorite! It's a small place but lively. Definitely recommend reservations. I will be coming back! I'm glad Lexington has Pearl's Pizza!

Automatic 20% gratuity and time limits on dining in. I normally tip at least 20% but that is my…read morechoice and based on my experience but being forced to tip 20% is a bad business model.

Pearls interior.

See all

Restaurant ambiance

OBC Kitchen

I think I've found my newest favorite restaurant in Lexington! Old Bourbon Country (OBC) Kitchen,…read moreis a showstopper! This place is a must for anyone local if you haven't been, and if you're not local, it's seriously worth the trip! There are so many great things I can say about OBC, the service is phenomenal; professional, amazing recommendations, and they go out of their way to give you an unforgettable experience! Their bourbon selection is fantastic; they're guaranteed to have everything you'd want and even some things you haven't tried or been able to find anywhere else. The food is on another level! Starting with with bacon in the glass for the table is a must! This gives you a taste of the quality to come and the peanut butter accompaniment that comes with it works so well! The depth of flavor in the Cola-Braised Short Rib Tacos is unreal & even their rolls are amazing! The Ribeye is cooked to your exact liking; is a very high quality cut, and has a delicious seasoning which is the differentiator for me that makes this one of my favorite steaks I've had in a very long time! I could go on & on, but you need to experience it for yourself!

I was truly stunned by the incredible bourbon/whiskey selection at OBC. They have over 800 unique…read moreoptions and the talented/educated staff to match in order to guide you through the selection process. The shear number of bottles on the bar will keep your eyes moving about and hard to focus on anything else. For food, I had the wagyu meatballs and couscous salad. Both were well sized and utterly delicious. I'll be back here again for sure

Bar is stocked with everything

Pimento cheese dip with sourdough bread

See all

$110/bottle

Char

We went for brunch this weekend. First time here and we both got the specials. I got the omelet…read morewith goat cheese and red onion. Husband had the bread pudding French toast. We also had coffees (regular drip for me and an iced latte for him). And I also tried the key lime gimlet. It's made with Castle & Key gin which is a favorite of mine. Ambience was very nice and the food was delicious. I asked for a side of bacon. I am very particular about my bacon and it came out cooked perfectly, crispy but not burnt. Service was fantastic and pleasant. The only criticism I had is that the red onion in my omelet was bitter. But no one's fault, sometimes onions are very astringent. Everything else was delicious and well made. Oh and we got the house made cinnamon roll for the table. This was delicious. So buttery and gooey with cinnamon. We will be back, maybe for dinner to try their dinner menu!

Char on Ashland is a must-visit in Lexington! We tried five items and here's the honest breakdown:…read more The Cinnamon Bun is a 10/10 -- hands down the star of the visit. It's enormous (easily shareable between 6+ people) and absolutely delicious. The Sourdough Breakfast Sandwich was a close second at 9/10, a great classic executed really well. The Banana Bread Latte was an 8/10 -- very good but ask for it less sweet. The Iced Cinnamon Bun Latte and Eggs in Heaven both landed at 6/10. The latte sounds incredible on paper but the cinnamon bun flavor didn't quite come through, and while the Eggs in Heaven dish itself is a good concept, my eggs were unfortunately not cooked to my liking. We really enjoyed sitting outside and enjoying our breakfast! Service was good, a little slow but they were very friendly! Overall a great spot with a lot of potential -- the pastry alone is worth the trip. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu!

See all

Athenian Grill

Nice place! Food was great!…read moreSmall area and only small outside eating location No indoor seating Mostly take out. Parking was difficult as no specific parking designated Might have to park in other businesses parking lot after hours. That was our biggest drawback Ordering was pretty okay straight forward Many regular Greek entrees and also could get meals by selecting different items to make a meal

Lamb gyro was wonderful. There's great outdoor seating. Staff is kind. Food was ready quickly!…read moreGreat quality.

Greek Garden Salad

See all

Storefront

East End Tap and Table

I love the Lomo Saltado Loaded Fries and I ask for extra brown sauce. It has an amazing rich umami…read moreflavor and the most prominent flavor is from Aji amarillo paste (Peruvian yellow chili). I love their version of this common Peruvian dish! As far as brunch goes, I love their breakfast burrito! They melt cheddar cheese on the flour tortilla before loading it up with eggs, potatoes and meat. That extra step of melting the cheese makes a difference -it's a nice layer of melted cheddar and they put a cheese sauce over the top too!l

My wife and I along with our youngest daughter stopped in on Saturday evening while in town for a…read moreconcert. We were seated immediately upon walking in. The place was packed. We had great service, which started with drinks and appetizers. Our table agreed to just order a bunch of appetizers and share. We had the Spring Rolls, Empanadas, Buffalo Chicken Wontons and a side of the Loaded Fries. Everything was delicious. They had a good selection of beer, wine and cocktails. We had two other family members join us after we ordered and our server got an extra chair for our table to accommodate a total of 5 of us. It worked out perfectly. The atmosphere last night was loud and lively, which was fine with us.

