I had a Pick up order for 4:30pm via their online order form, unfortunately the Pizza was overcooked which is pretty disheartening when paying $16.95 for a 10 inch Specialty Pizza called "Lady & the Ramp". The Garlic knots were just okay for being awarded one of the best in a competition last year. I ordered a side of their "garlic butter" however its a very artificial butter substitute of some sort which went straight into the Bin. The Stromboli with Pepperoni and Mushroom was the best of the lot. My second visit here, the first time we waited in the tiny dining space for a long time because the staff forgot we were waiting for our order. I won't be sadly disappointed a third time & will take my money elsewhere. read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

22 dollar pizza had very few toppings and the sauce was not good Was disappointing Cut in 8 pieces would estimate 2-3 pepperoni and 1-2 sausage on each piece read more

My kid is in college in Athens. We decided to drive up to try this pizza (and garlic knots!) after seeing this place on Instagram. It was totally worth the 3-hour round trip. The selection of specialty pizzas with dog pun names was amusing. We got the Three Little Pugs pizza, which had bacon, ham and sausage, along with artful dollops of ricotta cheese to cool down the spice from the hot garlic chili crunch oil. The garlic knots were big, fluffy and super garlicky and better even than the hype. We got some of their Tyrannodog Sauce (A house-made, dragon's breath chili pepper spicy ranch dressing) and dipped the knots into it. It was so good, we left with a bottle of it. It's spicy and garlicky in all the best ways. Staff was friendly and helpful. Be aware, there is ONE TABLE inside and a few outside the shop. It's mostly a to-go spot, but it's totally worth it. Absolutely amazing. read more

See all

Had Black Dog Pizza last night for the first time. Have to say we were pretty happy w/our experience. We got a 16" w/pepperoni, black olives & banana peppers & the distribution was well done. Sauce was good, not wowing; crust was not a thin but a "Medium " thickness. Baked well. The garlic knots were very good, but not as good as I thought they would be. Still, worth the price. There WAS a wait after the time they quoted me, but not much. Not bad overall. I would definitely go back & WOULD recommend it. read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - 16" New York Style with pepperoni, black olives & banana peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Black Dog Pizzeria has gotten buzz for their pizza, particularly the garlic knots. We got food to go, a large veggie pizza and order of garlic knots. Thoroughly enjoyed both. They serve pizza both New York and CBUS style. Got the latter. Cannot comment about the ambiance of the place. Presentation: 9/10. Pizza looks visually appealing, and cheese isn't burnt or underbaked. Enough veggies. Taste: 10/10. Every bite was great. The garlic knots were as advertised Overall, would get it again. It's close to where my in-laws live whenever we return to CBUS. read more

See all

Snowmaggedon and everyone is ordering Black Dog!! Best pizza in the area!! We wanted one last hurrah before getting house bound. Delicious pizza Fabulous wings!! I'm so glad they are back!!! read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Atta Boy - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

The pizza smell as soon as you open the door tells you that you are in for an amazing experience! I am an East coast pizza girl and VERY particular about pizza. Crust is always the first thing that makes/breaks a pizza. Black Dog's crust was spot on.....thin, pie sliced and tasty all the way up to the crust. The toppings .....oh my....endless....not stingy by any means. This will now be my to go place. read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

One Of the Most conflicting reviews, I have ever had to do. And it is frustrating because, This business has such a high-quality product and high-quality people, But the hours can confuse that average pizza connoisseur, Want a pizza on your lunch break at noon? Forget about. How but a bunch of pizzas, For that Sunday kick off game, or a Saturday Buckeye Game day Tailgate. These hours make that impossible. There are missing out of the main segments of business, for there amazing product. It took me 5 times just to try this, because of the hours, but is that why the staff is so nice? These people give exceptional service, but they are not a threat to anyone except around dinner time. Improve the hours keep the service, and you'll be able to have multiple locations and no problem unless they want to keep it it's a small I'm not sure what the goal is but thanks for a great product read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

