I have lived in Hilliard for 25 years. I have never eaten at Luigi's pizza before. Unfortunately the low stars reviews kept me away. So glad I decided to try it anyway. Really good pizza. Decided to order a pizza last minute while watching the Ohio State football game. Ordered online with no issues. Website worked perfectly and picked pizza up 35 minutes later. Ordered it crispy. And it was exactly that. Wonderful crispy thin crust pizza with nice toppings. Luigi's will now be a definite option for pizza in the future. Thank you! I should have taken a picture of the pizza when it was fresh instead of an hour later. But it still looks great! read more

Luigi's Pizza - Mushroom and onion with half Ezzo pepperoni other half Ezzo sausage pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Checked Google hours for Saturday. 11am-10pm. Tried to call and order a pizza at 8:50pm. Got a voicemail. Tried to order online. Couldn't. So I drove there at 9pm. Closed. Sign on the door say open until 10:30pm. Shitty way of doing business. Won't waste my time again. I'll go to a place where they are actually open when they say they are. I don't want to waste my time guessing if they are or not. Gets a 1 because I can't leave a zero. ​ read more

Luigi's Pizza - Luigis pizza 9pm on a Saturday night. - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

I am boring. I purchased a small cheese pizza. I ordered late Saturday not realizing what time they closed. He happily took my order. I picked it up shortly before closing. I did not take a picture. Upon opening the box the fresh aroma of cheese hit me. The sauce and the cheese was a perfect amount. Usually I have to order extra sauce and cheese. This was perfect. The sauce was perfect. It was not sweet nor spicy. The crust was thin and crispy with a hint it seemed of butter. Almost "crackerish" which was actually very good! I am sick of soggy crusts. I devoured it the minute I got home! I will definitely be going back! read more

Ordered takeout through DoorDash and they were great. Thin crust, crisp bottom will be ordering again.

Luigi's has been a favorite of ours forever. It's been around forever and it's just not like any other pizza we have found. There are tons of pizza places to choose from and we choose depending on what kind we are feeling. Luigi's is always a great option if you like thin crust, sweeter pizza. They have a thin, crispy sweet crust that is just like no other. The toppings are great as well, but we normally just go with the classic pep and cheese. We did branch out this time and try the sausage. It's really good too. read more

See all

Great hole in the wall mom and pop place. Gives you the vibes of just a classic pizza shop. We got 1 xl pep pizza 6 breadsticks and ravioli with 4 drinks and it was only 40 bucks. Can not beat the price. The pizza was greasy thin and good. Ravioli was deep fried and full of meat. Breadstick were covered in garlic and butter they were fluffy and delicious. The only complaint I have is the dipping sauce tasted like canned which is ok could have use some more seasonings but overall 8/10 for me. read more

Luigi's Pizza - They use old school wax plates. But do have real silverware. - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Great homemade pizza love the pizza. The pizza was so delicious service was great ready to eat. Don't know if there's another homemade for sure. A go to place in Hilliard. read more

You dont get what u pay for. The pizza taste good but its expensive; u get little bang for your buck

In my many, many years of dining out, I have never been as offended as I was at Luigi's Pizza in Hilliard OH. My family were the only people in the restaurant the entire time we were there, we ordered our meal and helped ourselves to a 2-liter soda in the fridge by the order counter. The employee asked if there was anything else to add to the order and I told him about the soda we had at the table, he replied in disgust that the 2-liter bottles are for take-out only, my bad, I didn't see the sign, sorry. I paid the tab and tipped the customary 20%. As we received our pizza at the table, not in a pizza tray, a plate or anything of the sort, but the pizza was on a round carboard cutout, not unlike the one you would get when heating a frozen pizza at home. We had gone through the 2-lt soda and were afraid to ask for another one for fear of being scolded again, so my 11-year-old son, who was still thirsty, went to pour himself a drink, with my consent, from the fountain. I was not sure if anyone else would like a fountain drink, so I made the decision to wait and pay all together once we knew how many fountain drinks I needed to pay for, instead of paying for them individually with a credit card. By the time my son went to get a refill, none of the fountain drinks were functional. My wife and I looked at each other with the same though, "could they have turned it off on us, surely they wouldn't?" I would be extremely offended by the lack of courtesy and hospitality, if that were the case. When we were done, I went to the counter to pay for my son's drink, and to my surprise, as soon as I made payment, the employee went to the fountain machine, took his key out and turned the fountain back on. The lack of welcomeness and friendliness from the staff is indicative of substandard management, the lack of supervision and guidance, and the very poor attitude of the ownership and their lack of willingness to promote repeat business. There are dining options around town, the next time I want to eat out in Hilliard OH, I will go WAY out of my way to make sure I am not made to feel like I was at Luigi's Pizza. read more

We're new to Hilliard so we decided to start trying the local restaurants and began here. The pizza was really no better than a frozen pizza. The crust was thin and yet not crisp. Additionally, we decided to try the spaghetti and meatballs as well as a sub. The sub was good and worth trying again, but the spaghetti sauce was so bland it was nearly tasteless. We paid extra for two extra meatballs but didn't get them. The rave reviews confused us but upon further inspection it appears the restaurant may have changed management, which would explain a lot. read more

Great Pizza! Very good thin crust pizza cooked perfectly. Great sauce and crust has its own taste like no other.