East End Breakfast Burrito

Interior and bar

See all

Dirty Old Fashioned

Miyako Poké Bowl

Love it! I'm so happy Cincy finally has a poke spot. The price is very affordable and food is…read morealways delicious

Once again, another amazing Poké bowl. This is my favorite restaurant in Lexington hands-down. Poke…read morebowls are my favorite item. And I've traveled a decent part of the country and this is my favorite Poké bowl place I've ever been to. Everything is fresh delicious and I love to build your own bowl. Another great option if you have friends that don't like sushi is they have chicken teriyaki bowls for people who don't want to eat raw. My go to is the build your own bowl with sushi rice, Ahi tuna, cucumber, sumiari, seaweed salad, corn, cilantro, carrots, pickled ginger, jalapeños , with a sesame dressing and just a teeny tiny bit of spicy mayo.

Spicy ahi Spicy Ahi Poke Bowl

Outside

See all

Miyako "Puke"? Very unfortunate signage. It's actually a good little place to catch a quick lunch.

Giuseppe's Ristorante Italiano

I had let them know when booking the reservation that it was for my wife's birthday dinner. When we…read morearrived at the hostess station, they told my wife Happy Birthday. As requested, we were seated on the bar side of the restaurant so we could hear the live Jazz music. Our server also acknowledged my wife's birthday after we were seated. She did a fantastic job taking care of us. We started off with cocktails. I had the Russell's Reserve Black Manhattan and my wife had the Ketel One Dirty Martini. For our entrees, I had the Scampi Fra Diavolo and my wife had the Risotto Crostaceo. Both were excellent. For dessert, my wife was served a complimentary slice of Red Velvet Cake with a lighted candle. It was a perfect way to end the evening. This has been our special occasion restaurant for 20 plus years. I'm so glad we found this place all those years ago.

Had the pleasure of dining here the night before my grandson got married - it was SPECTACULAR!…read more Everyone enjoyed their dinner and it was cooked to perfection. Thank you!

Beautiful interior.

INSALATA CESARE

See all

Carson's Back Porch

4.4

(21 reviews)

0.6 mi

I'm from nyc. Found this place by luck. All I can say is forget about it! This place is great the…read morefood is top notch!!! Try the shrimp cocktail it great

Wow! This is another beautiful space from Carson's! The menu is different than their other…read morelocations and it is something special. One item that is very popular is a very unique entree that the call they Millionaire's Baked Potato. It is epic!! The Seafood Bisque is to die for and the lobster tail was tender and delicious. They even top it with a little caviar. Try this place. You won't be disappointed.

See all

Women's restroom

The Rackhouse Tavern

3.7

(85 reviews)

1.7 mi

We had an amazing experience at The Rackhouse. The food was all incredible, and the drinks we tried…read morewere all delicious. Our server, Abby, was very personable and did an excellent job.

Went for lunch and the restaurant is open and airy with lots of seating. The lunch menu has a lot…read moreto offer; salads, sandwiches and hot plate lunches. I had the Hot Brown and it was delicious. The bechamel sauce was smooth and rich and the ham; thin sliced and devine. My guest had the chicken salad with fries. The salad was very good and the fries exceptional. They were fried twice; crisp on the outside and pillows on the inside. Only disappointment was the featured peach jalapeno margarita. I was served a regular margarita with heat but no peaches. Our server was delightful and attentive. I will go back.

Deviled Eggs Crispy Chicken Skins, Buffalo Sauce, Celery

See all

Fried Chicken Livers, Pork Rinds and Deviled Eggs

Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse - Lexington

Food was delicious and our server, Mark, and our associate server, Dalton, were WONDERFUL. They…read moremade our experience top tier (along with fantastic food).

Amazing dinner for my first time! Will definitely be back! The blackened ribeye was phenomenal!!read more

Jeff Ruby's Baked Macaroni & Cheese

See all

Crab Cake

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

51 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Bryan W.

18 years ago

Definitely my favorite pizza in Lexington. Goodfellas is open late and is frequented by downtown bar patrons, especially on the weekends. The staff is always churning out pizzas for instant by-the-slice purchases with little to no waiting. Prices are probably a little more expensive than your call-in delivery pizza but the end product is far superior. If you do plan to stop by at last call, be prepared to wait. It's often better to leave the bar a little earlier and snag a slice before the bar closing rush backs the line up out into the road. Google Street View: http://tinyurl.com/d9jkwf read more

Sonya W.