If you're a fan of specialty pizzas, which I am a super fan, the this place is a must try. Really loved everything. The black dog really delivered on the doubling of pepperoni! The pesto and burrata combo on man's pesto friend was excellent. Sometimes both of those things on pizza can be bland but it was seasoned very well. And the alohound was the big surprise. Not Hawaiian pizza fans in my house AT ALL, so was very surprised when my husband wanted to try. They over delivered on the meat which cut through the sweetness of the pineapple well and the addition of cinnamon broke my brain in the best way. My only minor complaint is that the crust was a little on the chewier side. Will definitely try again though. We ordered takeout and everything was delivered on time and as expected. Can't wait to try the rest of the menu! read more

See all

Black Dogs' is hands down my favorite pizza spot. Not only is the ambiance and service great, but the food is amazing ! Plus, what other pizza spot is offering buffalo chicken dip ?? My go to pizza is their Bark-BQ pizza. It's topped with chicken, jalapeños and mozzarella cheese and drizzled with bbq sauce, cooked to perfection! The shop is dope as well! 9.2/10 read more

See all

Since I live an hour west of Columbus, I don't get a chance to visit many of the newer places I'd like to try...that being said Black Dog has been on my list for awhile and finally had a chance to carryout these amazing garlic knots i've been hearing about! Totally worth the hype and the pizza was just as good! Definitely one of the best pizzas I've had in a longgg time! Definitely looking forward to trying some other pizzas from here! read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Got takeout so I'm unable to evaluate the bathroom, but I'm sure it's nice. This pizzeria caught my eye due to some dedicated foodies on the FB page and one of the owners sharing pictures of their delicious pies. I gotta say, I was not disappointed. The pizza has that classic crispy texture of NY style pizzas without being overly cracker-ish that I see in these more tavern style pies. I really liked the sauce and they were very generous with the peps. The price seems about average but that's a plus since I think the food has quality. The staff are lovely humans and even address by name at the counter. I really liked the ambiance Overall. Overall i'd give it a 3.8/5, Im excited to go back and try some of their other styles!! read more

See all

This is a great carry out pizza joint. It's super clean inside. The food is excellent! We had a mistake in our order, but they were great to make it right. We'll be back! read more

It was my fault but I mistakenly ordered a pizza that was way too hot for my liking but once again that was my mistake not the shops, but other than that a decent pie read more

See all

Great menu, the team did a great job interacting with us and making suggestions and the place comes across as friendly and supportive of dogs! read more

Ordered three pizzas and garlic knots for pickup on a Saturday night at 6:45 PM and was told it would be ready at 7:45 PM. Arrived at 7:45 and was told the pizzas were ready, but it would still be 15 minutes for the garlic knots. It ended up taking half an hour after I arrived to get my complete order, and then by the time I got home, the pizzas were cold and soggy from sitting out so long. They gave me a free dessert for the trouble, but it didn't make up for the now poor quality pizzas. The flavor was good but I think my family would have liked it much better if it was hot and fresh. 90 minutes isn't the worst wait on a Saturday night, but I wish they had managed to that expectation and not had my pizzas (and me) sitting around for half an hour in the store. read more

This is our favorite pizza in Columbus! The garlic knots are next level! We got two orders tonight! The service is always fantastic! Such a cute shop too!! read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Man's Man's Pesto Friend - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

This place was rated number one NY style pizza in Ohio, so I really thought it would be better than Brooklyn pizza in Powell, or Mikey's late night slice, or maybe sextons in Hilliard.. It's not, not even close. It's especially not even close in the reviews where they say it's as good as NYC pizza shops, to that i would laugh in the reviewers face. Must have been a paid review. I got a large 16in, price was competitive, and the ingredients individually are good, nothing tasted cheap on its own, but the process to make the pizza makes it turn out like a sponge. The crust was too thick in places and inconsistent, it had a really weird processed texture that made it inedible, It tasted like a thick cracker and had no airy texture, it tastes like a mass produced conveyor-belt processed puck. No love, just profit. There's a reason NY pizza tastes how it does, between the water and how the dough is handled, worked, sculpted, tossed, stretched, and maneuvered multiple times in an oven, it tastes like it's made with love, skill and passion. In general this method to making a NY pie will not only cook it consistently, but makes the pizza taste better. You can tell the crust could be good, but the process to spit out pizza ruins any hope of making a quality pie. The ingredients, cheese is right, but way too much, and the sauce was good, but way too little, which made the end product taste like a puck covered in a 1/4in of thick cheese. The pepperoni was too skinny, NY pizza has 2in round pieces of pepperoni and not loaded with it, the tiny 1/4in pepperoni all over a pizza is just too much, in typical ohio fashion they make pizza an open face sandwich and it's simply not. I would actually recommend Donato's over this place if you want good ingredients mass produced, as i genuinely feel like this is Donato's for outside Ohio locations. It's possible that loaded up other "open face sandwiches" are good, but there's nothing NY about the NY pie outside of how it's sliced. All that said, the people were busy, friendly, the place was packed and they were staying on top of orders while continuing to produce pizza's. The store is too small for the foot traffic and it can't make it easy for the employees. I saw plenty of reviews from angry delivery customers, if they got off their fat butts and saw how crazy it was during peak times, they wouldn't leave those reviews and if they did, they deserve a cold puck, to that I give the employees props, as they were absolutely working crushed, packed, and staying on top of things. read more