#worstpizzaever So we decided to try Luigi's because my husband and I didn't remember ever trying it before. We just wanted cheese this time while we watch our movie kid free. Is it us, or is this ACTUALLY the worst pizza in Hilliard? The pile in the box is ours we decided not to eat and threw back in the box. The sauce has no flavor. The crust is probably drywall. How hard can it be to screw up a CHEESE of all things, pizza??? A friend I spoke to tonight after this, said they used to be great but now have new owners who use the same recipes, but cheaper ingredients. Well you can sure tell. Would definitely not recommend. read more

Luigi's Pizza - a slice of cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

Lady that took my mom's order was very unwelcoming. You'd think that a mom-and-pop pizza joint that has survived for over 50 years would recognize the importance of at least being welcoming. Nope. Second, they literally have two random trash cans sitting in the middle of the main dining area. Pretty unappetizing. And finally, the food.... we ordered a pizza.... it was below-average at best but closer to disappointing. read more

Luigi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

We ordered from Luigi's on a Sunday night but the don't deliver on Sundays which is very odd. So we picked it up. We ordered one thin crust and one thick crust. The thick crust reminded me of the chef Boyardee pizza kits we had as kids. Aka not good. The thin crust wasn't much better. Canned mushrooms just aren't my thing. read more

Very tasty pizza. Our order was ready exactly when they said it would be. Can't speak to the dine in experience as we just did take away.

Bland, boring, never again. Like someone else already said, frozen pizza is a lot better than this. Very disappointing. The crust had no color or flavor. It's easily the most bland thing I've ever eaten. read more

See all

Whenever I come back to Hilliard, Ohio I always go to Luigi's. In fact, if it's a week or more, I go twice. Double Pepperoni/Double Cheese you will love it! read more

What a refreshing clean lunch spot. Fresh salads, piping hot pizza, or toasted hot subs! Something for everyone.

We just brought back our pizza & sub, & I have to say it wasn't bad. (Large pepperoni and mushroom) Not burnt anyplace, crispy, flaky crust, & we liked the sauce. The sub, which was a Supersub, (Italian sub w/extra meat and cheese) was very good. This was our first time at Luigi's & most likely we'll go back sometime. It won't be our "go-to" for pizza, but for a change it was pretty good. read more

First time trying Luigis. Very good cheesy garlic bread!! Would recommend! Excited to go back.

Thin crust pizza. Got a mushroom and sausage and a pineapple, ham, and bacon. The middle is slightly doughy, and outside was nice and crispy. My husband loved that it was doughy and crispy. I would agree for the most part. Very good pizza. We will get it again in the future. read more

Luigi's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

See all

First time trying this after driving by several times. I ordered a tossed salad (homemade Italian dressing), garlic bread w/ cheese, Large (14inch) pizza with Ezzo pepperoni, half banana pepper, half mushroom. The Ezzo pepperonis were perfectly cooked. The sauce has a slight sweet flavor, and it is amazing. For a local pizza place surrounded by corporate slum pizza, this place seems to be slept on in the yelp section. The staff was friendly and the order was ready on time. The dough they use was perfect for the flavor of the pizza. The homemade dressing on the salad was awesome. The garlic bread wasn't over powering and made a nice, after slice (of pizza), treat to combine all of the flavors. read more

This pizza is THE BEST PIZZA IN HILLIARD! Period. We order from here about once a week since the first time we had it. The bread of the pizza is so sweet and has the perfect texture. Their manicotti is also amazing! I'm sad to see they only have 3 stars because they deserve 10! read more

Cool local pizza joint, mostly supported by locals for after-sports meet-ups. Good but nothing to write home about. I guess you do it for the nostalgia. If you're picky or gourmet-oriented, give it a miss. If not, enjoy! read more

This locally owned, operated and well-loved gem was sold. I haven't been since the takeover but tonight I had a strong hankering for Luigis specifically. I tried to call for over an hour but the line was busy. So, I stopped in. No one greeted me or said they'd be with me in a moment. I stood under the "order here" sign for 10 minutes. Still nothing. I tried to call when I could see everyone. The phone never rang. I gave them the benefit of the doubt. More time passed and still was not helped in any way. There is no online ordering for Luigis. I left and I'll never be back. read more