16 years ago

Goodfellas has two locations in Lexington now, and this location is by far the better of the two. Friendly staff and quick service. The location on S. Limestone is terrible! They deliver where the Mill St. location doesn't. I gave them a shot and the service was awful. It took the driver an hour to find Main St. Less than a mile from the restaurant! Then he wouldn't bring the pizza to our apartment, only coming to the lobby. So if you want Goodfellas, choose this location. read more

Shamus O.

8 years ago

My three stars was based on the decor of the restaurant. It was pretty gigantic. The slice of pizza I ordered unfortunately hadn't started to thaw before I could try it. And then I was accosted on the patio while trying to post this review on yelp. This man (pictured below) begin yelling about permits, screamed 'NO PIZZA FOR YOU!' and took my frozen slice of cheese pizza. I was able to snap his picture before leaving the patio. read more

Tyler D.

12 years ago

One of my favorite pizzerias. The pizza tastes awesome and it's huge, so you get a lot for your dollar. Tuesday nights they have 1/2 priced pizzas so it's a great time to go. The only downsides is they don't deliver and there isn't really room to eat in the store. But if you don't mind going to pick it up, go Try it out. I'll continue to go back. read more

John M.

8 years ago

Goodfellas is one of my favorite pizza joints in Lexington. The service is great and the atmosphere is top notch. They have an impressive selection of cocktails and lots of good local beer. I love the patio overlooking the Town Branch of Elkhorn Creek. This a great place to meet up with friends, see music and enjoy high quality pizza. read more

Amanda J.

124

15 years ago

awesome place... its one of the best pizza's i ever ate... The lay out is a bit confusing, I'm guessing they have expanded a few times since opening. Definitely has a fun atmosphere though. Seems to be busy every night. read more

Shane B.

137

15 years ago

Goodfellas stands alone in a sea of mediocre pizza joints and local flavors, with giant slices and breadsticks the size of John Holmes on a GREAT day good fellas never disappoints... EVER read more

Jamohn M.

7 years ago

Very good pizza and HUGE bread sticks.......Visited when they first opened on a Saturday, at LEAST 4-6 pizzas were ready and they had great pizza by the slice deals! read more

Chris R.

10 years ago

I love Goodfellas pizza! Whenever i go downtown Lexington i always stop for some pizza time!!! the parking is hard in this area but other than that the pizza is good! read more

Sez R.

14 years ago

You can try a variety of their pizza as they sell sliced (for a few bucks). There are only two stools to sit and no bathroom. This place is meant to be a take-out. read more

Trisha D.

11 years ago

Best Pizza around! The lunch special is $6 for a HUGE pizza slice, a GIGANTIC bread stick with sauce, and a drink. And best of all, they carry Ale-8-1 on tap!!! read more

Andrew W.

6 years ago

The best pizza west of New York city. I been going once a week for 3 years. as close as it get to New York style pizza. The Sausage Sandwich is great to. read more

Jen D.

12 years ago

Best pizza in town. I am new to lexington and know my pizza but this is where I will be getting my pizza. Kids went crazy over it!

Hector A.

2 years ago

0.0 review. I can't believe they kept the guy who kicked out Dave from barstool. Every time I see that video I still get upset.

Hugh F.

3 months ago

Did they fire the clown who kicked Portnoy out. If they did I'll try it again when I go back. If he's still employed? Hell no.

David R.

1 year ago

Pizza is phenomenal! Customer service is top notch. Joe is amazing. Made me feel at home. This place is a perfect 10.00!

Michael C.

11 years ago

Big city pizza in downtown Lex! The meatball/banana pepper is awesome! Oh, dude with the headband is pretty cool.

James B.

10 years ago

Aaaaammmmaaaazzzziiiig seeeeeeeervvviice!!! Will definitely beeeeeeeee baaaaaack! Great great great pizza!!!

Maryann C.

2 months ago

Kicked out the pizza review guy who helps animals and struggling pizza places. Will not spend my money here

Paul K.

138

15 years ago

Surprisingly good if you had a few drinks. Not my favorite pizza in the area but this place is open late!