I'm a trucker who loves local foods from across America and even though I'm Chicago and I'm biased towards deep dish pizza I think I've had the best thin crust pizza of all time. I parked behind the black dog pizzeria and hopped on their website. I saw their signature "black dog" pizza was a thin crust double pepperoni so I ordered one with the spicy sauce. Crust? Perfect. Toppings? Absolutely outstanding pepperoni without being too salty. Cheese? Exactly the right amount. If you wanna know where this truck driver finds the perfect pepperoni pizza look no further. Can't wait to come back and try their other pies and I have to mention the goofy guys that took my order over. The phone were so cool and fun. It increased my experience. By the way, I tried the Nutella rainbow cookies and they were outstanding as well. I love this place! read more

I was sad to hear they were closed for 5 months due to a fire. Now that they are reopened, we decided to order some pizza for delivery. When ordering online, it will redirect you to the "Slice" app, which is relatively easy to use/place your order. It gives you an ETA but it's not 100% accurate. Our order ended up being delivered even though the app still said they were "prepping it". Even though it got delivered sooner than expected, the food was not hot when it got here, more like warm. We love their Cujo, NY style pizza. The flavors are great - pepperoni, bacon, mushrooms, topped with hot honey! I also decided to try their cheesy pesto sticks. I was a little disappointed when I didn't see a sauce since the menu stated it came with a side of pizza sauce. I'm not sure if they forgot to pack it in my order but my palate was really searching for it while I was eating the sticks. Without the sauce, the cheese sticks are good, with a mild pesto flavor, but they are very dry. They have a good crunch to them though! read more

See all

Pretty good pizza! Customer service is absolutely horrendous. Pizza was delivered 45 minutes late and cold. Tried to cancel but no one answered for over 1 hour. They take on too many orders thwn get waaaaaaay behind and take no responsibility. read more

Delicious New York style pizza. Ordered three pizzas, one gluten free, and all were fabulous. The gluten free pizza is the best in town. Tastes like regular pizza. Delicious! read more

I've had Black Dog now a few times. Typically have it delivered via a third party. It's a good price and ingredients seem to be high quality. My only knock is that it has been a bit inconsistent in my orders. Sometimes it's shown up perfect then other times it looks like it was just thrown together and shoved in an oven. read more

One of our new fav pizza spots! Have tried at least 4 different pizzas and have yet to be disappointed! Did a "make your own" this week, Columbus style with pep sausage ricotta and basil with hot honey. SO good! read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

Did an online order on Super Bowl Sunday. Place was packed! Did a great job of fullfilling orders. Thank you!

Yesterday we ordered and the confirmation was to pick it up at 4:00 p.m. when we got there it wasn't ready and was told to come back in 20 minutes. I came back, got the order only to find out when i got home, i was missing 3 of the 4 salads on our order. went back for a 3rd time. read more

Unfortunately this pizza was not one of the best we have ever had. It was burnt, greasy and pretty difficult to eat. Pretty much like cardboard. read more

The BEST pizza in Columbus. Absolutely love Black Dog. Could not be more thrilled that they are back open. I have several favorites but Atta Boy squeaks by as my #1, delicious. I like it New York style. You can not go wrong with any choice! Owners are super kind! Community involved. And always happy to answer pizza questions. If you delicious and fresh...this is your place. read more