Placed a delivery order, and it took over an hour to arrive. When I was on the phone ordering, the woman was very short with me, and didn't ask if I wanted to pay with a credit card. Once I asked her about it, she told me I would have to prepay any tip if I wanted to pay with my card, or I could give a cash tip. Why would I want to prepay a tip on a delivery order!? There's no incentive for speed at that point. Judging by how long it took for the pizza to get here, they didn't have much desire to be speedy anyways. After an hour passed, I called back to find out where my food was. This time a man answered the phone, and was far nicer than the original woman. He said he didn't know where my pizza was exactly, but that they had been extremely busy, and it was out for delivery. Less than five minutes later, my pizza showed up; piping hot. The pizza ended up being just as good as the service was bad. Mine and my girlfriend's pizzas were both very delicious. The garlic bread reminded me of Lucky Charms, in that it was magically delicious. With regard to food quality, I'd love to have Luigi's again, but the shoddy service is going to keep me pursuing other options. read more

Dined in this long time family LOCAL Hilliard Pizzeria. We had original crust (think extremely thin) Pepperoni and Cheese, and a Sausage Mushroom. Both were at our table in a reasonable amount of time. The pizzas were well topped, the sauce had just the right amount of spice. we also had small side salads, with house-made "Italian" dressing. Very good ! My take away, friendly folks, good unique real pizza. So if you like lots of thick dough from a huge chain, this may not be to your liking. For my money i will go LOCAL, not the same old thing every time !! Give Luigi's a try it is legit. read more

Crispy crust. Very cheesy without a lot of tomato sauce. Pepperonis were very good and not too spicy. Pizza since 1955. If you haven't tried them yet, you should definitely should! read more

Luigi's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hilliard, Ohio

Hilliard is the home of DiCarlos and this travesty to pizza. I'm not sure which is worse. One bite and you can tell the crust is frozen. School cafeteria pizza is better. If you're going to make a $5.00 pizza then you should charge $5.00. They have been open since 1955. When it opened in 1955 did they actually use frozen crust? We need some Italians to move into Hilliard so we can get some decent pizza. Just to rub it in they screwed up my order. Learn to MAKE fresh dough and perhaps you'll be in business until 2055. read more

Stopped by when Mikey's ran out of pizza during Free Comic Book Day events nearby. Thankfully, I don't live anywhere near this pizza place. Let me preface this by saying I used to work in the pizza biz. And I don't mean as a delivery guy. I started as a cook, and helped with a pretty successful pizza business back in my hometown in NY. I also grew up close to the owners of a couple other nice pizza restaurants. Start from the top to the bottom, they always say. The toppings: cheap, low quality. Greasy, scant mozz. Pretty run-of-the-mill pepperoni, which is about the only thing I won't fault them for, since it can be awful to find out people are using some of the more greasy varieties when you weren't expecting it. Sauce could have been from a can, it was so bland. But the real travesty was the crust. Oh, the crust. I think we got the original, but for all I know, they messed up and gave us the thin. It was very, very thin -- and I come from a place where thin-crust is a big deal. It tasted like a club cracker or saltine, as others had stated, and I am almost positive it was frozen. Overall, it was one of the most disgusting pizzas I had ever eaten. I feel like I could have just ordered from Domino's and gotten something better (and I HATE Domino's), or just gotten a tombstone out of the grocery store. And it was 9 bucks for a pretty underwhelming small, which is high in my books. Also, some guy in the back kept staring/glaring at me the entire time. I get it, I am not the most conventional looking human being in the world, but at least give me some relief when I am trying to eat. read more

I was a little underwhelmed with Luigi's pizza to say the least. While I was there I was like... "Yeah, I might come back here.", but the more I sat and thought about it.. I was like... "Hell, there's a lot more greater pizza places on the west side that deserve attention." The ambiance here is the same it has been since the 1980's. In fact my husband recalled nothing really changing since he had been there as a kid. The same arcade machines are still there, and the same color scheme is still showing. He said, "Oh there is something new... The tea machine." lol As much as I love a good thin cracker crust... Luigi's did provide this being 2nd to the thinnest crust I have ever had (See Cappy's in London), but I don't know.. I was just pretty "meh" about it all. We ordered fried cauliflower, which was pretty much straight off the GFS truck. No hand battering here. The cheese, and topping's Luigi's uses are great, but what really killed it for me was the crust. The crust takes on a sweet taste to it, and then once it hits you... you realize after puzzling, and contemplating on whether this pie is great or mediocre.... The crust just tastes like a giant club cracker. I was also disappointed that it looked like their crust was not made in house for the thin pizza. It looked like it was bought in and not hand thrown, or rolled from the creases on the sides of the crust, and perfect random holes on the bottom. Perhaps their thicker crust is where it's at, but I don't think I'll take that chance. I hate to say it, but it'll have to take a moment of pizza desperation to bring me back. Luigi's is not worse than chain pizzas, but it just failed to amaze. Sorry, Luigi's. read more