See more unrecommended reviews

Goodfellas Pizzeria - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Goodfellas Pizzeria also viewed

Mad Mushroom

3.7

(70 reviews)

Sheila is the goat, great pizza great sandwiches. Absolutely would recommend. Its the best.read more

Always awesome. Thank you MM for saving the day on several occasions!! The service and kindness…read morehere is always great and real good cheese

FatKats Pizzeria & Restaurant

3.9

(168 reviews)

We arrived at our hotel early today and needed to get dinner. We are traveling through town and…read moredon't know the area. So we looked up online what was good to eat here, in Georgetown. FatKats was labeled, "The Best Pizza in Town." Here are my thoughts. The restaurant had a reversed Pizza Hut vibe from the outside. The inside was full of purposeful graffiti and stickers on the walls. It was fine. It seemed fairly clean. The Good When we arrived, my daughter was having a HANGRY meltdown. One is the servers came over with crayons and coloring pages. I was optimistic! The pizza was pretty good. That is the star of the show. The prices were ok. The Bad Well, it took about 15 minutes to even order. Then, the salads arrived in a fairly quick manner. However, it had a little lettuce, some cheese, and a bunch of carrot slices. We were short on napkins and had to ask multiple times for them. My order was incorrect and had to be sent back and redone. We had to ask multiple times for drink refills, items that were missing from our order, and condiments. Overall, I would say the pizza was good but not amazing and the service was acutely lacking. I think if I could I would give a 3.5

I have eaten here 20 plus times and the last time was just a few months ago. It has always been…read moreclean and the staff has always been friendly. And, I love their pizzas. Today was sad. We came in and one of the servers hollered at us from the bar area that she would be with us shortly. She sat us in a booth in the front part of the restaurant. The floor was a greasy slick feeling under your feet. My wife said she slipped and slid all the way to the restroom and back. The restaurant smelled like dirty soured dish water. We don't even wait for our waitress to return to wait on us. We left without even ordering a water.

Parlour Pizza

4.0

(53 reviews)

Recently made a yelp account and wanted to highlight the amazing service I get here from abby the…read morebartender every time I go!

Place is trash. Dough is too sweet. Overpriced. No sriracha involved in their sriracha wing sauce…read more If you want a non-corporate pizza here in Lexington, go with something local. Louisville can keep this garbage

Pearl's

4.1

(132 reviews)

Automatic 20% gratuity and time limits on dining in. I normally tip at least 20% but that is my…read morechoice and based on my experience but being forced to tip 20% is a bad business model.

Smashing Tomato

4.2

(155 reviews)

Dinner special with the breadsticks. Totally worth it! My husband and I love this place and how…read morewell organized it is. Service is quick!

This place was so good. Even through door dash! I got the Margarita and the artichoke dip. The…read morebread they give you with the artichoke dip is unreal. The seasoning is so good. Just be careful it gets all over the place lol. Everything was perfect.

Smashing Tomato

4.3

(189 reviews)

Stopped by while traveling Quick service and pizza…read moreselection Food was good Would definitely eat there again

The pizza is good, but they are scammers. The website says, "Order online for free delivery" and…read morewhen you place the order it automatically charges $2 for delivery. It happens every time and, on each occasion, I call the Hamburg location and speak to the store manager. His response every single time is, we use outside vendors like door dash ..."and I don't know why it does that." Every single time! They should be prosecuted for false advertising because the management knows they are providing false information and they continue to do it.

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

3.9

(133 reviews)

•$

Delicious, simple food. Friendly staff--you order at the counter and they bring it to you. The…read moreatmosphere is fairly stripped down and not fancy, but clean and functional. The grinders are the star attraction. A regular is enough to stuffmost people. The large is better suited to split between 2-3 people.

Took our son there for his Birthday and it was wonderful …read more. Even ordered the same dinner to take home with us!!

Apollo Pizza

3.9

(105 reviews)

Our group stopped in for an early dinner after a couple of distillery tours, and we all left full…read moreand happy. This is a perfect casual dinner spot, with an extensive menu and good service. Their regular crust pizza is fluffy and had just enough chew. My boyfriend and I enjoyed the cauliflower wings (tossed in sweet chili sauce) to start--they were crisp and coated thoroughly. We also had the Rachel pizza, which boasts chicken, bacon, cilantro, pineapple, and bbq sauce. We were very pleased with our choices and would recommend both!

Pizza/food is awesome.. I usually like a glass of wine with dinner, been to Apollo on Leestown…read moreabout 4 times. Wine is hit or miss. "Chardonnay? We are out. Okay, red blend? Out. Um what do you have? Last drop of a bottle of Merlot?" Yikes. Would definitely go to this place more often if wine situation was more reliable.

Big City Pizza

3.6

(93 reviews)

Honestly I don't know what the negative reviews are about. Service was timely, food was good, the…read morespecial requests were observed. I recommend!

The worst pizza I have ever had in my life. They should change the name to BIG SHI..Y PIZZA…read more Despite being less than 10 minutes away from my home it took 90 minutes for the delivery. The pizza was very burned and despite that was cold. Not cool COLD! It was so charred that you could not tell what the toppings were. The delivery guy was surly despite getting a good tip. First and last time for BIG SH..TY PIZZA for me.

PieTana

4.5

(181 reviews)