See all

What an absolutely underrated gem! I was looking for pizza in the Hilliard/Dublin area and saw Black Dog on the map. I had never heard of it but saw good reviews and the menu looked delicious so decided to go for it. Now I'm sad that I live on the other side of town away from it! I can't remember the name of the pizza we had but it was a white style pizza with onions. We also had garlic knots and Angie's rainbow cookies which were both delicious. I will definitely be ordering again and have recommended Black Dog to others! read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

Passing through town from Chicago. Read the reviews and decided to give Black Dog a try. The staff was great! Warm welcome and made sure everyone waiting for an order was taken care of. I ordered the Ultimutt and a small house salad. The house salad was good size for a small, generous, and filled with fresh veggies, lettuce and pepperoni. It was delicious. The pizza was OUTSTANDING. One of the best I've ever had. It was loaded with fresh ingredients and the tomato sauce was awesome! If I'm ever back in the Dublin area, I will definitely be back! read more

Love this pizza!! And the customer service is just as good! NY style is my favorite but you can't go wrong with Columbus either.

Great food delivered! Priced right! Fresh salad and toppings a new favorite! Served hot! read more

See all

Delicious pizza! They've got both Columbus and NY style. I tried the Black dog pizza which was Columbus style. Fabulous! Good flavors and a fantastic crust. I'm down to try the NY style next time. I had ordered online and didn't get the drink I ordered but all good here. Just means I should stick with only the pizza lol read more

Tried their gluten free pizza tonight. SO good. Anyone with celiac knows it's hard to find good gluten free pizza. Will definitely order again. **** thanks for addressing this so quickly. That's great customer service! read more

Went in to place my order & was done in about 15 min! The pizza was so so so good. I'm still thinking about it! I love the pepperoni, the bake on it was perfection and their ranch was amazing also. I got bbq boneless wings and my only wish is that they were nice and crispy like normal boneless wings! Flavor was good though. I will definitely be ordering pizza again from here! 10/10. Cute little space also with a couple of tables to eat in if you wanted to! read more

See all

the service was top tier! thank you to the manager Brayden Miller for the exceptional service and hospitality! the food was so good! a very homey place and great service! read more

I placed an order online, in the morning, for pickup later in the day 6pm. The pizza was ready when we arrived at 6, so we were really happy about that, and it was sooo good. I just wish it wasn't such a far drive from our house. read more

"NY style" pepperoni and bacon. Cooked through and had some crunch to it despite being delivery. Not really typical of a NY slice, but doesn't matter to me. Plenty of toppings, both tasted great. Sauce is great and just a bit of sweetness to it. Solid pie. Th Garlic knots. Oh my damn lanta they are absurdly good. Plenty of garlic and butter all over there things. They dissolve a bit and have some nice chew to it. The sauce that comes with it is excellent. Scarfed them all before I took a bite of the pizza. Solid place. Will definitely try again. read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - Garlic Knots - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all

First time having Black Dog Pizzeria, and I gotta say I'm impressed!! We made an online order for 2 pizzas. 14-inch columbus style pizza with caramelized onions, basil and jalapeños with spicy sauce. 16 inch new York style with classic red sauce, black olive, and mushroom. Those 2 pizzas came up to $43 The columbus style was a little thicker than the typical columbus style but very good. The cheese they use taste very fresh ad well as the basil. The jalapeños actually had a kick and didn't taste like straight vinegar. The carmelized onions I barely tasted because they were light on those, but what I did taste was great. Spicy red sauce was very good but the pizza was very light on the sauce. The new York style dough was amazing! The olives and cheese were very good too. But we didn't get many mushrooms on the pizza just like the caramelized onions on the other pizza. This pizza could have used more sauce also. Overall we loved it and will go back but will be asking for extra sauce and hoping we will get more of the delicious toppings we paid for. read more

Boyfriend and I shared a medium Columbus Style crust with pepperoni, mushrooms, onion and banana peppers. Crust was crisp and very flavorful when we made it home. Only issue I had was the pizza was cut in six large pieces instead of nine so I could steal a corner on the ride home. Great flavor and fresh ingredients. We will be back! read more

Black Dog Pizzeria - 10" Columbus Style pepperoni, mushroom, onions and banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Dublin, Ohio

See all