I love supporting local food, but I just can't get on board with Luigi's. SERVICE ISSUES: When I ordered, the employee seemed really agitated and irritable - everyone has bad days, I get that - but when I got the food, they had forgotten my chicken fingers with the kids' meal. Stuff happens, but when I called back about the fingers, the same employee was very short with me, definitely didn't hide her irritation as she yelled back to another employee about the order, and kept telling me it was "in the bag." I assured her they weren't, and they did end up sending out our missing items, but not without me feeling like I had to argue to receive my food that I paid for. Good customer service can go a long way. THE FOOD: cardboard-dry crust, rubbery, plastic-tasting cheese, bland tomato paste sauce, nothing special about the pepperoni...it makes me think of the cafeteria pizza from my high school. Definitely not worth the price; Little Ceasar's packs more flavor and that's unfortunate. The chicken tenders were okay, not great, not the worst, and the mushrooms were meh.. I hope maybe they can breathe new life into this place, I would love to see a 180 and it transform into a place with great food. read more

I am not from the area, went to a event there. The pizza was very good I tried two different types. I would recommend it.

This is the best pizza. Thin, flaky, crispy, crust with a tomato based sauce that is perfectly balanced between spicy and sweet. No reason to have crazy toppings like broccoli or pineapple. Stick to legacy toppings like pepperoni or sausage. I expect to return on the regular. read more

I had Luigi's pizza for the first time ever tonight. My pizza was ready in 20 minutes. I got a 12 inch thin crust pepperoni mushroom and banana pepper pizza. I have to say for $16.65 it was not worth it. There is way better pizza around Hilliard Ohio than this. If it were a couple dollars cheaper it might be worth it. The three star reviews on this board are pretty much on par with what this pizza was. read more

Last night was our first time ordering from Luigi's and it won't happen again. We ordered a pizza, chef salad, fried ravioli, and a mini-corndog kids meal. The order took an hour to arrive and the pizza was flavorless. The fried ravioli were just okay (previously frozen). The chef salad was decent, minus the rubbery canned mushrooms (which were also on the pizza). I was pretty pleased with the kids meal though. In addition to six mini corndogs and a good helping of french fries, which was all I expected to receive, the kids' meal also came with a full-sized Capri Sun and a package of fruit snacks. Needless to say, my daughter ate her whole supper! All in all, we're crossing Luigi's off our list of pizza possibilities. Slow service and unsatisfying food make for a disappointing combination. read more

Worse than a generic brand frozen pizza. Very disappointed. I don't believe they use any seasoning or even bake the pizza for more than 30 seconds. read more

The food looks appetizing and is prepared fast. The food is very greasy but a lot of flavor. I would say the most impressive is the service, very quick and always filling up your drinks. Final rating 7.5/10 read more

We have driven by this location many times in the last four years and finally decided to give it a try. We decided to dine in to get the freshest pizza as possible. Luigi's had several website coupons and they gladly accepted it by seeing it on my phone...winning paperless. We kept the pizza simple and went with half cheese and half pepperoni. We also ordered a meatball sub and a large tossed salad. The dining area was simple with about seating for about 50. There were two highchairs available which we made use of. We did not have to wait too long for the salad and it easily gave our party of six enough for one if not two servings. The salad was simple, iceberg lettuce with shredded carrots topped with some pepperoni and mozzarella cheese. The dressing came on the side and was enough for our entire party. Luigi's uses paper plates with actual silverware, which worked fine. The pizza and sub came out together roughly 30 minutes after we ordered (we were given this estimated time at the order process). The pizza was piping hot. It was pretty easy to separate the squares and the X-Large pizza fed five of us well with leftovers. We stuck with the original thin crust and each bite had good crunch. The pizza was good but no particular topping or sauce stood out as "Wow." The meatball sub was similar. The sauce seemed lacking in flavor. I can't really nail down what ingredient was missing but the overall tastiness was not there. Overall it was a good dinner and my oldest son said he wanted to come back, but there are better pizzerias in Hilliard. I enjoyed supporting a local company and it was fun to eat pizza outside of the home. read more

I don't know why but this is the best pizza in the Hilliard area. The hours and times open are a little hard to keep track but definitely worth the wait! read more